Wednesday, October 15, 2014

The BCS was human after all

National Overview

It’s a little-known fact that Socrates was referring to college football when he said true wisdom comes from admitting one knows nothing. After Week 7 a mere six unbeatens remain: Florida State, Ole Miss, Mississippi State, Baylor, Marshall and… Notre Dame. It’s unlikely the four playoff contestants will come exclusively from this group, because four of the six play each other and Marshall won’t have the necessary strength of schedule. Heck, Baylor might not. So what now?

MSU should be the nation’s top team after knocking off LSU, Texas A&M and Auburn in consecutive weeks. Yes, LSU is now unranked and A&M should be, but that’s still a monstrous group to face in less than a month’s time. Florida State and Ole Miss are, in some order, the next teams in line. Things would be more clear had Texas A&M not looked so bad throughout SEC play. That’s not really fair to the Rebels, who had the misfortune of simply playing the Aggies a week later than the Bulldogs, but such is the unforgiving world of college football. The Seminoles have mostly sleepwalked through a garbage ACC schedule and finally get a chance for a big statement against Notre Dame this week.

The Fighting Irish had yet another close call with a bad North Carolina squad but once again survived to keep their playoff hopes alive. Without a conference affiliation and thus no chance for a 13th game before the postseason, Notre Dame will likely need to go undefeated to make the final four. That can definitely happen, as long as the Irish beat FSU this week. I’m skeptical of that outcome considering the game is in Tallahassee. However, if there’s one thing Notre Dame is it’s opportunistic, and the ‘Noles have clearly taken a step back this year with their sloppy play. Should be a good game.

It seems official that Mississippi State is now the 2014 version of last year’s Auburn team: a fast, athletic group that excels at running the ball and controlling the clock. God help the Bulldogs if they ever have to throw to win a game, but after the Tigers rode that formula to a near-title last season all bets are off. MSU is now the prohibitive favorite to win the West, I guess. It’s still very hard to trust this team with the games still remaining – at Alabama and Ole Miss – and the potential of an upset/letdown in the SEC Championship.

Baylor completed an epic comeback against TCU to stay unbeaten, though the Big 12 has always felt like a two-team league. Oklahoma lost to the Horned Frogs last week, but it still seems overwhelmingly likely the OU – Baylor game will decide the conference title (remember, the 10-team Big 12 is the only power league without a conference championship game). Good for Baylor, but the real test will come in a few weeks after both teams get a couple a weak tune-ups in the meantime.

The other big news from the weekend came from out west, where Oregon effectively ended the charade known as UCLA and USC knocked off an over-ranked Arizona squad to re-take control of the South Division, if only momentarily. The Ducks control their own destiny in the Pac-12 race, but more importantly actually looked like the old UO again. More on this in the Pac-12 section, where I’ll break down the only league more confusing than the SEC.

There’s a very exciting matchup Thursday night, when newly-ranked Utah meets Oregon State in Corvallis. A couple of good Big 12 contests kick off the weekend in Baylor – West Virginia and Kansas State – Oklahoma, while Texas A&M tries to save its season at Alabama. Oklahoma State and TCU complete the biggest week of the season for the Big 12, while Washington – Oregon and Stanford – Arizona State supply this week’s Pac-12 drama. Notre Dame and FSU play in primetime.

Playoff Poll

Once again, a shakeup. At this point I’m as confused anyone. The second and third tiers also see some movement, as we begin to question what we thought we knew about certain contenders.

College Football Playoff

1) Mississippi State vs. 4) Baylor
2) Florida State vs. 3) Ole Miss

MSU is a no brainer, even if I think the Bulldogs will drop one at some point. FSU gets the benefit of the doubt for a week, when the Notre Dame game should largely decide its fate. Ole Miss moves up one slot, while Baylor sneaks in over a group of other contenders.

Second Tier

Oregon
Michigan State
Oklahoma

Now the week-to-week movement becomes more pronounced. Oregon is back on the bubble, logically moving past Michigan State. Oklahoma didn’t look great against Texas, but that rivalry tends to be very close even when the teams are mismatched.

Third Tier

Notre Dame
Alabama
TCU

Notre Dame was in my third tier last week and shouldn’t move up after a close call against North Carolina. TCU is still in the Big 12 mix after the heartbreaking Baylor loss but will need to run the table from here on out. Alabama drops after an ugly win because the Crimson Tide haven’t beaten anyone.

Pac-12 Report

The death knell has nearly sounded for Washington State (though hopefully not for head coach Mike Leach’s time in Pullman). If the opening loss to Rutgers didn’t raise a red flag, the succeeding one to Nevada certainly did and it’s pretty much been downhill from there. Save for a great defensive effort and fourth-quarter comeback against Utah, the Cougars have simply not improved enough in the third year of the Leach era to contend in the Pac-12. Thursday saw WSU fall to 2-5 at Stanford in a depressingly predictable contest, with the Cardinal outgaining the Cougs by more than 200 yards and allowing a mere five of 19 third-down conversions.

From a basic schematic perspective, WSU’s struggles with Stanford clearly stem from Leach’s Air Raid system, which, despite its many strengths, is particularly ill-equipped to beat the Cardinal. The rigidity of the Air Raid, such as its insistence on four-receiver sets and near-refusal to run the ball, can work well against many opponents. But Stanford’s dominant front, populated with pass-rushers capable of quickly beating their blockers one-on-one, makes everything much more difficult for the Air Raid. Other spread teams like Oregon (even in losses to the Cardinal) have a great deal more flexibility when the primary offensive focus isn’t working, whereas the Cougars more or less have to try to pass their way out of any problems. The result sometimes isn’t pretty.

Washington – Cal was notable for being the first time all season we’ve seen either team play as expected. UW finally looked like the defensive force it was supposed to be, while the Bears actually looked overmatched for once. The Huskies built a giant lead, capitalized on Cal’s mistakes and bounced back nicely after the bumbling Stanford loss (and bye). We’ve gotten used to seeing the Bears look competent on the field this year, but this could be a potential turning point. The remaining six games are brutal: UCLA, Oregon, at Oregon State, at USC, Stanford and BYU. If only Cal had beaten Arizona! Two more wins to get to bowl eligibility seems like a lot to ask for from that schedule.

Oregon also rebounded nicely from a disappointing loss to throttle UCLA in Pasadena. I’ve been calling for it for a while and I think the national media is finally catching on – UCLA isn’t very good. In theory, there’s loads of talent on the Bruins’ roster, but you wouldn’t know that watching this team. UO smacked UCLA around for three quarters before the backups allowed the final score to look respectable, but make no mistake, this was a beatdown. It bodes well for the Ducks that getting one lineman – left tackle Jake Fisher – back from injury made this much of a difference, but the Bruins are in a world of trouble. My prediction from August that this squad was all hype seems to be coming true.

The last game of the week was Arizona’s upset loss to USC, if you can really call it that. Reactionary rankings happen all the time, but ‘Zona moving from unranked to 10th in the last poll was especially egregious. Look, the Wildcats are a good team. They played well against Oregon. But that was the first time all year UA had gotten a win of any quality and it came against a team that not only played poorly but was also down FOUR offensive linemen. Simply put, the Wildcats are not great. USC is flat-out better, despite being coached by Steve Sarkisian. The Trojans have the inside track to the title game again, because Arizona State (which holds the tiebreaker over SC) faces a murderer’s row the final seven games.*

*You thought Cal’s slate was nasty? How about Stanford, at Washington, Utah, Notre Dame, at Oregon State, Washington State and at Arizona? Yikes.

So, how about that Utah – Oregon State matchup? This is a very interesting contest that should make for great TV. I like Utah, which should be 5-0 and leading the South. The Utes appear to finally be ready to play for real in the Pac-12. But I also like OSU, a team that isn’t getting nearly enough credit going into this week. Reser Stadium is not an easy place to play and the Beavers defense has been impressively stout so far this year. I very much doubt OSU quarterback Sean Mannion is going to play as badly as he did at USC and the week off could only help the Beavs, a team that has seen a fair amount of injuries already. Moreover, how much do we know about Utes QB Kendal Thompson? He played fantastic against UCLA, taking over for the ineffective Travis Wilson, but that was the first extensive game action of his career. Oregon State could easily win this game.

UCLA is also on upset alert (although is it really an upset at this point?) at Cal. The Bears, as I said previously, badly need to win to keep the dream of a bowl game alive. They could find some traction against the wounded Bruins. To be clear, UCLA is the far more talented side and should win handily. The Bruins have the defensive athleticism to hem in the “Bear Raid” and the offensive firepower to make short work of the talent-strapped Bears D. Strange things can happen in this series, though. The teams have traded home blowouts the past four seasons despite Cal not being all that good… and UCLA won last year in Pasadena.

Colorado at USC is the only conference game this weekend that figures to be a complete dud, as CU – though much improved from the last two seasons – simply doesn’t have the horses (or Buffaloes, I guess) to keep up with SC. I don’t have a lot of faith in the coaching in L.A., but that shouldn’t matter too much against the talented, albeit thin, Trojans. Look for USC to revive the up-tempo attack it showed early in the year. It worked well against inferior competition before, so why not now? The Buffs will need a big game from QB Sefo Liufau to stay competitive and that still might not be enough.

