Wednesday, September 19, 2012

You wouldn't like me when I'm angry


Questions were answered this week. A whole bunch of ‘em, in fact. Let’s see: my doubts about USC? Vindicated. Issues with Virginia Tech? Lost to previously winless Pittsburgh. I didn’t predict Notre Dame handling Michigan State with ease, but it officially let the nation know that the Big 10 is a joke (although Wisconsin and Ohio State should have tipped us off to that).

The headlining story of the weekend was USC’s loss to Stanford, but the more relevant news long-term was the continuing series of awful performances by Big 10 schools. The conference picked up right where it left off last week, with Ohio State fortunate to escape an average Cal team at home. Minnesota struggled to put away Western Michigan, Iowa barely beat Northern Iowa, Ball State beat Illinois and Wisconsin needed a missed field goal to survive Utah State. All of these games were at home. Then, of course, there was the league’s last real hope, MSU, getting shut down in its own stadium. All 12 Big 10 teams played at home, by the way. Shameless.

(I noted last week that MSU was the last undefeated Big 10 team, which wasn’t entirely true. Northwestern and OSU are still undefeated, but I didn’t include them because no one expects the Wildcats to challenge for the BCS title and the Buckeyes are postseason-ineligible.)

I was certainly surprised to see USC go down in the fashion the Trojans did, even though I said before the season I didn’t think they were as good as people were saying. It was more surprising to me that Stanford was the team to expose USC. Given the lack of secondary speed on the Cardinal D, you would have expected the Trojans’ receivers to run wild. They did for about a quarter, but then the Cardinal wised up to Matt Barkley’s game, which seemed to consist of throwing solely to Marquise Lee, never deeper than five yards down the field. The Trojans never really threatened again. More on both teams in the Pac-12 section.

In more frightening news there was the performance Alabama put on in Fayetteville, where they eviscerated Arkansas 52-0. Granted, we now know we can add the Razorbacks to the list of teams that were vastly overrated in the preseason (which also includes Wisconsin and Virginia Tech). But 52-0 is impressive against an FCS team. It’s hard to know what to think about this Bama team. Are they really that good? Thus far the things that should have at least somewhat bothered them – new starters on defense, zero experience at receiver – have been no problem whatsoever. It helps that Crimson Tide’s O line can flatten almost anybody in the country, but even the run-heavy nature of the offense shouldn’t be a big deal. I can’t imagine the team ever being in a must-throw situation anyway.

Last week ended up being more entertaining than expected, but this week conference play really gets going so I shouldn’t have to say that again. Thursday night features an interesting mid-major mash-up when BYU travels to face Boise State on the blue, while the Friday game has last year’s darling (Baylor) versus this year’s early favorite for that title (Louisiana-Monroe). The Saturday slate is light until the evening, when we get some of the best matchups of the young season: Michigan – Notre Dame, Kansas State – Oklahoma, Clemson – Florida State and Arizona – Oregon.

Top 25

It finally makes sense to rank teams, even though some (like Oregon) still haven’t been tested. At least at this point we’ve seen enough of most squads to know more or less where they’re headed this season.

1) Alabama

As stated above: Wow. The receivers are all young, the backs are a step down from the past two seasons and the defense is relatively inexperienced. So far, it hasn’t mattered. Right now I’d take the Crimson Tide over anyone at any location, home or away. They look that dominant.

2) LSU

The Tigers haven’t really played anyone (Washington doesn’t count) so it’s possible this is too high. Then again, they returned most pieces from last season’s juggernaut but upgraded at quarterback. I’m not going to knock them for a weak nonconference schedule after the historic run they nearly completed.

3) Oregon

The Ducks closed out an underwhelming preseason by crushing Tennessee Tech. There are still kinks to be worked out on both sides of the ball, but the fact remains that the only way to beat this team seems to be to physically overwhelm them. Right now the only schools with that capability are the two above.

4) Oklahoma

Stupid for the Sooners to get jumped because they didn’t play. Until I see evidence to the contrary (a la USC), this team should be treated like one of the elite. The Big 12 road is long and perilous, but I still believe in OU. They might have even more playmakers on offense than Oregon.

5) Florida State

Very, very nice win against Wake Forest. True, the Demon Deacons are bad, but just as I said with Alabama, 52-0 is impressive no matter who you play. Besides, we’ll know just how for real these Seminoles are after this week’s mega-showdown with Clemson. FSU at home? I’ll take the ‘Noles.

6) West Virginia

Were it not for a) FSU’s win this week and b) WVU’s weak opponents thus far, I would have had the Mountaineers at fifth. Boy, have they been impressive. Geno Smith looks flawless, the offense shares the ball wonderfully and the defense has been solid. The competition is going improve just a bit, though.

7) Georgia

What about UGA’s first-half struggles (again) against mightily inferior FAU compelled voters to move the Bulldogs up to number five? Georgia has looked very good at times this year, very average at others, so rewarding them seems short-sighted. Remember how they looked last season against every good team they played? Wait and see with this squad.

8) Clemson

I’m biting. I like what the Tigers have shown so far this year. Even if Auburn is awful. Clemson has played in the efficient manner they began last season with before that second-half downturn. I don’t think they’ll win in Tallahassee this weekend, but they’re still a very good team that, at this point, deserves a high ranking.

9) South Carolina

The Gamecocks hammered another hapless patsy this week. Given that they struggled in their only real live action this season, I’d be lying if I said I had a lot of confidence in Carolina. Nevertheless, their defense is about as good as you’ll see this side of Alabama, so perhaps that can carry the team most of the year.

10) Stanford

This is an unfortunate side effect of so many Big 10 teams losing; I don’t have anyone else to rank above the Cardinal. While their win over SC was stirring, this really isn’t a top 10 team. I have to put them ahead of the Trojans, though, so for now this is where they go. The offense still needs a lot of work.

11) USC

Even I, a fairly vocal dissident to the USC bandwagon, was stunned at the ineptitude of the Trojan offense on Saturday. We already knew they couldn’t run; now this team can’t pass either? It’s not all doom and gloom, though. SC remains a very talented team with (thus far) few injuries, and their defense only gave up 21 points in defeat. Things could be a lot worse.

12) Notre Dame

Toyed with the idea of jumping ND into the top 10, but I have a sneaking feeling Michigan State might not be that good. The relevant thing is the Irish are, well, relevant. For the first time in my lifetime, there’s a team in South Bend that legitimately has the potential to win it all. Love it or hate it, that’s good for college football. Everybody needs a good villain.

13) Kansas State

I have K-State ahead of Texas for several reasons. We know what we have with KSU: a returning 10-win team whose grit is second to none and a veteran leader at the QB position. Texas has looked good so far this season, but the competition has been lackluster. I’m going with the proven commodity before I believe in the Longhorns.

14) Texas

With that said, the UT defense has been excellent in 2012. The question marks coming into the season were pretty much all on the offensive side but Texas seems to have improved in that regard (just ask Ole Miss). They’re not good enough to run the table in the Big 12 this year but they’ll figure into the picture and remain the chic pick in 2013.

15) Ohio State

The first Big 10 school, down at fifteenth? Gulp. Unfortunately for the Big 10, this is about as generous as I can be at this point. Nobody in the conference has looked particularly good and even the seemingly powerful Buckeyes were nearly tripped up at home by a mediocre Cal squad. Too bad OSU is banned from the postseason.

16) TCU

I’m a bit skeptical after the Horned Frogs could only manage a 20-6 win against Kansas in their first Big 12 game. I like QB Casey Pachall a lot and TCU has some nice weapons around him, which makes 20 points against what was one of the nation’s worst defenses a year ago underwhelming. They don’t play another league game until October, though.

