Thursday, October 8, 2015

Dawg Days

Oh, Georgia. My sweet summer child. Somehow, we all knew it would end like this. Well, perhaps not quite like this. A 38-10 annihilation at home probably wasn’t on the minds of even the most pessimistic of Bulldogs fans. And so begins yet another round of, “If not now, when?” with UGA.

Mark Richt’s tenure has endured this turmoil seemingly in perpetuity. By all reasonable standards, Richt is a very good coach, with a strong record in what has been the nation’s toughest conference over the past decade. Amidst the savagery of the SEC, he’s won two league titles, taken another team to the brink of one and had at least one squad undone by injuries.

Yet there’s undeniably an air of unfulfilled promise in Athens. During the past 20 seasons, Tennessee and Florida have won national championships out of Georgia’s own division, while LSU, Alabama and Auburn have combined for another six. Georgia has been as good or better than three of those five programs during that time, but never able to win the big one. It felt as if 2015 might finally be the time… now, it seems UGA will need to win the East to ensure Richt keeps his job.

Week Five came through with a load of quality action, starting with Cincinnati’s nice win over Miami (FL) on Thursday evening. TCU finally looked like a contender in a napalming of Texas. Ohio State and Michigan State continued to struggle against inferior competition. New darling Ole Miss learned what it means to be the hunted, getting roundly exposed by a surprising Florida squad. Notre Dame and UCLA got more of the same, falling to Clemson and Arizona State, respectively.

In a development worth keeping an eye on, Navy dominated rival Air Force to improve to 4-0. The Midshipmen, solid as usual while playing their first-ever season in a conference, might have what it takes to run the table in the AAC. If they get by Notre Dame this week – absolutely not out of the realm of possibility – they could be looking at an undefeated year.

Poor Tennessee was all but eliminated from the SEC race with a third consecutive heartbreaking loss, this time at the hands of Arkansas. The Volunteers should have made the East a three-team chase, but are probably already stuck playing spoiler after what easily could have been a 5-0 start.

Northwestern came through in a big show-me moment, blanking Minnesota 27-0. At 5-0, the Wildcats look as if they’re ready to fulfill the hype they got a couple seasons too early. Meanwhile, surprising Iowa has also moved to 5-0 after a big road win at Wisconsin, setting up the Hawkeyes and Wildcats for a very interesting division clash the next two months.

With conference play fully underway, Week Six looks to deliver even more excitement, along with a few potential knockout blows to would-be contenders. USC needs to demonstrate its lofty preseason ranking wasn’t all hype when it hosts Washington on Thursday night. Newly ranked Iowa figures to get a challenge from quietly 4-1 Illinois, while Oklahoma and Texas meet in the often-unpredictable Red River Shootout in Dallas.

Baylor travels to Kansas in a contest that might see the Bears put up the most points anyone will score this season. That game could get really ugly. Penn State and Indiana, both 4-1, will square off in Happy Valley. Clemson has a scary hangover game with Georgia Tech’s option, while Georgia meets Tennessee in a desperation match for the SEC East rivals.

In the midday slate, there’s a big one in the Big Ten: Northwestern at Michigan, with the 5-0 Wildcats taking on the 4-1 Wolverines. I wouldn’t be shocked to see UM pull that game out. Florida is at Missouri in a potential letdown game for the Gators and in the nightcap, surprisingly undefeated Cal and Utah teams get set for a showdown in Salt Lake City. This week is going to be fun.

Playoff Poll

It’s gotten very difficult to separate the teams at the top of the list, as presumptive favorites Michigan State, Ohio State and TCU have struggled tremendously to this point. Alabama, Ole Miss and USC have already lost. Most schools have yet to play an opponent of their own caliber.

First Tier

Ohio State
Michigan State
TCU
Utah

The Spartans and Horned Frogs return, proving that sometimes it is just survival that matters. Utah maintains its position for now, facing a big test against Cal’s passing attack this week.

Second Tier

Alabama
Clemson
Baylor

The Bears and Tigers move up thanks to losses above them. Neither has been that impressive, but at least Clemson has played a couple teams with a pulse.

Third Tier

Oklahoma
Ole Miss
Florida State

The Sooners have gone under the radar but should be 6-0 after this week. Ole Miss took one on the chin, but still has the all-important ‘Bama win to its credit. I don’t trust Florida yet.

Pac-12 Report

Well, well. Welcome back, Arizona State. The Sun Devils crushed UCLA in Pasadena, showing that perhaps all that offseason hype had some substance behind it. In the process, ASU saved its season and might have given the South a whole new look. I was never sold on UCLA, but the Sun Devils were desperate.

Stanford is the clear North favorite after dominating Arizona, though Cal could still play a major role. The Golden Bears moved to 5-0 after escaping Washington State, though the Cougars could have easily won the game. Cal will have improve its pass defense to truly contend. Oregon beat Colorado in the final game of the weekend after a weather delay; the Ducks have some serious issues at quarterback to fix but still have the talent to potentially win the division.