Washington and Oregon renew their contentious rivalry in Eugene, though to be honest the rivalry could use some spicing up. UO has been quiet in victory, UW quiet in defeat these past ten years. As an Oregon fan I certainly don’t want to see anything but a big Ducks victory, sure. But nastiness has given way to respect (at least between the players) during this decade-long streak. The Huskies have the front seven capable of slowing Oregon’s offense to a crawl, which will be crucial because I don’t think the offense can win it alone. UW isn’t dynamic enough to win a shootout, so it will be up to the defense – particularly the line – to ground the Ducks and turn the game into a slugfest. Oregon should win… but the last time this team was a three-touchdown favorite at home, things didn’t go as planned.

The nightcap is Stanford at Arizona State, a matchup the Cardinal dominated in two meetings last year. ASU’s explosive but small offense had no answer for the monstrous Cardinal front, which forced the Sun Devils into short gains and miscues time and time again. The teams aren’t exactly the same this year. Stanford’s offense has, if anything, gotten worse. The same is true for the ASU D. However, in the end I expect this contest to end in similar fashion as in 2013 – with the Cardinal grinding things out, bleeding the clock and containing the Sun Devils’ big-play ability. Kevin Hogan not playing like garbage at QB would help.

Heisman Watch

The Heisman list is usually crowded at this point in the season. Not so this year. Surprisingly, upsets and off-field incidents have sapped the field of several contenders. FSU QB Jameis Winston is assuredly out. Georgia running back Todd Gurley might be suspended for the year. Baylor QB Bryce Petty weathered an early injury and has to play catch-up. Right now, these are the only guys worthy of consideration.

Marcus Mariota, QB, Oregon

Mariota is almost certainly the best player in the country and proves it every time he doesn’t have to play with three backup offensive linemen.

Dak Prescott, QB, Mississippi State

Prescott isn’t nearly the QB Mariota is, but he’s the type of gritty runner-passer who often garners Heisman buzz – especially on an undefeated team.

Evertt Golson, QB, Notre Dame

Golson has been inconsistent lately but was much improved at the start of the season and voters would love to see another winner from Notre Dame.

Random Thoughts and Observations

It’s time to re-evaluate the SEC West. Before the year started it looked like a three-team race between perennial heavyweights Alabama, LSU and Auburn, with Ole Miss as a potential dark horse. Two weeks into the season, Texas A&M had thrown its hat into the ring as well, creating a five-team minefield. When Mississippi State upset LSU in Week 5, it appeared nearly the entire division was playoff-worthy (and it’s not as if Arkansas is some patsy, either).

Now? The picture is somewhat less rosy. LSU has proved to be a pretender, with whispers that this is the worst Tigers defense under Les Miles. The same is true of Texas A&M, which got throttled in back-to-back weeks by the Mississippi schools. Ole Miss and MSU have been great, but Alabama and Auburn have been surprisingly pedestrian in many ways. Auburn should have lost to Kansas State and got beat by the first really good team it played, while Alabama… well, look at the Crimson Tide’s schedule and tell me exactly why this team has earned a top-ten poll spot.

The problem has been the domino effect, which has reared its head in several seasons of late. It all began this year with South Carolina, which has proved to be a mediocre squad. But in the preseason, the Gamecocks were ninth, which made Texas A&M’s blowout of SC on opening day highly impressive. The Aggies rode that “big” win to a No. 6 national ranking before getting exposed by the Mississippi schools. Mississippi State, in particular, benefitted from knocking off a “powerhouse” in A&M. Now, despite losing back-to-back games in decisive fashion, the Aggies are still ranked, because the teams that beat them are so good. What was a major contributing factor to Ole Miss and MSU being highly ranked? Beating A&M. There’s a problem here…

That’s not to say the SEC West isn’t a very tough division. It is. But despite the circuitous logic of the polls, it also clearly isn’t quite as dominant as September seemed to indicate. This is important to remember heading forward as the playoff committee begins to hash out the teams it thinks should get priority. Unless a very specific set of circumstances unfold, there’s no way a single division should get two teams into the playoff. That’s what the regular season of college football has always been about – weeding out teams in “one-game playoff” scenarios. The danger of moving to a true playoff has always been the potential of cheapening what is routinely called the greatest regular season in sports. The committee needs to ensure this doesn’t happen.

Speaking of the polls, well, even in the twilight of the BCS they’re proving just how fallible human voters are. This week, both the media and coaches’ polls have Michigan State above Oregon and Oklahoma over TCU. How does this pass the most basic logic test? All four teams have exactly one loss. Oregon beat Michigan State and TCU beat Oklahoma. On what planet does it make sense to have the Spartans and Sooners ranked ahead of the Ducks and Horned Frogs? For all the frustration with the BCS computers, it’s sobering to see that it was the human element that skewed the process all along.

Stanzi Watch

A three-time winner? Everett Golson may have this thing wrapped up before Halloween. Last season we didn’t get a single player with more than a pair of weekly Stanzis. Golson just notched his third in six games and there are already more two-time winners than all of last year. More proof that 2014 is turning into 2007, Part II. Here are this week’s winners and the updated standings.

Justin Holman, UCF
Opponent: BYU
Performance: Two INT, one FUM, won in overtime

Everett Golson, Notre Dame
Opponent: North Carolina
Performance: One INT (for TD), two FUM, won by seven

Bryce Petty, Baylor
Opponent: TCU
Performance: Two INT (one for TD), won by three

Dak Prescott, Mississippi State
Opponent: Auburn
Performance: Two INT, won by 15

Daxx Garman, Oklahoma State
Opponent: Kansas
Performance: One INT, one FUM, won by seven

Greg Ward, Jr., Houston
Opponent: Memphis
Performance: One INT, one FUM, won by four

Everett Golson, Notre Dame: 3
Jameis Winston, Florida State: 2
James Knapke, Bowling Green: 2
Fredi Knighten, Arkansas State: 2
Logan Woodside, Toledo: 2
Kevin Hogan, Stanford: 1
Blake Decker, UNLV: 1
Nick Arbuckle, Georgia State:1
Justin Holman, UCF: 1
Sean Maguire, Florida State: 1
Davis Webb, Texas Tech: 1
Patrick Towles, Kentucky: 1
Conner Halliday, WSU: 1
Tanner Lee, Tulane:1
Trevone, Boykin, TCU: 1
Reggie Bannafon, Louisville: 1
Grant Hedrick, Boise State: 1
Greg Ward, Jr., Houston: 1
Taysom Hill, BYU: 1
Jared Goff, California: 1
Bryce Petty, Baylor: 1
Tyler Jones, Texas State: 1
Garrett Grayson, Colorado State: 1
Anu Solomon, Arizona: 1
Michael Brewer, Virginia Tech: 1
Christian Hackenberg, Penn State: 1
Wes Lunt, Illinois: 1
Hutson Mason, Georgia: 1
Gunner Kiel, Cincinnati: 1
Sefo Liufau, Colorado: 1
Dak Prescott, Mississippi State: 1
C.J. Brown, Maryland: 1
Brian Burrell, Fresno State: 1
Nick Mullens, Southern Miss: 1
Angel Santiago, Army: 1
Grayson Lambert, Virginia: 1
Dane Evans, Tulsa: 1


The Stanzi list will need to be cut soon, to make room for those serious about winning. There will be no one-time winners here, no sir! My money is on Golson, but that's the fun thing about this game: you never know until the final whistle blows. 

Friday, October 10, 2014

Hail Mary madness

National Overview

Well, then. That was insane. This post took a long time to write thanks due to the inherent difficulty in processing what it was we witnessed last week, possibly the craziest in the 150-plus-year history of college football. Where to begin? Oregon’s stunning home flop against unranked Arizona? UCLA’s, to Utah? How about the brutal fate suffered by Alabama, Oklahoma, Texas A&M, LSU and Stanford, all of which bowed out on the road against ranked foes? In all, four of the top six, five of the top 10 and 10 of the top 25 teams ranked in the Week 6 AP Poll went down.

I said a few weeks ago we seemed headed for a 2007 redux, when no dominant team emerged and a two-loss LSU squad backdoored its way into a BCS title, but this is unprecedented territory. On Friday morning Oregon’s championship hopes appeared all but dashed; by midnight Saturday, the Ducks were as alive as anyone. With the exception of Florida State’s fluffy ACC schedule, no team will be favored to run the table. The SEC and Pac-12 are too good, the Big Ten’s last unbeaten squad (Nebraska) just lost and the Big 12… is just tough enough to predict a loss somewhere for both TCU and Baylor. As in 2007, things are going to come down to the final week of the season and the conference title games. Even then, it’s unlikely there will be four clear-cut playoff-worthy teams.

The biggest winners of the weekend were clearly the Mississippi schools, which responded to the national spotlight by going two-for-two against top-six teams. It’s hard to imagine either Ole Miss or Mississippi State finishing unbeaten in the rugged SEC West, though. While both are great stories, there’s a reason the Rebels and Bulldogs were predicted to finish behind multiple other powerhouses in their own division: talent. Good though both Mississippi teams are, Alabama, Auburn and possibly Texas A&M are all more stacked. Stumbles are inevitable.

Now the question becomes, “Which ranked team falls next?” Stanford (though it already lost twice) faces a dangerous Washington State team Friday. Oregon and UCLA meet in a potential playoff elimination game (ditto for Georgia – Missouri) and 5-0 Arizona has USC. However, the obvious choice(s) are the two matchups of top-10 foes: Auburn at Mississippi State and TCU at Baylor. We’ll finally get to see just how good this Baylor squad is, and while I’d lean toward Auburn, MSU has proved to be formidable.