17) Michigan

In a holding pattern after beating up new FBS member UMass. Three games into 2012, Michigan appears to be exactly what they were in 2011. That’s nothing to be ashamed of, but it’s not going to get UM back to where their fans think they ought to be. There’s more work to be done here. Beating Notre Dame next week would help.

18) UCLA

Houston wasn’t a test at all, but you still have to be impressed with the job on the whole UCLA did in the preseason. It was workmanlike, physical and efficient, and the end result was a 3-0 record heading into Pac-12 play. We’ll need to see the Bruins knock off a couple conference foes too, but for now I’m convinced this team will have a say in the division race.

19) Louisville

After crushing North Carolina for three quarters, the Cardinals had a near-disaster on Saturday. There’s no question that this team is the class of the Big East, but they very nearly gave one away, on their home field no less. At least there’s plenty for Teddy Bridgewater and Co. to improve before they get too pleased with themselves.

20) Florida

I’ll throw the Gators a bone here. After watching their inept offensive performances in the first two weeks I couldn’t possibly see them as a top 25 team. Given a couple games, though, Florida seems to have rounded into a very South Carolina-like form. As long as they can play defense and run effectively, they can win games. If they ever get down, all bets are off.

21) Arizona

A close win over a pretty good Toledo team, then the shootout win over Oklahoma State, now a blowout over FCS South Carolina State. I think Arizona has its best team since the ‘Cats nearly won the conference in 2009. The defense gave up big numbers in its only real test of the season (OSU), but the offense looks like it can score in bunches. We’ll know this week, when ‘Zona travels to Autzen to meet the three-time conference champs.

22) Nebraska

The 2-1 record is actually a bit of a smokescreen; I think Nebraska is better than last season. At the very least the Cornhuskers should be the co-favorites in the competitive Legends division. The one issue is that all the difficult games come in a row; after Idaho State this week, Nebraska doesn’t have an easy game until November against Penn State. If they make the league championship, they’ll have earned it.

23) Michigan State

The good news? MSU is giving up just 13 points per game. Those are Alabama-like numbers. The bad news? They’re only scoring 20. The conference opener in two weeks is Ohio State. The Spartans had better make some significant gains in the next 14 days, or we could have a massacre on our hands.

24) Boise State

The Broncos are stuck in a frustrating spot after their opening woulda-shoulda-coulda loss to Michigan State. They have the ability to run the table the rest of the way, but even an 11-1 record has proved insufficient for a midmajor to reach a BCS bowl in the past. However, given their struggles in-conference the past two seasons (BSU has not won a league title since 2009), perhaps it’s just best to focus on that.

25) Oklahoma State

All right, the OSU offensive machine is still humming along. We get it. But can they stop anyone? They couldn’t last year, even when they went 12-1. So far in 2012, there’s been no evidence that they’ve improved. I like the Cowboys, but it seems apparent they’re going to have problems in conference play. The Big 12 ain’t no cakewalk.

Pac-12 Thoughts

Well then. Mayhaps my calls for Stanford’s demise were a bit premature? In any case, Cal isn’t going to be a problem for the Cardinal this season, so there goes that prediction. Give all the credit in the world to David Shaw and the Stanford defense for putting the clamps on USC’s offense. However, Oregon is still the clear favorite in the North, even with the impressive display we say this week. Here why:

First, without taking anything away from Stanford, it is clear that I was absolutely right about USC. The team just isn’t nearly as good as the media hyped them up to be. Stanford’s front seven controlled the line of scrimmage, forced the Trojans to throw and adjusted nicely once they realized Barkley had locked on to one receiver. The Cardinal won’t be able to do the same against Oregon, because Oregon’s offense naturally spreads the ball around much more than USC’s does. That’s just a simple strategic fact.

Second, Stanford won’t be able to play as soft against UO because that’s exactly what Oregon wants. The Ducks live off the short and medium game with both quick passes and option runs. Playing conservative defensively over the top – as Stanford did to USC do prevent the deep ball – will thus backfire.

Third, the Oregon-Stanford game this year is at Autzen Stadium. The Ducks have blown out the Cardinal the past two seasons and scored over 50 points in both contests. Despite his late-game heroics Saturday, new QB Josh Nunes completed fewer than half his passes and remains a work in progress. When an opposing offense cannot throw consistently, UO tends to go blitz-crazy. I’m not confident Nunes can stand up to that and beat them in a shootout.

Now, it’s possible Stanford may try to adjust to fix these problems. Play the Ducks one-on-one outside. Blitz to control the interior line (as they did against USC). Continue to pound the ball to slow the game down. But they tried these things the past two years and the result was the same. This season’s Stanford team is certainly weaker than the last two; why should their defense suddenly be able to contain an Oregon offense that hasn’t slowed down in the slightest? In the end, as it always does, it’ll come down to UO’s athletes in the open field versus Stanford’s defenders. That’s a matchup Oregon always wins.

All of this does not apply to USC, though. It’s all a matter of styles. Stanford doesn’t have the personnel to outscore Oregon. The Trojans do, despite what we saw Saturday. That doesn’t mean USC will necessarily beat the Ducks on November 3rd, but I expect they’ll play them closer than Stanford will. They might have to, because another conference loss – combined with UCLA’s resurgence – might mean they only get one shot at Oregon this season.

The Bruins, meanwhile, have become much more than that “other” team in L.A. Despite rolling out a new head coach, new offense and redshirt freshman QB in Brett Hundley, UCLA is leading the conference in offense through three games. Could they win the South – for real this time? Time will tell, though I’d still favor USC until the Bruins prove it in conference play. They have a great opportunity this week to make a statement against Oregon State, who remains an enigma after Hurricane Isaac forced them to play just a single game.

The important game this weekend is of course the cross-divisional matchup between Arizona and Oregon. The Ducks are undoubtedly the better team, but as we’ve seen many times, that doesn’t necessarily mean they’re guaranteed a victory. The Wildcats have taken to Rich Rod’s spread-option with aplomb and have the key element that made his West Virginia teams so lethal: a great QB-RB combo. Matt Scott and Ka’Deem Carey are the real deal, and given the lapses UO’s defense has shown in the first few weeks it’s same to assume the ‘Cats will score. The real question is whether they can slow down the Oregon offense in turn, which is probably unlikely.

In other league action, there’s the “Battle at the Bottom” when Colorado plays at WSU, a chance for USC to rebound at home versus Cal and a sneakily-important South contest between Utah and ASU in Tempe. Is USC really overrated, or was last week a fluke? Can Utah’s defense play well enough to cover for their pedestrian offense? How much better are the Sun Devils at home? Tune in and find out!

Heisman Watch

Although he hasn’t played a semblance of real competition yet, Geno Smith has to be considered the frontrunner. He’s a highly efficient QB on a title-contending squad that puts up big offensive numbers, so he fits the description. I predicted before the season that West Virginia would stumble against the tougher Big 12, but until that time comes Smith is the most likely candidate. His numbers thus far have also been eerily similar to RG3’s last year, if you believe in that kind of thing.

The case for Matt Barkley was severely damaged Saturday. It’s a long season, so there’s plenty of time for him to make up ground, but nothing he’s done to this point has been that impressive. To be honest, Jonathan Franklin is the better candidate in the City of Angels to this point. The UCLA back leads the nation in rushing and is dynamic enough to make plays in the passing game as well. If the Bruins continue to roll offensively, he’ll have a shot.