This week figures to be more interesting, starting with the Thursday night Washington – USC tilt. The Trojans haven’t lived up to expectations yet and need to beat the Huskies impressively, which I think they will.

Oregon State is at Arizona for an interesting contest. The Wildcats are a better team, but are coming off a rough two weeks and have to deal with QB Anu Solomon’s health issues. The Beavers just got a bye. ‘Zona should still win, but OSU could make a game of it.

Oregon is favored by 17 at home against Washington State, which seems far too high given the Ducks’ awful secondary and Wazzu’s propensity to air it out. UO is a better team, but hasn’t looked like it to this point, which makes this a scary matchup.

Colorado and ASU are both 3-2, though the Buffaloes do appear to still be a year away from competing in the South. ASU was a huge disappointment until last week’s UCLA upset, so perhaps the Sun Devils have gotten things back on track. Or perhaps it was a fluke and CU will triumph in Tempe.

Finally, there’s Cal at Utah, a matchup that ought to tell us a lot about both teams. I tend to think the Bears are in a little over their heads here; the hot start could have easily included losses to WSU and Texas, and the defense has looked as porous as usual. However, it’s also quite possible the Utes got a perfect storm against Oregon – they certainly didn’t look dominant over the first few games – and are more of a top-15 squad than a top-5 outfit. Utah should win this game, but we’ll have to see how the defense fares.

Random Thoughts and Observations

I don’t want to hear how Clemson “turned a corner” versus Notre Dame. But for a failed two-point conversion, this would have been the Clemsoniest Clemsoning of them all. The Tigers were at home, up three scores in the second half, against a team with a freshman QB and a host of other injuries. The Fighting Irish had four turnovers and a massive yardage edge. How exactly was this an impressive win? Clemson is good enough to win the ACC and maybe even go undefeated, but there’s no chance this team is title-worthy.

2015 Stanzi Awards

It was a quiet week for the prestigious Stanzi, with a mere four QB’s taking home weekly awards. Oklahoma State’s Mason Rudolph moved into the multiple winner category, while two more SEC passers announced their intentions to be crowned the worst QB in the land.

Week Five Awards

Mason Rudolph, Oklahoma State
Opponent: Kansas State
Performance: One INT, one FUM, won by two

Philip Ely, Toledo
Opponent: Ball State
Performance: Two INT, won by 14

Johnny McCrary, Vanderbilt
Opponent: Middle Tennessee
Performance: Two INT, won by four

Patrick Towles, Kentucky
Opponent: Eastern Kentucky
Performance: Two INT, won by seven

2015 Standings

Jeremy Johnson, Auburn: 2
Mitch Leidner, Minnesota: 2
Clayton Thorson, Northwestern: 2
Mason Rudolph, Oklahoma State: 2
Hayden Moore, Cincinnati: 1
Johnny McCrary, Vanderbilt: 1
Josh Rosen, UCLA: 1
Patrick Towles, Kentucky: 1
Dane Evans, Tulsa: 1
Chad Kelly, Ole Miss: 1
P.J. Walker, Temple: 1
Matt Johns, Virginia: 1
Matt Linehan, Idaho: 1
Chris Laviano, Rutgers: 1
Jaquez Johnson, Florida Atlantic: 1
Baker Mayfield, Oklahoma: 1
Chase Litton, Marshall: 1
Deshaun Watson, Clemson: 1
Cody Clements, South Alabama: 1
Kendall Hinton, Wake Forest: 1
Patrick Mahomes, Texas Tech: 1
Max Wittek: Hawai’i: 1
Maty Mauk: Missouri: 1
Michael Birdsong, Marshall: 1
Tanner Mangum, BYU: 1
Thomas Sirk, Duke: 1
Philip Ely, Toledo: 1


It’s been a lovely, wild season so far. Who knows what the next week will bring? Can one of the Big Ten’s titans be toppled? What about the Big 12’s? It’s going to be a fascinating October.

Friday, October 2, 2015

Duck Down

Well, then. It was an illuminating Week Four, thanks mostly to the events that occurred in the Pac-12. Outside of the west coast action, there were plenty of entertaining matches up and down the weekend slate. Memphis and Cincinnati kicked things off with a barn-burner on Thursday night, while Stanford outlasted a game Oregon State squad on Friday. Then came the shockers.

Co-third-ranked TCU and Ole Miss both got scares of varying degrees. The Horned Frogs, who have been tremendously disappointing thus far, got an extremely lucky tip to beat Texas Tech, while the Rebels survived a bit of an Alabama hangover by beating Vanderbilt. Ole Miss has a great win to its credit, but I’m still not sold on either of those teams.

