Sunday, January 20, 2013

Au Revoir


It seemed a good idea to wait a few days before reflecting on the 2012 season in order to fully appreciate everything that happened. No, Alabama’s butt-kicking for the ages didn’t need any extra thought, but the overall bowl experience only served to muddle the national picture once more. The SEC rebounded from a rocky start to post huge blowouts in its final two games, leaving no doubt as to which conference remains at the top of the mountain (a seventh straight championship will do that as well). The two contenders for second, though, both had lackluster campaigns. The Big 12 seemed poised to emphatically grab the title after the Pac-12 dropped to just 2-4 in the postseason, including a blowout loss by UCLA to Baylor. But the leagues’ fortunes reversed following the start of the New Year. The Big 12 lost its last two and three of its last four, culminating in successive humbling efforts by Oklahoma and Kansas State, the latter of which lost to Oregon. Stanford also won in the BCS, pulling the Pac-12 back up to .500 while the Big 12 dropped to 4-5.

The ACC finished with the same winning percentage as the SEC, but played only six bowls to the SEC’s nine. Meanwhile, the Big East continued its surprising success in the postseason, with yet another team downing a higher-regarded foe in a BCS game. Of course, both conferences played weaker opponents than the rest of their automatic-qualifying brethren, but the Sugar and Orange Bowl wins still count. Bringing up the rear (of the BCS conferences) was the Big 10, which gratefully waved goodbye to a miserable 2012 after going 2-5.

So what lies ahead for 2013? The SEC shows no signs of releasing its death grip on the sport, even though it took a couple of surprising losses to even get Alabama back into the title game. The truth is that this run won’t be over until someone beats an SEC team in the championship, and even then Alabama will probably need to be the team that loses. No one will be impressed if the Big 12 or Pac-12 champion wins the title over South Carolina or Arkansas. The season’s final rankings thus point toward where college football might end up in the final year of the BCS.

Alabama ends 2012 the same way it did 2011 and 2009 (and were it not for some ethically murky schedule-making in the SEC, 2010 as well). The Crimson Tide will undoubtedly start next season as the unanimous number one team. They should, they’ve earned it. All of my doubts about this inexperienced but otherwise very talented group were answered by season’s end: the young receivers performed like veterans, the committee of backs adequately replaced Trent Richardson and the defense calmly reloaded to put up similar, if slightly lesser, numbers to 2011. If the program continues at this clip, Alabama will win the next ten national titles.

Of course, that’s improbable because it’s incredibly difficult for a coach and his players to maintain that level of excellence for that long without slipping. We saw that this year when the Tide lost to Texas A&M. At any point, any seemingly unbeatable juggernaut can be brought to its knees. It happened to Nebraska, it happened to Miami (FL) and it happened to USC. Eventually Alabama’s run will end. But with Nick Saban apparently committed to Tuscaloosa long-term, the program is in better shape to sustain a dynasty than any of those others schools. It’s a scary thought.

If the Tide are firmly ensconced at the top, who can challenge them? Even before the thrashing of Notre Dame ended, prognosticators were throwing out ideas for next season. Notre Dame, after that performance, is clearly not on the same level as the nation’s elite. Stanford is on the rise and the team best equipped to match Alabama’s roughneck style, but the Cardinal lack the versatility of the Tide. ‘Bama can play with or without the lead; Stanford, as currently assembled, must always be within one or two scores to win games.

Challenges could come from within the SEC, from Texas A&M, LSU, Florida, Georgia or South Carolina. But all those teams, like Stanford, have issues that would ultimately make them underdogs to Alabama. A&M will probably suffer a sophomore slump next season. LSU loses a lot defensively and still hasn’t found a quarterback; they won’t beat Alabama without one. Florida used the Sugar Bowl as their non-coming out-party. Georgia has lived a charmed life for the past two seasons but this year the schedule catches up with them as they play LSU and Clemson. South Carolina has a lot of potential but a small window. I think the Gamecocks need to knock off ‘Bama while they still have Jadeveon Clowney or they’re not going to do it.

While all the SEC rivals are formidable, Alabama would still be favored against each one. That leaves Oregon, the team that many are already projecting as the Tide’s opponent in next season’s BCS Championship. These way-too-early predictions are just that, but there’s logic to them as well. Oregon’s radically different style is hard to emulate and the Ducks do have a lot coming back in 2013. Oregon is better than the Texas A&M team that beat ‘Bama this year. But for all of Oregon’s advantages, Alabama has a counter. The Tide are so stocked with great athletes on defense it seems imperative to get them during the wear of the regular season. Given the 40 or so days off for a bowl game, it’s very hard to pick against them. The Ducks would need to play a brilliant game built from an outstanding gameplan and get up early like the Aggies did. Even then, if you recall, A&M needed a last-second pick at the goal line to secure victory. That’s the kind of battle Oregon would be in for. It could happen. It’s just not likely.

All of this could change. The Tide could be struck by injuries next season. Players could regress, or some of the touted guys coming in could turn out to be program-killing busts. Perhaps Alabama has been secretly paying recruits and gets blindsided by the NCAA. The fact that these are the biggest obstacles to another title, though, tells you all you need to know about the current separation between this team and the rest of the country.

Pac-12 Final Report

In a strange twist, the conference ended up more or less where it started when the year began. Early upsets of ranked, big-name nonleague foes buoyed the Pac-12’s reputation substantially. Oregon State knocked off Wisconsin. UCLA took out Nebraska. Arizona beat Oklahoma State. In a move that actually helped the conference’s national reputation, Stanford upset USC, another example of how badly preseason polls skew the season’s actual results. When a series of teams started to beat each other in conference play, outsiders started to praise the Pac-12 for its depth, not unlike the SEC. If Stanford beat USC, the Cardinal had to be good. If Washington then beat Stanford, so did the Huskies. All the while, Oregon State was creeping out to a 6-0 record, its best since 1905. With Oregon and USC already assumed to be BCS title contenders, anything else just made the league look good.

Then the other shoe dropped. USC collapsed like the frauds they were. Arizona did likewise (though not before beating USC). Oregon State went 3-3 down the stretch. And in the most damaging result of all for the conference, Oregon was upset by Stanford, costing the Ducks a trip to the national championship against Kansas State or Notre Dame, two teams they would have dominated. The slump continued into the postseason, where the Pac-12 started 2-4 (including a miraculous 13-point comeback from sure defeat by Arizona) with a couple of truly embarrassing blowouts. Even Stanford’s win over middling Wisconsin in the Rose Bowl was unimpressive. Oregon’s strong victory over Kansas State wasn’t enough. The damage had been done during the second half of the season. The Pac-12’s reputation isn’t any lower than it was at the start of the year, but it’s not any higher either.

So what does 2013 have in store? There will no doubt be a lot of changes before next year begins, but here’s the state of each team at the end of bowl season.

North:

Oregon will be the favorite to win the North and the conference. The Ducks return most of the offense (Kenjon Barner notwithstanding) and a decent portion of the D. Most importantly, UO’s style allows many players to get experience, so even younger roster members can make contributions without starting next season. The loss of Chip Kelly is big, but not crippling. Barring setbacks with the NCAA – and that’s a BIG question mark – Oregon will be loaded again.

Stanford will be the close second to UO. With an ever-growing offensive line and an improving group of athletes on defense, the Cardinal will be the team best-equipped to challenge the Ducks. They’ll need more from their offense to become truly elite, but this is a talented team. Finally getting over the hump and winning the conference this season was a big deal. My only question is whether this program can keep up this level of excellence, which has been difficult in the past.

Oregon State’s young group rebounded exceptionally from the disappointments of years past and returns a solid number of players as well. The Beavers will surely miss their best players on both sides (receiver Markus Wheaton, corner Jordan Poyer), but have a committee of backs and receivers on offense and secondary players on defense who should be able to soften the blow. The issue is QB: can Sean Mannion fully recover from his knee injury and consistently play like the guy we saw at the beginning of 2012, or was that an overachieving fluke? OSU’s fortunes depend on the answer.