There’s a distinct sectional bias when it comes to the Heisman this year, though that’s because so many of the best candidates seem to come from the West (and because it’s hard to imagine Ohio State’s Braxton Miller playing at this level all season). That continues with the final member of my current short list, Oregon’s De’Anthony Thomas. In one sense, it’s strange to think that a player with no real position could be a Heisman frontrunner. However, as with all things relating to Thomas, the usual rules don’t seem to apply. He makes more of his minimal touches than any player in recent memory and, early in his career, seems to be the most perfect blend of player-to-system college football has ever seen. It’s hard to imagine such an indefinable player taking football’s top honor; yet at the end of this season perhaps it’ll be hard to imagine that we ever could have thought otherwise.

Random Thoughts and Observations

It will be fun to see what Michigan and Notre Dame have in store after playing one of the most memorable games of the season in 2011. Hopefully we’ll see better defense than the insane finish last year featured, when the teams scored a combined 21 points in the final 1:12 in just seven plays from scrimmage. It would only be fitting, though; the past two seasons Denard Robinson has stunned the Irish with touchdowns in the final 30 seconds to win.

SI cover curse? Oregon’s young Thomas will grace the cover of the September 24th Sports Illustrated. The subsequent injuries and poor play of athletes who have appeared in the past are well-documented. Thomas has been remarkably healthy in his first year-plus at UO despite his slight frame (listed at 5’9”, 173 lbs., he is probably smaller). Could this be the end of his good fortune? Gulp.

Miller of Ohio State nearly earned himself a Stanzi award Saturday (named for the recent hot-and-cold Iowa QB) by tossing what should have been the go-ahead pick to Cal in the waning moments, then coming back to fire a long bomb for the lead. Miller gets off the hook because a) Cal didn’t score and b) he didn’t play badly enough throughout the game to really earn a Stanzi. I haven’t seen a performance worthy of one yet this season, but don’t worry, it’s coming.

Speaking of Cal… I normally would never take such a strong position on a coach’s employment, but that loss to the Buckeyes proved it’s time for Jeff Tedford to go. I’ve long defended Tedford (he’s an Oregon man, after all) and his inability to get the most out of the good recruiting classes Cal brings in. But the game has clearly passed him by to some degree. The Bears blew an absolutely golden – yeah, I went there – opportunity to beat Ohio State in the ‘Shoe and many of the reasons they did not can be attributed to playcalling. In particular, the decision to kick a fraidy-cat field goal on fourth and one deep in OSU territory with the score tied sticks out.

There’s just so much to say about this. Cal had momentum following Miller’s interception. Isi Sofele was averaging four yards a carry and the team averaged nearly six on the afternoon. Cal’s kicker had already missed two attempts left, and the ball was on the left hash. The Bears’ defense had stymied the Buckeyes the entire second half, allowing just a single scoring drive after the 13:30 mark of the second quarter. Yet out came the kicker (after a timeout by Cal, no less) to shank another one.

Well, we know what happened. Three plays later Miller dropped in a 70-yard touchdown that ended up winning the game. Here’s the excruciating thing: the odds are in the offense’s favor on fourth-and-one. Any number of scenarios could have played out if the Bears had gone for it: closer field goal, TD, turnover followed by another OSU turnover, or just forcing OSU to punt from deep in their own territory. Yet even had Cal gone for it on fourth down and failed, the absolute worst-case scenario would have been EXACTLY WHAT HAPPENED. There was no excuse for this decision, which finally turned me against Tedford. Now he’ll probably do something like go out and beat USC this week to save his job. But he shouldn’t.

Next week: I find something else to rant about, while we mourn the end of De’Anthony Thomas’ career following his unprecedented “spontaneous kneecap combustion,” which doctors simply dub “SI injury.”

Thursday, September 13, 2012

Wherein I lament the lack of any good games


Well, well, well. Look who finally came crawling to the big-boy table. Wednesday’s announcement that Notre Dame would partially join the ACC was, without question, the biggest news of the week. The Fighting Irish will now play five games per year in the ACC with seven independent, but that plan is fooling nobody. Eventually, ND will be a full member.

The news was a huge blow to the Big East, which undoubtedly hoped to retain Notre Dame as a flagship university in football (the Irish currently play all other sports there) to resuscitate its on-lifeline long-term prospects. After the ACC’s grab last season for Pittsburgh and Syracuse, I assumed this would happen – my blog from that week is now eerily prescient – so it can’t have taken the conference completely by surprise. But that doesn’t mean it isn’t devastating. I can’t see any scenario now where the Big East can survive longer than the first few years of the playoff. What school serious about competing for a championship would want to play there?

In other news, there was almost no news. For the first time in 32 weeks there was a total of zero ranked-versus-ranked matchups, a barren slate even less appetizing than week one’s meager fare. The idea of a playoff is wonderful, but if schedules like this are the result... I'm not sure it will be worth it. Everyone assumed a postseason selection committee would force teams to give up games against cupcakes, but what if it has the opposite effect? The early-season returns this year have been pitiful. Very few schools have taken the initiative to schedule real opponents in non-conference play. I hope this isn't where the sport is headed.

To be honest, this week’s schedule doesn’t impress much either. Alabama plays at Arkansas, but given what just happened to the Razorbacks (Huzzah for Louisiana-Monroe!) I don’t have much hope for that one. There is the intriguing Florida-Tennessee matchup, but that rivalry is a lot more fun when both teams are near the top of the polls rather than the bottom. USC also plays at Stanford – I’d be surprised if the Cardinal made a game of it – and, in the most important game of the weekend, Notre Dame goes to Michigan State.

Why is this game so important? For one, Notre Dame could threaten for a BCS berth this year. While the Irish didn’t look the part last week against Purdue, they still boast an undefeated record and their once-daunting schedule might not turn out to be quite as brutal as it initially appeared. If they can get by the Spartans – a perennial thorn in their side – it will go a long way toward locking up a lucrative bowl bid. Michigan State, on the other hand, is the Big 10’s lone unbeaten squad after just two weeks. Any title hopes the conference had now rest on the Spartans. No pressure.

The only truly noteworthy result from last week was the performance of the Pac-12 and Big 10 on the national stage. In three visits out west, the League of Legends and Leaders went a crushing 0-3, watching ranked powerhouses Wisconsin and Nebraska go down along with Illinois at Oregon State, UCLA and Arizona State, respectively. It was a stunning and embarrassing finish for the storied conference, yet where the Big 10 saw infamy, the Pac-12 flourished. Bouncing back from ugly losses by its newcomers Colorado (FCS-level Sacramento State) and Utah (Utah State), the Conference of Champions dropped all three of its Rose Bowl bedfellows and then finished the night off with Arizona’s second-half evisceration of Oklahoma State. Needless to say, it was the Pac-12’s best Saturday in a long time.

Top 25

Many ranked teams have still failed to face any sort of reasonable challenge, which makes picking a top 25 extremely difficult. Going against my instincts, though, I’m going to release a (very) tentative list this week, with the caveat that it may change dramatically as soon as my next post. As such, I’ll only give a short description of my thoughts.

1) Alabama

Have shown enough through two weeks to be the undisputed number one.

2) LSU

Runner-up last year, runner-up this year? Possibly.

3) USC

Unimpressive against Syracuse, but fewer question marks than Oregon.

4) Oregon

Explosiveness is undeniable but injuries are now a big concern.

5) Oklahoma

Looked better against Florida A&M… but who wouldn’t?

6) Florida State

Game against Savannah State called early. Still haven’t learned anything about this team.