UCLA got a highly misleading blowout of Arizona on its resume, which I’ll go into later. Northwestern continued to live on the edge with another close win, this time over Ball State. Duke and Michigan pulled off huge upsets (over Georgia Tech and BYU, respectively), Texas managed to lose another game in improbable fashion (as did Tennessee), and Auburn proved to be exactly as overrated as we thought it was with a second consecutive loss.

Of course, all of this paled in comparison to the stunning result in Eugene, where Utah handed Oregon its worst loss in more than a decade. This game requires a lot more analysis, which is coming later. Rest assured, though; the Pac-12 might have changed dramatically in the last week.

So as we head into October and the true end of non-conference play, it appears the only thing we know is that we know nothing. The weekend holds intrigue again, with a couple of very high-profile games, including some teams facing make-or-break contests.

South Carolina and Missouri start SEC action early, with the loser probably removed from the division race. Surprising West Virginia and Oklahoma teams collide in Norman for a fun Big 12 opener, while Minnesota is at Northwestern for a Big Ten matchup that should provide a lot of insight as to whether the league will be more than a two-team race this season. Boston College at Duke could provide the same for the ACC.

Fresh off a near-upset of TCU, Texas Tech travels to Baylor, which could either be a big upset or an ugly hangover game for the Red Raiders. The big one is Alabama at Georgia, a rare contest in which the Crimson Tide are not favored. I think the Bulldogs are the better team, but it feels very dangerous to pick ‘Bama to lose two games in a row.

Washington State is at newly ranked Cal in a game that promises to light up the scoreboard, while Ole Miss takes on upstart Florida (the Gators are 4-0) in The Swamp. In primetime, we get Notre Dame at Clemson, with the Tigers coming off an underwhelming performance last week but facing a very banged-up Fighting Irish squad. It’s a great lineup for Week Five.

Playoff Poll

There’s a big shakeup after Oregon’s seismic loss. How should Michigan State – previously the most decorated team in the country – be judged after what Utah did? Ohio State has been mediocre against weak competition, and TCU and Ole Miss both looked bad last week. It’s time to reset and rebuild the rankings.

First Tier

Ohio State
Ole Miss
Georgia
Utah

Don’t worry, I feel weird moving Utah this high, too. But here’s why: The opening win over Michigan looks a lot better after the Wolverines dominated BYU; the road thrashing of Oregon is much more impressive than Michigan State’s close home win, and TCU should have lost last week.

Second Tier

TCU
Alabama
Michigan State

Oregon’s loss kills Michigan State. The Spartans haven’t been that impressive overall, and their poor performance against the Ducks putrid pass defense speaks volumes. Alabama has a chance to make a statement against Georgia.

Third Tier

Baylor
Clemson
Florida State
Oklahoma

Seems about right. I’ve held off on Notre Dame because of the Irish’s injuries; with a win at Clemson this week, they would move into the second tier – at least. UCLA has done nothing to this point to garner respect, and the only reason Baylor is here is because of how good the Bears have been the last few years.

Pac-12 Report

A quick recap before we get to the news that matters. Stanford’s slogging victory over Oregon State did nothing to assuage fears that the win over USC was a bit flukey. UCLA’s big win over Arizona looked impressive, but it had all the same hallmarks of a faux-Bruins blowout the likes of which we’ve seen before: turnovers leading to misleading margins of victory, injuries to the other team’s best player, etc. The Bruins are going to have to earn respect after their flops the last few seasons.

Colorado got a nice win to move to 3-1, while Cal got an improbable turnover to down Washington move to 4-0. Hooray Cal! The Golden Bears are ranked for the first time since 2009. USC also essentially ended any hope Arizona State had at a special season with a beatdown in Tempe.

So… about that Utah – Oregon game. There were signs, yes. The Ducks’ pass defense had looked bad against Eastern Washington (though curiously, not against Michigan State), and the offense hadn’t quite been its usual prolific self through three games. A home conference opener, though, seemed to be the thing to put things right.

Well, it wasn’t. And things might not ever be “right” again in Eugene, at least as far as the Duck Dynasty is concerned. We only get these kind of games once in a very great while, so I’ll try to put it in perspective for those who might warn against overreactions.

UO allowed Utah to rack up 62 points and win by six touchdowns, all within the confines of the cauldron of noise that is Autzen Stadium. Over the past seven seasons, Oregon was 80-14, averaged two losses per season and never won fewer than ten games. The Ducks have won 11 games in each of the past five seasons, the nation’s longest streak. When Oregon lost, it was by close margins and/or on the road; a 44-10 loss at USC in 2008 was the worst result in that span, and only once since then was UO truly blown out (42-16 at Arizona in 2013).