There’s a handful of other good contests Saturday, such as the renewal of the Red River Shootout (never forget), Louisville versus Clemson, Ole Miss at Texas A&M (another chance for a top team to fall) and disappointing Washington at surprising Cal. Don’t laugh! Cal is in first place in the Pac-12 North! And keep an eye on Georgia Tech, sitting at 5-0 and hosting defending Coastal Division champ Duke. Fun all around.

Playoff Poll

The seismic shift last week threw my playoff into disarray. All four of my finalists went down. They’ll reappear in the second and third tiers this week, but the final four is all new. What a world we live in.

College Football Playoff

1) Auburn vs. 4) Ole Miss
2) Florida State vs. 3) Mississippi State

Gulp. Yeah, that’s three SEC schools. Fear not, though. All three reside in the same division and have to play each other. It’s unlikely more than one makes the final cut. I like MSU over Ole Miss because the Bulldogs have two quality wins (LSU, Texas A&M) to the Rebels’ one (Alabama).

Second Tier

Michigan State
Alabama
TCU
Oklahoma
Baylor

Close road losses to ranked teams keep the Crimson Tide and Sooners in the second group, while Michigan State quietly moves up after a dominating, then momentarily scary, victory over Nebraska that solidified the Spartans’ Big Ten dominance. TCU and Baylor will fight for the right to be considered for the final four this week.

Third Tier

Oregon
Texas A&M
Notre Dame

How times change. Oregon and A&M were the clear-cut leaders for the playoff after the first month of the season. Why not Arizona over the Ducks? Well, impressive though the Wildcats’ win was, it’s hard to argue ‘Zona is a better team overall than UO. I need to see more than an upset of a team with a wrecked offensive line to truly buy in. The Fighting Irish got lucky against Stanford, but they’re undefeated and should remain so until the Florida State matchup.

Pac-12 Report

Whoa. Who had both Oregon AND UCLA going down at home to unranked teams? Yeesh. If the conference championship game was held this week, the representatives would be Cal and Arizona. Approximately zero percent of analysts (or fans) saw that coming. Now, the Wildcats are better positioned to actually win their division because they’re A) simply better and B) just beat the most talented team on their schedule. Cal, although a surprising 4-1 (with a loss to Arizona that should have been a win), still has to face Oregon, Stanford, USC and UCLA. That’s too tough a slate to expect the Bears to navigate.

‘Zona’s upset of the Ducks really wasn’t that shocking when you consider the problems Oregon has. Losing four O-linemen to injury would cripple almost every team and the Wildcat’s 3-3-5 stack defense has traditionally given UO trouble. Arizona is also a good team in its own right. For the Ducks, the answer seems simple: if the line gets healthy, this can still be a very good team. If not, it won’t happen. Opponents will do exactly what WSU and Arizona did: beat the Ducks at the point of attack and force the offense into quick, short-yardage plays.

UCLA’s issues are actually even more widespread, which isn’t good if you’ve watched Oregon the past couple of games. The Bruins have been inconsistent in every area, massively disappointing on defense and seemingly unable to deal with any kind of adversity. Quarterback Brett Hundley has been merely average despite a wave of preseason hype. The offense has been predictable and the line has been among the worst in the country. You thought Ducks QB Marcus Mariota was dealing with pressure? Try being poor Hundley, who was sacked a ridiculous 10 times in the Utah loss alone. It will be interesting to see how both teams adjust this weekend when they meet.

Stanford blew the Notre Dame game because of course they did. The Cardinal’ M.O. the past few years has been to dominate in-conference and embarrass themselves outside it, as seen by pretty much every non-Pac-12 game Stanford has played in the David Shaw era. I’m still astounded the Stanford head coach is thought of so highly; his offenses have been pathetically vanilla and his default strategy is to go ultra-conservative and lean on the defense to win games. When will his coaching acumen finally be questioned?

Because this is the Pac-12, all three of the late games (of which Utah – UCLA was one) went down to the wire. Arizona State and backup QB Mike Bercovici showed remarkable poise in never giving up at USC and winning on (yet another) wild Hail Mary. Bercovici threw for 510 yards and five touchdowns without an interception, incredible numbers for a guy making his first road start. SC’s defense, on the other hand, was abysmal, allowing scores on plays of 73 and 46 yards in the final three minutes.

However, that wasn’t even (arguably) the craziest moment of the night. Washington State and Cal staged a laughably defense-free shootout on the Palouse, combining for more than 1,200 yards passing and 12 TD’s. The Cougars’ Connor Halliday set an NCAA record with 734 yards, yet WSU still lost. How? Couging it, of course: a missed chip-shot field goal as time expired. Still, Wazzu could have put the game away much earlier had it not allowed back-to-back kickoff return TD’s in the third quarter. This was a total team loss.

So what’s on tap this week? Glad you asked. WSU is at Stanford Friday, and while the Cardinal have fared quite well against the Air Raid in the past it’s hard to feel particularly confident about this Stanford team. The Cougars are in desperation mode and have the playmakers to give any defense trouble. Oregon –UCLA will be a referendum on which preseason favorite was more overrated, while Washington heads to Cal to try to save their season. An 0-2 league start would be devastating for the Huskies, but the Bears could move to 3-1 and be one win away from bowl eligibility by knocking off UW.

The last game is USC, another disappointment, at Arizona. SC is undoubtedly the more talented squad. Unfortunately, in an all-too-familiar scenario for fans of a Steve Sarkisian-coached team, the Trojans don’t seem to be getting the most out of their players. Arizona has really only looked great in two games – the opener against UNLV and last week – so it certainly wouldn’t be out of the question for the Wildcats to have a come-down loss here. But that also puts a lot of the onus on Sarkisian to actually get things done, which is apparently asking a lot.

Random Thoughts and Observations

 The bizarre rise of the national Hail Mary success rate this season has to be addressed. There are always a few last-gasp desperation heaves that work out in the course of a season, but 2014 has seen the Hail Mary literally go viral. I’ve lost track of how many games have seen a successful one, and we’re only in Week 7. Off the top of my head, there were halftime Hail Mary’s in Houston – BYU and Oregon State – USC as well as the game winners in Arizona – Cal and Arizona State – USC and another mid-major contest I can’t quite recall. While the Hail Mary is scary for a defense, it has that name for a reason: it’s supposed to be a lucky play to convert.

Who’s to blame for the spike this year? Defensive backs across the country are at fault, to be sure. However, the bigger problem has to be coaching. In any kind of late-game jump ball scenario, defenders are (or should be) taught to bat the ball down or, as a last resort, tackle the receiver for a penalty rather than allow a game-winning completion. Look at the “Jael Mary” from ASU – USC. Two Trojans attempt to cradle catch the football, while the Sun Devils’ Jaelen Strong (for whom the play is named) leaps in front and high-points the ball. Uncontested TD, and a black eye for the SC staff.

Stanzi Watch

It was a somewhat quieter week for the Stanzis, but there were a couple of notable performances. Florida’s Jeff Driskel avoided a Stanzi because he was pulled before backup Treon Harris saved the day against Tennessee. However, Arkansas State’s Fredi Knighten, Toledo’s Logan Woodside, Notre Dame’s Everett Golson and Bowling Green’s James Knapke all joined the multiple winners club, giving FSU’s Jameis Winston some competition. At this rate, we’ll have a photo finish for college football’s most ignominious award! Here are this week’s winners and the standings.

Brian Burrell, Fresno State
Opponent: San Diego State
Performance: One INT, one FUM, won by 11

James Knapke, Bowling Green
Opponent: Buffalo
Performance: One INT, one FUM, won by one

Trevone Boykin, TCU
Opponent: Oklahoma
Performance: One INT, three FUM (one lost), won by four

Everett Golson, Notre Dame
Opponent: Stanford
Performance: One INT, one FUM, won by three

Tyler Jones, Texas State
Opponent: Idaho
Performance: Two INT, won by five

Fredi Knighten, Arkansas State
Opponent: Louisiana-Monroe
Performance: Two INT, one FUM, won by 14

Grant Hedrick, Boise State
Opponent: Nevada
Performance: One INT (for TD), one FUM, won by five

Logan Woodside, Toledo
Opponent: Western Michigan
Performance: One INT, one FUM, won by one

Jameis Winston, Florida State: 2
James Knapke, Bowling Green: 2
Everett Golson, Notre Dame: 2
Fredi Knighten, Arkansas State: 2
Logan Woodside, Toledo: 2
Kevin Hogan, Stanford: 1
Blake Decker, UNLV: 1
Nick Arbuckle, Georgia State: 1
Sean Maguire, Florida State: 1
Davis Webb, Texas Tech: 1
Patrick Towles, Kentucky: 1
Conner Halliday, WSU: 1
Tanner Lee, Tulane: 1
Reggie Bonnafon, Louisville: 1
Taysom Hill, BYU: 1
Jared Goff, California: 1
Garrett Grayson, Colorado State: 1
Anu Solomon, Arizona: 1
Michael Brewer, Virginia Tech: 1
Christian Hackenberg, Penn State: 1
Wes Lunt, Illinois: 1
Hutson Mason, Georgia: 1
Gunner Kiel, Cincinnati: 1
Sefo Liufao, Colorado: 1
C.J. Brown, Maryland: 1
Daxx Garman, Oklahoma State: 1
Nick Mullens, Southern Miss: 1
Angel Santiago, Army: 1
Grayson Lambert, Virginia: 1
Dane Evans, Tulsa: 1



What a season this is becoming. After the past few weeks there’s no reason to expect anything less than complete madness. The best thing to do is sit back and watch it unfold.