7) West Virginia

Idle in week two, but I’ll ride the buzz from their opening win a little longer.

8) Georgia

Closed nicely in Columbia, but Mizzou isn’t top-25 material.

9) Michigan State

Spartans have one of the few good wins to date, even if they were lucky not to fumble it away.

10) Ohio State

So far looking like the class of the Leaders division, though ineligible for postseason.

11) Clemson

Have looked powerful thus far, even without WR Sammy Watkins.

12) South Carolina

Close win in opener said a lot more than blowout over patsy. Vandy is better than ECU.

13) Kansas State

Might be really, really good, but we don’t know how bad Miami (FL) is yet.

14) TCU

With only one game, hard to judge. Horned Frogs’ reputation carries enough weight for a ranking, though.

15) Texas

I’m not blown away by what I’ve seen, but this week’s game at Ole Miss might clear things up.

16) Virginia Tech

I’m very confident these guys are frauds. Any struggles with Pitt and we’ll know.

17) Michigan

Wolverines lucky to not be 0-2, but I doubt they’d lose to anybody below them.

18) Notre Dame

Fantastic against Navy, so-so against Purdue. MSU game is absolutely huge.

19) Louisville

If the Cards don’t put on a show against North Carolina, the Big East is in trouble.

20) Stanford

A much better performance than the opener, though I’m still not convinced.

21) UCLA

This feels like a bit of an overreaction… but I’m intrigued to see what these Bruins can do.

22) Arizona

Once again, could be premature, but they were just so good against Okie State.

23) Nebraska

To be honest, they’ve looked better than Michigan. But Alabama > UCLA, so tough luck.

24) Boise State

Opening loss shouldn’t really count against them; Broncos will roll through Mountain West.

25) Florida/Tennessee

The winner this weekend will be deserving of a spot in the rankings.

Pac-12 Thoughts

From Friday evening through Saturday afternoon, the Pac-12 couldn’t have fared much worse. On Friday night QB Jordan Wynn went down against Utah State and took Utah’s season with him. Cal and Wazzu looked average against FCS teams, Colorado actually lost to Sac State and both Oregon and USC wrapped up unimpressive victories. It appeared to be a very disappointing weekend. Then the Oregon State-Wisconsin game went final and everything went crazy. UCLA took down Nebraska in dramatic fashion. ASU hammered visiting Illinois. Arizona dropped 59 on Oklahoma State. As I said before, it was pretty stunning. It was also a major boost to a conference that desperately needed one.

Despite Stanford’s success over the past few seasons, the Pac-12 has mainly had a lone banner-carrier since 2008. Oregon dominated the league, going 25-2 in three seasons. While the Rose Bowl win last year was nice, it didn’t provide the total validation the conference needed in the absence of major non-conference wins (UO over Tennessee in 2010 doesn’t count). Last Saturday changed all that: the Big 10 can say nothing to the Pac-12 for at least one year, national respect shot through the roof and the polls reflect it.

Of course, playing at this level for the rest of season would also be helpful, starting with Cal at Ohio State this weekend (not a chance). But regardless of the outcome of that game, the damage has been done. This was particularly crucial because of how vulnerable USC and Oregon looked this week.

The Ducks’ injury concerns have now reached critical, with senior stars Carson York and John Boyett for the season and Josh Huff sidelined again. On top of that, UO has played terribly inconsistent so far in 2012, outscoring opponents 85-6 early before getting beat 53-14. USC wasn’t great against Syracuse at the Meadowlands, either, holding just a five-point lead in the fourth quarter and sinking to even more ludicrous depths to pad Matt Barkley’s stats (187 yards, six touchdowns? Please). While I would still pick them both to represent their divisions in the conference championship, they could both actually lose a game.

That’s because both divisions suddenly look to have challengers who can truly, well, challenge the Ducks and Trojans. OSU might have thrown off two years of frustration with that win over the Badgers. Stanford looked much better in game two of the post-Luck era. Arizona can apparently score with anybody. Even UCLA, who can generally be relied on to faceplant, scored a big upset. Could the Bruins actually pose a threat to the league's elite? Look out. The Pac-12 just got very interesting.

Random Thoughts and Observations

A lot was made this week of the alleged “evils” of both Oklahoma State and Florida State scheduling hapless FCS foe Savannah State early in the season. Savannah State has just four wins over other FCS teams in the past seven seasons, so the media focus was on how unethical it was for these FBS powerhouses to pay a inferior foe to show up and get annihilated. My reaction was, “Who cares?” Savannah State wanted the money. They scheduled the games, they weren’t forced into it. If that’s how the program wants to make money, they have every right to do so. OSU and FSU shouldn’t be ashamed for doing the same thing as most FBS teams in the country.

In the ridiculous news of the week, I present: pass-happy offenses! Arkansas’ home loss to Louisiana-Monroe was stunning, but the forgotten statistic in the upset was QB Kolton Browning’s 67 pass attempts (he completed 42) that carved up the Arkansas defense. Of course, that was nothing compared to the Houston Cougars, who let new QB David Piland toss the rock an astounding 77 times in their loss to Louisiana Tech. Piland completed 53 attempts for 580 yards. Good god. The NCAA record is 83, by Drew Brees in 1998.

If the Heisman were given out after week one, I opined, it would have gone to West Virginia QB Geno Smith. After week two, it would probably go to UCLA RB Jonathan Franklin, who leads the nation in rushing and has an upset of a ranked team to his name. Obviously this will change as the season progresses, but for now Franklin has been the best player in the country. 

Wednesday, September 5, 2012

Ball so hard


There weren’t any major upsets in week one, but it wasn’t for lack of trying. Several ranked teams showed absolutely nothing in their openers and would have lost had they not scheduled terrible opponents. Michigan did not follow suit, leading to the Wolverines’ unfortunately predictable beatdown at the hands of Alabama. Say what you will about UM being overrated – they most certainly were – the Tide were still impressive. If I were releasing a top 25 this week, they would be number one. However, I’d rather wait for another week or two to really get a sense of where teams deserve to be ranked.

Michigan, on the other hand, is an interesting case. We know UM will win games; Denard Robinson is just too good of an athlete for them to lose more than a few times. But the truth is that he is not now, nor has he ever been, a quarterback. It’s the equivalent of Oregon lining De’Anthony Thomas up behind center: it would be cool for a while, but gimmicks don’t work against real defenses. Michigan is talented enough to still challenge for a division title, but just like last season, they aren’t close to a top 10 team.

While a lot will be made of Oklahoma’s struggles against UTEP, at least give the Sooners credit for going on the road when they didn’t have to. The team has enough time to figure things out and be a player in the BCS championship race. The defense didn’t allow a point Saturday; the offense is the only real concern. I’d knock OU down if I had a poll this week, but only a few spots.

South Carolina, on the other hand, is a different story. Even with QB Connor Shaw, the Gamecocks were anemic against Vandy. They were lucky to not go down 14-0 in the first quarter, a position that, as it turns out, would cost them the game. The forward pass remains a mystery to the Gamecocks, which should really have cost Steve Spurrier his “genius” label by now. However, analysts still seem to think it’s 1996 and the “Fun ‘n Gun” is tearing up the SEC. If Shaw is out for any length of time this team is in huge trouble, and they’re not a top 10 team with him anyway.

The same is more or less true for Stanford. I’ve been indignantly defending Andrew Luck’s greatness this entire offseason and my preseason prediction became prophetic when the Cardinal barely escaped San Jose State opening night. Yes, Stanford still has a great O-line and a quality (though not elite) defense. But Luck was REALLY, REALLY good. I don’t understand why this is so difficult for people to grasp. He made the Cardinal better than they were and this is a fringe top 25 team right now.

