Wednesday, October 5, 2011

It was nice to be vindicated in so many games this weekend, but I’m stilling pulling my hair out over the polls. Let’s see: I said Virginia Tech, South Carolina, Nebraska and Florida were all overrated. All four lost. And yet only one of them fell double digit-spots in the polls, highlighted by Florida getting wiped out at home and dropping just five spots, from 12th to 17th. That is ridiculous.

Unfortunately, several other ranked teams also went down, which would logically mandate that the polls would undergo a radical reconstruction. Because both the AP and Coaches’ polls failed to do so, it was up to me to re-rank everybody correctly. I take care to value on-field performance over things like preseason ranking, unlike the voters. That’s why I wasn’t surprised to see Nebraska lose to Wisconsin, for example; while the AP had the Cornhuskers 8th, I had them a much more reasonable 12th.

By and large, the upsets that occurred weren’t terribly shocking (even though I was sad to see Baylor blow it against Kansas State). But there was one notable exception: South Florida. Someone needs to arrest Pittsburgh for assault and battery, because that showing on Thursday night got brutal. When the season started I had circled the Pitt game as a potential stumbling block for USF, but after the Bulls’ 4-0 start I thought the inconsistent Panthers wouldn’t pose much of a threat. Never mind. I guess West Virginia really is the only decent team in the Big East.

This week’s schedule is curiously light on good games. Auburn-Arkansas is easily the best matchup. Oregon and California on Thursday has potential, but Oregon should win.
The Red River Shootout (I will NEVER let this be referred to by the P.C. moniker “Red River Rivalry”) is Saturday, but I’d be shocked if Texas made a game of it. The only other ranked-vs.-ranked game is Florida-LSU… enough said. Maybe against this SEC West foe Florida can get a hundred yards of offense in the final three quarters combined! But I doubt it.

Certain teams are to blame for the tepid fare this weekend. There ought to have been a pair of great interconference showdowns, as Ohio State-Nebraska and Arizona State-Utah looked to be solid games. But both OSU and Utah have disappointed, and as a result we’re not left with much. The good news is there will be yet another interesting Friday night matchup when Boise State travels to the snake pit that is Fresno State. This has always been a good series, even if it has been decidedly one-sided in recent years. And speaking of Friday night, let us shed a tear for poor Utah State, who blew a late-game lead for the third time this season against BYU last week.

Top 25

1) Alabama

I thought about it some more. I don’t have a whole lot of respect for Florida, but the Tide’s physical dominance defensively is hard to go against. I still worry about the quarterback situation. Like LSU, it’s a mixed bag. The difference is that we’ve seen enough of LSU’s QB’s to know that they’ll eventually make bad plays. Bama’s signal-callers are still young and may yet surprise.

2) Oklahoma

This week will be critical for OU in my rankings. I think the Sooners are much better than Texas, who has been overrated by the pollsters. If they want to hold this position they have to win big, because LSU can further increase their stock with a dominating effort against Florida. This game is also important because Oklahoma hasn’t been as good away from home.

3) LSU

If LSU beats Florida with the same kind of crushing performance Alabama did, they’ll be number two. If they really impress me, the Tigers could rise to number one. LSU has thrived because Jarrett Lee has avoided the big mistakes that have plagued his career. But don’t look now! QB Jordan Jefferson is back, and he wants to start! This is exactly the sort of distraction the team doesn’t need.

4) Boise State

Last Saturday’s Nevada game was the worst Boise State has played in five years. The Broncos dropped passes, turned the ball over and committed 10 penalties. And they led 30-0 until the Wolf Pack got 10 garbage-time points. There’s no denying it – this team is really good. The one weakness I see is a lack of downfield receiving threats; understandable, considering who BSU lost, but potentially a problem down the road.

5) Wisconsin

I was sorely tempted to move the Badgers up to fourth. But then I remembered a couple things. TCU shut down Wisconsin’s run game in last year’s Rose Bowl. And Boise State tends to eliminate their opponents’ biggest threat quite skillfully. I’d pick Boise over Wisconsin. But that doesn’t mean this team isn’t very good. That much was evident from the 34 unanswered points the Badgers dropped in the second and third quarters on Nebraska. And it sure was fun to see Russell Wilson deliver an eloquent lesson to Taylor Martinez on what the word “quarterback” means.

6) Oklahoma State

There are technically four ranked teams remaining on OSU’s schedule. But three of them are only decent at best (Baylor, Kansas State) or imposters (prove me wrong, Texas). Unless there’s a major slip-up – or a full-game performance like we saw in the first half in College Station – I don’t see how the Cowboys aren’t 11-0 heading into the Bedlam Game with Oklahoma. Oklahoma State just has to avoid such overconfidence themselves.

7) Stanford
When is a blowout not really a blowout? Stanford’s 45-19 win over UCLA looked good on paper, but watching the Cardinal all I could think about was how eminently beatable they looked. UCLA is not a good team, and yet for a few key plays this would have been a very different game. Stanford only outpassed the awful Bruins throwing attack by 38 yards, and the teams averaged exactly the same yards per carry. At times the Cardinal can be physically imposing, but their lack of top-end speed is becoming very apparent.

8) Oregon

This midweek game against Cal could tell a lot about the Ducks. Have they rebounded from last year’s near-meltdown in Berkeley? Or were the Bears really onto something scheme-wise about how to stop Oregon? You’d think that the night atmosphere would be too much for Cal, but they do have an X-factor in dual-threat QB Zach Maynard. He can be spectacular at times and inconsistent at others. He was both against Washington. Let’s see if Oregon’s defense – spotty so far – can make him uncomfortable.

9) Clemson

I would have liked to reward Clemson for beating another ranked team by moving them up. But I expected the Tigers to beat Virginia Tech because the Hokies hadn’t played anyone. Additionally, I can’t honestly say that I’d take Clemson against Oregon, Stanford or Oklahoma State. This squad is young but talented, and they’re looking like the team to beat in the ACC. Unfortunately for them, they miss the three worst teams out of their division, so they’ll have to earn a trip to the conference title game.

10) Georgia Tech

And here’s the other ACC heavyweight. At times you wonder how Tech can be so successful, because defenses will stop that option over and over. And then the Yellow Jackets will explode, as they did in a three-touchdown, two-and-a-half minute burst to open the fourth quarter against North Carolina State. Like Oregon, the offense will never be as good when opponents have extra time to prepare. But that’s an unfair criticism. In any given week, this can be the most explosive attack in the country.

11) Arkansas

This is too high for Arkansas, as we know now that Texas A&M just can’t hold big leads. But I had to move the Razorbacks up given how many other teams lost, and when deciding where to rank them I realized I’d pick them to beat everybody else on this list. This team is still merely average on defense and too one-dimensional on offense, but at times – as the Southwest Classic showed – it can be a hell of a dimension.

12) Illinois

So we come to Illinois, who I resisted ranking at all last week because I didn’t think they had done enough to earn it. So what changed my mind, the last-second win over Northwestern? I like the Wildcats, but no. The issue is that Arizona State was moving up, and I couldn’t in good conscience rank the Illini lower than a team they beat. I don’t think the best team necessarily won that game – I said as much at the time – but as long as they remain undefeated, Illinois will retain the higher rank.

13) Arizona State

ASU played about as bad as is possible in the first quarter against Oregon State and still won by double digits. Is OSU that bad, or are the Sun Devils that good? I’ll say somewhere in the middle, giving Arizona State a big chance to prove themselves this week on the road at Utah. The Utes are reeling, turning what might have been a key divisional showdown into a potential laugher. Don’t screw this up, ASU.