Thursday, October 2, 2014

Michigan's folly

National Overview

Mmm-hmm. A person could get used to the filet mignon that was Week 5. The party started Thursday night in Lubbock and didn’t end until late Saturday in Salt Lake City. In between we got a handful of shootouts, a Heisman statement (and a Stanzi statement!) and very nearly saw the nation’s top-ranked team go down. Now that’s some good eating. If October can match what the end of September provided, college football fans will be stuffed long before Thanksgiving.

Texas Tech actually held serve quite impressively against Oklahoma State but for an inexplicable inability to diagnose and defend the Cowboys’ deep ball. OSU quarterback Daxx Garman went nuts with his speedy home run-hitting receivers, completing seven passes of 20 or more yards. Yet the game was still in doubt until Tech QB Davis Webb left the game in the fourth quarter with a shoulder injury. Bad news for the Red Raiders, but a strong showing for Okie State to come back after a lifeless first quarter.

The big Pac-12 showdown materialized, then evaporated, in a bizarre game in Tempe behind a flurry of big plays from UCLA. Arizona State held a 17-6 lead early in the second quarter, then was hit by a 42-3 avalanche over the next 20 minutes of game time. The Bruins’ Brett Hundley returned from injury to post perhaps the best game of his career, as the QB tossed four touchdowns without an interception go along with 355 yards through the air. Were the doubters wrong all along? More on this later.

Georgia outlasted Tennessee in a back-and-forth affair that saw RB Todd Gurley’s Heisman hopes revived in a big way, thanks to a career high 208 yards on the ground. The Bulldogs are still hanging around in the SEC (and championship) discussion because of South Carolina’s second conference loss (the Gamecocks just can’t get out of their own way). UGA has too many issues on both sides to be considered a true contender, but in the surprisingly watered-down East this team has a great shot at a return to Atlanta.

Florida State’s second-half rally at North Carolina State – a place the Seminoles have struggled historically, for some reason – was enough to save an undefeated season, but it revealed even larger cracks in FSU’s armor that are getting harder and harder to ignore. I already moved the ‘Noles out of my playoff group last week; with more performances like this it wouldn’t be a surprise to see pollsters do the same. The ACC is not very good and style points are necessary. This is a new era for college football. Slipping by in a weak league is no longer a free ticket to the big game.

Texas A&M also had its closest call to date, coming back from a 14-point deficit to win in overtime. Arkansas closed poorly, but the Aggies really didn’t deserve to win. After witnessing South Carolina’s struggles, it’s looking more and more like this A&M squad is very good but not elite. We’ll see when the Aggies move into the meat of the SEC schedule. The West is a unforgiving minefield and at this point I don’t see any team navigating it unscathed.

Stanford also managed to live another day after a horrendously ugly game at Washington. Neither offense had much success doing anything and the 13-13 halftime score stood until the winning TD at the 4:29 mark of the fourth quarter. While UW’s hopes for much of anything out of the 2014 season are all but dashed, the Cardinal have once again positioned themselves to play the role of tortoise to Oregon’s hare in the Pac-12 race. The North will be very interesting to watch unfold.

In Big Ten news, the conference’s undefeated teams were whittled to one when Penn State got hammered at home by Northwestern, virtually assuring the Nittany Lions will be shut out of the new playoff. 5-0 Nebraska travels to Michigan State this week in a game that will likely serve as an eliminator for the national championship. MSU can’t afford another loss but is otherwise alive and well in the playoff chase, while the Cornhuskers could make a huge statement with a road win over the Spartans. I think MSU is easily the better team, but Nebraska has been tough to pin down over the past several seasons.

Several other big matchups loom as we enter October: Arizona – Oregon on Thursday night is a major trap game for the Ducks; there’s a trio of giant SEC West showdowns in Texas A&M – Mississippi State, Alabama – Ole Miss and LSU – Auburn; TCU opens Big 12 play by hosting Oklahoma; Stanford renews its rivalry with Notre Dame; Arizona State gets a chance at redemption at USC (where QB Taylor Kelly may return), and of course there’s Nebraska and Michigan State. October is upon us.

Playoff Poll

As I explained last week, it feels wrong to write a top 25 when we’re living in a post-BCS world. Instead, I’ll be doing a power poll for the “last four in” or playoff participants, followed by a second and third tier of contenders. It will look similar to how the NCAA Tournament "bubble" is formulated, with an emphasis on recent performances and the body of work in relation to other teams. Here is my first playoff power poll.

College Football Playoff

1) Oregon vs. 4) Oklahoma
2) Texas A&M vs. 3) Alabama

Oregon retains the top spot (barely) thanks to the best win any team has all year: 46-27 over Michigan State. Texas A&M nearly slipped but has a pair of decent wins: at South Carolina and against Arkansas in Arlington. Alabama has looked very good – though not, perhaps, at the level people expected – and hasn’t played anyone. Oklahoma has been more dominant than Alabama but struggled in its first game against a real team.

Second Tier

Florida State
Auburn

Just two schools for now. Auburn is lucky to be here following that near-loss at Kansas State, while FSU simply cannot be in the top four after playing three underwhelming games against all three of its FBS foes.

Third Tier
Michigan State
Baylor
UCLA
Mississippi State

The Spartans have the potential to run roughshod over the Big Ten and they’ll need to in order to move up. Baylor has a scary ceiling but is more susceptible to a “blown tire” loss than any other contender. UCLA gets credit for that big win at ASU but will need to continue to play like that to keep my trust. Mississippi State is the first real darkhorse after crushing LSU (although the Bulldogs nearly gave the game away late).

Pac-12 Overview

Well, let’s start with the Thursday showdown. UCLA at ASU. Two top-15 teams, albeit one missing its star QB. The Sun Devils had the home-field edge and came out hot. Then the Bruins responded with a 28-0 run that turned a 17-6 deficit into a 34-17 lead. UCLA scored in all three phases and had four TD’s of 80 yards (!) or more. ASU never got closer than 14 the rest of the way. It was a statement for the away team as it flexed its top-10/playoff bona fides. At least, that’s what the media narrative seems to be. It’s not exactly what happened.

Make no mistake, the Bruins turned things around in impressive fashion. ASU looked like the better team in the first quarter and then very suddenly didn’t. But a lot of inadequacies got covered up by a perfect storm of turnovers, situational play and luck. For one, UCLA will go another 50 years before it scores four TD’s of 80 or more yards in a single game. That kind of explosion just doesn’t happen. And yes, UCLA did win by 35 – but the defense gave up 626 yards to an offense helmed by a backup QB making his first start. The Sun Devils had four turnovers to the Bruins’ none, which made a reasonably close game look like a rout. And finally, ASU’s defense, as I explained in the preseason, could be the conference’s worst along with Colorado and Cal’s.

All this doesn’t mean UCLA isn’t good. It just means the praise emanating from the media (who picked the team to be better than it has been, if you recall) are far more self-serving than realistic. The Bruins still face a tough schedule and are by no means a favorite – yet – to make the playoff. Let’s see them win the division before we make grandiose predictions. A strong performance against Utah this week would be a good start and prove this team can be consistent.

Colorado – Cal sure was fun, eh? Seven TD passes on either side (tying an NCAA record), a frantic comeback followed by another frantic comeback and double OT. Not bad for the league’s alleged bottom-feeders. Granted, both defenses are pretty bad. But the Buffaloes and Bears are a combined 5-4 after this week, which doesn’t exactly scream “awful.” Cal, in particular, should be 4-0. I had the Bears pegged for two or three wins this year, but if the D can improve a bit the offense might be good enough to drag this squad into bowl contention.

There’s not much more to be said about Stanford – Washington I didn’t bring up earlier. The Huskies are clearly not ready to take that next step despite upgrading their coaching situation. The offense was abysmal against the Cardinal. Cyler Miles may or may not be the answer at QB, but the problems are much more wide-ranging than that. We now have five games of evidence to prove UW isn’t consistent at all. For the team to have any shot at competing in this conference that has to change. As for Stanford… well, Stanford is as Stanford does. It doesn’t seem to matter how bad QB Kevin Hogan plays. The defense will bail the offense out a half-dozen times. The other team will have at least one big play called back by penalty. And the Cardinal will generally win. So it goes.

Washington State got a season-saving win at Utah Saturday night, coming back from 21-0 and 27-10 holes to upend the previously undefeated Utes 28-27. It was a nice win for the Cougars, who truly deserved to win. Utah’s offense was curiously anemic against WSU’s famously soft D, failing to produce anything on offense outside of one long run. Then the defense collapsed in the fourth, costing the Utes a chance at a 4-0 start. I didn’t expect Utah to be a real player in the South race, but it was possible with a victory. Wazzu has an uphill climb to get back to bowl eligibility, but it’s nip-and-tuck wins like this that will make it happen.

The final game of the week was unfortunately a dud, as Oregon State stumbled to a 35-10 defeat in L.A. USC is a better team than the Beavers, but OSU showed a surprising lack of composure. I’m still not convinced the Trojans are that great, and all the Beavs could manage on offense was a field goal. Part of the problem was QB Sean Mannion, who turned in possibly the worst game of his career. However, the overall issue seems to be that OSU just isn’t very good. This team is in about the same place as it was last year, minus a superstar receiver in Brandin Cooks. Seven wins feels about right. SC is definitely one of the South favorites, although we’ll be able to confirm that – or not – this week against ASU.