There have been exactly three times in the past 25 years when the Pac-12 has seen the balance of power shift in the conference. The first was on October 22, 1994, when Oregon’s famous pick-six turned back dominant Pac-10 power Washington and sent the Ducks on a skyrocketing course of success for the next two decades. October 26, 2002 was the second, when UO passed the mantle on to USC at the beginning of the Trojan Dynasty. The third came on October 31, 2009, when the Ducks snatched the title back from the Trojans with a dominating win on Halloween night.

I was there for the Fall of Troy. I remember how much faster, stronger, smarter Oregon looked than the vaunted Trojans. Last week’s Utah – Oregon game carried the same hallmarks. That’s not to say the Utes are destined to go on to unprecedented success, as the conference is stronger now than it was in any of those previous eras. But it seems fairly safe to say that Oregon’s run has ended, moving us into a new Pac-12. The last time Oregon’s secondary was this bad was in 2003, when poor pass defense doomed UO into years of mediocre malaise (before the arrival of Chip Kelly).

It’s a sad state of affairs for Duck fans, but it’s an exciting day for the league. From 2010-2013 the two best teams in the conference, every season, were Oregon and Stanford. The Ducks were on top in 2010, 2011 and 2014, Stanford won the conference in 2012 and 2013. The two North Division foes dominated the South each season, winning every conference championship game to this point. Last year, the South was the better division for the first time; this season, it appears poised to actually win the league.

Who will it be? Utah, UCLA or USC, though it’s anyone’s guess as to which one. As unlikely as it seems after September, Oregon or Stanford could make a run and still win the Pac-12. But after the Utah loss (and Stanford’s performance at Northwestern), all bets are off.

This weekend kicks off with a delightful firecracker of a game, as WSU travels to Cal to reignite the most defense-free series in the nation. Last season’s matchup saw the teams combine for 1,400 yards and 119 points, only to end in a shanked Cougars field goal. Cal should have the upper hand here at home, but with these offenses you can never be sure.

Arizona State gets one last chance to save its season at UCLA, and it’s not really a stretch to say Arizona faces the same situation at Stanford. Neither Arizona school can afford to start 0-2 in conference play in the deep South, but there’s a reason the California schools are both favored by two TD’s. Oregon likewise has a must-win at Colorado, but this should be merely a formality – lose here, and the Ducks season will REALLY be over.

Random Thoughts and Observations

I sincerely hope Boise State’s hammering of Virginia on national TV was enough to end the ridiculous narrative surrounding the Cavaliers. UVA was beat badly by UCLA in Week One, then on a miracle TD a week later versus Notre Dame. This week they suffered their worst loss yet, getting a close win over FCS opponent William and Mary in between. For some reason, both the Bruins’ and Fighting Irish’s victories were treated as big wins. Why? Virginia is a bad team. It has been a bad team for years. Notice that UCLA and ND are both in the top 10 of the polls. Now notice that neither has even cracked my third tier. There’s a reason for this.

I continue to be skeptical of LSU. The Tigers got a close win over an average Mississippi State team, then blew out what has proved to be a highly overrated Auburn team before winning close at Syracuse last week. Leonard Fournette is great, sure, but the passing game once again looks too anemic for LSU to truly contend. Brandon Harris has thrown for 302 yards in three games. There’s no way that gets it done against Alabama and Ole Miss.

It’s been said more a few times this week, but Georgia really needs to beat Alabama. The Bulldogs have had some talented squads that didn’t live up to potential and a couple that were victimized by the SEC’s divisional scheduling, but the excuses have to end. UGA is at home. Alabama looks vulnerable. Georgia has to win this game.

2015 Stanzi Awards

It was another banner Stanzi week, with seven ugly performances on record. Northwestern’s Clatyon Thorson has tied for the lead with back-to-back Stanzis! I’ve modified the weekly standings to better reflect the current leaders and given this award the special section it deserved. Here is the Week Five update.

Week Four awards

Chad Kelly, Ole Miss
Opponent: Vanderbilt
Performance: Two INT, won by 11

Clayton Thorson, Northwestern
Opponent: Ball State
Performance: One INT, two FUM, won by five

Thomas Sirk, Duke
Opponent: Georgia Tech
Performance: Two INT, won by 14

Mason Rudolph, Oklahoma State
Opponent: Texas
Performance: Two INT, one FUM (for TD), won by three

Chris Laviano, Rutgers
Opponent: Kansas
Performance: Two INT, won by 13

Chase Litton, Marshall
Opponent: Kent State
Performance: Two INT, won by seven

Jaquez Johnson, Florida Atlantic
Opponent: Charlotte
Performance: Two INT (one for TD), won by 10

2015 Standings

Jeremy Johnson, Auburn: 2
Mitch Leidner, Minnesota: 2
Clayton Thorson, Northwestern: 2
Hayden Moore, Cincinnati: 1
Josh Rosen, UCLA: 1
Dane Evans, Tulsa: 1
Mason Rudolph, Oklahoma State: 1
Chad Kelly, Ole Miss: 1
P.J. Walker, Temple: 1
Matt Johns, Virginia: 1
Matt Linehan, Idaho: 1
Chris Laviano, Rutgers: 1
Jaquez Johnson, Florida Atlantic: 1
Baker Mayfield, Oklahoma: 1
Chase Litton, Marshall: 1
Deshaun Watson, Clemson: 1
Cody Clements, South Alabama: 1
Kendall Hinton, Wake Forest: 1
Patrick Mahomes, Texas Tech: 1

Ah, what a time to be alive! When summer turns to fall, and a young Stanzi in the making throws his first pick-six. We truly live in interesting times.