Florida is in the same boat. The Gators were fortunate to beat Bowling Green, looking out of sorts defensively and atrocious offensively. The QB situation in Gainesville is a mess, which has dragged the entire offense down. It makes sense now that Will Muschamp couldn’t pick a starter before fall camp – Jeff Driskel and Jacoby Brissett are both awful. Regardless of who starts (it looks like it might be Driskel from now on), Florida is going nowhere this year.

On the other hand, West Virginia was nothing but impressive on opening weekend. QB Geno Smith was easily the best player Saturday with his hyper-efficient, 32-36 performance against Marshall. The Mountaineers are a legit top 10 squad. As I said in the preseason, I still have reservations about the team’s ability to hold up over the course of a nine-game Big 12 schedule, but right now they deserve nothing but praise. Likewise for Oregon and USC, but I’ll get to that later.

Top 25

I have to say, I’ve never been as impressed with the polls as I am right now. Almost every team came in right about where they deserved after week one. Teams that should have dropped (Michigan, Stanford, Oklahoma) did so, and dropped the appropriate amount. Teams that deserved to move up (Oregon, West Virginia, Ohio State) also moved a few spots. The only real complaint is South Carolina – we’re still pretending that’s a top 10 team? – and the coaches jumped WVU over the Gamecocks anyway. Looks like people are finally doing their homework.

As I said, I’ve decided to hold off on releasing rankings for at least one more week, two if I deem it necessary. Some teams still have players under suspension or don’t play real opponents for a while, so it’s better to take some time. However, that doesn’t mean I can’t draw conclusions from what happened this week.

Without a doubt, the top four teams are: Alabama, LSU, USC and Oregon; I’d also throw Oklahoma in there to round out the top five. Based on last week, Bama deserves to be number one and OU should be fifth; other than that it doesn’t really matter. The SEC teams and the Pac-12 teams play each other. I feel there’s a fairly clear delineation between this group and the next tier of schools, composed of West Virginia, Florida State, Georgia and Arkansas. The third tier consists of most of the teams currently ranked in the teens, followed by the fringe top-25-er’s like Stanford, Florida, Boise State, BYU, Utah and Notre Dame.

I hate to say it, but the truth is that most of the rankings don’t matter. If any two of the current top-five schools go undefeated, they will advance to the BCS Championship. In fact, I’d go so far as to say that the usual group of about eight to 12 true title contenders has been whittled down to those five this season. Teams from the second group could challenge (or more likely, impact by upsetting) members of the elite class, but realistically the list is very short. More on this next week, when I may or may not have my initial rankings.

Pac-12 Thoughts

USC and Oregon were both about as excellent as one could expect, given the atrocious level of competition. The Ducks rolled up 50 points in 23 minutes, then watched their backups allow 31 points, which was a little disheartening. Still, new QB Marcus Mariota looked great in his limited minutes, which was the biggest concern. SC didn’t do their reputation any favors by attempting three two-point conversions and playing their starters into the fourth quarter, but that’s what you gotta do when you’re working on a Heisman campaign, brah! BARKLEY 2012!

In the end, we didn’t learn anything from these games we didn’t already know. Oregon and USC are both extremely talented and faced completely overmatched opponents. Let’s be honest: both squads are just trying to avoid injuries on the road to their November 3rd showdown. These are two of the best five teams in the country and they’ll represent the Pac-12 well throughout the season.

That’s good, because there was little else to get excited about Saturday. We should have known it would be a cursed week for the conference when, thanks to Hurricane Isaac, Nicholls State was unable to travel to Corvallis to hand the Beavers a much-needed confidence-boosting win (this could really end up hurting OSU down the road, though at 5-6 they could apply for a bowl waiver). But where to begin? Wazzu began the Mike Leach era with a dispiriting “thud” on Thursday night, getting blasted 30-6 by BYU. Utah, ASU and UCLA all won, but against vastly inferior opponents.

Stanford then gave the Pac-12 its biggest scare of the weekend by nearly losing at home to San Jose State on Friday night. Make no mistake, the Cardinal looked terrible. As the league’s only ranked team other than USC and Oregon, they must stay ranked for the Pac-12 to be taken seriously this year. The conference can’t afford this sort of embarrassment.

Of course, Cal was having none of that, and promptly lost their opener Saturday to Nevada. Oh, Cal. Every time I think I’m done with you, you pull me back in. I had believed, reasonably, that a year of strong defense and a more efficient offense could drive the Bears to a successful 2012 campaign, but it seems we’re right back where we started with this team. What do inconsistent QB play, a defense worse than the sum of its parts and miscues at the worst possible moments have in common? They’re hallmarks of the last several years of Cal football. Ugh.

Now, just to prove that Cal wasn’t the only team that could lose to a mid-major, Colorado dropped the Rocky Mountain Showdown with Colorado State, Arizona got taken to overtime by Toledo and Washington sweated out a victory over San Diego State. It may be rash to state only one week into the season, but right now the Pac-12 looks like Oregon/USC and a bunch of pancakes. The league will need some member to come up with a big non-conference win, or things could get ugly.

Random Thoughts and Observations

Apparently Joe McKnight took money while at USC, a charge that could have serious ramifications for the Trojans if true. It’s unclear at this point how the powers that be might treat this given that it occurred after Reggie Bush but before the program was put probation. However, it’s a possibility that it could be treated as a violation of NCAA bylaw 19.5.2.3.1., AKA the “repeat violator” clause. That’s the one they got SMU for. Keep an eye on that developing story.

Penn State played its first game since the Sandusky scandal/fallout/Joe Paterno’s death/severe sanctions fiasco, losing 24-14 to Ohio. Not Ohio State, Ohio. From one perspective, I was glad that the NCAA chose to make PSU ineligible for the postseason but still able to stay – why punish the players? However, it was very hard to watch that game and not wonder if the NCAA had erred by not going with their original punishment of a four-year death penalty. If the death penalty wasn’t invented to correct the exact kind of cult of personality still clearly residing in Beaver Stadium and Happy Valley, then what was it created for? It’s going to be interesting to see how the Nittany Lions are received at visiting stadiums this season.

I liked Oregon’s new uniforms in the sense that they combined a futuristic design with old-school coloring. Not sure about all the potential combinations, but we’ll get a chance to see a whole lot of them. I wasn’t happy with Northwestern’s new digs, which looked like a failed attempt at space-age and just came across as pointless. The same was true for Georgia Tech’s ridiculous honeycomb pattern and Cal’s white helmets. Why wear white helmets with home jerseys? It makes no sense. I thought we’d learned from the 2009 Oregon-Utah disaster.

There’s much more to come in the weeks ahead. We’ve only just begun!

Sunday, August 5, 2012

2012 Preview, Part III


It’s time we looked at that wacky bunch of teams out West. Yes, it’s my Pac-12 predictions.

Pac-12 Preview

There’s been the expected chatter about how the Pac-12 will be stronger, improved as a whole, etc. this offseason. But let’s be honest: it will be a shock if anyone other than Oregon and USC play in the title game. The Ducks and Trojans are simply the two most talented teams in the league and both face favorable schedules. Outside of their November clash in Los Angeles that will likely decide only the venue of the rematch, neither team will see an opponent at their level. This makes SC and UO the overwhelming favorites to win their divisions and essentially play a BCS championship game semifinal.