If Taylor Kelly plays this week everything changes. I like ASU’s offense regardless, but Kelly makes the Sun Devils a whole different beast. It’s not exactly going out on a limb to predict a big day for the Trojans offense. If Kelly is good to go, Sparky can make this a shootout. I don’t know if ASU can win a grind-it-out affair. There’s a reason people still have faith in this SC squad: the Trojans have some athletes the Sun Devils can’t match. At one month into the season, though, this might be when USC’s depth issue (due to sanctions) rears its ugly head. I hope that’s not the case.

The Arizona – Oregon game Thursday is one people have been waiting for. On paper, the Ducks should cruise. ‘Zona’s defense is pretty bad, the offense has been up and down since the opener and the Wildcats are starting a freshman QB at Autzen. That feels like a recipe for disaster. But any honest Oregon fan could point out the biggest problem for UO so far this season: pass defense. The Ducks, whether by accident or design, have been content to drop everyone into soft coverage and let teams carve it up underneath. That’s a problem against the talented UA receivers, who can really make teams pay. Oregon should win, but the huge line (24 points) seems high.

Stanford gets a small chance at revenge for 2012’s Bad Officiating masterpiece when it returns to Notre Dame Stadium. The Cardinal haven’t looked great against quality competition this year, but I’m very hesitant to accept this Fighting Irish team is the real deal. They’re 4-0, but they haven’t played anyone. Stanford absolutely has what it takes to go on the road and get another gritty, ugly win. It’s so hard to trust this team, though. Will Hogan come through, or will the embattled Cardinal QB drop another multiple-turnover dud? Can the D save the offense yet again? Is Notre Dame really that good? We’ll find out Saturday.

Oregon State had better beware – this is not the same Colorado Buffaloes team from last year. Going into Folsom Field isn’t an easy task for any team, especially one playing there for the first time in 50 years. CU has improved substantially over the past couple of seasons and is finally ready to start competing – if not contending – in the Pac-12. OSU has looked shaky thus far. The Beavers are a better team, but if enough goes right for the Buffs early we could see this become a solid game. At the very least, it shouldn’t be a repeat of 2013’s 44-17 laugher in Corvallis.

It will be interesting to see how UCLA responds at home against Utah after notching its biggest win of the season. Utah’s reaction to that heartbreaking loss to WSU will also be intriguing. This was very nearly a matchup of two undefeated (and presumably ranked) teams. Can the Bruins keep the momentum going from that ridiculous outburst against the Sun Devils? They shouldn’t need to in order to win, but the Utes are a feisty bunch and will be smarting from last week’s frustrating finish. I expect Utah to keep it close for a half before falling too far behind… unless UCLA reverts to its early-season form.

The other late game is Cal at WSU, which should give us yet another marvelous reason to watch the Bears. Cal has played back-to-back high-scoring thrillers and there’s no real reason to expect anything different this week. I don’t think the Cougars are any better than Arizona, who the Bears should have beat. This collision of Air Raid attacks should feature roughly 120 passes and could even challenge Cal’s game last week with Colorado in the “TD passes thrown” department. I favor the Cougs at home, but there’s something about this improved Bears squad that I like. Wouldn’t be surprised to see it go either way.

Random Thoughts and Observations

There’s been so much turmoil around the Michigan program it’s hard to know where to begin with this. Let’s start with the facts. The Wolverines are the most successful program in FBS history, with 912 wins. They have the second-highest winning percentage of all time at .731, are third in recognized national championships with 11 and are one of only four teams to hold a winning record versus every conference, including independents (the others are Notre Dame, Ohio State and Tennessee). This is a top-five program all-time any way you look at it. So why does it feel like UM has fallen into an irreparable state of decay? There are several factors, but in my estimation it stems from a toxic combination of arrogance, ignorance and unwillingness to adapt to the changing football landscape.

Since longtime coach Lloyd Carr (a disciple of legendary head man Bo Schembechler) was forced into retirement following the 2007 season, the Wolverines have taken a wild ride on the coaching carousel. At the time, Carr was viewed as a man who had seen the game pass him by, unable to respond to the new up-tempo spread attacks taking over the sport. This notion undoubtedly gained traction following the 2006 regular-season finale against rival Ohio State, when the previously stout Wolverines D was shredded by the Buckeyes’ spread offense. It was then bolstered after the stunning loss to Appalachian State to start the 2007 season and subsequent blowout defeat at the hands of Oregon, both of which ran fast-paced, futuristic spreads. Carr was said to be a coach who didn’t use his program’s talent to the best of its ability.

The move was not without controversy. Carr, after all, had led the team to the 1997 national title. More importantly, he was a “Michigan Man,” a nebulous term used in Ann Arbor for decades to describe players and coaches who did things the Right Way, from academics to sportsmanship to – above all – loyalty to the university. Carr had served under Schembechler, the ultimate Michigan Man, who is revered to this day by the Wolverine faithful. However, ultimately disappointment over how the 2007 season (with sky-high expectations) ended won out. Carr was gone.

Enter Rich Rodriguez. One of the early architects of the spread and zone-read, Rodriguez had built a minor dynasty at West Virginia. His teams led the now-defunct Big East out of the dark period that followed the defections of Miami (FL), Virginia Tech and Boston College to the ACC (the move that triggered the chain reaction of all conference realignment since) and reshaped the entire conference with style and substance, including a massive 2005 Sugar Bowl upset of SEC champion Georgia. Michigan, naturally, figured the best way to beat the spread was to hire a master of it. Unfortunately for all parties, this was destined to look like a knee-jerk reaction.

Rodriguez, for all his faults (which we’ll get to), was placed in a no-win situation. From the start, his tenure was marred by a not-insignificant faction of Michigan boosters and supporters who viewed their new coach with suspicion, if not downright disdain. Rodriguez was not a Michigan Man. He was a country bumpkin, born and raised in West Virginia. What right did he have to lead the great Michigan Wolverines? To make matters worse, Rodriguez wanted to change the entire identity of Michigan football, moving the team into a multiple-receiver offense that emphasized speed over power.

Never mind that this was exactly what the administration had in mind when Rodriguez was hired. It was a flagrant violation of the Michigan Way, of time-honored Big Ten principles such as running the ball downhill and bludgeoning opposing defenses into submission. The new offense was viewed as a fad, a gimmick, one that couldn’t possibly succeed in a “real” conference. Many players even bought into this and left the program. In this regard, Rodriguez was doomed from the start.

History has proved those doubters wrong. Even while Rodriguez posted middling records during his three-year tenure, Michigan’s offense was superb, going from 20 points per game in his first season to nearly 33 in his last. Moreover, the success nationwide of spread tactics has shown the “three yards and a cloud of dust” crowd to be woefully behind the times. The spread is here to stay. However, Rodriguez’s 15-22 record (largely due to his poor defenses) convinced the old guard they were right all along about this charlatan who didn’t play “big-boy football.” Rodriguez was fired in 2010.

All of this is not to say Rodriguez was blameless. He was, and remains, a mediocre defensive coach. The lack of progress made by his third season was not promising. NCAA sanctions regarding unauthorized extra practices were a black eye for the program. Yet there is little doubt he knows how to design quality offenses. His success at West Virginia and now Arizona speaks to that. Rodriguez’s ignominious time in Ann Arbor illustrates the importance of cohesion between an athletic department, a coach and a fan base. He was set up to fail, and he did.

However, the worst part of Rodriguez’s legacy at Michigan is the errant philosophical mindset he engendered among Wolverines boosters and higher-ups. Here was all the proof they had ever needed that spread offenses were nothing but smoke and mirrors. What the team needed in order to turn around was a return to Michigan football: running the ball from the I-formation and playing defense. That was what had worked for decades and what would still work now. With that in mind, UM hired Brady Hoke in 2011.

Hoke is an interesting case. Prior to his arrival at Michigan he was viewed as something of a defensive mastermind. He had only ever coached at mid-major schools, but spent time at UM as an assistant, so he qualified as a Michigan Man. The national narrative was that he would return the Wolverines to their roots with pro-style offensive formations and tough-minded D – just what Michigan wanted. And lo and behold, it worked: in Hoke’s first season UM won 11 games and upset Virginia Tech in the Sugar Bowl. Hosannas rang out in Ann Arbor, for Michigan was surely “back.”

The picture is a little grimmer now. After riding Rodriguez’s excellent classes (he did recruit well) to that sterling record in 2011, the Wolverines stumbled to 8-5 and 7-6 finishes the next two years and have started 2014 2-3. The defense has declined each of the past two seasons. To make matters worse, Michigan had an ugly and embarrassing episode last week when Hoke allowed QB Shane Morris to return to the field following a concussion, then compounded that error by claiming Morris “said he was fine.” Not only did this fly in the face of any injury protocol (let alone for concussions), it made Hoke look confused and oblivious to player safety. The rally on campus Tuesday to oust Hoke and athletic director Dave Brandon looked even worse.

So what happened? Did Hoke forget how to coach? Going back through his previous stops, the answer seems a little more obvious. Hoke spent six season at Ball State, going 4-8, 2-9, 4-7, 5-7, 7-6 and 12-1. Which season seems like the outlier? Nevertheless, it was enough for San Diego State to hire him before the Cardinals’ bowl game in 2008. Hoke promptly went 4-8, then 9-4 before moving on to Michigan. Once again, a program decided one good year was enough to qualify him as a great coach.