Friday, September 25, 2015

All along the Western front

Another week, another conference takes it on the chin. This time it was the ACC’s turn, as Clemson and Florida State stunk up national TV on two consecutive nights before the weekend even started. Sure, you could make the argument that the Pac-12 and SEC’s most high-profile programs losing was more embarrassing, but Clemson and FSU are literally all the ACC has. If Week Three was any indication, neither is playoff-worthy.

Start with the Tigers, who bumbled their way to a three-point win at Louisville on Thursday evening. Regardless of how ESPN feels like spinning it, no, this was not a “big road win” or a “test.” Louisville is 0-3. Houston has a three-point road win over the Cardinals. Clemson looked terrible.

Florida State managed to be even worse. At least Louisville has a name people more or less respect. Boston College hasn’t been relevant since Matt Ryan left town, and the Seminoles scored one time on the Eagles’ D. It seems harsh given that both the Tigers and ‘Noles won, but these were bad opponents. This was a disaster for the ACC.

I’ll get to USC later, because the Trojans are a whole different mess. Instead, let’s talk about Alabama, and whether the Crimson Tide are in trouble. The 43 points allowed at home are alarming, yes. So too, is the increasingly likely notion that a dynasty is impossible to maintain for more than a few seasons, even in the uneven world of college football. Quarterback play, long an aspect of the game Nick Saban has managed to skate by without addressing, now appears paramount to ‘Bama’s continued success.

Yet I still can’t shake the thought that this was a fluke. Fortunately, SEC play is still a meat grinder, so we’ll find out soon enough. But the Tide outgained the Rebels by eighty yards. They had 29 first downs to Ole Miss’ 16. They held the ball for more than 35 minutes, and lost the turnover battle 5-0. And they lost the game by six. Forgive me for not crowning the Rebels – or eulogizing the Tide – just yet.

This week should be exciting, a fitting follow-up to the semi-craziness that invaded Week Three. Most of the quality contests are in the Pac-12, but there's a lot more  fun to be had around the country. There’s an early game in Piscataway worth keeping an eye on, as Kansas and Rutgers battle in what could be a matchup of the two worst Power 5 teams. Maryland and West Virginia renew their rivalry at noon, while Tennessee gets an opportunity to prove it really is back at Florida.

Cal has a similar chance at Washington in the Pac-12 opener for both teams. Later, UCLA travels to Arizona for a contest that should provide a lot of insight into how the South race will play out. Utah and Oregon also face off in another big Pac-12 showdown, while USC meets Arizona State in a game that could knock the loser out of the division race in September. In other words, the plot will thicken.

Playoff Poll

Alabama drops out of the top tier this week, though I have a strong feeling we’ll see the Tide again before the season’s out. There seems to be a lot of decent teams, but few elite ones this year. Time will tell if that theory holds true.

First Tier

Michigan State
Georgia
Ohio State
TCU

Ohio State has to fall a little after an ugly win over Northern Illinois. Georgia hasn’t really been tested yet, but SEC play will reveal what we have with the Bulldogs.

Second Tier

Baylor
Ole Miss
Alabama

I consider Ole Miss a second-tier candidate still because of the road the Rebels still have to traverse, while ‘Bama stays here because of the reasons I explained above.

Third Tier

Oregon
Clemson
Florida State
Georgia Tech
Oklahoma

The ACC looked this week, and both FSU and Clemson need to drop. No one else really moved that much.

Pac-12 Report

There were some pleasant surprises this week, as Washington and Colorado notched swing-game wins over Utah State and Colorado State, respectively. Washington State and Oregon State likewise came through in the second halves of their games to down Wyoming and San Jose State, which ensured the conference wouldn’t end the non-league slate with too many embarrassing moments.

Oregon, Utah and the Arizona schools all walked over highly inferior opponents, which brings us to the L.A. schools (Cal also got a win at Texas, though it was more fortuitous than impressive). UCLA escaped with a win over an injury-depleted BYU squad, while USC yet again proved to be unable to deal with expectations in a shootout loss to Stanford.

This is nothing new for the Cardinal, who have made a habit of embarrassing the Pac-12 in non-conference play and then wreaking havoc by knocking off the contenders during league action. It’s much more inexcusable for the Trojans, who have run out of excuses as to why they’re not a title contender any longer.