Washington continued to make strides (and upset at least one big opponent) in Steve Sarkisian’s third year. Still, it’s obvious the offense took a step back and the team ended with the same record as 2011 after looking set up for a nine-win finish. To return to the Pac-12’s upper echelon, the Huskies need both their explosive offense of 2011 and their plucky defense of 2012. While improving, the program has been caught by Oregon State and passed by Stanford. As their league rivals up their game, UW needs to do the same.

Washington State’s first season under Mike Leach was underwhelming, it’s true. The offense was certainly below Air Raid standard and the Cougars’ defensive limitations were on full display. However, the Apple Cup comeback had to be heartening. There is talent on this team and Leach should be the right type of coach to utilize it. That’s not to say it won’t be a slog back to relevance, but more time in the system should start to pay dividends in 2013.

Despite finishing above Wazzu, Cal had to be the last team on this list. The Golden Bears entered 2012 with decent hopes that were dashed to pieces by a 3-9 finish and the firing of Jeff Tedford. I liked Tedford but had long maintained that he and Cal needed to part ways; here’s hoping Sonny Dykes can get this team back on track. Cal has way too many resources – player and otherwise – to be this bad. Dykes is a Mike Leach disciple who led Louisiana Tech to a huge 2012. Let’s see what he can do in a year or two.

South:

UCLA came from semi-nowhere to beat USC and win the division. With a new coach in Jim Mora and a new QB in Brett Hundley, it seems the Bruins have finally broken their rival’s stranglehold on L.A. Can they keep it up? UCLA has not been consistent in the past 15 years. Seasons of promise have led to missed expectations and coaching turnover, despite the fact that the program sits in one of the most talent-rich areas in the country. This team needs to capitalize now on the Trojans’ misfortune.

Arizona State missed out on the South title by virtue of one late UCLA drive but had to feel very good after ending the year with an upset of Arizona and a bowl blowout. Todd Graham’s first season surpassed everyone’s expectations, largely thanks to his dedication to cleaning up a sloppy, undisciplined team. Of course, it also helped to have a great new QB in the fold in Taylor Kelly, who is poised to lead the Sun Devils for years to come. Who knew all ASU had to do was get rid of Dennis Erickson?

USC can only go up from here after their embarrassing 2012 ended with losses in five of their last six games. Lane Kiffin may not have been fired but he’s on a blazingly hot seat and losing Matt Barkley and Robert Woods is not going to help. I think the Trojans will win more than seven games next year, but they certainly won’t be favored to win the division or the conference. For this program, that’s unacceptable. Kiffin has a lot to prove, fast.

Arizona was the definition of up-and-down throughout 2012, but it had to be considered a successful first year in the Rich Rodriguez era. The Wildcats notched a giant upset over Oklahoma State in week two, rebounded from a couple of close losses and were poised to stunningly win the South at 5-3 after upsetting USC. But they went 2-2 down the stretch, with both losses at the hands of their division brethren UCLA and ASU. Losing Matt Scott is a big deal. However, the program looks in infinitely better shape than it did with Mike Stoops.

It’s unfair to criticize Kyle Wittingham and Utah too harshly for 2012’s failures. For the second straight season, the Utes lost veteran QB Jordan Wynn for the year to a shoulder injury, at the cost of the entire offense. There’s no denying that Utah, with its quality defense, would have been a different team with a competent signal-caller. However, the squad has to make plans without Wynn and keep improving its depth, which has been suspect since moving up to a BCS conference. At this point Utah has not yet looked ready to compete in the Pac-12.

Although the Buffaloes beat fellow bottom-dweller Wazzu, it’s obvious this is the worst team in the conference. There are a lot of questions over whether firing Jon Embree was the right move, but what’s done is done. CU has been horrendous the past two seasons; think 2008-2010 Washington State bad. There are few players on the roster who would start for any other teams in the league, there’s no identity on offense or defense and the coaching situation is in flux. Unfortunately, this may yet get worse before it gets better. History shows that Colorado is a place where football games can be won. It’s just hard to see that happening in the near future.

Season-ending Thoughts

I don’t even know where to begin with the Manti Te’o story. Suffice it to say that his and Notre Dame’s explanation of what happened seems more than a little suspect, and even if this Tuiasosopo character (dear Lord, there’s ANOTHER one?) confesses to everything many people will never believe this was anything but a cover-up. Only Te’o knows what happened and I doubt he’ll ever come clean. I’d like to believe that he lied to school officials about the situation and they were unaware… but this is Notre Dame. Myth-making is practically a major there.

In more relevant Notre Dame news, I went looking for answers as to why the Irish defense – so good during the regular season – looked utterly outmatched against the good, but not elite Alabama offense. Granted, the Tide play a physical, in-your-face game, but style isn’t enough to explain the domination we saw. Notre Dame led the entire country in scoring defense (before the bowls). An elite D should have been able to do something to adjust. So was it possible that the Fighting Irish’s strong defense was a product of a weak schedule?

Recall, in August, that Notre Dame’s schedule was daunting. 10 BCS conference opponents, the only good academy (Navy) and a solid independent (BYU) lay in wait. If the team could get through that minefield unscathed, they deserved to play for a national championship, I said. And they did. However, as the season progressed it became clear that, through no fault of its own, many of the team’s opponents were decidedly underperforming. USC was the biggest flop, but Oklahoma – despite a 10-win season – underachieved as well (Side note: Kirk Herbstreit, how do you feel about OU playing in the BCS now?).

This trend continued down the Irish’s schedule. With the exception of Stanford (and we all know how that game ended), not one of Notre Dame’s foes lived up to the hype. BYU dropped to 7-5. Likewise for Miami (FL). Traditional rivals Michigan and MSU were a combined 14-10. All in all, the schedule turned out to be merely average. More to the point, the offenses the Irish faced weren’t even that. That’s where the defensive numbers begin to be explained.

Notre Dame faced exactly three offenses ranked in the nation’s top 50, and even that comes with an asterisk – USC, the lowest ranked of the three, was playing without Matt Barkley (One might argue that being coached by Lane Kiffin was in fact a bigger handicap, but I can neither confirm nor deny that). In any case, that’s a pretty easy group of offenses to play against. The story becomes even clearer when you compare Notre Dame to the other scoring defenses in the top five nationally: Alabama, BYU, Rutgers and Florida.

Each of those teams played at least four top-50 offenses and none was against a crippled team like USC. Additionally, comparing the 12 FBS offenses each of the five defenses faced in descending order (from best to worst) reveals a couple of things. For one, Notre Dame had the strongest opponent in only two of twelve games (their eighth- and ninth-best foes), while they had the weakest opponent in three and the second-weakest in two more. In eight of 12 games – or two-thirds of the season – the Irish faced the third, fourth or fifth rated offense, i.e., average to below-average. That includes each of the best seven offenses they played.

This is particularly relevant because the gap in quality gets much wider past the middle of the pack. At a certain point, be it ranked 75th or 85th, an offense just isn’t very good. Every offense in the top 50 is pretty solid. All of the top-five defenses played at least one top-25 offense, so those numbers are about even. But because the other schools faced additional offenses near that level of quality and Notre Dame did not, the results show that the Irish faced a fairly weak set of teams en route to their lofty defensive ranking.

Even with this information, though, I wasn’t satisfied. There wasn’t a consistent pattern to explain what made the ND defense overrated. That’s because I hadn’t noticed the outlier. Oklahoma’s offense finished 12th in the nation and Notre Dame played its best game of the season – on both sides – against the Sooners. But OU was by far the best team the Irish faced. What would happen, I wondered, if you eliminated the best and worst offenses each team played and then re-averaged those opponents?