Combined with his in-progress numbers at UM, Hoke is 75-66 overall in 11-plus seasons as a head coach. His best years at each school are marked by one very specific thing: exceptional QB play. In 2008, Hoke’s middling tenure at Ball State was jolted to life by a 12-0 regular season, led by Nate Davis, the school’s all-time leading passer (at the time). Hoke parlayed that into a new job, where, after a 4-8 debut, he went 9-4, thanks to Ryan Lindley, who would finish his career as that school’s all-time leading passer. Once again, Hoke got a new gig. In his first year on the job, Michigan’s Denard Robinson – definitely an up-and-down player, but inarguably the most electric QB the Wolverines have ever had – posted a career-best 36 TD’s. What’s the common denominator here?

I don’t think Hoke is a bad coach, but it seems apparent he’s an average one who capitalized on some good fortune to move to a job above his station. I don’t blame him, but the on-field results speak for themselves. I doubt he makes it out of this season as the Wolverines’ head coach, and after this concussion incident, he shouldn’t. That would send the team right back to where it was not just four years ago, but seven; except this time, the old methods have failed. Michigan is not viewed as favorably as a coaching destination as it was when Carr left. The spread didn’t work. The old-school approach didn’t work. UM is 1-9 against Ohio State the last decade. It’s a dark time for the Wolverines. But after going through the events that led to this point, it’s hard to argue the program didn’t bring it upon itself.

Stanzi Watch

There were a couple of Stanzis this week I didn’t feel good about handing out because the players who earned them otherwise played so well. But rules are rules. I can’t go easy on guys because they also threw for a couple of scores. Turnovers are the biggest controllable factor for QB’s. As such, Week 5 saw the most weekly Stanzi winners ever, as an astounding 12 signal-callers picked up close wins despite handing the ball to the opposition. We also got out first two-time Stanzi-er of the season. Here are this week’s winners and the overall standings.

Daxx Garman, Oklahoma State
Opponent: Texas Tech
Performance: Two INT, held on for 10-point win

Hutson Mason, Georgia
Opponent: Tennessee
Performance: Two INT, won by three

Patrick Towles, Kentucky
Opponent: Vanderbilt
Performance: One INT (for TD), three FUM (lost two), won by 10

Garrett Grayson, Colorado State
Opponent: Boston College
Performance: Two INT, won by 3

James Knapke, Bowling Green
Opponent: Massachusetts
Performance: Three INT, won by five

Jameis Winston, Florida State
Opponent: North Carolina State
Performance: Two INT, one FUM, won by 15

Reggie Bonnafon, Louisville
Opponent: Wake Forest
Performance: Two FUM (one for TD), won by 10

Jared Goff, California
Opponent: Colorado
Performance: One INT, one FUM, won by three

Kevin Hogan, Stanford
Opponent: Washington
Performance: One INT, two FUM, won by seven

Logan Woodside, Toledo
Opponent: Central Michigan
Performance: One INT, one FUM, won by 14

Everett Golson, Notre Dame
Opponent: Syracuse
Performance: Two INT, three FUM (lost two), won by 16

Connor Halliday, Washington State
Opponent: Utah
Performance: Two INT (one for TD), one FUM, won by one

Blake Decker, UNLV: 1
Nick Arbuckle, Georgia State: 1
Fredi Knighten, Arkansas State: 1
Sean Maguire, Florida State: 1
Davis Webb, Texas Tech: 1
Tanner Lee, Tulane: 1
Taysom Hill, BYU: 1
Anu Solomon, Arizona: 1
Michael Brewer, Virginia Tech: 1
Christian Hackenberg, Penn State: 1
Wes Lunt, Illinois: 1
Gunner Kiel, Cincinnati: 1
Sefo Liufau, Colorado: 1
C.J. Brown, Maryland: 1
Logan Woodside, Toledo: 1
Nick Mullens, Southern Miss: 1
Angel Santiago, Army: 1
Grayson Lambert, Virginia: 1
Dane Evans, Tulsa: 1
Jameis Winston, Florida State: 1


The real season has begun. Thank goodness.

Thursday, September 25, 2014

The long and winding road

National Overview

Last week didn’t look particularly good on paper, but as the saying goes, that’s why they play the games. Starting with Thursday’s showdown in the Little Apple, Week 4 provided thrills and near-shockers across the board. Auburn survived that trip to Manhattan with a “quality” win over Kansas State but provided the doubters with a lot of ammunition. The Tigers were fortunate to benefit from a deluge of K-State miscues and probably should have lost. The same can easily be said for defending champion Florida State, which looked downright average against a Clemson team that might not be very good at all. Oregon also escaped an inferior opponent when Washington State was unable to get one last equalizing score, while Oklahoma, so dominant in the first few weeks, was somewhat exposed by West Virginia.

What does this all mean? As usual, it probably indicates no one is quite as good as people think. This could end up being one of those years when no truly dominant team emerges, like 2007 or 2010. People seem to forget that seasons in which a juggernaut (or two) thrashes everyone in sight (such as 2005 USC/Texas or 2014 FSU) are more the exception than the norm. Every contender (with the possible exception of Texas A&M) has shown legitimate problem areas thus far, from Oregon and Alabama’s pass defense to Oklahoma’s pass offense to Florida State’s… whatever that was without quarterback Jameis Winston.

Back to that Auburn – Kansas State contest. Credit AU for getting it done in the fourth quarter, but if things went even remotely the Wildcats’ way the outcome would have been very different. KSU gifted the Tigers a pair of extremely lucky early turnovers and missed three field goals that should have put Auburn into a deep hole. Had the Tigers been forced to rely on QB Nick Marshall’s passing to win, they wouldn’t have.

As frustrated as the Wildcats might be, though, there’s no one in the country more angry than Clemson this week. The Tigers had every opportunity to put FSU away and probably should have. From a comically inept (and ill-timed) bad snap to missed field goals to blown coverages, this edition of “pulling a Clemson” (the East Coast version of “Couging it”) was the Clemsoniest Clemsoning yet. As a result, the Seminoles now have the easiest path of any contender to the playoffs. But would they deserve a spot there if they do pull off an undefeated season? More on that in a moment.

The final week of September yields the most impressive crop of games so far. Texas Tech and Oklahoma State meet Thursday in both teams’ Big 12 opener, while UCLA heads to Tempe that same night to face defending division champion Arizona State. Minnesota and Michigan rekindle their ancient rivalry Saturday, as do old Southwest Conference foes Arkansas and Texas A&M. Florida State is at North Carolina State in an intriguing, if not particularly promising, matchup. More interesting is Stanford’s visit to Washington in a series that has been razor-close lately. In yet another chance for Big Ten misery, Cincinnati’s trip to in-state rival Ohio State has major implications. Finally, the nightcap of Oregon State – USC should be competitive and watchable. The wait is over. It’s the first slate of quality games this season.

Top 25

I’ve tentatively decided on creating a power poll instead of a traditional ranking for the playoff candidates from this point forward. The poll will consist of the four teams most deserving to be included based on their resumes to that point, along with a short list of the teams on the “bubble,” much like with the NCAA Tournament. The first full power poll will come out next week, but for the moment the top four teams are, in some order: Texas A&M, Alabama, Oregon and Oklahoma. Those schools have looked the best the most consistently in 2014.

Note: Top-ranked Florida State is not currently included because the Seminoles have not been impressive in two of three games this season. To make things more interesting, the schedule from here on out is extremely weak. Without a series of dominant wins the rest of the way FSU could find itself left out of the playoff.

Additionally, I suppose I shouldn’t be surprised Mississippi State posted its best win in more than a decade just after I gave the Bulldogs my ultimate vote of no confidence last week. Oh, well. MSU’s road blowout of LSU – though the Tigers may not be that good – is one of the best wins any team has posted this year and moves State to the playoff bubble.

Pac-12 Report

Oregon’s struggles at Washington State were, as I predicted last week, not entirely shocking. WSU is the best passing team in the nation, Oregon’s corners are mostly inexperienced and the Ducks have tended to give up yards in chunks against one-dimensional offenses the past few years. The good news is UO won’t face another foe as pass-happy (and as competent doing it) as Wazzu all year. Unfortunately, there are some other issues that might come back to haunt this team.

The pass defense is a fairly fixable problem, or at least, it would be in any other conference. But the Pac-12 is a cruel and unforgiving mistress to weak secondaries. Oregon still has the ability to tighten things up, but it’s hard to imagine this suddenly becoming an elite unit. Then there’s the offensive line, which has gone from perhaps the team’s greatest strength to barely hanging on after a rash of injuries. QB Marcus Mariota was sacked seven times in Pullman and the Ducks failed to rush for 200 yards, a rarity for this offense. If reinforcements don’t arrive soon, UO will succumb to the brutal conference schedule.

It was delightful to see Cal and Arizona go down to the wire, but bittersweet to see the Bears blow a 22-point halftime lead in Tucson and fail to go to 3-0. Simply put, Cal deserved the win. Arizona is the better team, no doubt; despite shooting itself it the foot numerous times, the Wildcats moved the ball at will. The Bears should still have stolen the W, but ‘Zona survived and now enters the meat of the Pac-12 schedule in great shape to play a major role in the South race.