The sanctions and scholarship restrictions were painful, but this is still USC. The coaching may be a mere ghost of what it was in the halcyon days of Pete Carroll, but the talent is still second to none. What I saw in the Stanford game was simply more of the same thing we’ve seen for the past five seasons: hubris. It appears the instant the program gets attention for potentially being “back,” the entire roster gets self-satisfied, complacent and delusional to the point of arrogance.

Arrogance is what makes wideout JuJu Smith-Schuster – whom the announcers repeatedly referred to as “the best receiver in the nation” during the game – return a punt from his own six, setting up Stanford for a short touchdown on the ensuing drive. It’s what makes the Trojans’ defense relax before the half, assuming the Cardinal couldn’t possibly drive down the field in a minute to take the lead. It’s what makes center Max Tuerk commit a ridiculous late hit in the third quarter to turn a third-and-short into a third-and-15, costing SC a chance to score on the drive.

And most importantly, it’s the tactical advantage conceded to David Shaw, who flat-out coached circles around Steve Sarkisian after halftime. USC’s run game, as it has countless times in dumb losses this decade, disappeared in the second half, despite an incredible passing attack to keep the defense honest. And on the game’s crucial play – a third-and-long to prevent the Cardinal from taking a two-score lead late – the Trojans were burned on a flare screen. The same flare screen USC had been running all night (but which had been bottled up by the third quarter). That’s a total team failure, and it couldn’t more aptly summarize what’s wrong with this team.

So… on to Week Four! Stanford should handle Oregon State Friday night. Colorado has Nicholls State in an easy walkover, which is when the fun begins. Cal – Washington ought to be a great barometer of how competitive the North will be, as the winner will have the inside track to spoiler status. I wouldn’t be surprised at all to see Arizona knock off UCLA in Tucson given how overhyped the Bruins have been. Then there’s Utah at Oregon, a contest in which I expect the Ducks to hold serve, but could be interesting. Finally, there’s the USC – ASU nightcap, which looked quite promising in the preseason but now looks like a total dud. The Sun Devils could save their season here, but against an angry Trojans squad, I doubt it’ll happen.

2015 Stanzi Awards

It was a veritable treasure trove of Stanzi madness last week, as nine new signal-callers jumped into the fray. Minnesota’s Mitch Leidner also snagged his second Stanzi of the year, just one week after Auburn’s Jeremy Johnson appeared poised to run away with the award.

Jeremy Johnson, Auburn: 2
Dane Evans, Tulsa: 1
Mitch Leidner, Minnesota: 1
Baker Mayfield, Oklahoma: 1
Cody Clements, South Alabama: 1
Max Wittek: Hawai’i: 1
Maty Mauk: Missouri: 1
Michael Birdsong, Marshall: 1
Tanner Mangum, BYU: 1

Deshaun Watson, Clemson
Opponent: Louisville
Performance: Two INT, won by three

Mitch Leidner, Minnesota
Opponent: Kent State
Performance: Two INT, won by three

Kendall Hinton, Wake Forest
Opponent: Army
Performance: Two INT, won by three

Clayton Thorson, Northwestern
Opponent: Duke
Performance: Two INT, won by nine

P.J. Walker, Temple
Opponent: Massachusetts
Performance: Two INT, won by two

Hayden Moore: Cincinnati
Opponent: Miami (OH)
Performance: Two INT, two FUM, won by four

Matt Johns, Virginia
Opponent: William & Mary
Performance: Two INT, won by six

Matt Linehan, Idaho
Opponent: Wofford
Performance: Two INT, won by three

Patrick Mahomes, Texas Tech
Opponent: Arkansas
Performance: Two INT, won by 11

Josh Rosen, UCLA
Opponent: BYU

Performance: Three INT, won by one


One can only hope Week Four brings as much ridiculousness as the previous weekend. With conference play heating up, it's a pretty decent bet.


Friday, September 18, 2015

Southern Discomfort

Week Two didn’t end up telling us much. Auburn was exposed and Michigan State got a big win, but neither of those teams were true front-runners to begin with. The biggest takeaway from the weekend was that the SEC wasn’t as good as the pollsters thought, but with an absurd eight teams in the top 25 that’s not exactly a shock.

The trouble with Michigan State’s nice victory over Oregon – and it was certainly a quality win – is that it doesn’t mean much in the larger context of the Big Ten season. Under normal circumstances the Spartans would rocket to the top of the polls with such an impressive early-season win, but beating the Ducks is more or less irrelevant until the Ohio State game. Everyone saw Michigan State get outclassed by the Buckeyes last season, and to this point there’s no reason to believe anything has changed in 2015.