The results speak for themselves:

                      Average rank of opposing offense       Average rank (minus best/worst)
Florida           58.4                                                      58.3
Alabama        64.7                                                      65.5
Rutgers         70.4                                                      71.5
BYU               71.3                                                      71.7
Notre Dame   69.8                                                      82.6

First off, well done, Florida. A top-five defense with that schedule? Wow. When you consider how bad Florida’s offense was, you can make a strong case that the Gators, not the Tide, had the nation’s best defense. Now, about these numbers. It’s fairly obvious that Oklahoma severely skewed Notre Dame’s average. None of the other four schools here saw their number change by any more than about one point. Notre Dame’s skyrocketed. It further explains why the Irish defense was “less than meets the eye.” All of these teams played a few terrible offenses and few so-so ones, but only Notre Dame failed to face any that were truly great (save one).

By the way, I also didn’t count the national championship, when Notre Dame gave up 42 points.

It was a wild and wonderful season. True, I had hoped someone other than an SEC team might be holding the crystal football in January, but there’s always next year. This was also a season in which I learned a few lessons, which I’d like to share.

Traditional football logic says that offense wins games and defense wins championships. That’s certainly never been truer than in this SEC-centric age. However, within that philosophy there’s always been a certain understanding that crucial to playing great defense is the ability to keep said defense rested by denying the opposition the ball. Hence the decades of offenses based on rushing as a first, second and third option. The spread revolution of the past decade has been the greatest challenger in history to that philosophy and changes in the rules at the pro and college level have enabled offenses to soar to heights that would have been laughable only a generation ago.

Running the football, though, requires at least a token ability to keep the defense honest with the threat of the pass. One of my biggest irritants is teams that win by stubbornly handing the ball off 40 times and tossing a half-dozen bad passes a game with a mediocre QB. However, given the success of several SEC schools in the past several years, it’s become clear this formula is not without merit. By placing the best athletes on the defense (to keep games close) and at the skill positions (to break one or two big plays), these teams can play this ugly style to great effect. It’s immaterial that they get stuffed on the ground over and over, as long as the QB can get the ball downfield more or less in the area of one of his talented receivers on that one occasion the defense bites. It’s an aggravating strategy, but what’s inarguable is that it’s effective.

How will the rest of the country respond? They’ve got eight months to figure something out and end the conference’s stranglehold on the sport. For some reason, I think they’ll be ready. Until then, we’re all just living in an SEC world, albeit one in which their boost from the BCS will soon disappear. Who knows what the brave new world of a playoff will hold? The countdown has begun.

Saturday, January 5, 2013

BCS Championship (and more!)


All I have to say is, bowl season is a wacky time. I saw pretty much what I expected in the Orange Bowl when Florida State methodically wore down Northern Illinois. The ensuing night, however, I got the exact opposite of my pregame prediction in the Sugar Bowl. Louisville absolutely crushed Florida, which, when combined with LSU’s earlier loss to Clemson, threw some doubt into the SEC’s bulletproof image. Texas A&M’s stampeding win over Oklahoma helped fix that a little, but Alabama will need to handily beat Notre Dame – which they’re very capable of doing – to fully restore the league’s name.

In other news, the Pac-12 escaped bowl season with a 4-4 record after winning its final two (and most important) games, the Rose and Fiesta. However, there’s no hiding how overrated the conference looked in the postseason. All of the good will built up from its strong non-league performance is gone, and now the Pac-12 will need a repeat of that showing in 2013 to once again garner national respect. While Oregon easily beating Kansas State was important, it won’t go nearly far enough to help the entire conference.

There are only three games left, one each day until Monday’s BCS Championship. As always, they are rated on a 1-5 scale and listed in Pacific time.

BBVA Compass Bowl
Pittsburgh (6-6) vs. Ole Miss (6-6)
January 5, 10:00 a.m.

Actively shun this game. The worst trend of the bowl explosion – even worse than the newer bowls butting in on the New Year’s Day party – has been the addition of horrendous games like this between the title game and the rest of the BCS bowls. What do these two .500 teams, neither of which deserves to be in the postseason, get out of playing this game? At the very least, these bowls should be played in the first week to get them out of the way. Anyway, Pitt and Ole Miss are a pair of teams who both had a losing record in conference play and have zero positive or interesting characteristics whatsoever. The Panthers’ record was a product less of ineptitude and more of inconsistency. The team alternated two wins and two losses all season long, upsetting Rutgers and Virginia Tech but losing to Youngstown State. Pitt’s saving grace was its defense, which gave up only 20 points a game. Ole Miss gave up a full touchdown more but was also more productive offensively. I’d say the outcome of this game depends on which Panthers team shows up. If it’s good Pitt, the Rebels will be in trouble. If not, it could go either way. I’ll bet on that happening and take Pittsburgh.

Watchability: 1. Probably doesn’t deserve that.


GoDaddy.com Bowl
Kent State (11-2) vs. Arkansas State (9-3)
January 6, 6:00 p.m.

This is a clash of styles. Kent State is a bunch of old-fashioned grinders with an opportunistic defense, while Arkie State looks to spread you out and go. The Golden Flashes are feeling a bit of a letdown following the double-overtime loss to NIU in the MAC Championship that cost them a spot in the Orange Bowl. Whether that carries over to the actual game will be important. The Red Wolves were shocked in their first Sun Belt game but reeled off seven straight to end the year as repeat conference champions.
 Despite playing in a stronger conference (the MAC) and achieving a better record, I’m not confident in Kent State here. For how many turnovers their defense forces the Flashes aren’t very stout yardage-wise and they certainly don’t have the weapons to come back if they fall behind. This is a team that needs to play in front. Arkansas State, meanwhile, has a solid quarterback in Ryan Aplin who has both talented receivers to throw to and a good running back to hand off to in David Oku. The Red Wolves will win this game.

Watchability: 3. The extreme differences in scheme make this an interesting matchup.


BCS National Championship
Alabama (12-1) vs. Notre Dame (12-0)
January 7, 5:30 p.m.

Finally, here we are. It was a strange and almost unbelievable last few months to get to this point, but that seems to be becoming the norm in college football. This is a dream matchup from a media perspective, though from an actual football point of view it may end it up somewhat lacking. You’ve heard the adage “Defense wins championships”? Nobody will argue that point this year. Notre Dame features the nation’s number one scoring defense. Alabama is second. Both teams needed their defenses to carry them, because their offenses are pedestrian. The statistical measure of the offenses, though, fails to tell the whole story. ‘Bama will be favored because there are actually several young but talented players at the skill positions (not to mention likely the best offensive line in the country). Amari Cooper is a future star at wideout, while both T.J. Yeldon and the dependable Eddie Lacy rushed for 1,000 yards. The Fighting Irish have less to work with; Cierre Wood and Theo Riddick are good slotback-type guys, but neither is capable of carrying an offense. Notre Dame’s best weapon is end Tyler Eifert. He’s a great one, but offenses who rely on their tight end as their biggest playmaker eventually find out that their inability to stretch a defense vertically is a problem. Just ask Stanford. The most important position against these strong defenses is QB and the Crimson Tide have the edge there as well. A.J. McCarron, much like his predecessor Greg McElroy, has slowly transformed from a neutrino into a positron (go with it). He came of age in last year’s BCS Championship against LSU, has improved from his simple caretaker days and is now capable of winning a game rather than only managing. Notre Dame’s Everett Golson is the opposite. A bit of an enigma and still just a sophomore, he managed to finagle 12 wins out of the Irish’s schedule this year (though at times he left the game for senior Tommy Rees). He’s a talented athlete but a mediocre passer. For ND to have any chance he will need to have a great, efficient game.

