Saturday, January 2, 2016

A battle for the soul of college football

At 24-12, I’ve performed respectably – although somewhat underwhelmingly – through the first two weeks of the bowl season. The toughest loss was Oklahoma getting blanked in the second half against Clemson; I really thought the Sooners, the hottest team in the country, were going to pull an Ohio State in 2014 and ride their late-season momentum to a title. Oh, well.

The last few games and the national championship are pretty legit, even though TCU lost Trevone Boykin two days ago to a ridiculous arrest and suspension. The games are all in Pacific time and rated one a 1-5 scale of watchability.

Taxslayer Bowl
Penn State (7-5) vs. Georgia (9-3)
January 2, 9:00 a.m.

Before the season, this would have looked like a great matchup, with a potential first-round QB in PSU’s Christian Hackenberg squaring off against a highly-regarded UGA team. Unfortunately, Hackenberg never looked that good, and the Bulldogs were a very disappointing 9-3, with zero wins of note in a bad division. I’ll take Georgia, but it’s not a happy pick, nor is this a good game.

Watchability: 1. Neither team inspires anything but yawns.

Autozone Liberty Bowl
Kansas State (6-6) vs. Arkansas (7-5)
January 2, 12:20 p.m.

This doesn’t seem like a particularly exciting January matchup at first glance, but Arkansas ended the year hot and looks ready to take the next step under Bret Bielema. The Razorbacks would have had six straight wins to end the year if not for a 51-50 shootout loss to Mississippi State, and their 53-52 upset of Ole Miss a couple weeks earlier was one of the year’s best games. If you’re wanting for a team that will get some attention next preseason, look no further. K-State lost to a lot of good teams, but 6-6 is 6-6, and the Wildcats aren’t winning this game.

Watchability: 2, but could hop up to a 3 if KSU puts up a fight.

Valero Alamo Bowl
Oregon (9-3) vs. TCU (10-2)
January 2, 3:45 p.m.

What a shame that Boykin made the decision to sneak out after curfew and get arrested after a bar fight. This promised to be one of the best matchups of the bowl season, featuring the two most dynamic quarterbacks in the country (sorry, Clemson’s Deshaun Watson) and a pair of hyper-fast, hyper-explosive offenses. Alas, it now appears to be Oregon’s game, unless the Horned Frogs put together a truly tremendous game plan. Ducks take it.

Watchability: 4, down from a solid 5 with Boykin.

Motel 6 Cactus Bowl
West Virginia (7-5) vs. Arizona State (6-6)
January 2, 7:15 p.m.

West Virginia should have beaten Kansas State to end the year, but it’s Arizona State that has the misleading record. The Sun Devils threw away games against Utah, Oregon and Cal, as inconsistency doomed a campaign that could have very well ended in the Pac-12 title game. ASU is a more dangerous pick, but the Mountaineers are missing All-Big 12 corner Daryl Worley due to academics and played in a softer conference. I like the Sun Devils in a minor upset, provided they can take care of the ball and rein in Dana Holgorsen’s high-octane attack.

Watchability: 3. Not elite squads, but there should be scoring.

College Football Playoff National Championship
Alabama (13-1) vs. Clemson (14-0)
January 11, 5:30 p.m.

Of course, Clemson is talented. The Tigers have built up their program in impressive fashion over the past several years, notched the key high-profile wins every rising team needs, and finally vanquished rival Florida State. Clemson upset an Oklahoma team a lot of people, myself included, thought would go on to win the title. It’s past time the Tigers started getting some respect.

But this is Alabama, and I simply can’t pick against the Crimson Tide. Once again, the SEC champs have an elite defense; once again, they’ve overcome doubts about their offense; once again, Nick Saban has proved that in the end, it’s recruiting that wins championships. Urban Meyer is the only coach I’d take against Saban in a one-game, winner-take-all scenario. Dabo Swinney has to prove his chops before I’ll give him the benefit of the doubt. As good and as capable of winning this game as Clemson is, the pick has to be the Tide.

Watchability: 5


It’s been a wild, unpredictable season, and we’ve seen that echoed in the bowl season. There are just a few games left, but most promise to be pretty fun. The National Championship should be, too. See you there.