USC has what appears to be the most formidable single challenger in-league with Utah, who the Trojans play in Salt Lake City. The Utes will have a strong defense featuring future NFL DT Star Lotulelei and should trot out a much-improved offense with QB Jordan Wynn returning from injury. Eight other starters also return, including former JUCO gem John White at tailback and their top six – that’s right, six – pass-catchers from 2011. This is an experienced team and the Utes will once again miss Oregon and Stanford from the North. I have Utah pegged for about nine wins, so SC can’t take them lightly.

However, the Trojans should still take the South, as the rest of the competition is pretty pitiful. UCLA has changed coaches (again) and is still inferior to their cross-town rival. They return a lot of pieces on both sides of the ball, (most notably the oft-injured signal-caller Kevin Prince and workhorse RB Johnathan Franklin) but still. This is UCLA. When this program decides on a direction, a long-term coach, or even a defined playing style, let me know. Until then, I’ll expect to see what I’ve seen every year for the past decade-plus: underachieving and mediocrity.

Arizona is in a similar situation, but actually lost as much or more than the Bruins did. If only Rich Rodriguez had come in a year ago, when the ‘Cats had a fleet of senior receivers... they might have been quite good. Alas, the new boss takes over in 2012, after losing four of the team’s top five receiving targets and senior QB Nick Foles. That last part might actually prove beneficial, as Matt Scott appears to be the perfect candidate to lead Rich Rod’s spread-option attack. Also good news: the O-line should have grown up after entering last season with only one returning start. Now for the bad news: While it might take Pac-12 teams by surprise, the Wildcats’ new 3-3-5 defense (long favored by Rodriguez) will require an adjustment period. That’s something ‘Zona does not have: Toledo and Oklahoma State are the first two opponents, and Oregon follows two weeks later.

Then we come to Arizona State, who I have a very bad feeling about. The Sun Devils were in disarray in the second half of 2011, lost a truckload of starters and have seven returning pass attempts on the roster. The program is also in a funny spot, having hired Todd Graham, who has quickly jumped ship from three schools in his six-year coaching career. Graham can certainly coach – only once has he had a losing record, and he led Tulsa to double-digit wins three times – but it remains to be seen whether he was a good hire for the school at this point. ASU’s lack of returning talent (basically, just stud RB Cameron Marshall) combined with the coaching turmoil could mean an ugly year. Like three wins ugly.

Yet that isn’t even the dregs of the South, as we still haven’t looked at Colorado. Thankfully, the Buffaloes don’t take on nearly the gauntlet they did last year, when they faced a brutal 10 bowl teams (including ineligible USC) in 13 consecutive game weeks. That’s pretty much where the optimism ends though, as CU returns almost nobody from the Pac-12’s worst team. Who’s the starting QB? The replacement for all-everything RB Rodney Stewart? The team’s lone bright spot was frosh WR Paul Richardson, who promptly tore his ACL in spring ball. Doug Rippy is a good linebacker, but that’s about all there is to be excited about on defense. Outside of an expected victory against FCS Sacramento State, Colorado might be looking at a winless season.

Now that we’ve run through the list of reasons why USC will win their division, let’s look at why Oregon will win the North. The Ducks are essentially in the same position, with no true challengers, but the North is more balanced than its two-deep counterpart. The bottom teams aren’t nearly as bad, though I don’t think the second-best squad is as good as Utah.

The national assumption is that Stanford is once again UO’s divisional foil, but I think too little is being made of the loss of Andrew Luck. Yes, Stanford has recruited quite well and will continue to run people over with a dominant line, probably to the tune of eight or nine wins. But it’s foolish, disrespectful even, for analysts to continuously ignore how many of the Cardinal’s shortcomings Luck covered for. Did anyone actually watch Stanford last year? The team was simply not as good as in 2010, beating up on an early slate of patsies and struggling against more talented teams like USC, Cal and Oregon. The lack of perimeter speed on both sides of the ball was readily apparent and that problem hasn’t been magically fixed this offseason. Make no mistake, this team will be solid, but no one should be scared of them until replacement QB Brett Nottingham proves what he can do.

From Oregon’s perspective, in fact, the most formidable division foe in 2012 could be Cal. Up front, I’ll make my caveat clear: much of my prediction relies on the development of QB Zach Maynard, who had a 2011 season best described as erratic. However, even with Maynard at the helm and a lack of returning starters, I expect a lot from the Golden Bears. Always a recruiting power, the program has enough defensively to frustrate opponents and the skill players offensively to score in bunches. Keenan Allen (Maynard’s half-brother) is an elite receiving talent and the rushing game features a very dependable committee of backs. The Bears also get Stanford and Oregon at home, the latter a week after the Ducks’ emotional game versus USC. With all that in mind, I think the Big Game will decide who finishes second in the North this year.

What about Washington, who finished third last season? The Huskies continue to crow that they’re “back,” not realizing how ignorant of their own history that sounds. To be fair, UW is much-improved from the dark, pre-Sarkisian days. The unfortunate thing is, Washington will probably be a better team in 2012. The offense lost several playmakers, but the defense will likely take a big step forward to even things out. The problem is the schedule. The Huskies travel to LSU in their second game, then later open conference play against Stanford, Oregon and USC. Despite his talents, QB Keith Price’s health is a question mark, so any missteps with this schedule could force UW to need wins in their last four games to reach a bowl.

The bottom of the division is rounded out by the States, Oregon and Washington. I don’t think there’s a whole lot of separation between the two, so I’ll just start with my closest team geographically. Oregon State has more or less collapsed since the 2009 Civil War and Mike Riley has come under unsurpassed scrutiny during his second stint in Corvallis. On one hand, such regression is natural. OSU relied on a seemingly-endless supply of forgotten talents and diamonds-in-the-rough during their heyday from 2006-2009. Eventually, their luck was going to run out and, even more likely, other schools would begin taking a harder look at the guys the Beavers were recruiting. That doesn’t mean the coaches (or the players, some of whom clearly mailed it in the last couple of years) are blameless. OSU needs to get back to playing classic Beavers football – fast defense, efficient West-Coast offense. There’s enough young talent at the skill positions to do so, but the line is still a major “if.” The defense should likewise be improved, but to what extent? I think Oregon State could reach bowl eligibility but will ultimately come up short.

Last (though possibly not last in the standings, for the first time in five years!) is Washington State, who seem to be on the brink of climbing out of the deep hole the program has been stuck in since Mike Prince left. I liked Arizona’s Rich Rodriguez hire, but I LOVE Wazzu’s decision to bring on Mike Leach. A perennial overachiever, Leach and his style have the potential to work wonders in Pullman, particularly this year. WSU returns a great duel-threat QB in Jeff Tuel and an All-American candidate in WR Marquess Wilson. The idea of those two in the Air Raid should be enough to terrify Pac-12 defensive coordinators. With that said, though, an overall lack of talent remains an issue and Leach was never known for his defenses. Like Oregon State, I think the Cougars will vie for a bowl but fail to reach one.

So with the choices for divisional winners obvious, the question is whether the overall champion will be Oregon or USC. I’ve gone back and forth on this many times, first thinking USC would sweep a pair of meetings, then deciding on a split of some kind, then going with an Oregon sweep. The thing is this: home field for the Pac-12 championship game depends on the outcome of the first meeting. If the Ducks win in November, I can’t see SC winning the title in Eugene. That may sound silly given that the Trojans beat UO there last year, but for all the bluster about how USC dominated the first three quarters (an irrelevant stat), the hard truth is that Oregon should have won the game. The Ducks outgained (in both yards and first downs) and outrushed (yards and YPC) the Trojans, who won the turnover battle and got a hyper-efficient performance from Matt Barkley.