It doesn’t seem rash at all to say that Oregon has probably taken a step back this year. The Ducks are still probably very good (they’re definitely talented and as speedy as usual), but they might be a few pieces short of legitimately competing for a title. The question then becomes, “Is Michigan State better than last season?” Based on what we saw in East Lansing on Saturday, the answer is no, or at least not definitively. Nothing in that contest – particularly the Spartans’ anemic passing attack – engendered any hope that this squad is significantly stronger or in any way ready to defeat the Buckeyes, who get MSU at home.

Thus, while the win is nice in the short-term, it’s probably not going to make a difference in the long run. There is a quirky end-of-year outcome in play, where Oregon goes on to finish 12-1 and win the Pac-12 championship while the Spartans go 11-1, losing to Ohio State and missing out on the Big Ten title game. In that scenario, MSU fans would surely assume their team’s head-to-head win would carry more weight for the Playoff committee. There’s a small chance they’d be right… but a much, much larger chance they’d be wrong, for two reasons.

First, the Pac-12 is a vastly stronger conference than the Big Ten. This is an irrefutable fact in 2015 and seems it will be the case for the next few seasons, or until the Big Ten pulls itself together. Oregon, as a potential 12-1 Pac-12 champion, would have a significantly stronger resume than an 11-1 non-champion MSU team.

Second, the final score of the game this weekend would be huge. Oregon’s win last season in Eugene came by 19 points, leaving no doubt as to which side was stronger. A three-point home win isn’t very impressive from an analytic standpoint. Remember that home field in football is valued at around three points, although it’s actually closer to 4-6 points for a big-time school like Michigan State. Bettors would look at this result and say Oregon is the stronger team on a neutral field.

Of course, all of this is very premature. We still have nearly three months of action to go before such a scenario could take place. But it’s worth pointing out now, just in case the controversy does arise.

So what’s on tap this weekend? Not much, unfortunately. There are a couple big caveats to that statement, but overall Week Three looks about as appetizing as… well, opening week. Clemson at Louisville on Thursday night probably seemed like a much bigger deal before the Cardinals went ahead and lost their first two games. Now it’s essentially a tune-up for the big plate of nothing on Saturday.

Cincinnati and Miami (OH) are on in the midday slate, renewing the third-most-played rivalry in the nation, but only a small pocket of the country cares about that game. East Carolina is at Navy for the first conference game in the Midshipmen’s history, which is exciting from a historical standpoint but little else.

Georgia Tech visits Notre Dame in one of the day’s few matchups of ranked opponents. The Yellow Jackets might upset the Fighting Irish, who are already dealing with a host of injuries. At the same time, Auburn gets a chance to prove it isn’t a fraud at LSU. That’s more than enough to keep us occupied during the midday slate; sadly, it’s also most of the quality contests of the day.

Ole Miss – Alabama in primetime should be a very good gauge of where these teams stand as SEC play opens. There are a lot of people who think the Rebels might upset the Crimson Tide for the second straight season. It’s possible, though I’m not particularly inclined to trust the Rebels until I see they’re for real. In any case, it’s one of only two decent games in the entire late afternoon/evening slate.

The other is BYU at UCLA, which features two teams with near-comical over-rankings. BYU might have been a reasonable choice for a top-25 ranking later in the season, had it not lost quarterback Taysom Hill to yet another season-ending injury. The Cougars have won two games in charmed fashion, but let’s be honest: this isn’t a top-caliber team. The same could be said of UCLA, which has ridden a pair of wins over terrible teams to a top-10 ranking. This will probably end up being a coup for the Pac-12, as the Bruins will get what amounts to a free “quality” win. If UCLA struggles here, let it be known the Bruins are, once again, not for real.

Playoff Poll

Michigan State leaps into the top tier by virtue of the win over Oregon. Keep in mind this is not a traditional poll, so I don’t actually think the Spartans are the best team in the country. Rather, it’s a ranking of where teams ought to be valued in terms of their playoff worthiness at this point.

First Tier

Michigan State
Ohio State
Alabama
Georgia
TCU

The jury is still out on TCU and Georgia, but we'll get an early read on Alabama this week versus Ole Miss.

Second Tier

USC
Baylor
Florida State
Clemson

I got to cheat a little with Clemson playing on Thursday night. Yikes. A three-point win over Louisville is decidedly not impressive.

Third Tier

Oregon
Georgia Tech
Oklahoma

The Sooners live! Oregon is too talented to drop out entirely, but the Ducks now have ground to make up. Tech has a big opportunity this weekend at Notre Dame.

Pac-12 Report

It would have been nice for the conference if Oregon had managed to eke out a win at Michigan State, but in the end a hard-fought loss isn’t the worst thing in the world. Oregon didn’t look good in Week One, so the more important thing is that the Ducks played a quality opponent close – thus indicating improvement – in a larger-scope goal of being elite by season’s end.