I don’t see it happening. Alabama is once again loaded with top-tier defensive players who will make it to the next level. It would be astonishing if a Nick Saban-coached team allowed a guy like Golson to run around and win the game. The Irish don’t have the receivers to pressure ‘Bama on the edge, which will allow the Tide to mercilessly attack the run game (which isn’t even that good). Notre Dame will try to do the same, but Alabama is better offensively and will eventually score. Building a lead, they’ll be able to do what they do best: run people over inside. Once trailing, the Irish will be unable to crack the ‘Bama D by repeatedly passing. The offense isn’t good enough or fast enough to make up a big deficit. Notre Dame found itself down big in the second half only once this season and it took a terrible penalty to bail them out of it. They’re not used to playing from behind and they’re not equipped to do it. Alabama wins and covers.

Watchability: 5. The offenses could be hard on the eyes, but the defenses are very good.


That’s it for 2012. I plan to return once more with some final thoughts and observations. When the bowls end I’ll be here, as I always am. The countdown to the playoff starts in three days!

Monday, December 31, 2012

New Year's Blowout



After a delightful 5-1 start to the bowl season I found myself sitting at a mere 6-5 thanks to flop artists like UCLA. Hopefully the next few days will be kinder, if Friday's 3-0 mark is any kind of indication. The big news in the past week was Nevada's Chris Ault deciding to call it a career after 28 seasons with the Wolf Pack. Ault is a Hall of Famer and deservedly so; elements of his Pistol offense are now found in football at all levels. It's sad to see such an important figure in the sport leave.

But on to the picks! A time crunch will only allow me to preview this weekend's games. I will edit this post later to account for all the contests through next Friday. For now, you'll have to be satisfied with Saturday's five-game slate. The same criteria apply: all times are Pacific and the matchups are rated on a scale from 1-5.

Bell Helicopter Armed Forces Bowl
Rice (6-6) vs. Air Force (6-6)
December 29, 8:45 a.m.

See what I mean? There is no reason for this game to happen. Two .500 mid-majors with zero decent wins between them, and our reaction is, "Boy! Those teams deserve a bowl game!" The Falcons have been their usual selves this season, rushing for a million yards a game in the triple option and passing for almost none. The Owls are much more balanced offensively. Neither squad can play anything resembling respectable defense. To be honest, I don't have any idea which team will win this game. It's not compelling in any way. My instinct is to go with Air Force, even though they lost to Army (Army, for goodness' sake).

Watchability: 1. Maybe.


New Era Pinstripe Bowl
West Virginia (7-5) vs. Syracuse (7-5)
December 29, 12:15 p.m.

Were this game happening in September, I would have taken WVU by 100. As it stands now, it's tough to say. Was the Mountaineers' 5-0 start really that much of a mirage? Are they really as mediocre as they looked during the Big 12 schedule? Or was it a product of playing in a good conference for the first time? Syracuse limped out of the gates at 1-3 and looked as bad as they have for several years. Then the Orange made a stunning reversal behind QB Ryan Nassib and finished 5-1. Meanwhile, WVU's Geno Smith seemed to lose his ability - and his confidence - as the year wore on. My brain doesn't want to accept that West Virginia is this bad, but I think those are the facts we've been shown. In an previously unthinkable decision, I'm going to go with 'Cuse.

Watchability: 2. Big East teams aren't good. WVU still counts.


Kraft Fight Hunger Bowl
Navy (8-4) vs. Arizona State (7-5)
December 29, 1:00 p.m.

Interesting matchup, this. Navy once again claimed the crown of king of the academies (for about the 15th straight season) by running over everyone, but the Midshipmen were average offensively overall. It was a solid 2012, but they didn't really beat anyone. ASU was one defensive stop against UCLA from winning the South and playing for the Rose Bowl in Todd Graham's first year. Even at 7-5, they have to be happy with how the season played out. Frosh quarterback Taylor Kelly was a revelation for the Sun Devils, a player who they hope to build around for years to come. While ASU played somewhat erratically, losing to Missouri and beating Arizona, they are the more talented team in this game. And for once - thanks to ditching Dennis Erickson - they're also quite disciplined. Navy's ground game can be tough to get a handle on, but ASU's Will Sutton is a monster at eating up the option. Arizona State should win.

Watchability: 3. Few teams run the flexbone as well as Navy and ASU is explosive.


Valero Alamo Bowl
Texas (8-4) vs. Oregon State (9-3)
December 29, 3:45 p.m.

This game is a bit of a riddle. No one would argue that Oregon State has been a better team in 2012, leaping out to a 7-0 start and losing only to Oregon, Washington and Stanford. Texas won several games by narrow and lucky margins and was  actually fortunate to make a bowl game. However, OSU has traditionally struggled going up against teams with greater talent. There's no denying that the Longhorns have a lot of that. In a worst-case scenario, the Beavers get overwhelmed by UT's speed and athleticism on both sides. However, there are a few things going in OSU's favor. First, there's the matter of that potentially ugly assault case involving two Texas players. Aside from being disturbing, that kind of thing has a knack for really distracting teams. There's also game planning and play calling. If there's one thing I've learned in my years of football obsession, it's that Mack Brown can't coach to save his life. Mike Riley,on the other hand, is outstanding. No coach gets less out of his resources than Brown; few get more from their talent than Riley. If I have to choose between the two, I'll go with Riley 10 times out of 10.

Watchability: 4. We're talking a springboard for 2013 for both teams, as well as Brown possibly coaching for his job.


Buffalo Wild Wings Bowl
TCU (7-5) vs. Michigan State (6-6)
December 29, 7:15 p.m.

I'll say this for Michigan State: they're not nearly as bad as you think. That 6-6 record includes a whole lot of close losses. 8-4 was a couple of fortunate bounces away and there's no reason why the Spartans couldn't have won the conference title (hey, they beat Wisconsin). Now for the bad: The offense is atrocious; if "implosive" was a word ascribed to football teams, it would apply to this one. The defense is good, but not as elite as its numbers indicate. Playing in the Big Ten tends to do that. MSU stands a good chance in this game, though, because TCU is fairly similar. The Horned Frogs had to adjust to a mid-season QB change and did it admirably; but it was obvious this was the worst TCU team in about five years. I can easily see this matchup turning into a slow-motion slugfest. Michigan State could win such a game. However, TCU has an advantage in the big-play ability of QB Trevone Boykin, who gives the Horned Frogs a dimension the Spartans simply cannot match. Good though the MSU defense may be, I can't pick a team whose offense is this low-wattage. TCU should win.

Watchability: 2. The teams are decent but the playing style won't be.



Franklin American Mortgage Music City Bowl
North Carolina State (7-5) vs. Vanderbilt (8-4)
December 31, 9:00 a.m.

It killed my soul a little bit to have to type the name of this game. Vanderbilt is average offensively and despite an 8-4 record didn’t defeat a single decent team this year. NCSU features a pretty good QB in Matt Glennon and was the only team to beat Florida State in the regular season. However, there are a few unfortunate facts about this game that swing things in Vandy’s favor. For one, the Wolfpack running game is atrocious. Combine that with their mediocre D and you’ve got a recipe for disaster if the explosive but inconsistent passing attack isn’t clicking. The Commodores, on the other hand, have a top-15 scoring defense. As a clincher, the SEC tends to win these kind of bowl matchups and I’m not going to pick against them now.

Watchability: 2. Neither team is particularly interesting, but they’re better than most mid-majors.


Hyundai Sun Bowl
USC (7-5) vs. Georgia Tech (6-6)
December 31, 11:00 a.m.

USC will be without QB Matt Barkley, but that’s about all the Yellow Jackets have to pin their hopes on in this one. At 6-7, Tech is fortunate to even be in the postseason. After a hot start with the triple option under Paul Johnson the flexbone has become less and less effective. The Trojans’ defense has been terrible this year, but it should get enough stops here to allow SC’s talented offensive playmakers to outscore whatever Tech comes up with. I’m putting a lot of faith in Lane Kiffin, but I think in this case he’ll come through. There’s no way the Yellow Jacket’s defense should be able to contain Lee, Woods and Co.