As for Cal, the Bears suffered their first loss but surely must feel better about their chances in league play than in 2013. The defense is going to get lit up a whole bunch, but the offense has proved to be worthy of a major-conference squad. At the very least, Cal seems to have stabilized as a program under Sonny Dykes. With the Bears still pulling in good recruiting classes this team ought to be competitive in the near future, much sooner than expected

Washington, on the other hand, notched a win over Georgia State that raised even more red flags. The Huskies trailed 14-0 at halftime and led by seven entering the fourth quarter against a program that has been playing football less than five years. Chris Petersen has started his tenure as UW head coach 4-0, but it’s about the shakiest undefeated start imaginable. Hopefully, his guys were looking ahead to the big showdown this week. If not, it could be a long year for the Huskies.

Oregon State’s win over San Diego State wasn’t really noteworthy in any way – the Beavers were the better team and looked like it – so let’s move on to Utah. The Utes extended the Big Ten’s streak of awfulness with an overpowering performance in Ann Arbor to move to 3-0. It’s early, but this might be the most talented team head coach Kyle Whittingham has fielded, at least since joining the league. The Utes were 4-4 and poised to win the division in their first Pac-12 season (2011) before blowing a HOME finale to Colorado, of all teams. I think it’s highly likely this Utah team is better than the 2011 version.

On that note, I think it’s likely Utah knocks off WSU this week. The Utes are equipped to win a shootout or a slugfest and have the requisite home-field advantage to get it done. The Cougs are certainly capable of winning this game – that 1-3 record is highly misleading – but it’s hard to trust this erratic, turnover-prone squad. If Wazzu is going to make it to a bowl the season has to turn around in Salt Lake City. I’m not confident it will happen.

Colorado at Cal looked like a matchup of even teams before the year started, but that was before the Bears started looking competent. The Buffaloes, despite their 2-2 start, are still not ready to take the next step. At home, Cal is the clear favorite in this game. What might have been for this Bears team? If not for that stupid Hail Mary at Arizona, 4-0 and a bowl bid would be a real possibility.

OSU – USC was a game I went back and forth on in my preseason predictions before settling on the Trojans taking it at home. That struggle looked ludicrous after SC’s big win over Stanford, but it swung right back to reasonable after that appalling effort at Boston College. Here’s the thing, though: the Trojans might be overrated, Steve Sarkisian might be a complete hack of a head coach and the program might be hobbled by scholarship reductions… and I still don’t like the Beavers’ chances in L.A. OSU has been notoriously bad in these situations historically and there’s not really any reason to think this team is good enough to turn that streak around. I’m not sure the 2014 Beavs are as good as last year’s squad that went 7-6.

There’s a huge South showdown Thursday between UCLA and ASU. Or is there? The Bruins are being coy about the status of QB Brett Hundley, but I’d bet he plays. ASU’s Taylor Kelly, arguably the superior QB, is definitely out. The game is at night in Tempe, which obviously favors the Sun Devils. This game was supposed to determine which side would play in the Pac-12 Championship, but now the picture is muddled. Kelly is hurt. UCLA has looked like the most overrated team in the country thus far. Is either of these teams going to win the South? Were the Devils at full strength, I’d take them in a heartbeat. Now I have to lean toward the Bruins by default, though it wouldn’t shock me to see ASU still pull this game out.

So… there’s this interesting thing happening. A pair of undefeated, top-15 Pac-12 squads will play on Thursday, but there’s another game happening Saturday in Seattle that might feature two teams better than either of them. Stanford, without a doubt, is at least the equal of UCLA and ASU. Washington has been curiously sloppy this month, but the Huskies have still started 4-0. If UW and Stanford finished ahead of their South Division brethren at the end of the year, would it really surprise anyone? I don’t think so. This series has gotten tight the past couple of seasons and this contest appears to be of the same mold. The Cardinal cannot afford another conference loss. Washington surely doesn’t want to start with one either. Buckle up.

Random Thoughts and Observations

A lot has been made of how the Big Ten “rebounded” last week, going 12-1. Let’s see…Iowa knocked off Pittsburgh on the road… Nebraska beat Miami (FL) at home… Indiana upset Missouri in Columbia… and that’s it. Am I supposed to be impressed by Rutgers’ win at Navy or Maryland’s road victory over Syracuse? Indiana’s comeback against Mizzou was nice, but let’s face it, the Tigers were probably vastly over-ranked following their incredible 2013 run. Pitt is decent, but that’s hardly a ringing endorsement, while Miami is a .500 football team. The Big Ten didn’t “rebound” last week. It just didn’t play anyone of note and looked good because of it. This is still the worst Power 5 conference, which, considering the state of the ACC, is really saying something.

After nearly upsetting South Carolina and knocking off Virginia Tech in Blacksburg, what would East Carolina do next? How about obliterating in-state rival North Carolina by a score of 70-41? The Pirates rolled up 789 yards on 97 plays, officially stamping themselves as the team to beat in the AAC. The game wasn’t even as close as it looks. UNC built an early lead thanks to two touchdowns on trick plays. There’s no way to spin this positively for the ACC, no matter how good ECU is. I thought the Pirates might contend for the league title in their first season out of the Conference USA, but this is unexpected.

Stanzi Watch

It was a banner week for the Stanzis as an astounding seven new candidates entered the fray. Florida State is now facing the same conundrum TCU did in 2013: two quarterbacks earning Stanzis in the same season. Which one to start?! With conference action just getting started, things can only get better from here. Here are this week’s winners and the overall standings.

Sean Maguire, Florida State
Opponent: Clemson
Performance: Two INT, won in overtime

Sefo Liufau, Colorado
Opponent: Hawai’i
Performance: Two INT, won by nine

Fredi Knighten, Arkansas State
Opponent: Utah State
Performance: One INT, two FUM, won in OT

Gunner Kiel, Cincinnati
Opponent: Miami (OH)
Performance: Two INT, won by seven

Nick Mullens, Southern Miss
Opponent: Appalachian State
Performance: Two INT, won by one

Anu Solomon, Arizona
Opponent: California
Performance: Two INT, won on Hail Mary

Logan Woodside, Toledo
Opponent: Ball State
Performance: One INT, one FUM, won by 11

Blake Decker, UNLV: 1
Nick Arbuckle: Georgia State: 1
Davis Webb, Texas Tech: 1
Tanner Lee, Tulane: 1
Taysom Hill, BYU: 1
Michael Brewer, Virginia Tech: 1
Christian Hackenberg, Penn State: 1
Wes Lunt, Illinois: 1
C.J. Brown, Maryland: 1
Angel Santiago, Army: 1
Grayson Lambert, Virginia: 1
Dane Evans, Tulsa: 1
Jameis Winston, Florida State: 1



Conference play! It’s here! No longer will we have to slog through 66-0 pastings like the one Wisconsin laid on Bowling Green last week. Well, unless you’re watching the SEC. That league loves to sprinkle in patsies throughout the season, not unlike a fancy dinner getting constantly interrupted for Hostess Cupcakes breaks. Fortunately, from this point forward that dinner should be so filling no one will need to even consider reaching for one.

Thursday, September 18, 2014

Pacific Blues


National Overview

For a slate with only one ranked-versus-ranked matchup Week 3 turned out to be decently entertaining. No, there was no earth-shattering upset that eliminated a team from playoff contention, but overall it’s hard to be dissatisfied with a weekend that produces a couple of ranked teams going down and a conference (Pac-12) on the edge of its seat for a couple hours late Saturday night.

How about that Georgia – South Carolina game? For the third time in four years the Bulldogs and Gamecocks went nuts in their early-season meeting, flying around the field in delightfully reckless fashion. Carolina prevailed for the fourth time in five years, perhaps signaling that the East is still Cocky’s to lose. Despite UGA’s two recent trips to the SEC title game the Bulldogs have struggled with SC. In both those division-title seasons Georgia got to Atlanta by virtue of the Gamecocks’ own inability to avoid missteps. It seems the opening loss to Texas A&M won’t be the death knell some thought it was for Carolina.

Speaking of ominous signs, Week 3 had more than a few for the Pac-12. Injuries to the two best quarterbacks in the South (ASU’s Taylor Kelly and UCLA’s Brett Hundley)? Check. The conference’s two most prominent programs (historically) trailing on the road in the second half against inferior opponents? Check. How about one of those teams actually losing, just one week after knocking off a ranked Stanford team on the road? Ugh. The league avoided complete disaster when Jerry “TwoWeasel*” Neuheisel led UCLA back to a 20-17 win over Texas in Arlington, but USC’s defensive flop at Boston College was on display for the whole nation to see. More on the Trojans in the Pac-12 section, but let’s agree to cool it with the “Pac-12 is as good as the SEC!” talk for now.

*Jerry’s father Rick, the former UCLA, Washington and Colorado head coach, was derisively referred to by rival fans as Rick “Neu-Weasel” for various rules violations and transgressions. I thought it only fitting to bestow the moniker “TwoWeasel” upon his son.

However, it was once again the Big Ten that brought up the rear. The beleaguered home of the Leaders and Legends (not really, but the conference will never live that down) saw Illinois and Minnesota blown out by big-league competition, Indiana drop a close one to Bowling Green, and Iowa and newcomer Maryland fall to rivals Iowa State and West Virginia, respectively. The B1G is now 1-10 versus schools from the other Power 5 conferences in 2014, with Rutgers’ shootout victory over Washington State on opening night the only mark in the win column. It seems there’s no end to this misery and the reality that this once-respected league will be excluded from the first playoff in college football history is looming larger every week.