14) Auburn

Auburn has played hopscotch in my rankings for weeks by winning games they shouldn’t, losing one they shouldn’t and now upsetting South Carolina. I don’t think the Tigers look very good on paper or even the traditional “eye test,” but they keep winning and now sit at 4-1. There should be no way they can compete with LSU and Alabama. Arkansas is a different story. I wouldn’t be completely shocked if Auburn managed to win this week against the Razorbacks.

15) Texas A&M

Logic would seem to dictate that after two straight awful collapses and no good wins to speak of the Aggies would drop farther. Yet I can’t get over the fact that this team does pass the eye test quite nicely. I think everyone would agree that A&M should have beaten both Arkansas and Okie State. If not for some mental errors and probably overconfidence with the lead, this team would be 4-0 and ranked in the top five. I can’t punish them too much for losing close games to good teams.

16) West Virginia

After South Florida’s debacle against Pitt, I’m prepared to admit that I was wrong about the Big East. It’s still West Virginia and everyone else. The Mountaineers haven’t always won the conference, but they’re easily its most consistent and respected team and the one every other Big East school wants to beat. This might be a little too high, but I have little faith that the ‘Eers could get beat by any of the teams directly below them.

17) Nebraska

Hmm, looks like having no passing attack at all can hurt you sometimes. Take note, Michigan. It’s always amusing to me when a team like Nebraska reels off a few September wins against mediocre competition and people think they’re elite. Didn’t anyone watch the Huskers last season, or remember Taylor Martinez being benched for poor play? He didn’t just magically get better in the offseason. That said, Nebraska’s overall athleticism and depth will still overmatch a lot of teams.

18) Florida State

FSU is lingering around the bottom of the rankings, and I have to ask why. The ‘Noles’ two losses are to a team that was recently ranked first in the polls and another now in the top ten. The Oklahoma game was close and the Clemson game was even closer (not to mention on the road, with a frosh backup QB). The pollsters shouldn’t get down on the Seminoles. Look at the rest of their schedule. They miss Georgia Tech and could easily win out.

19) Texas

Texas may have been a little better than expected, but there’s no chance the Longhorns are the eleventh-best team in the nation. I expect Oklahoma to knock these guys around on Saturday. However, UT has clearly found some young players to rally around (particularly at QB and receiver) and as I said last week, they could make a run by the end of the year. I doubt it’ll start in time for their rivalry game this week, though.

20) Michigan

Analysts have put Michigan on “upset alert” for the Northwestern game, but I happen to think the Wolverines are much more likely to pull that one out than the following game against Michigan State. Although this team is 5-0, they still haven’t beaten anyone, and I’ve yet to see any signs that the problems of last year (poor defense/defensive depth, inconsistent offense against a defense with a pulse) have been solved in any way. Perhaps this week will provide some answers.

21) South Carolina

The Auburn loss was so ugly Steve Spurrier decided to make a QB change. Stephen Garcia had been winning, so you can’t say it’s exactly overdue, but everyone knew the guy was a time bomb who was going to eventually cost the team a game. Here’s hoping Connor Shaw can be the one thing Garcia wasn’t: consistent. South Carolina should be better than the way they’ve been playing.

22) Baylor

Oh, Baylor. Just when it seemed as if you’d turned a corner, you blew the K-State game. But unlike with Illinois and Arizona State, I have no problem keeping the Bears ranked higher. Baylor has already gotten a quality win (TCU) and it took a late collapse and a fluke interception from Robert Griffin for them to lose. I know this team is better than KSU, and the rest of the season should prove that.

23) Houston

The gloves are coming off, folks. Houston, what’s wrong with you? The Cougars should be so much better than the way they’re playing. After another close escape versus weak competition, I had no choice but to penalize UH. The Cougars are going to lose at some point, because the Conference USA ain’t bad. This team has been very disappointing.

24) Virginia Tech

Well, that’s what I expected. Now that the Hokies have their obligatory loss out of the way, maybe they’ll start meeting some of that preseason hype. I like running back David Wilson a lot, but he’s the only real threat on the offense. I wonder about the defense, too. Bud Foster and Frank Beamer have long been bastions of excellent defense in the ACC, but VT hasn’t played that well over the last dozen or so games.

25) Kansas State

As I said, Kansas State isn’t better than Baylor. But the Wildcats have done enough to be ranked. I don’t expect too much from this team, as they seem bound to get lost in the middle of the shuffling Big 12. Seven or eight wins? Likely. Asking for any more would require more upsets. You think K-State can beat Texas A&M? Oklahoma State? Oklahoma? Not happening.

Pac-12 Thoughts

How about Wazzu escaping with that win over Colorado, eh? I was hoping the Cougs would win because Colorado’s bowl hopes are a lost cause. That sets up more or less a bowl elimination game in this weekend’s WSU-UCLA game. It seems cruel to assign this status to a game so early in the year, but that’s probably what both teams are looking at. WSU faces three ranked teams in their next five games following the Bruins, while UCLA has to play the entire South division plus rival Cal.

Speaking of bowl elimination and the like, here’s Arizona and Oregon State. It seems crazy now to think of the Beavers as a potential bowl team, but there’s no time like the present, right? This is mathematically the end of the line for OSU; at 0-5, they’d need to beat either Oregon or Stanford to make the postseason. At 1-4, there’s a chance, however unlikely, that they could rebound. For Arizona, it’s a chance to prove that their losses have been the result of elite competition and not their own incompetence.

I’ve already touched on Oregon-Cal and ASU-Utah… the Ducks and Sun Devils should win. There’s certainly upset potential in both games, but Cal would need a repeat of last season’s virtuoso defensive performance to beat UO in Eugene and Utah has been a complete mess outside of their smashing of BYU. The rays of hope for the Bears and Utes: Oregon’s defense has shown weaknesses and ASU can play bafflingly terrible at times.

Heisman* Watch

*Andrew Luck

Robert Griffin III, QB, Baylor

How’s this for ridiculous? Griffin’s stat line from Saturday: 23-for-31, five touchdowns. AND I WAS DISAPPOINTED, because he misfired on three of his last four passes and threw his first pick of the year. When that performance is considered underwhelming, you’re doing pretty well.

Kellen Moore, QB, Boise State

I almost dropped Moore off the list for a week after his poor showing against Nevada, the first really bad game of his career. Of course, it was for the second fact that I kept him on. BSU may not have the opponents to back it up, but Moore will rebound in elite fashion.

Random Thoughts and Observations

I was considering placing Clemson’s Tahj Boyd on my Heisman Watch, but I don’t think he quite deserves it yet. To this point, his play has been outstanding, but we’re not even halfway through the season. If he’s still moving the Tigers up and down the field in November, then we’ll talk. I don’t doubt that he can do it, but the schedule isn’t going to do him any favors.

How does the hierarchy go right now in Texas? We can rule out the lightweights: North Texas, Rice, UTEP… TCU is eliminated thanks to their loss to Baylor…and Houston has been disappointing. Texas Tech is undefeated but about to get a rude awakening from Texas A&M this weekend. I think the same is probably true for Texas versus Oklahoma. Baylor is good, but too flawed. So that leaves Texas A&M as the likely best team in the state… and SMU.

Hear me out on this. SMU did lose handily to A&M in their opener. But interceptions on the Mustangs’ first two possessions put them in a hole they couldn’t recover from. SMU has since made a QB change and won their last four. This could be the best team in the Conference USA, which isn’t something to sneer at. I’d give them a good shot to defeat all of the other Texas schools, including Texas. June Jones has that Run and Shoot humming along as usual, which makes the Mustangs tough to stop. Texas A&M is probably the best team in the state, but it’s possible SMU is number two.