Watchability: 2. Barkley was the big draw, although Marqise Lee is always fun to watch.


Autozone Liberty Bowl
Iowa State (6-6) vs. Tulsa (10-3)
December 31, 12:30 p.m.

It’s been a struggle for ISU to run and throw in 2012 (though that’s not exactly a new thing). Tulsa has been its typical offensive machine, but playing in the Conference USA stretches those numbers sometimes. These teams met on the opening weekend this year, which adds a little extra intrigue. Rematches are strange in football, particularly in college. The adage that it’s always harder to beat an opponent a second time will apply. However, the records and stats don’t account for strength of schedule, so what’s lost in this apparent mismatch is how good the Cyclones were this year in the tough Big 12. They very nearly upset a handful of top programs and have become a squad no one wants to see. The Golden Hurricane have gaudy numbers but beat pretty much no one. I’ll take ISU again.

Watchability: 2. When Tulsa is scoring they’re a joy to watch, but ISU is defense-oriented.


Chick-fil-A Bowl
LSU vs. Clemson
December 31, 4:30 p.m.

I like Clemson. Clemson is a good team. Clemson has the best (maybe the three best) offensive player(s) in this game. Tahj Boyd, Sammy Watkins and Andre Ellington are a trio of which most teams in the country are envious. But we’re talking about LSU here. Say what you what about Les Miles and the Tigers – Lord knows I have – but dadgummit if they aren’t lethal in these scenarios. A finesse, spread offense featuring small, quick skill players? Sound familiar? LSU eats those teams alive. It doesn’t matter that they don’t have a QB or an offense with a pulse. The defense will get things done long enough for the offense to make one or two plays. That’s how it always works for the Bayou Bengals in non-conference games. Clemson is no slouch, but the ACC is, and I would never be foolish enough to pick the ACC over the SEC after what we’ve seen out of both leagues, not only in the past but during this season. Don’t trust the ACC. Believe in the SEC. LSU wins.

Watchability: 4. I expect a one-sided game but there will be a lot of talent on the field.



Taxslayer.com Gator Bowl
Mississippi State (8-4) vs. Northwestern (9-3)
January 1, 9:00 a.m.

MSU followed a familiar pattern of beating up a bunch of patsies to steal a national ranking, then flopped once they started playing good teams. It wasn’t as if the Bulldogs lost close, either: in four of their final five games, MSU lost by at least 17 points. Northwestern had a heartbreaking year that should have ended in a Big Ten championship but was undone by a handful of unlucky breaks. Now, in the past MSU and the SEC have rebounded from underwhelming regular seasons to win these bowl games, but in this case I’m going against historical trends. I like the Wildcats’ playmaking combination of Kain Colter and Venric Mark. Despite Northwestern’s inability to throw the ball, they can make enough plays to beat this overrated Bulldogs squad. MSU crumpled when the spotlight was on this year, while the Wildcats hung with the best teams in the conference even when they didn’t win.

Watchability: 3. About as inadequate as a New Year’s bowl can get.


Heart of Dallas Bowl
Purdue (6-6) vs. Oklahoma State (7-5)
January 1, 9:00 a.m.

It’s no secret that I’m fond of this Oklahoma State team. But for a few key injuries, the Cowboys could have actually been contenders this season in the Big 12. But past my own bias, this is a game OSU should win. Purdue went .500 in the dreadful Big Ten and had to win its final three against bottom-feeders Iowa, Indiana and Illinois to get to bowl eligibility. Okie State puts up points fast and can make it look easy. Though the Cowboys’ defense is pretty shoddy, it’s not really much worse than the Boilermakers’. This should be a rout.

Watchability: 2. Actually, THIS is as bad as New Year's bowls get. OSU will score but the game won’t be close.


Capital One Bowl
Georgia (11-2) vs. Nebraska (10-3)
January 1, 10:00 a.m.

Before their respective conference championship games, I might have gone with Nebraska. Both teams’ performance in those games, though, changed things significantly. Georgia didn’t beat anyone of value during the regular season, but showed up big-time against Alabama. The Cornhuskers, with a Rose Bowl berth seemingly in their grasp, choked spectacularly against Wisconsin. Nebraska doesn’t play much D, as seen by the 70 the Badgers threw on them. UGA will have a field day running and throwing and I expect them to build a decent lead. When that happens, Nebraska’s QB-oriented attack will stall out, because dinky play fakes and option runs tend to not fool a defense when it has a multiple-score lead. If the Huskers have to throw, they will lose. Their only hope is to get up on the Bulldogs early, both to protect their own defense and to allow their offense to stay balanced. I don’t see it happening. Georgia will take it.

Watchability: 4. A couple of name programs and a good number of pro prospects in this one.


Outback Bowl
South Carolina (10-2) vs. Michigan (8-4)
January 1, 10:00 a.m.

Injuries schmin-juries. South Carolina brushed off devastating personnel losses to reach 10 wins despite actually playing some difficult cross-division games in the SEC. Michigan, despite gamely limping to a 8-4 record themselves, proved everything we had assumed about them in their blowout loss to ‘Bama in the opener. The Wolverines were never really in the Big Ten chase and have clearly regressed from 2011. At times this season Big Blue was an absolute mess on offense. The defense was solid, but remember, this is the Big Ten we’re talking about. I don’t care who the Gamecocks trot out on offense, they’re not losing this game. The defense is still scary-good and features a plethora of potential NFL talent. UM won’t score on these guys. It’s possible that Carolina’s crippled offense may have some problems of its own, but in the end the SEC team will be able to make the plays to win this game.

Watchability: 3. Michigan shouldn’t be playing on New Year’s Day.


Rose Bowl
Wisconsin (8-5) vs. Stanford (11-2)
January 1, 2:00 p.m.

On paper, Stanford should be able to mow down this Badgers team. However, I’ve got a feeling, much like I did before the Big Ten Championship, that Wisconsin is going to surprise us. Before that game I outlined why the Badgers were underrated, an argument that noted how many close games the team had unluckily lost. Question: which of these teams has the better offense? If you said Wisconsin, you’re right. The Badgers are superior in both yards and scoring. The defenses are roughly comparable. Both squads rely on running the ball down the opposition’s throat and squeezing them inside defensively. The Cardinal have the better passing attack, which would seem to give them more options regardless of what type of game this turns out to be. But anyone who has watched Stanford this year knows that regardless of what the stats say, this is not a team comfortable throwing the ball. There are a number of other factors that loom in Wisconsin’s favor: the motivation to not lose a third straight Rose Bowl, the opportunity to silence critics who believe they shouldn’t be there and the chance to send Montee Ball out right. On top of that, there’s the nagging issue of the Pac-12’s atrocious performance so far this bowl season, which has made me highly suspicious of the conference’s overall quality. What the heck, I’ll go for it: Wisconsin in an upset.

Watchability: 4. The only thing keeping this from a top rating is the extremely boring style of both teams.


Discover Orange Bowl
Northern Illinois (12-1) vs. Florida State (11-2)
January 1, 5:30 p.m.

The superb Husky offense meets the outstanding Seminole D. I like this NIU team a lot and defended them vociferously after their BCS selection, which I felt they deserved. Jordan Lynch is as good a player as the mid-majors can offer and the defense is ranked in the top 20 in scoring. However, it’s probably true that FSU will overwhelm them in this game. It’s not because the Huskies are bad; it’s much more a matter of matchups, and the truth is that the Seminoles are a terrible team for NIU to play. What defeats the spread option and dual threat QB’s like Lynch? Fast, athletic defenses with size and speed. The ‘Noles have that in spades. For a team that rushes for as many yards as NIU does, they’re remarkably small. That bodes ill against the monstrous (and quick) FSU front. On the perimeter the matchups may be even worse. Florida State has been inconsistent at times offensively this year but has the ability to score with anyone. I doubt the Huskies will get many stops in this game. When they get down, they won’t be able to answer in their usual fashion, which throws the whole team out of rhythm. FSU will win.