If that sounds familiar, it should – it’s very similar to the Stanford game in 2009, when Andrew Luck fired dart after dart between defenders and over fingertips to upset UO. Given a chance for redemption, though, Oregon’s defense adjusted and crushed Luck and Stanford in the following two meetings.

The counter to this argument is that Barkley is playing with much better receivers than Luck ever did, which is a fair point. Robert Woods and Marqise Lee are future NFL players. USC’s O-line is just as good as Stanford’s recent lines as well, and their stable of backs (which now includes Penn State defector Silas Redd) is just as talented. I actually still think Curtis McNeal is the best back on the roster, but increased depth – one of the Trojans’ few weaknesses – can only help.

Offense isn’t what will decide these meetings, though. We know both teams can score. The more important issue is how many stops each defense can get. In that regard, SC is in a better position than Stanford. Oregon repeatedly exposed the Cardinal the past two years with their speedy backs and receivers; they can’t do the same to USC. Despite the NCAA sanctions, the Trojans pulled in a number of athletes to run on the defensive side, and they know from being scorched by the Ducks in the past (45 points per game since 2009) just what UO’s playmakers can do in space. To be sure, this is top-five team, and it wouldn’t surprise me to see the media rank SC number one in their initial poll.

Yet I still have problems with anointing the Trojans. Depth is the issue that must be addressed first, because USC has little of it. The addition of Redd will be a boon, sure. The receiving corps is elite, though a bit of development from the highly-touted George Farmer would be nice. The team doesn’t have a tight end, though. The defense is one or two injuries away from panic-mode – star DE Devon Kennard already tore a pectoral muscle and could miss the season. The safeties are great, but I’m not totally sold on the entire secondary. This sounds like nitpicking, but they’re legitimate concerns.

Moreover, though, it’s the general feeling I have about this USC squad. With all the raving from TV analysts, you have to wonder how many people really watched the Trojans until that triple-overtime loss to Stanford. The way 2011 began, you’d be hard pressed to find anyone who believed in SC. They beat an awful Minnesota team by two, scraped by Utah, then got blasted in the second half by Arizona State. Then came a close win over a bad Arizona team. After a couple of solid wins, they blew the Stanford game, which got people interested. With the new attention, they ran up the score on poor Colorado (six TD passes? Come on) and an average UW team. Then came the brilliant Oregon performance and 50-0 shellacking of UCLA, which for some reason got just as much acclaim (I think some East coasters perpetually think UCLA is a top-25 team because they haven’t watched them since 1995). It was an very solid end to the season.

Or was it? Yes, USC won their last four games. But three of them were against bad-to-terrible teams. When I look at how commentators are trying to extrapolate that finish to success this season, I get serious déjà vu to the 2008 Georgia team. You may or may not remember (it was news at the time), but Georgia entered 2008 as the preseason number one. Why? Well, they returned a flashy veteran QB in Matthew Stafford and seemingly had all the pieces in place to make a title run. More importantly, though, the Bulldogs had drawn considerable hype from their hot finish to 2007, when they won their final seven games and blew out Hawai’i in the Sugar Bowl. However, UGA flopped (relatively speaking) and went just 9-3 in the 2008 regular season.

In retrospect, it’s obvious that many of the supposed “quality” teams Georgia beat at the end of 2007 were highly overrated. This particularly applies to previously unbeaten Hawai’i, whose only win of relevance was over the worst Boise State team of the Chris Petersen era. The Warriors were frauds, but Georgia still reaped the rankings hype for 2008 until they themselves were exposed.

USC won’t suffer the same fate as Georgia (for one, their schedule won’t allow it. Who else besides Oregon is going to beat them? Notre Dame?). I do believe, however, that SC will drop at least one game to UO. I think it could be the Pac-12 championship game. Chip Kelly is a masterful offensive innovator, but he’s also underrated at making adjustments following losses. I haven’t seen enough from Lane Kiffin yet to think he can beat Kelly twice in one year.

Because I dissected USC’s chances of going undefeated, though, I feel it’s only fair if I do the same to Oregon. You want question marks, you got ‘em. QB? Be it Bryan Bennett or Marcus Mariota (and it looks like it might be Mariota at this point), you’re going to see a new man handling those shotgun snaps this year. Both players add a running dimension Darron Thomas simply did not, but both are also completely inexperienced. The running backs are frighteningly good, but the receivers are just frightening. There’s a ton of talent but very little production outside of Josh Huff, who has battled injuries. Sometime this decade, UO needs somebody to step on the outside to truly make this offense stretch the field. Even the usually dependable line might be a problem if Carson York can’t return from his Rose Bowl knee injury. The offense, long Oregon’s calling card, could be significantly muzzled this season.

The reasons for optimism for the Ducks are twofold: defense and schedule. The D-line should be dominant, the linebackers elite. The secondary is young but played several freshman last year, which generally pays off. Then there’s the schedule, which is just a teensy bit soft. The first four games are at home and after years of taking on at least one name opponent in September, the Ducks decided to take it easy this year. In a perfect world, this would allow the young QB(s) to gain confidence in the offense while the team builds an undefeated record heading into the showdown with USC.

Of course, there’s also a very real danger in playing this kind of schedule. No matter how well the team goes, no one will really know how they are. Not unlike Stanford last year, Oregon could go a long time without facing a serious challenge, which breeds complacency. It could also make the team woefully unprepared for the Trojans, who are not the only difficult opponent on the roster. The Ducks face the two other teams most likely to win the North in successive weeks after playing SC; first at Cal (a house of horrors for UO in the past), then against Stanford. It’s conceivable that Oregon could lose all three.

Despite these very real concerns about the Ducks, the Trojans are imperfect as well. It’s early and I may even change my mind again once we see the teams in action, but for now I still feel most comfortable picking Oregon to beat USC for the Pac-12 championship. I’m unsure of the outcome of the first matchup, but on the big stage I’ll go with the proven commodity. I’ve also roughly predicted the entire season for all 12 conference teams with a margin of a few wins and losses. The results are below.

North

Oregon: 9-3 – 12-0 (projected 11-1)
California: 7-5 – 10-2 (projected 9-3)
Stanford: 8-4 – 10-2 (projected 8-4)
Washington: 4-8 – 8-4 (projected 7-5)
Washington State: 4-8 – 7-5 (projected 3-9)
Oregon State: 3-9 – 6-6 (projected 3-9)

Projected winner: Oregon

South

USC: 9-3 – 12-0 (projected 11-1)
Utah: 7-5 – 11-1 (projected 10-2)
UCLA: 5-7 – 8-5 (projected 7-5)
Arizona: 3-9 – 6-6 (projected 5-7)
Arizona State: 2-10 – 6-6 (projected 3-9)
Colorado: 1-11 – 3-9 (projected 2-10)

Projected winner: USC

Pac-12 Championship game: Oregon over USC


And that's it. Let the season begin!

Saturday, August 4, 2012

2012 Preview, Part II


Yesterday it was the title contenders, today I bring you my picks for each conference, sans the Pac-12. My in-depth Pac-12 preview will come tomorrow.

Conference outlook

ACC

Projected champion: Florida State over Virginia Tech

On paper, the Seminoles seem to have it all: talent, schedule and bitter taste from last season to build on. They’ll still need to dethrone Clemson, but with this season’s matchup at home that isn't unreasonable. The Tigers will certainly make a run at a second Atlantic and conference crown, but it's doubtful all the lucky finishes from last season will repeat themselves in 2012. The dark horse pick in the division is North Carolina State, who have quietly built a little buzz during the offseason. The Wolfpack do host FSU, but I don’t see it. Virginia Tech appears to be the obvious choice to win the Coastal after the way the Hokies tore through that division last year. Minor challenges are possible from North Carolina (though the Tar Heels are ineligible) and Georgia Tech, but VT ought to have it locked down. In the title game, I think FSU is just more talented than Tech.