Wednesday, September 28, 2011

Into a bold new October we go

It was another thoroughly enjoyable weekend around the country. There was drama at all three standard game times (9:00, 12:30 and 3:30 PST) and in every conference. If you got up early, you saw the back-and-forth shootout that was North Carolina-Georgia Tech along with the ugly slugfest of Pittsburgh-Notre Dame. Just after noon the best matchups kicked off, including a trio of ranked-versus-ranked games topped by Oklahoma State’s fantastic comeback over Texas A&M.

As the afternoon wore on we saw close finishes at California-Washington and Kansas State-Miami (FL). Those were followed by the  primetime games (Missouri-Oklahoma and LSU-West Virginia), both of which were interesting but never really in doubt. However, the day did end with a pair of shootouts in the desert, as Arizona State toppled USC and Oregon held off a furious charge by Arizona.

Thankfully, this weekend saw the quietest off-field action of the young season. Yes, the SEC has now officially added Texas A&M and says it doesn’t plan to grab another team (because 13 teams really makes sense, right?), but that felt like an inevitability at this point. But that was about it. No scandals broken, no crazy coach interviews, no new teams bolting for other leagues. For once the focus was on football, and rightfully so, because this week was just as good as every other has been in 2011.

The one sour note was the unfortunate result of the Toledo-Syracuse contest, where Syracuse’s erroneously “good” PAT cost Toledo a win in regulation in a game the Rockets lost in overtime. The MAC school was apparently demanding to be awarded the victory this week, as the Big East acknowledged its replay official had made a mistake. However, MAC commissioner Jon Steinbrecher has said that NCAA rules do not allow scores to be changed after games are declared over. I think that’s the right attitude to take. While Toledo should have won, bad calls happen all the time, and sometimes someone gets unfairly punished. Retroactively changing the outcome of games is a bad idea.

Top 25

1) Oklahoma

I think Missouri is a fringe top-25 team. The Tigers will be ranked again at some point this year. OU should thus get credit for a relatively decent win. The Sooners’ problem seems to be consistency. I saw the AP Poll has dropped Oklahoma from the top spot; I don’t understand that. Missouri and West Virginia are equal in my mind.

2) Alabama

I would have jumped LSU past Alabama… but once again, look at who the two teams played this week. Arkansas, while overrated, is certainly better than West Virginia. So I can’t justify dropping Bama any more than Oklahoma. It’s illogical. The Crimson Tide should roll Florida this week without much trouble.

3) LSU

Of the top three teams, LSU has the best win (Oregon) and the best body of work. But… I thought last week that the Tigers were number three. I think it can be argued that West Virginia was in fact the weakest opponent between the three this weekend. Based on that, it makes no sense to move them up like the 28 AP voters who suddenly did. Really? You thought WVU was that good?

4) Boise State

Honestly… I think Boise might be the best team in the country. Their competition isn’t close to the kind the Big Three will face. But looking at the Broncos, I can’t find a weakness. And considering how quarterback-driven college football has become, it doesn’t make sense to go against Kellen Moore, who outclasses the signal-callers at the other three schools.

5) Wisconsin

The Badgers finally get a worthy opponent this week in Nebraska, though exactly how worthy the Cornhuskers are is still in question. With the game in Madison, I expect Wisconsin to deliver a sharp “welcome to the conference” to the Huskers. But could this simply be a preview of the Big 10 title game?

6) Oklahoma State

If OSU plays the way they did in the first half against Texas A&M, they’re barely a top-25 team. If they play the way they did in the second half – when they could have scored another two touchdowns and run away with a win – the Cowboys are a legit BCS title contender. The Weedon-to-Blackmon connection is magic, and with the defense forcing turnovers like it did against the Aggies, OSU is a darkhorse.

7) Stanford

Moving the Cardinal down isn’t indicative of their play (Stanford was off last week). It’s more a sign of how good I think Oklahoma State can be, although it didn’t help that Arizona, Stanford’s best win, got pasted yet again. I do wonder about this team. I don’t think they’re as good as the 2010 version. Then again, neither is Oregon.

8) Oregon

Which team is Oregon? The one that shredded Arizona’s defense and held down its offense en route to a 35-3 lead? Or the one that gave up three unanswered touchdowns on back-to-back-to-back possessions, turning a blowout into a scary situation? The good news for the Ducks was that UO finally got the ground game going. That’s going to be crucial as their young receivers grow.

9) Clemson

Clemson’s victory over FSU was closer than it should have been, but the Tigers are still off and running at 4-0. I’ve been really impressed with this offense so far, though the defense does have some things to improve on. I jumped Clemson all the way into the top 10 because I think they’ve been much better than Virginia Tech so far this year and should beat the Hokies this week.

10) Virginia Tech

In most years, the idea of an explosive offense getting the better of VT would be ludicrous. Ever since Stanford torched Tech in last season’s Orange Bowl, though, it’s been a possibility. The Hokies have played solid defensively in 2011, but they’ve yet to face an offense half as powerful and diverse as Clemson’s. VT needs this win at home to prove that they’re still the ACC’s top dogs.

11) Texas A&M

I didn’t drop A&M too far because of the closeness of their loss. But ouch. Somehow the Aggies turned what would have been a program-boosting win over Oklahoma State into a gut-wrenching loss. If the team was hoping to make a statement in their final Big 12 season, they sent the worst message possible to the SEC: we’re soft. That was one of the worst collapses in recent memory.

12) Nebraska

Well, here you are, Nebraska. You wanted to play in a bigger, better conference. You wanted out of the Big 12, a league you never loved. You wanted to turn your nose up at your former rivals by joining the Big 10. Here’s your reward: a night game on the road against powerhouse Wisconsin. Enjoy.

13) South Carolina

What’s up with South Carolina? In the 21-3 win over hapless Vanderbilt, QB Stephen Garcia threw four picks and stud running back Marcus Lattimore was held to less than 100 yards while the offense scored just twice. If the Gamecocks keep playing like this, they’ll have no shot at a conference title.

14) Baylor

I know I’ve talked about Robert Griffin III a lot, but this is getting ridiculous. Through three games, he’s completed 85 percent of his passes. He’s thrown 13 touchdowns against just 12 incompletions. I still think of Baylor as a young, up-and-coming team that can’t beat the best Big 12 squads, but Griffin’s play is so impossibly efficient that the Bears could be dangerous.

15) South Florida

USF hasn’t exactly had to work very hard since their season-opening upset of Notre Dame. As with Boise State, though, that might not be because of the schedule. I believe the Bulls are pretty good, though we’ll see just how good once they enter Big East play. If the team is worthy of a top-15 ranking, they should dominate in this conference.

16) Georgia Tech

Ever though the teams I had ranked above Tech last week won, I still had to move the Yellow Jackets up. Shrugging off a quality challenge from North Carolina (as well as a significant matchup problem on the line), Tech kept its offense churning and burning. They should have beaten the Tar Heels by a wider margin and have emerged as a real contender in the ACC.

17) TCU

It’s hard to know what to make of TCU. On the one hand, you have a team who was tied with Portland State at 3-3 with two minutes to play before halftime. Then you have a team who scored three times in just more than a minute and went on 52-3 run through the next two-plus quarters. TCU is talented but needs to learn how to play more consistently.

18) Houston

Last week saw another highly overmatched opponent go down. No surprise, but in general my warm feeling about Houston before the season has started to cool. The Cougars’ offense should be able to play with anyone, but that doesn’t make them BCS-worthy. It seems that Houston is always in danger of laying a multi-turnover egg and going down.