Watchability: 3. It’s the Orange Bowl, but this might be one-sided.


Allstate Sugar Bowl
Louisville (10-2) vs. Florida (11-1)
January 2, 5:30 p.m.

Look, the Big East is awful. We know that. But this truly may be a beatdown for the ages. Florida was one grossly unlucky fumble away from going undefeated. Even if the offense is sickeningly bad, the Gators are good enough defensively to make up for almost anything. Louisville is a feel-good team but one that just didn’t do anything impressive during the regular season, even against a very weak schedule. They only averaged 31 points and gave up about one touchdown less per game. I’m positive they’re not as good as Northern Illinois. Florida’s offensive numbers are worse than the Cardinals’, yes, but that comes from playing in a league where defense is more than just an urban legend. This game distinctly reminds me of the 2009 Cincinnati-Florida matchup, when the high-scoring Big East champs were throttled by the Gators. The difference this time is that while UF’s D is just as good, Louisville is much worse on offense than that Cincy team. This could get really ugly.

Watchability: 3… if you like sacks and interceptions.


Tostitos Fiesta Bowl
Oregon (11-1) vs. Kansas State (11-1)
January 3, 5:30 p.m.

Ah, fate. But for a few lost hours on the night of November 17, this matchup might be taking place a few days later in the National Championship. Alas, it was not to be. At least we’ll always know who WOULD have won that game. Both defenses are solid units that have given up too many big plays at times this season. The biggest advantage appears to be the Oregon offense; the Ducks average 550 yards and 50 points a game. K-State is no slouch themselves, scoring over 40 per contest, but UO is in another stratosphere. The catalyst for this has been Oregon’s young QB Marcus Mariota, who coolly guided a young offense with 30 TD passes and an unflappable demeanor. Of course, when it comes to unflappable signal-callers, even Mariota has to bow to KSU’s Collin Klein, who has dragged the Wildcats to 21 wins in their last 24 games seemingly through sheer force of will. He’s not fast or a great passer, but he makes plays in crunch time. Oregon has struggled some with dual-threat QB’s in the past, but seemed to turn a corner in the 2010 BCS Championship with a stellar effort against Auburn’s Cam Newton. Since then UO has been quite good at scheming away what opposing offenses want to do. Kansas State has seen some powerful offenses in the Big 12, but this is probably the best of them all and I’m not sure they’ll be able to handle the Ducks’ speed and versatility. Mariota’s emergence has given UO a factor they lacked until this year. Oregon won’t stop the Wildcats’ offense, but they’ll attack their bread-and-butter ground game and force KSU to throw more than they want. If the Ducks get up and keep scoring, I don’t see Kansas State keeping up. Oregon should win.

Watchability: 5. There will be scoring and these are two high-quality squads.


AT&T Cotton Bowl
Texas A&M (10-2) vs. Oklahoma (10-2)
January 4, 5:00 p.m.

What a matchup this is. While neither the Sooners’ nor the Aggies’ defense is anything to sneer at, the story here is offense. Offense offense offense. Both teams average 500+ yards a game and can explode at a moment’s notice. Give the edge through the air to OU for their talented receivers and the advantage on the ground to option-friendly A&M, but both attacks are versatile enough to go either way. For the Sooners, it’s a question of consistency. Can this team bring enough defensive intensity to contain Johnny Football and avoid the offensive mistakes that have plagued them in their confounding losses? A&M is on a roll and boasts the Heisman winner, although that’s historically been a footnote rather than an exclamation point. Oklahoma should be seething at being left out of the BCS and ready to prove that they belonged there. I’d imagine both of these teams, so familiar with each other, would also like to strike a blow for conference bragging rights. I want to pick OU, but I’ve just been burned too many times in big games by these guys. Until the Sooners can prove that they deserve my respect in high-profile showdowns like this, I’m not taking them again. Texas A&M beats the Heisman Curse and wins.

Watchability: 5. Historic powerhouses in what is essentially a BCS game.


So that’s it through Friday. There are only three games next week, after which we will celebrate the looming one-year death-day of the BCS. Onward, to victory! And a playoff that works for the people, by the people!

Friday, December 28, 2012

New Year's Blowout


After a delightful 5-1 start to the bowl season I found myself sitting at a mere 6-5 thanks to flop artists like UCLA. Hopefully the next few days will be kinder, if Friday's 3-0 mark is any kind of indication. The big news in the past week was Nevada's Chris Ault deciding to call it a career after 28 seasons with the Wolf Pack. Ault is a Hall of Famer and deservedly so; elements of his Pistol offense are now found in football at all levels. It's sad to see such an important figure in the sport leave.

But on to the picks! A time crunch will only allow me to preview this weekend's games. I will edit this post later to account for all the contests through next Friday. For now, you'll have to be satisfied with Saturday's five-game slate. The same criteria apply: all times are Pacific and the matchups are rated on a scale from 1-5.

Bell Helicopter Armed Forces Bowl
Rice (6-6) vs. Air Force (6-6)
December 29, 8:45 a.m.

See what I mean? There is no reason for this game to happen. Two .500 mid-majors with zero decent wins between them, and our reaction is, "Boy! Those teams deserve a bowl game!" The Falcons have been their usual selves this season, rushing for a million yards a game in the triple option and passing for almost none. The Owls are much more balanced offensively. Neither squad can play anything resembling respectable defense. To be honest, I don't have any idea which team will win this game. It's not compelling in any way. My instinct is to go with Air Force, even though they lost to Army (Army, for goodness' sake).

Watchability: 1. Maybe.


New Era Pinstripe Bowl
West Virginia (7-5) vs. Syracuse (7-5)
December 29, 12:15 p.m.

Were this game happening in September, I would have taken WVU by 100. As it stands now, it's tough to say. Was the Mountaineers' 5-0 start really that much of a mirage? Are they really as mediocre as they looked during the Big 12 schedule? Or was it a product of playing in a good conference for the first time? Syracuse limped out of the gates at 1-3 and looked as bad as they have for several years. Then the Orange made a stunning reversal behind QB Ryan Nassib and finished 5-1. Meanwhile, WVU's Geno Smith seemed to lose his ability - and his confidence - as the year wore on. My brain doesn't want to accept that West Virginia is this bad, but I think those are the facts we've been shown. In an previously unthinkable decision, I'm going to go with 'Cuse.

Watchability: 2. Big East teams aren't good. WVU still counts.


Kraft Fight Hunger Bowl
Navy (8-4) vs. Arizona State (7-5)
December 29, 1:00 p.m.

Interesting matchup, this. Navy once again claimed the crown of king of the academies (for about the 15th straight season) by running over everyone, but the Midshipmen were average offensively overall. It was a solid 2012, but they didn't really beat anyone. ASU was one defensive stop against UCLA from winning the South and playing for the Rose Bowl in Todd Graham's first year. Even at 7-5, they have to be happy with how the season played out. Frosh quarterback Taylor Kelly was a revelation for the Sun Devils, a player who they hope to build around for years to come. While ASU played somewhat erratically, losing to Missouri and beating Arizona, they are the more talented team in this game. And for once - thanks to ditching Dennis Erickson - they're also quite disciplined. Navy's ground game can be tough to get a handle on, but ASU's Will Sutton is a monster at eating up the option. Arizona State should win.

Watchability: 3. Few teams run the flexbone as well as Navy and ASU is explosive.


Valero Alamo Bowl
Texas (8-4) vs. Oregon State (9-3)
December 29, 3:45 p.m.