Big 10

Projected champion: Wisconsin over Nebraska

This is tough one. It’s safe to say that the Leaders division will likely come down to the Badgers and Ohio State (who is ineligible). Wisconsin hosts that contest, so I’m pretty comfortable with taking the Russell Wilson-less (but still-formidable) boys from Madison there. The Legends is a mess, though. Will it be Nebraska, the team who crushed last year’s winner, Michigan State? Or will it be Michigan, the team who hammered Nebraska? Perhaps MSU, who comfortably handled Michigan? Even Iowa, who misses Wisconsin and Ohio State, could factor into the mix. I went with the Cornhuskers because I think they have the best defense of the lot, but any of these four teams could conceivably take the division. Once there, though, the sheer power of Wisconsin’s ground game should be enough to beat any challenger into submission.

Big 12

Projected champion: Oklahoma

It’s gotta be the Sooners. Texas is a legitimate second option if OU stumbles, but as I laid out in my BCS title contenders section, few teams in the country are as loaded as Oklahoma. After being a massive disappointment since 2009, Texas should really return to form this year as the yin to Oklahoma’s yang, but the Longhorns still need another year of seasoning. I’m ready to proclaim them the favorites in 2013, though. Oklahoma State is also still hanging around, but let’s be honest: last year was it. Everything fell into place perfectly in a way it might never again for OSU. I don’t expect the program to fall off the map, but a clear step backwards this season is inevitable. I also already explained why West Virginia, despite a wealth of offensive riches, won’t cut it this season. The only other team on a similar level is TCU, who I think will surprise in their first Big 12 season. However, they still shouldn’t finish higher than about third.

Big East

Projected champion: Louisville

There are a lot of teams at the same wavelength in the Big East, five of which I think have a legit shot at the title and requisite BCS berth (sweet Lord, please let it be 2014 already so we can stop subsidizing this league’s mediocrity). USF, Pitt, Cincy and Rutgers are all about as good as the Cardinals. Each team hosts some combination of the other contenders. There’s nothing to really separate them, so I like Louisville. They’ve got the best QB by far in young Teddy Bridgewater, who I touted last season as a player of the future. Well, I’ve decided the future is now. I’ve also always liked USF’s B.J. Daniels, but he can never seem to play consistently or stay healthy. The Cardinals get the Bulls in the ‘Ville, so picking them makes about as much sense to me as anything that goes on in this nutty conference.

Conference USA

Projected champion: SMU over Southern Miss

In the East the main contenders are the Knights and last year’s champ Southern Miss. USM is still a threat but the Golden Eagles do lose a lot. In terms of overall talent I think UCF has been the best or second-best team in this conference for three or four years now, which should translate into a highly successful year in 2012. Unfortunately, the Knights were just banned from the postseason. The West is a little trickier. Houston, Tulsa and SMU are all very similar in both talent and scheme (explosive passing offense, little D). I think the Cougars will drop off a bit after losing Case Keenum, so that leaves the Golden Hurricane and the Mustangs. While I have a very healthy respect for Tulsa, I’ll take SMU, who gets not only Tulsa but also Houston at home this season. In the championship game, I predict SMU will finally break through and take the conference crown.


MAC

Projected champion: Ohio over Western Michigan

I see the West as a two-team race between WMU and Toledo. Defending champ Northern Illinois would also be in the mix, but losing QB Chandler Harnish will prove to be too much to overcome. Both the Broncos and Rockets are led by excellent signal-callers; WMU’s Alex Carder is probably the best QB in the MAC, and Toledo’s two-headed monster of Terrance Owens and Austin Dantin will wreak havoc on the conference as well. Toledo has a slightly tougher schedule and has to play at Western, so I’m going with the Broncos. In the East, Ohio looks to be the team to beat. I don’t see a true threat to the defending division champs, who have quietly built a very solid program under Frank Solich. The title game will go to the Bobcats, who should use the motivation of last season’s heartbreaking loss to break through in the same way NIU did last year.

Mountain West

Projected champion: Boise State

How weird is it that despite going 12-1 each of the past two seasons the Broncos have not won a conference crown since 2009? No matter. Boise will roll through their last season in the MWC. Even with uncertainty at QB for the first time in four years, BSU remains the envy of their mid-major peers (especially now that TCU is in the Big 12).You can’t look at this conference and see a legitimate challenger for Boise. Nevada is decent but still young, Fresno State and Hawai’i changed coaches and San Diego State has to play everyone good in the conference on the road. There will be very little suspense in this race. The Broncos have to replace a lot of veterans but they're still in another class right now.

Pac-12

Projected champion: Coming tomorrow

SEC

Projected champion: LSU over Georgia

I’ve been over the disgusting talent level on LSU’s roster and also laid out why I think Alabama and Arkansas won’t be good enough to beat the Tigers this year. The Crimson Tide need another season to reload; the Razorbacks just don’t have enough to compete. The West seems pretty cut-and-dry to me. The East is less so, but I still like Georgia to repeat. Florida will definitely be improved and the Gators D has the potential to be scary-good. I think South Carolina will take a step back this year, while Tennessee will re-emerge as a program. The stiffest test will come from UF, but the Bulldogs will have enough to win the division (they absurdly miss LSU, Bama and Arkansas AGAIN). Then they’ll be served on a sacrificial altar to LSU in Atlanta again. If anyone cares about the newbies, Texas A&M will be about a .500 team this year and Mizzou will win around eight games.

Sun Belt

Projected champion: Troy

The Sun Belt, ever the butt of jokes and derisive laughter, has made a some strides in the past few years. No longer is the SBC the nation’s worst conference (that honor now goes to the WAC). Furthermore, some members have made a splash on the public’s radar, such as last year’s Arkansas State team that went 10-3. That doesn’t mean the league is ready to start beating power conference teams on a regular basis, but the SBC’s future is looking solid, especially with the planned expansion to 10 schools. There are no fewer than four legit contenders for the crown in 2012, with wildly varying strengths and weaknesses. Perennial powerhouse Troy finished a shocking 2-6 last season, but the Trojans will undoubtedly be back. Emerging mid-major power FIU lost the league’s best player but return a great defense. Western Kentucky returns a ton of starters from last year’s second-place finish, and defending champ Arkansas State is still a threat as well. In the end I’ll pick Troy to rebound, though I could be way off the mark here.

WAC

Projected champion: Utah State

Oh, how far the WAC has fallen. Once a 16-school behemoth that provided a home for all the displaced small programs, the West Coast’s original mid-major conference has almost completely dissolved. I honestly don’t expect the league to last much longer as an FBS conference, which is a shame. With the defections of Boise State, Hawai’i, Nevada and Fresno State, the WAC has lost not only its best teams but also its identity. Of the seven 2012 members of the conference, two (Texas State and UT-San Antonio) are making their FBS debuts. You can’t expect much from those schools, so the race will likely come down to the other five teams. I think only defending champ Louisiana Tech and Utah State will truly be in the running. The Aggies lost multiple winnable games last season, and I think they’ll make sure that doesn’t happen again this year.

Tomorrow is the third and final section of my 2012 preview, which concludes with all my wonderful thoughts about the Pac-12 this season.