19) Arizona State

That was the ASU team we should have seen against Illinois. Tough, physical and able to respond to adversity. Where previous Sun Devil teams would have left the door open for a late USC comeback, the 2011 version slammed it shut. At the least, ASU should perform great at home this year. Now it’s a matter of finding some consistency on the road.


20) Ohio State

Colorado wasn’t much of a challenge, obviously. The fact that Miami lost just a week after beating the Buckeyes stings, but the Hurricanes probably had an emotional letdown. I’m still fairly confident in this defense, which can cause major issues for the – let’s face it – somewhat impotent Big 10 attacks. Gotta get that passing game going, though.

21) Michigan

It’s been another September to remember for Michigan fans. Unfortunately, as the Wolverines have shown in the past few years, it’s not all about September. We’ll see if Big blue can continue this run once they jump into conference play. I have a feeling that the mismatched parts of the offense aren’t going to look very good when they face a decent defense.

22) Florida State

I think this is probably too low for the Seminoles. They’re 2-2, but they lost close games to a pair of very good teams. I mean, do you think FSU couldn’t beat Michigan? Ohio State? I’d bet on the ‘Noles in those games. The health of E.J. Manuel is going to be critical, though. FSU won’t hold up over the course of a season with a freshman at QB.

23) Texas

All right, Texas. If I’m going to rank you, get out there and win some games. Starting with that team who notched their first-ever win over you last year: Iowa State. And really, the Longhorns had better get this one, because the next two games – against the Oklahoma schools – could leave them battered and bruised.

24) Arkansas

Arkansas showed a little more fight early on against Bama than I expected before getting steamrolled. There’s definitely some SEC-caliber talent on this team, but I just don’t see them performing very well given their schedule. Apart from the rigors of the SEC West, the Razorbacks still have to take on Texas A&M. I guess it will be a preview of next season, eh?

25) Florida

With all the losses sustained by ranked teams, I’m willing to bring the Gators into my top 25. But their consensus number 12 poll ranking is astonishing. Is anybody watching this team? Their four wins are against teams with a combined record of 4-9 who have a single win over a BCS-conference school (the Big East's Cincinnati)! The next two games are Alabama and LSU, who I expect will put an end to this charade.

Pac-12 Thoughts

The North race has been Oregon and Stanford all along. But Saturday’s Washington-Cal game showed that it’s possible neither the Ducks nor the Cardinal will make it through the conference unscathed. The November 12th showdown in Palo Alto should decide the division, but Oregon plays Washington the week before (in Seattle) and Stanford faces Cal the next week. From what I saw of the Bears and Huskies this weekend, they’re both ready to give a fierce challenge to the Pac-12’s top teams.

Arizona’s unfortunate schedule combined with ASU finally getting the job done against USC seemed to signal that it’s the Sun Devils’ year in the South. Starting out 0-2 in conference play really puts the Wildcats in a hole, making this week’s USC game a must-win. Utah is still out there too, but based on the Utes’ performance in their conference opener I’m not confident they’re up to the task of beating either Arizona school.

USC has obviously started a bit of a downhill slide, which is to be expected given the NCAA penalties. Can UCLA take advantage? Rick Neuheisel’s job depends on it, for good reason. If the Bruins can’t overtake their L.A. rivals in this season, when are they ever going to do it? Looking at UCLA’s schedule, I think six wins is doable. Beating WSU and Colorado at home is imperative, then if the Bruins can just beat SC and sneak out one more win, they’ll be in a bowl. But based on this season’s early returns, they’ll have to improve to make it there.

I think WSU still has a shot at a bowl as well, but a lot rides on this week’s date with Colorado. Win, and the Cougs could ride the momentum to a road victory against UCLA (whom they nearly beat last year) the following week. From there, at 4-1, WSU would need only a win over Oregon State (whom they did beat last year) in Seattle and one upset to reach the postseason. At some point QB Jeff Tuel should return as well, which would improve the Cougars’ chances down the stretch.

As far as teams counted out of bowl contention right now, I see only two for sure: Colorado and Oregon State. Colorado has a brutal schedule and isn’t very good anyway. The Beavers… well, I don’t know what’s wrong with OSU. The UCLA loss hurt.

In previous years, you could count on the Beavs to get up when they had to and beat the teams necessary to avoid letting the season spiral out of control. From 2006 onward, the OSU would rebound after tough starts, upset a couple of quality opponents, and finish the year strong. Ever since the midway point of last year, though (actually, right about the UCLA game), something has been off. The talent level of the team, never a strength, has been decimated by injuries. But OSU managed to work around that in the past. It’s anyone’s guess as to why this team has looked so bad.

Heisman* Watch

*You know how this goes.

Robert Griffin III, QB, Baylor

The competition has yet to be a roadblock, I’ll say that. But how can you not be awed by the accuracy of this guy? Given his next two opponents (K-State, Iowa State), it’s entirely possible that Griffin could continue throwing the rock at an 80 percent or better rate. That would be extraordinary.

Kellen Moore, QB, Boise State

If you want to talk about efficiency, you can’t forget Moore. He’s up there at nearly 80 percent passing too and has a nice 12-2 TD-to-INT ratio thus far. Let’s see how he fares this week against Nevada, who gave up six TD passes to Oregon’s Darron Thomas. This could be fun to watch.

Random Thoughts and Observations

There are a couple of mid-major teams currently flying below the radar who are actually pretty good and might make a splash later in the season. Both have faced nonconference gauntlets early but both also fared well in their losses. I’m referring to Tulsa and Toledo, two teams that could very well win their respective leagues after difficult starts.

Both teams lost three times in September. Tulsa played on the road against Oklahoma, Oklahoma State and Boise State. The Golden Hurricane gave up a lot of points, but averaged 22 points a game themselves. Faced with their less-rigorous Conference USA slate, Tulsa could make some noise and eventually gain a national ranking. The offense – long what the Golden Hurricane have been known for – is definitely there. Additionally, Tulsa gets two of their three hardest remaining opponents (Houston and SMU) at home.

Toledo dropped games at Ohio State and Syracuse and at home versus Boise State. Although Ohio State isn’t what we thought they were, the Rockets played all of their games closer than Tulsa did. Toledo had a first down on the Buckeyes’ 15 trailing by just five at the end of the game and failed to score. As I noted earlier, the team was cheated out of a win in the Carrier Dome (a really loud stadium) this past weekend. And though the Rockets lost by 25 to Boise, the score of that game wasn’t indicative of how close it really was. Toledo had multiple turnovers in the red zone and dropped a wide-open touchdown in the second half. The MAC is easier than the Conference USA, so look out for the Rockets.

Thursday, September 22, 2011

The ACC is NOT screwing around

Some nice action this weekend was sadly overshadowed once again by too much off-field clutter. Rather than building excitement toward the evening’s Oklahoma-Florida State matchup, the nation’s mood was grim, centered on Syracuse and Pittsburgh’s stunning bolt from the Big East to the ACC. This has been a theme all this year and in the season’s opening weeks – uncertainty off the field stealing the spotlight from on-field action.

And it’s a shame, because there were several more genuinely entertaining games this past Saturday. Oklahoma-FSU, Auburn-Clemson, Navy-South Carolina (a telling game, that one) and West Virginia-Maryland all went down to the wire. Most of the major conferences came out with at least one or two nice victories, but there were some disappointments too.