This game is a bit of a riddle. No one would argue that Oregon State has been a better team in 2012, leaping out to a 7-0 start and losing only to Oregon, Washington and Stanford. Texas won several games by narrow and lucky margins and was  actually fortunate to make a bowl game. However, OSU has traditionally struggled going up against teams with greater talent. There's no denying that the Longhorns have a lot of that. In a worst-case scenario, the Beavers get overwhelmed by UT's speed and athleticism on both sides. However, there are a few things going in OSU's favor. First, there's the matter of that potentially ugly assault case involving two Texas players. Aside from being disturbing, that kind of thing has a knack for really distracting teams. There's also game planning and play calling. If there's one thing I've learned in my years of football obsession, it's that Mack Brown can't coach to save his life. Mike Riley,on the other hand, is outstanding. No coach gets less out of his resources than Brown; few get more from their talent than Riley. If I have to choose between the two, I'll go with Riley 10 times out of 10.

Watchability: 4. We're talking a springboard for 2013 for both teams, as well as Brown possibly coaching for his job.


Buffalo Wild Wings Bowl
TCU (7-5) vs. Michigan State (6-6)
December 29, 7:15 p.m.

I'll say this for Michigan State: they're not nearly as bad as you think. That 6-6 record includes a whole lot of close losses. 8-4 was a couple of fortunate bounces away and there's no reason why the Spartans couldn't have won the conference title (hey, they beat Wisconsin). Now for the bad: The offense is atrocious; if "implosive" was a word ascribed to football teams, it would apply to this one. The defense is good, but not as elite as its numbers indicate. Playing in the Big Ten tends to do that. MSU stands a good chance in this game, though, because TCU is fairly similar. The Horned Frogs had to adjust to a mid-season QB change and did it admirably; but it was obvious this was the worst TCU team in about five years. I can easily see this matchup turning into a slow-motion slugfest. Michigan State could win such a game. However, TCU has an advantage in the big-play ability of QB Trevone Boykin, who gives the Horned Frogs a dimension the Spartans simply cannot match. Good though the MSU defense may be, I can't pick a team whose offense is this low-wattage. TCU should win.

Watchability: 2. The teams are decent but the playing style won't be.



Franklin American Mortgage Music City Bowl
North Carolina State (7-5) vs. Vanderbilt (8-4)
December 31, 9:00 a.m.

It killed my soul a little bit to have to type the name of this game. Vanderbilt is average offensively and despite an 8-4 record didn’t defeat a single decent team this year. NCSU features a pretty good QB in Matt Glennon and was the only team to beat Florida State in the regular season. However, there are a few unfortunate facts about this game that swing things in Vandy’s favor. For one, the Wolfpack running game is atrocious. Combine that with their mediocre D and you’ve got a recipe for disaster if the explosive but inconsistent passing attack isn’t clicking. The Commodores, on the other hand, have a top-15 scoring defense. As a clincher, the SEC tends to win these kind of bowl matchups and I’m not going to pick against them now.

Watchability: 2. Neither team is particularly interesting, but they’re better than most mid-majors.


Hyundai Sun Bowl
USC (7-5) vs. Georgia Tech (6-6)
December 31, 11:00 a.m.

USC will be without QB Matt Barkley, but that’s about all the Yellow Jackets have to pin their hopes on in this one. At 6-7, Tech is fortunate to even be in the postseason. After a hot start with the triple option under Paul Johnson the flexbone has become less and less effective. The Trojans’ defense has been terrible this year, but it should get enough stops here to allow SC’s talented offensive playmakers to outscore whatever Tech comes up with. I’m putting a lot of faith in Lane Kiffin, but I think in this case he’ll come through. There’s no way the Yellow Jacket’s defense should be able to contain Lee, Woods and Co.

Watchability: 2. Barkley was the big draw, although Marqise Lee is always fun to watch.


Autozone Liberty Bowl
Iowa State (6-6) vs. Tulsa (10-3)
December 31, 12:30 p.m.

It’s been a struggle for ISU to run and throw in 2012 (though that’s not exactly a new thing). Tulsa has been its typical offensive machine, but playing in the Conference USA stretches those numbers sometimes. These teams met on the opening weekend this year, which adds a little extra intrigue. Rematches are strange in football, particularly in college. The adage that it’s always harder to beat an opponent a second time will apply. However, the records and stats don’t account for strength of schedule, so what’s lost in this apparent mismatch is how good the Cyclones were this year in the tough Big 12. They very nearly upset a handful of top programs and have become a squad no one wants to see. The Golden Hurricane have gaudy numbers but beat pretty much no one. I’ll take ISU again.

Watchability: 2. When Tulsa is scoring they’re a joy to watch, but ISU is defense-oriented.


Chick-fil-A Bowl
LSU vs. Clemson
December 31, 4:30 p.m.

I like Clemson. Clemson is a good team. Clemson has the best (maybe the three best) offensive player(s) in this game. Tahj Boyd, Sammy Watkins and Andre Ellington are a trio of which most teams in the country are envious. But we’re talking about LSU here. Say what you what about Les Miles and the Tigers – Lord knows I have – but dadgummit if they aren’t lethal in these scenarios. A finesse, spread offense featuring small, quick skill players? Sound familiar? LSU eats those teams alive. It doesn’t matter that they don’t have a QB or an offense with a pulse. The defense will get things done long enough for the offense to make one or two plays. That’s how it always works for the Bayou Bengals in non-conference games. Clemson is no slouch, but the ACC is, and I would never be foolish enough to pick the ACC over the SEC after what we’ve seen out of both leagues, not only in the past but during this season. Don’t trust the ACC. Believe in the SEC. LSU wins.

Watchability: 4. I expect a one-sided game but there will be a lot of talent on the field.



Taxslayer.com Gator Bowl
Mississippi State (8-4) vs. Northwestern (9-3)
January 1, 9:00 a.m.

MSU followed a familiar pattern of beating up a bunch of patsies to steal a national ranking, then flopped once they started playing good teams. It wasn’t as if the Bulldogs lost close, either: in four of their final five games, MSU lost by at least 17 points. Northwestern had a heartbreaking year that should have ended in a Big Ten championship but was undone by a handful of unlucky breaks. Now, in the past MSU and the SEC have rebounded from underwhelming regular seasons to win these bowl games, but in this case I’m going against historical trends. I like the Wildcats’ playmaking combination of Kain Colter and Venric Mark. Despite Northwestern’s inability to throw the ball, they can make enough plays to beat this overrated Bulldogs squad. MSU crumpled when the spotlight was on this year, while the Wildcats hung with the best teams in the conference even when they didn’t win.

Watchability: 3. About as inadequate as a New Year’s bowl can get.


Heart of Dallas Bowl
Purdue (6-6) vs. Oklahoma State (7-5)
January 1, 9:00 a.m.

It’s no secret that I’m fond of this Oklahoma State team. But for a few key injuries, the Cowboys could have actually been contenders this season in the Big 12. But past my own bias, this is a game OSU should win. Purdue went .500 in the dreadful Big Ten and had to win its final three against bottom-feeders Iowa, Indiana and Illinois to get to bowl eligibility. Okie State puts up points fast and can make it look easy. Though the Cowboys’ defense is pretty shoddy, it’s not really much worse than the Boilermakers’. This should be a rout.

Watchability: 2. Actually, THIS is as bad as New Year's bowls get. OSU will score but the game won’t be close.


Capital One Bowl
Georgia (11-2) vs. Nebraska (10-3)
January 1, 10:00 a.m.

Before their respective conference championship games, I might have gone with Nebraska. Both teams’ performance in those games, though, changed things significantly. Georgia didn’t beat anyone of value during the regular season, but showed up big-time against Alabama. The Cornhuskers, with a Rose Bowl berth seemingly in their grasp, choked spectacularly against Wisconsin. Nebraska doesn’t play much D, as seen by the 70 the Badgers threw on them. UGA will have a field day running and throwing and I expect them to build a decent lead. When that happens, Nebraska’s QB-oriented attack will stall out, because dinky play fakes and option runs tend to not fool a defense when it has a multiple-score lead. If the Huskers have to throw, they will lose. Their only hope is to get up on the Bulldogs early, both to protect their own defense and to allow their offense to stay balanced. I don’t see it happening. Georgia will take it.