What’s on tap for Week 4? So glad you asked. To start with, there’s a very interesting Thursday night matchup between Auburn and Kansas State in Manhattan that’s been pointed to for weeks now as a potential trap for the Tigers. I’m not entirely sure I buy it – not because Auburn is a elite title contender, because I have a lot of skepticism about that – but because I’m not sure K-State is that good. The Wildcats were lucky to escape Week 2 with a win over Iowa State, and regardless of what Iowa may have had to say about it last Saturday I don’t think the Cyclones are anything more than average. We’ll see on Thursday.

Moving forward to the weekend, we get the always-entertaining Tech-vs.-Tech battle when Georgia Tech meets Virginia Tech in Blacksburg, Bowling Green taking on a shaky Wisconsin team and North Carolina at East Carolina in another round of what has become a great intra-state series. Florida at Alabama is getting some hype, but I tend to doubt the bona fides of teams that just needed three overtimes to beat Kentucky. I feel similar about Mississippi State at LSU. Seemingly every year the Bulldogs start hot by beating some garbage teams, then look average in SEC play. MSU hasn’t finished better than .500 in-conference for more than a decade. Why exactly should I believe this is the year the streak ends?

Utah at Michigan is an intriguing non-league contest. The Utes did upset UM in the Big House a few years back and it’s safe to say this iteration of the Wolverines has been less than impressive thus far. Still… it’s hard to trust Utah, which has struggled mightily since making the leap to a major conference in 2011. Likewise for Virginia – BYU, which is being hailed as a good matchup because of the Cavaliers’ upset of Louisville last week. The Cavs did knock off the Cougars last season, but that was a Week 1 slugfest BYU should have won. This year, in Provo, they will.

Miami (FL) also travels to Nebraska in another opportunity for the Big Ten to fall on its face, while undefeated Cal and Arizona teams (say what?) meet in Tucson for an early Pac-12 battle. However, the big game (and in many respects, the only game) this week is Clemson at Florida State. The Tigers were eviscerated last year at home and I don’t really think they’ve improved much, if at all. However, FSU looked vulnerable in their opener, so we’ll see if Clemson can keep this thing closer than the 2013 meltdown. If the Seminoles struggle to put this game away it might be a warning sign.

Top 25

It’s still too soon. The more I think about it, the more I feel that perhaps the traditional top 25 should be replaced this season to better reflect this new era of college football. After all, at the end of the year it won’t matter who’s ranked where. The opinion of the playoff committee is what counts. I’ll toy around with some ideas in the next couple of weeks before deciding. For the record, Oregon and Texas A&M should be first and second. Those teams have quality wins no other squad can match. Based on the eye test, I’d say Oklahoma, Alabama and FSU ought to round out the top five. Any combination of those schools would make for a fantastic final four.

Pac-12 Report

Hmmm. Hmmm indeed. After all the talk this preseason about how the Pac-12 was ready to challenge the SEC for conference supremacy, it nearly all came crashing down in a matter of hours in Week 3. Sure, Oregon and Stanford handled their business against underpowered mid-majors and the Washington schools looked good, but from mid-afternoon on almost nothing went right for the Conference of Champions. UCLA continued to look bad before and after Hundley’s injury, only to be saved by a familial blast from its past. Arizona State got a comfortable win over Colorado but lost Kelly for at least a few weeks, including the big South showdown with UCLA next Thursday. Arizona barely held on against Nevada, a team that had just beat Wazzu the week prior. And then there was USC.

I was skeptical after Week 1, when the Trojans got way too much credit for running more than 100 plays against Fresno State. That feeling has been justified, as the Bulldogs are now 0-3 with three blowouts on their resume. But SC survived Stanford on the road despite being outplayed, so I thought perhaps my initial preseason prediction of a division title would turn out to be correct. That changed drastically this weekend, as Boston College trampled the Trojans’ D with 452 yards on the ground.

452! I can’t remember ever seeing a USC team get that thoroughly whipped at the line of scrimmage. Even in the 2009 Halloween night massacre that signaled the end of the Trojans’ dynasty, Oregon only rushed for 391 yards. However, the Ducks on that night also passed for 222 yards. BC completed five of 13 passes for 54 yards and an interception. The fact that SC knew exactly what was coming on every play and still couldn’t stop it is unforgivable. There’s been some talk of a “Stanford hangover,” a phenomenon that seems to affect teams the week after playing physical squads like the Cardinal, but that’s no excuse for losing to an clearly inferior side in BC. In just seven days USC went from chic playoff pick to potential Pac-12 also-ran.

Fortunately for the Trojans, they still have QB Cody Kessler, whose superb performance Saturday was overshadowed by the loss. UCLA and ASU can’t say the same. That alone might keep SC on top of the suddenly shaky South. None of those three teams plays this week, which is probably a good thing (Stanford is also off). There are still only two conference games, which we’ll get to in a minute.

I expect Washington to finally play a complete, error-free game against Georgia State. No real danger there. Hawai’i at Colorado is an decent matchup of two relatively evenly-matched squads. The Buffaloes should be able to come out with a win to climb to .500 (four games into the season! Way to go, Ralphie!), but you never know with CU. Utah – Michigan has a chance to be a death blow to the Big Ten, though I’m nervous about the Utes leaving the friendly confines of Rice-Eccles. This team is 2-9 on the road the past two seasons. Michigan isn’t particularly good, but I have nothing to assure me Utah is either. The last non-conference game is San Diego State at Oregon State, a team OSU very nearly lost to in 2013. There’s some potential for an upset, but I expect the Beavers to pull out the win.

That leaves a pair of evening matchups I find very interesting. Cal’s visit to Arizona should be no big deal for the Wildcats, right? After all, the Golden Bears are still terrible. Well, I’m not so sure. First, Cal has already won more games in two weeks than it did all last season. Second, the Bears got a week off to prepare for this conference opener. Third… how good is ‘Zona, really? After annihilating UNLV in their opener the ‘Cats have been average at best. Close wins over UTSA and Nevada don’t exactly scream “playoff contender.” The Roadrunners, in particular, seemed to figure out frosh QB Anu Solomon, who – like many young passers – tends to struggle when forced to make second and third reads. I wouldn’t be surprised to see this turn into a close affair.

Oregon’s trip to WSU has some great trap potential as well. The Ducks, for all their talent and versatility, often look at a loss when faced with an offense that wants to only do one thing. What’s more, UO’s coverage has been spotty so far this season and might be missing starting CB Troy Hill in Pullman. The Cougars want to throw the ball upwards of 60 times, and they’ll need to against an offense they should have little hope of slowing down. But there’s always potential for a Mike Leach offense to catch fire. Throw in a turnover or two and a busted play and this could become a shootout in a hurry.

Random Thoughts and Observations

The Heisman Watch is also on hold for another few weeks, but let’s take the time to appreciate the true ridiculousness of Florida State QB Jameis Winston’s stupidity. Not only has he repeatedly made headlines for off-field behavior since the allegations of rape made against him went public, he’s apparently tone-deaf enough to think shouting a particular phrase (click the link if you dare) in the middle of the student union would go unnoticed. Nevermind that this meme isn’t particularly funny outside of the college-humor sphere; it’s astounding that he would think this is a good idea after the charges leveled against him last year.

The Heisman’s purity among individual athletic awards is somewhat of a sham, but there’s virtually no denying it is still, in the Heisman Trust’s own words, “The most coveted individual award in sports.” The trophy has also traditionally been associated with good character and strong academic standing. While some of those platitudes are really just that, the fact remains that Winston has made it extraordinarily difficult for voters to consider him for the honor again.

Stanzi Watch

It was a quiet week in the Stanzis but for one wild game: Louisiville at Virginia saw not only the return of the Double Stanzi (when the winning QB on either side would receive one), but a truly remarkable near-feat in the Triple Stanzi! UVA played two QB’s – Grayson Lambert and Matt Johns – and the duo came up one Johns turnover short of both earning Stanzis. Lambert threw one pick and fumbled, while Johns threw a pick of his own. For the record, Louisville’s Will Gardner tossed two interceptions and fumbled as well. So close! I’d never considered it before, but I suppose there’s really no limit as to how many Stanzis could be awarded in a single game. It would take absurdly poor quarterbacking, coaching staffs eager to pull guys after a couple turnovers and a healthy dose of unintentional comedy from the Football Gods. Let’s get Florida and Texas together and do this. Here are this week’s winners, with previous weekly winners and standings below.

Taysom Hill, BYU
Opponent: Houston
Performance: Two INT, one FUM (recovered by teammate), held on for 33-25 win

Grayson Lambert, Virginia
Opponent: Louisville
Performance: One INT, one FUM, escaped with 23-21 win

Tanner Lee, Tulane
Opponent: Southeastern Louisiana
Performance: Two INT, won by two scores

Blake Decker, UNLV: 1
Nick Arbuckle: Georgia State: 1
Davis Webb, Texas Tech: 1
Michael Brewer, Virginia Tech: 1
Christian Hackenberg, Penn State: 1
Wes Lunt, Illinois: 1
C.J. Brown, Maryland: 1
Angel Santiago, Army: 1
Dane Evans, Tulsa: 1
Jameis Winston, Florida State: 1


We’re so close to good football. Keep on believing for one more week. UCLA – ASU is next Thursday night. It can’t possibly be worse than Florida – Alabama will be this weekend. Onwards and preferably upwards we go.