The Big 10 and Pac-12 both came out of the weekend looking pretty bad, even in their various victories. There might not be a single championship-worthy team in either conference, and I’m including Wisconsin, Stanford and Oregon in that assessment. Penn State was lucky to escape Pitt. Nebraska was as unimpressive as a team can be in a double-digit win (over Washington). Stanford and Arizona played a listless first half. Michigan State got blindsided by Notre Dame. Ohio State was crushed at Miami (FL). UCLA was embarrassed by Texas. Arizona State played sloppy (again) and lost to Illinois. The results were ugly.

But, fortunately for the two leagues, any and all competitive problems were forgotten in the wake of what appeared to be, at least for a few days, the death of the Big 12 and Big East conferences. I’ll talk about the new conference realignment later; for now it seems safe to exhale, as Armageddon has been narrowly averted again. But I’m sure we haven’t seen the end of the madness.

Top 25

1) Oklahoma

I wasn’t sold on Florida State, but the Sooners deserve credit for battling back in a tough environment (how long has it been since Doak sounded like that?!) and winning a low-scoring slugfest. The last time OU had an offense of this caliber, they couldn’t win close and ugly. This time, they got it done, which is enough to take over the top spot.

2) Alabama

The development of A.J. McCarron is encouraging for the Crimson Tide. It just seems weird that Bama has a far inferior quarterback this week against Arkansas, yet I’m picking them to win handily. Such is the fortune of having a great defense. As long as Alabama takes care of business the next two weeks, they should be undefeated going into their showdown with LSU.

3) LSU

Did anyone really expect the Tigers to have trouble with Mississippi State? Moreover, did anyone actually think MSU was a top-25 team? I’ve been watching the Bulldogs longer than most SEC teams and in my estimation they’ve merely moved up from doormat to decent. So, no big pat on the head for LSU doing what they should have done against an overhyped team.

4) Boise State

As it turns out, Toledo is pretty good. Ohio State needn’t be embarrassed any longer. But additionally, it turns out Boise State is really, really good. Much better than OSU. Kellen Moore is a legit Heisman candidate, and the Broncos’ stable of running backs might be the best in the country (with Oregon’s Kenjon Barner out, this is a dead heat). Is this finally the year BSU gets the breaks that land them in the title game?

5) Wisconsin

I moved the Badgers over Stanford because they pasted a team I think isn’t bad in Northern Illinois and because Stanford didn’t look very good for a while at Arizona. Another ho-hum 300-yard passing performance by Russell Wilson and continued excellence on the ground ensured the victory. This team is clearly the class of the Big 10.

6) Stanford

Very interesting, that first half was. It was strange seeing the Cardinal so out of sync. The team predictably picked it up in the second half and left ‘Zona in the dust, but Shane Skov going down is going to kill Stanford. The guy was a beast and meant everything to their defense. It’s not hyperbole to say that his injury may cost them a conference championship and a shot at the BCS title.

7) Texas A&M

I like Texas A&M a lot, but I fear the Aggies may be in over their heads with Oklahoma State. Fortunately for A&M, they got last week off (so to speak, against Idaho), whereas OSU had to play Tulsa after midnight because of a weather delay. But even at home, the Aggies had better come to play. That Cowboy offense is scary.

8) Oregon

The second of Oregon’s patsies passed by without much of a fight and the Duck defense played a lot better this week. I still have concerns about whether this team is really elite, but I suppose that should be answered Saturday night against Arizona. The Wildcats are beaten and bruised from their previous two top-10 opponents. An elite team would squash them here.

9) Oklahoma State

If the Cowboys knock off A&M on the road this week I’m fully prepared to jump them three or four spots. The issue is going to be unit matchups. I see OSU as a team with a brilliant offense and an average defense. The Aggies are more balanced on both sides of the ball. Like an arena league squad, the Cowboys just need to get enough stops to allow the offense to take over.

10) Virginia Tech

Another sluggish start for the Hokies. I know their schedule does them a lot of favors, but Tech has to be careful. They could easily lose either of their first two conference games (Clemson and Miami (FL)) if they don’t respect them. Clemson in particular is looking like a real challenger. I’m still not convinced that either Tech’s offense or defense is that good.

11) Arkansas

Three home games against three bad teams… the season’s first road game… a great Alabama defense… is it just me, or does this game look really ominous? Not to mention that the next game is against Texas A&M, who will either be flying high after beating Oklahoma State or looking to take their frustrations out on someone after losing to the Cowboys. Oh boy.

12) Florida State

I didn’t drop FSU too far, because in truth the Seminoles did pass the most important test against Oklahoma. Short of winning, Florida State had one task Saturday: win back the nation’s respect. I think they did it. I know they have mine. It’s been years since I’ve seen FSU compete with an elite team for four quarters. They have to keep playing this way to stay relevant, but it’s fair to say that Florida State is back.

13) Nebraska

Nebraska is going to keep sliding down my rankings until they prove that they can actually be great for a full game. Both Fresno State and Washington had chances to beat the Cornhuskers. That should be unacceptable for a team allegedly in the hunt for a national championship. If they keep playing at this level someone is going to bring them down to earth. Hard.

14) South Carolina

Were announcers really celebrating the Gamecocks’ last-gasp escape at home against Navy? Look, I like Navy a lot, but they’re just not a great football team. How in the world anyone can look at South Carolina and think they’re a top-10 team is beyond me. The offense is Marcus Lattimore plus whatever Stephen Garcia happens to contribute that particular day. The defense wasn’t very good against the Midshipmen either.

15) Baylor

The Bears are only 2-0, but with several teams ahead of them falling, they’ll get a chance to show what they can do with expectations. I’m not confident in Baylor’s chances, but it should be interesting to see how the team performs now that people expect them to play well. I can’t remember that ever happening before.

16) South Florida

USF is destined to stay below the radar for a while, but looking at their schedule, I was struck by something I hadn’t noticed before: the Bulls could win every game they have left. That doesn’t mean I think they actually will run the table, but it’s not out of the question either. If they get past Pitt, they could really go on a nice run.

17) Clemson

The win over Auburn wasn’t everything (though the Tigers’ performance in the last three quarters was certainly impressive); rather, this is an admission of oversight on my part. I hadn’t taken Clemson too seriously, but there is clearly a lot of talent on that roster. If Tajh Boyd continues to play like he did against Auburn, look out.

18) USC

Well, I guess I’ve been suckered in by the Trojans. SC turned it on and left Syracuse in the dust the way they should have done with their first two opponents. Next up are the two best remaining teams in the South: Arizona State and Arizona. Could USC go undefeated in division play but be ineligible for the Pac-12 title game? I’m sure the league office hopes not.

19) West Virginia

That wild, close win over Maryland told me everything I needed to know. Unless the Mountaineers show a whole lot more this week than they have so far this season, they’re going to get smashed by LSU. That doesn’t mean they couldn’t still win the Big East, mind you, but losing sure won’t help their confidence any.

20) TCU

A curiously slow start against Louisiana-Monroe again raises questions about the Horned Frogs. Are they for real or not? Welcome to the rollercoaster that has been TCU’s 2011 season so far. I really can’t say what we have in this team, though it’s fair to guess that we probably won’t find out this week against Portland State.

21) Houston

I kept the Cougars in the rankings but was very concerned about their near-loss to Louisiana Tech. Houston is simply better than that and the team won’t get any respect if they can’t dominate against lesser foes. I hope the upcoming start of the Conference USA schedule will startle the Cougars into being the team they can be if they try.

22) Ohio State

OSU’s defense wore down against Miami (FL), but it’s still clearly one of the best in the country. The problems are all on offense: the backs and receivers aren’t as explosive as they have been, and the passing game is just pitiful. Unfortunately for the Buckeyes, this situation is probably going to get worse before it gets better.