Watchability: 4. A couple of name programs and a good number of pro prospects in this one.


Outback Bowl
South Carolina (10-2) vs. Michigan (8-4)
January 1, 10:00 a.m.

Injuries schmin-juries. South Carolina brushed off devastating personnel losses to reach 10 wins despite actually playing some difficult cross-division games in the SEC. Michigan, despite gamely limping to a 8-4 record themselves, proved everything we had assumed about them in their blowout loss to ‘Bama in the opener. The Wolverines were never really in the Big Ten chase and have clearly regressed from 2011. At times this season Big Blue was an absolute mess on offense. The defense was solid, but remember, this is the Big Ten we’re talking about. I don’t care who the Gamecocks trot out on offense, they’re not losing this game. The defense is still scary-good and features a plethora of potential NFL talent. UM won’t score on these guys. It’s possible that Carolina’s crippled offense may have some problems of its own, but in the end the SEC team will be able to make the plays to win this game.

Watchability: 3. Michigan shouldn’t be playing on New Year’s Day.


Rose Bowl
Wisconsin (8-5) vs. Stanford (11-2)
January 1, 2:00 p.m.

On paper, Stanford should be able to mow down this Badgers team. However, I’ve got a feeling, much like I did before the Big Ten Championship, that Wisconsin is going to surprise us. Before that game I outlined why the Badgers were underrated, an argument that noted how many close games the team had unluckily lost. Question: which of these teams has the better offense? If you said Wisconsin, you’re right. The Badgers are superior in both yards and scoring. The defenses are roughly comparable. Both squads rely on running the ball down the opposition’s throat and squeezing them inside defensively. The Cardinal have the better passing attack, which would seem to give them more options regardless of what type of game this turns out to be. But anyone who has watched Stanford this year knows that regardless of what the stats say, this is not a team comfortable throwing the ball. There are a number of other factors that loom in Wisconsin’s favor: the motivation to not lose a third straight Rose Bowl, the opportunity to silence critics who believe they shouldn’t be there and the chance to send Montee Ball out right. On top of that, there’s the nagging issue of the Pac-12’s atrocious performance so far this bowl season, which has made me highly suspicious of the conference’s overall quality. What the heck, I’ll go for it: Wisconsin in an upset.

Watchability: 4. The only thing keeping this from a top rating is the extremely boring style of both teams.


Discover Orange Bowl
Northern Illinois (12-1) vs. Florida State (11-2)
January 1, 5:30 p.m.

The superb Husky offense meets the outstanding Seminole D. I like this NIU team a lot and defended them vociferously after their BCS selection, which I felt they deserved. Jordan Lynch is as good a player as the mid-majors can offer and the defense is ranked in the top 20 in scoring. However, it’s probably true that FSU will overwhelm them in this game. It’s not because the Huskies are bad; it’s much more a matter of matchups, and the truth is that the Seminoles are a terrible team for NIU to play. What defeats the spread option and dual threat QB’s like Lynch? Fast, athletic defenses with size and speed. The ‘Noles have that in spades. For a team that rushes for as many yards as NIU does, they’re remarkably small. That bodes ill against the monstrous (and quick) FSU front. On the perimeter the matchups may be even worse. Florida State has been inconsistent at times offensively this year but has the ability to score with anyone. I doubt the Huskies will get many stops in this game. When they get down, they won’t be able to answer in their usual fashion, which throws the whole team out of rhythm. FSU will win.

Watchability: 3. It’s the Orange Bowl, but this might be one-sided.


Allstate Sugar Bowl
Louisville (10-2) vs. Florida (11-1)
January 2, 5:30 p.m.

Look, the Big East is awful. We know that. But this truly may be a beatdown for the ages. Florida was one grossly unlucky fumble away from going undefeated. Even if the offense is sickeningly bad, the Gators are good enough defensively to make up for almost anything. Louisville is a feel-good team but one that just didn’t do anything impressive during the regular season, even against a very weak schedule. They only averaged 31 points and gave up about one touchdown less per game. I’m positive they’re not as good as Northern Illinois. Florida’s offensive numbers are worse than the Cardinals’, yes, but that comes from playing in a league where defense is more than just an urban legend. This game distinctly reminds me of the 2009 Cincinnati-Florida matchup, when the high-scoring Big East champs were throttled by the Gators. The difference this time is that while UF’s D is just as good, Louisville is much worse on offense than that Cincy team. This could get really ugly.

Watchability: 3… if you like sacks and interceptions.


Tostitos Fiesta Bowl
Oregon (11-1) vs. Kansas State (11-1)
January 3, 5:30 p.m.

Ah, fate. But for a few lost hours on the night of November 17, this matchup might be taking place a few days later in the National Championship. Alas, it was not to be. At least we’ll always know who WOULD have won that game. Both defenses are solid units that have given up too many big plays at times this season. The biggest advantage appears to be the Oregon offense; the Ducks average 550 yards and 50 points a game. K-State is no slouch themselves, scoring over 40 per contest, but UO is in another stratosphere. The catalyst for this has been Oregon’s young QB Marcus Mariota, who coolly guided a young offense with 30 TD passes and an unflappable demeanor. Of course, when it comes to unflappable signal-callers, even Mariota has to bow to KSU’s Collin Klein, who has dragged the Wildcats to 21 wins in their last 24 games seemingly through sheer force of will. He’s not fast or a great passer, but he makes plays in crunch time. Oregon has struggled some with dual-threat QB’s in the past, but seemed to turn a corner in the 2010 BCS Championship with a stellar effort against Auburn’s Cam Newton. Since then UO has been quite good at scheming away what opposing offenses want to do. Kansas State has seen some powerful offenses in the Big 12, but this is probably the best of them all and I’m not sure they’ll be able to handle the Ducks’ speed and versatility. Mariota’s emergence has given UO a factor they lacked until this year. Oregon won’t stop the Wildcats’ offense, but they’ll attack their bread-and-butter ground game and force KSU to throw more than they want. If the Ducks get up and keep scoring, I don’t see Kansas State keeping up. Oregon should win.

Watchability: 5. There will be scoring and these are two high-quality squads.


AT&T Cotton Bowl
Texas A&M (10-2) vs. Oklahoma (10-2)
January 4, 5:00 p.m.

What a matchup this is. While neither the Sooners’ nor the Aggies’ defense is anything to sneer at, the story here is offense. Offense offense offense. Both teams average 500+ yards a game and can explode at a moment’s notice. Give the edge through the air to OU for their talented receivers and the advantage on the ground to option-friendly A&M, but both attacks are versatile enough to go either way. For the Sooners, it’s a question of consistency. Can this team bring enough defensive intensity to contain Johnny Football and avoid the offensive mistakes that have plagued them in their confounding losses? A&M is on a roll and boasts the Heisman winner, although that’s historically been a footnote rather than an exclamation point. Oklahoma should be seething at being left out of the BCS and ready to prove that they belonged there. I’d imagine both of these teams, so familiar with each other, would also like to strike a blow for conference bragging rights. I want to pick OU, but I’ve just been burned too many times in big games by these guys. Until the Sooners can prove that they deserve my respect in high-profile showdowns like this, I’m not taking them again. Texas A&M beats the Heisman Curse and wins.

Watchability: 5. Historic powerhouses in what is essentially a BCS game.


So that’s it through Friday. There are only three games next week, after which we will celebrate the looming one-year death-day of the BCS. Onward, to victory! And a playoff that works for the people, by the people!