23) Michigan

No, I still don’t think the Wolverines are that good, and no, Denard Robinson still can’t pass to save his life. On the other hand, the defense has already come a long way from the Rich Rodriguez era. That’s a promising sign as Michigan enters conference play. First up, though – a dangerous San Diego State squad.

24) Georgia Tech

Words cannot express my joy at what I saw out of my Yellow Jackets against Kansas. It was merely one of the most explosive and dominant offensive performances of the past century, as the Ramblin’ Wreck careened to a glorious 600 yards rushing on a 12-yard-per-carry average. At 3-0, this team has a chance to make a statement against North Carolina this week.

25) Texas

The fact that Texas beat the same UCLA squad Houston did – but more impressively – is the sole reason the Longhorns make this list. I still have little to no faith in the QB situation, and the team seems to still be uncharacteristically reloading despite a down year in 2010. If they can ride out this rough patch, though, the Horns might be good by season’s end.

Pac-12 Thoughts

Not a whole lot to say this week. It looks like Oregon State will be getting James Rodgers back, but I’m of a mixed opinion on that. Should he really come back now? Or even this season? Is it worth it when the Beavers look to be headed for another bowl-less year? More importantly, will he be the same player? Unfortunately, I have my doubts. I think Rodgers may be in the same boat as former Oregon back Jeremiah Johnson: able to return, but a shell of his former self. (Note: Rodgers’ “shell,” not unlike Johnson’s, could probably still be formidable.)

Utah looked amazing against BYU; perhaps there’s hope for the South yet! Because the USC loss looked bad but was meaningless in the standings, the Utes just have to beat the Arizona schools to make the Pac-12 championship. Do you think they can’t pull that off? Have you seen Arizona and ASU? Given Utah’s propensity to create turnovers (a ridiculous seven against BYU), it’s not a crazy idea at all.

Speaking of Arizona State… now there’s the Dennis Erickson team I know and love! Let’s see: outgaining an inferior opponent on the road – check. Turning the ball over multiple times – check. Around a hundred yards in penalties – you got it. And thus the Sun Devils lost for the first time in 2011. Boy, did I call that one or what? Unbelievable. ASU should play in the Pac-12 title game this season, but it’s anyone’s guess as to whether they can actually get there.

Heisman* Watch

*Excluding Andrew Luck, etc., etc.

Robert Griffin III, QB, Baylor

Stats against FCS teams shouldn’t really count, so the TCU game is still all we have to go on with Griffin. It’s enough. He’s great. If he’s only half as good as he was against the Horned Frogs, he’ll still be spectacular.

Kellen Moore, QB, Boise State

You can say a lot about Moore’s competition, but eventually that argument loses weight. Moore is going to become the NCAA’s all-time winning QB this season, he’s going to put up some incredible numbers yet again, and he’s probably the most accurate passer outside of Luck. He’s beaten all the elite teams he’s played and dominated.

Random Thoughts and Observations

You can blame Texas A&M for being petulant. You can blame Larry Scott for getting the superconference ball rolling in the first place. You can blame Pitt and Syracuse for bailing for greener pastures. But you can’t blame the ACC for doing what was best for itself. In the most surprising realignment development yet, the one BCS conference everyone saw as an afterthought made the biggest move.

I think it’s safe to say everyone saw the Pac-12 and SEC as the major players as the national landscape continued to adjust. The Big 10, it was assumed, would follow suit once those two leagues upped the ante to 16 teams. Logically, the ACC would have to fight it out with the Big East to survive as one of the four superconferences, though I definitely thought the ACC would win that battle.

Now? Forget the Big East. The conference may yet survive the defections of two of its flagship members, but it simply has no hope to compete anymore with the other BCS leagues on the football stage. The ACC has now successfully raided the Big East twice, with more schools (Connecticut, Rutgers) potentially on the way. The SEC might yet look to snatch up West Virginia, too. The remaining members of the Big East have to be terrified for their own futures.

The news that the Pac-12 has decided to remain at a dozen schools looks to have brought the Big 12 back from the dead again (and credit the conference for not compromising its principles by inviting Texas, even though the Longhorns would have been a boon to revenue). Somehow, someway, the Big 12 lives to fight another day. And of course, in doing so, this in turn may have saved the Big East, which could theoretically invite a couple of Conference USA schools (ECU, who I think is a great fit, has already applied). The Big East is also heavily considering all three of the service academies, which could work for Army and Navy but not Air Force.

I’m happy with those results, because I’m a traditionalist at heart and want to see all of the conferences survive. However, having said that, I still have to applaud the ACC and give it an internet-worthy tip o’ the cap. Well played, sir. Well played. The ACC made two major moves in the last few weeks – one quiet, the other not so much – to permanently crush the Big East as a potential rival, shift the national spotlight to itself and ensure that it wouldn’t be the forgotten party in the next round of realignment.

First, the members of the league agreed to quadruple the buyout for every school to a pricey $20 million. This ensured that if the ACC itself got raided by the SEC, it would cost the departing member(s) dearly. Then it clearly went in under the radar – while everyone was talking about Texas A&M, Oklahoma and Texas – to gauge Pitt and Syracuse’s interest. This culminated in last weekend’s announcement that oh, by the way, two of the most important members of the Big East were jumping ship. Before the sputtering Big East could even react, the ACC members had already voted in the Orange and Panthers. For that kind of efficiency to take place, the two schools and their new conference had to have been in talks for some time. Don’t think for a second that this was an overnight decision.

The final count? The ACC put a knife into the Big East’s back (and twisted it), spooked the Pac-12 out of making a potentially incredibly profitable decision and put the SEC on notice that it’s no longer the biggest, baddest conference in the East. Oh, and by accelerating the demise of their now-crippled rival, the ACC dramatically increased its opportunity to one day land Notre Dame. This wasn’t conference realignment, it was a series of calculated, mob-style hits. Lesson learned: never, ever underestimate the ACC again.

And as a bonus, ACC member Georgia Tech last weekend played the most perfect offensive football I’ve ever seen. A dozen yards a carry on 50 rushes with only seven passing attempts (two of which went for touchdowns) is unheard of in today’s game. This was purist football to the nth-degree. The triple-option scheme confused and flattened the Kansas defense in a way only the option attack can. I appreciate all forms of offense (and there are so many today), but I hold that the best collegiate offense ever designed is still the option. Georgia Tech isn’t a great team that was playing a bad one. The Jayhawks and Yellow Jackets are pretty evenly matched. But Tech’ supreme command of their offense overwhelmed the Kansas defense. I encourage everyone to check out a replay on ESPN3. It’s worth a look. Not unlike the bold new ACC.

Wednesday, September 14, 2011

Well that was fun

Nothing earth-shattering in the top 25 this week, but the rest of the country sure made up for it. For the second straight week, there was a wild Friday night thriller, and that was before the outrageous shootouts that were Georgia-South Carolina, Mississippi State-Auburn and Notre Dame-Michigan. I mean, how absurd were those games? How much excitement can one weekend possibly supply? This last weekend epitomized what makes college football great.

At the same time, though, all of these crazy finishes left something to be desired. Namely, defense. It wasn’t just the football purists who shed tears for their sport this week. Seriously, can’t anyone even slow down an offense these days? I would hope that the results of the two aforementioned SEC contests would finally put to rest the myth that Southern teams play better defense than anyone, but we know that’s probably never going to happen. But how dense do you have to be to not see it? SEC offenses aren’t exactly known for their productivity. Here’s how many points those four teams gave up in their collective eight games thus far: 35, 45, 37, 42, 38, 34, 41 and 14. Some rock-solid SEC defense there, eh?

Or, rather, is it that elite SEC defenses – just like elite defenses around the nation – are better than the rest of their weaker conference counterparts? Yes, some SEC teams play outstanding defense. LSU and Alabama are probably the two best defensive teams in the country. But to apply their greatness freely to the rest of the conference without looking at the truth of the matter is to aggressively ignore reality.

By the way, my Georgia-South Carolina rankings prediction from last week unfortunately couldn’t come to be because Georgia really is that overrated. However, we got a perfect illustration of what I was referring to when (unranked) Auburn upset 16th-ranked Mississippi State and surprise, surprise! – both teams were ranked the next morning. Because God forbid we admit that MSU isn’t really that good. No, better for the voters to cover themselves by ranking both teams, even though Auburn definitively proved last week that they aren’t that good when they luckily escaped a terrible Utah State squad.

But I rag on the SEC enough (and truly, the SEC West is the best division in the sport). Besides, the “worst defense” award doesn’t go to any of those schools. No, the worst defense of the week – nay, the young season (and possibly of all time) – was on display in Ann Arbor, where Michigan and Notre Dame honored the first night game at the Big House in the most ironic way possible, donning throwback uniforms on the very evening both teams decided to not play any defense. Knute Rockne and Bo Schembechler would have been appalled.

Of course, at the expense of defense, we got to see one of the most exciting college football finishes in recent memory. It was as if both teams’ secondaries just lost their collective minds. Have you ever seen so many wide-open receivers running downfield? It was a monumental combination of errors and incompetence. But it sure made for great viewing.

Top 25

1) Alabama

The Crimson Tide’s defense is superb, but for the first time I’m worried about their offense. The complete lack of a reliable quarterback in Tuscaloosa is going to hurt at some point, just as LSU will discover. The difference is that Nick Saban is a very good coach.

2) Oklahoma

Seems a little unfair that Oklahoma got to take week two off to get ready for FSU, but the Seminoles will just have to deal. I considered moving the Sooners up to the top spot this week because of their vast QB advantage over Bama, but it didn’t feel right given that OU had a bye. If they hammer FSU, though, that might change.

3) LSU

LSU predictably sleepwalked through their first post-Oregon game. Next up: recently wounded Mississippi State, who blew their shot to make an important conference-opening statement. Though even the mediocre Chris Relf presents an upgrade over Tigers QB Jarrett Lee, I expect LSU’s defense to win the day once again.

4) Boise State

How much can you say about the Broncos? Unless there’s a huge upset or someone important gets hurt, there’s almost nothing to write about. BSU will probably continue to win and win big. There is an interesting challenge this Friday against a game Toledo team who took Ohio State to the brink, though.

5) Stanford

That 10-point halftime lead was a bit worrisome, but the Cardinal did put the hammer down in the second half. Andrew Luck throwing a pick-six was a little jarring too. No matter. This week the team starts their conference schedule with a school, Arizona, who they blasted last year.

6) Wisconsin

I was tempted to move the Badgers to number five for a minute. Then I remembered that unimpressive first-half showing against a bad Oregon State defense and decided it would be prudent to wait another week to make that call. If nothing else, the Beavers showed that anyone can sell out to stop the run and be competitive with Wisconsin.

7) Texas A&M

A&M will likely wake up sometime in the second half this Saturday to put down Idaho. The Aggies’ minds are going to be on next week’s opponent, Oklahoma State. I’m really getting amped for that game, as it will announce which team will be the front-runner to challenge Oklahoma for the Big 12 title.

8) Oregon

Dropping 69 on Nevada demonstrated that, once again, it’s only the best defenses that can keep Oregon down. Do I think the Ducks are anywhere near last season’s level yet? No. But fortunately for them, they’ve got another couple of weeks to work things out. Even the conference opener at Arizona should be easier than expected, because the Wildcats will be in the middle of a horrendous stretch against three straight top-10 foes.

9) Virginia Tech

So did the Hokies beat East Carolina more or less impressively than South Carolina did? Both of the bird-mascot schools trailed the Pirates at some point, though Tech won a slugfest while South Carolina won a shootout. In the end, I dropped VT one rung because I seriously doubt they could match up with Oregon.

10) Oklahoma State

I’m ready to believe, Cowboys. Now don’t do something stupid, like losing to dangerous Tulsa this week en route to that big showdown with Texas A&M. There a lot of potential for fireworks both of the next two games, given the nature of OSU’s defense. The offense just can’t afford to be off.

11) Florida State

I’ve been rather harsh about FSU’s legitimacy. Now they finally get a chance to show what they can do when they host Oklahoma this week. While there’s ACC pride on the line, I really think this is even a bigger game for the FSU program. The Seminoles desperately want to be the team they used to be, and they need this win.

12) Nebraska

The Huskers, like many BCS teams over the past dozen-odd years, took Fresno State too lightly and almost paid for it. Taylor Martinez was exposed yet again as a receiver playing QB, which might eventually be the reason Nebraska fails to win the Big 10. I don’t see how they can hope to beat Wisconsin with him.

13) Arkansas

I’m very fond of Arkansas, but it kind of feels like we’re just waiting until they play a decent team and get crushed to drop them in the rankings. As a sign of respect for the Razorbacks’ potent offense, I won’t move them down until that happens, but I don’t have a lot of faith that they can compete in the SEC West.

14) Ohio State

Some analysts said this week that Toledo is a very good team and the fact that they almost beat the Buckeyes demonstrates their legitimacy rather than Ohio State’s middling quality. I’m not buying it. I’m comfortable with the idea of Toledo being a good team, but there is just no way they should have been able to compete with OSU.

15) South Carolina

I left the Gamecocks right where I had them last week. The win over Georgia was certainly exciting, but Georgia isn’t that good. However, you can’t truthfully say the Bulldogs are a bunch of bums, and the game was on the road, so… South Carolina stays in the same spot. Seems fair to me.

16) Michigan State

I gave Ohio State a lot of credit for completely crushing Akron’s offense in week one, so I have to do the same for the Spartans. Of course, what MSU did defensively was even more impressive. Really? 48 yards and one first down? That’s unheard of. I know it was Florida Atlantic, but still. Next up for Sparty: Notre Dame.

17) Arizona State

Arizona State got to show off for the nation on Friday night, and they gave the most honest team performance I’ve ever seen. The Sun Devils’ abundance of talent and potential were on full display as they built a two-touchdown lead on Missouri. Then everyone got to see their propensity to make foolish mistakes and stupid penalties as they let the Tigers back in the game. This team can win, but they have to play smarter.

18) Baylor

No word yet on whether Baylor can really hang with the big boys in the Big 12 this season (I kind of doubt it, but we’ll see). What is clear through the first two weeks is that people are finally cottoning on to the greatness of Robert Griffin III. Any and all Heisman hype directed at a certain QB in Ann Arbor should be focused on RG3.

19) South Florida

I don’t think USF will really be tested until they go on the road for their first two league games against Pittsburgh and defending Big East champ UConn. Certainly Florida A&M and UTEP shouldn’t be too much to handle. The biggest challenge for the Bulls will be to stay healthy until October.

20) West Virginia

After an alarming halftime deficit to Norfolk State the Mountaineers got it going. That’s good, because their competition ramps up sharply in difficulty in both of the next two weeks: first against rival Maryland, then versus LSU. Any chance WVU gets out of September undefeated? Ask again once they play the Terrapins.

21) Houston

How in the world is Texas ranked and not Houston? The Cougars would destroy the Longhorns. BYU nearly beat Texas, and those Cougars are about half as good as Case Keenum’s crew. This is a travesty. Houston’s schedule doesn’t give them a whole lot of chances to impress voters, so people should give them some credit now.

22) TCU

Hmm. I wouldn’t have been shocked if Air Force had upset the shell-shocked Horned Frogs, but TCU clobbered the Falcons. Perhaps they were written off to the bottom half of the top 25 too soon. The Mountain West actually presents some decent obstacles, so we’ll find out if Boise State has a true challenger.

23) USC

I don’t know what to make of SC. They could have easily lost both of their games, yet here they stand at 2-0. The lack of playmakers on the Trojan offense is disturbing given their touted recruiting classes, but it could be that the extreme focus on Roberts Woods (which is understandable) has stunted the growth of other players.

24) Auburn

All right, I’m willing to concede that Auburn can be ranked. Somehow, despite fate’s best efforts, the Tigers just can’t seem to lose. I certainly don’t think they’re ready to take on LSU or Alabama, but having Gus Malzahn in your corner helps a lot. With time, and a continued propensity for lucky breaks, this team could become formidable.

25) Michigan

Big Blue has the same “never say die” attitude as Auburn right now. Though last week’s win was more about Notre Dame blowing it than what Michigan did, you have to give the Wolverines credit for not folding while there was still time on the clock. One problem, though: the new offense hasn’t gelled at all. That’s going to be an issue.

Pac-12 Thoughts

Checking in on all our friends out west… let’s start with the North. Cal did beat Colorado in that weird conference-game-that-wasn’t, but they needed overtime to do so and were outgained by 200 yards, mostly through the air. That bodes very badly for the Bears. Stanford curiously didn’t pull away from Duke until the second half, though it’s possible the Cardinal were holding back for their conference opener against Arizona. Oregon was explosive but struggled to run the ball on Nevada, which is a bad sign. The Ducks’ offensive line clearly needs some work.

Oregon State just got killed at Wisconsin despite a pretty good defensive performance, and now Mike Riley has switched QB’s. I don’t honestly have a clue about why he’s dropping Ryan Katz for Sean Mannion. It would make sense for the Beavers to give up on 2011 and have a “youth movement” if Katz was a senior, but he’s still got a couple dozen games left as an amateur and I don’t see how pulling the plug on him is a positive move. Mannion didn’t play any better against the Badgers. We’ll have to watch this controversy with bemusement – and believe me, it’s already a controversy.

Washington struggled to put away Hawai’i just as they did against Eastern Washington. The Huskies might have some defensive issues, but they won’t see another passing offense like the ones the Warriors and Eagles ran. That’s a positive – as is UDub starting the year 2-0 for the first time since 2007. Washington State is also off to a 2-0 start, which is a much bigger deal given how bad the Cougars have been in recent years.

USC got the first Pac-12 season started with a closer-then-it-should-have-been win over Utah. The Trojans may be the second best team in the South, but they’ve got to find some consistency on both sides of the ball if they want to be taken seriously. Utah looked decent in their first game in a BCS conference, but the Utes had no business being in position to tie the game. They’ll still be a bit player in the Pac-12 race, but losing the opener hurts.

Poor Colorado could have really used that win over Cal. This week will be the Buffaloes’ best chance all season, against Colorado State. They’d better get this one, because I don’t see a guaranteed win on the rest of their schedule. Arizona got waxed at Oklahoma State, but that’s not too embarrassing. OSU is quite good. Much more concerning was UCLA’s pedestrian 10-point win over San Jose State. Psst. Want to hear a secret? I think there’s a chance the Bruins aren’t very good…

So then we come to Arizona State. The Fork was feared on Friday in Tempe, but man, did the Sun Devils make it hard for themselves. Anyone watching that game could see that Missouri was simply overmatched, but as is their custom, ASU had to try to give it away. At this point, I don’t think you can write it off as immature play – I’ve seen too much of this over the years from Dennis Erickson-coached teams. More on this later.

Heisman* Watch

*As my last post explained, this list excludes Andrew Luck because the actual Heisman race is all but over. This is a “best of the rest.”

Robert Griffin III, QB, Baylor

I’ll keep him here until he falters. Griffin is a rare athlete for a player so gifted as a passer. Unlike Michigan QB Denard Robinson, he’s as good as the hype surrounding him. He just needs to avoid injuries.

Random Thoughts and Observations

Good thing the NCAA cracked down on those crooks from Boise. Handing out three years’ probation and scholarship losses sure beats having to deal with any of the real problems around the country at Ohio State, Auburn, Oregon, or Miami. I mean, have you even seen the rap sheet of “impermissible benefits” Boise dealt out? Come on, NCAA. People sometimes say the NCAA goes after the little programs upsetting the balance of power and covers up for the big-name schools. I don’t normally buy it, but how is this not a perfect example of the NCAA doing just that?

There’s a lot of hype around Michigan’s Denard Robinson again. It’s understandable – he just brought UM back from certain defeat against Notre Dame, and he ran for an NCAA-QB record 1,700 yards last season while also throwing for 2,500. He’s a great athlete. However, he isn’t particularly accurate, a fact his athleticism masks (just 11-for-24 last week). And while his fourth-quarter performance against Notre Dame was extraordinary, you can’t forget the fact that it was partially because of his three interceptions that Michigan was in that position in the first place.

Because of this, I’ve awarded Robinson my first “Stanzi” award. Named for late Iowa QB (he graduated, he’s not dead) Ricky Stanzi, “Stanzi-ing” a game refers to a player (generally a QB) who is responsible for putting his team into a huge hole and then receives the credit for bringing the team back. Stanzi was infamous for tossing multiple picks in a game, then going nuts in the fourth quarter and winning the game. Thus the phrase is born: Robinson “Stanzied it” against the Fighting Irish.

I liken this term to the phrase “Cougin’ it,” which arose after Washington State became famous for their late-game collapses. No season was more indicative of Wazzu’s ability to “Coug it” in winnable games than 2005, when the Cougars lost an astonishing six games in this fashion by a total of 27 points. The phrase has since spread to the general college football lexicon whenever a team “snatches defeat from the jaws of victory.” I think “Stanzied” is just as appropriate.

My last thought is regarding Arizona State Dennis Erickson. I think Erickson is a pretty good coach, though he hasn’t always succeeded in the face of great expectations. But it’s funny that people still can’t see how his coaching style works. What has Arizona State been known for since Erickson took over in 2007? Underachieving, thanks to sloppy, undisciplined play and tons of penalties, particularly personal fouls. What was Oregon State known for when Erickson was in charge? The Beavers featured a high-octane offense, a speedy defense, and… a reputation for unsportsmanlike play. I couldn’t find the data online, but I believe the 11-1 OSU team from 2000 led the nation in penalties. I do remember the 2001 Fiesta Bowl following that season, when the Beavs annihilated Notre Dame 41-9 and racked up 18 penalties for 174 yards.

All of this is before we even get to Erickson’s Miami tenure (the guy has coached a ton of places). I think everyone knows what the Hurricanes were famous for. My point is that this is not an isolated incident or a problem than can just get fixed. People have to realize that this is how Dennis Erickson teams play: fast, out of control and undisciplined. He has never put a premium on getting his players to win the mental game along with the physical one. That’s just the way he coaches. In the end, it’s a shame, because he’s ended up wasting a lot of potential.

So that’s it for week three. We should start getting some real definitive information this week about who’s for real and who’s not and how the conference races are going to shape up. See you next week.