Utah doesn’t really blow teams out, but it was another solid week for the Utes, turning back rival Utah State and moving to 2-0 with a trip to Oregon to open conference play looming. Not much was expected of Oregon State at Michigan and the Beavers delivered, getting shut out 35-0 after scoring a touchdown on their opening drive. Washington, Colorado, Arizona, UCLA and USC all registered predictably easy wins against bad competition.

Washington State and California both came through, though in different ways. After the Cougars lost to FCS foe Portland State in their opener (and keeping in mind the ugly loss to Rutgers last season), there was little hope WSU could knock off the Scarlet Knights in a cross-country trip. Instead, Wazzu saved itself from Couging it; stuck in a back-and-forth game (and after giving the Scarlet Knights a go-ahead punt return TD), the Cougs confidently marched down the field for the winning score with 13 seconds left. It was an excellent win I had pegged as a loss since the schedule came out.

Cal got a big win of a different kind, spotting San Diego State a seven-point lead before rattling off 35 straight. It was the kind of performance to give people who think the Bears might be pretty good this year (like me!) some hope. Now, with a very interesting matchup at Texas on deck, we’ll get to see what this team is made of.

The night slate was awful for the league, as Stanford bumbled its way to a 10-point first half before putting UCF away, doing little to assuage fears that the team that got shocked last week at Northwestern is woefully undermanned to compete in the Pac-12 this season. Arizona State was even worse, looking nothing like a Power 5 team, let alone a top-25 squad, by struggling with FCS foe Cal Poly. The Sun Devils have been tremendously disappointing so far.

This week, ASU gets another chance to look like a reasonably decent FBS team against New Mexico. Oregon has Georgia State in a walkover, while Arizona hosts Northern Arizona in a similar situation. Utah State – Washington has a chance to be decent, given that USU has the chops to pull the upset in Seattle. Colorado meets rival Colorado State in Denver for the annual Rocky Mountain Showdown; sadly, I’m going with CSU there.

The afternoon slate brings the intrigue, as Cal heads to Austin to take on Texas. This has the potential to be the Golden Bears’ coming out party, as a 3-0 start entering conference play would be pretty sweet for this program. Next, we get to see once and for all whether Stanford is the fraud it’s looked in the season’s first two weeks, when the Cardinal face USC in both teams’ Pac-12 opener. I wouldn’t be shocked to see Stanford get up for this game and make SC’s job difficult. The underdog has been surprising in this series the past few years.

Oregon State and Washington State both get a shot to improve to 2-1 with not-guaranteed but eminently winnable games versus San Jose State and Wyoming, respectively. The Beavs and Cougars should be safe, but seeing as both these schools have dropped home games to FCS teams in recent years, I wouldn’t take anything for granted.

Utah is at Fresno State in a battle of old WAC foes (R.I.P., dear conference) that might have been interesting had the Bulldogs not looked so mediocre in their first two contests. The Utes should handle the crowd in Fresno fairly easily and come away 3-0 with a fun league opener at Oregon on the docket.

Finally, there’s BYU at UCLA, which could have been a really good game had BYU not suffered the aforementioned injuries. The Cougars are generally much more athletic than people realize, but unless the Bruins are significantly more overhyped than they deserve – not out of the question, to be sure – I don’t see BYU making this much of a contest.

Random Thoughts and Observations

The SEC took it on the chin in Week Two, echoing the embarrassment the Pac-12 suffered in Week One. Auburn was extremely lucky to escape Jacksonville State and tumbled in the polls as a result; Arkansas was upset at home by Toledo; Florida and Mizzou struggled to put away mid-majors, and Tennessee blew a 17-3 lead over Oklahoma to lose in overtime. Perhaps both leagues were less stacked than expected? It seems possible, though with the awful state of the Big Ten and ACC, neither will move from the top two of the unofficial conference rankings.

It’s looking more and more as if Kansas will indeed be the worst team in the Power 5 this season. One week after falling to FCS South Dakota State in their opener, the Jayhawks were clobbered by Memphis 55-23. KU’s first – and possibly only – chance at a win comes on October 3rd, when the team travels to fellow bottom-feeder Iowa State.

2015 Stanzi Awards

It was a lovely start last week, and things only heated up in Week Two. Here are the standings thus far, with the new winners below. Auburn’s Jeremy Johnson is threatening to run away with the award, with five turnovers in two weeks and a pair of weekly Stanzis.

Jeremy Johnson, Auburn: 1
Dane Evans, Tulsa: 1
Cody Clements, South Alabama: 1
Max Wittek, Hawai’i: 1
Michael Birdsong, Marshall :1

Jeremy Johnson, Auburn
Opponent: Jacksonville State
Performance: Two INT, won in OT

Mitch Leidner, Minnesota
Opponent: Colorado State
Performance: Two FUM, won in OT

Baker Mayfield, Oklahoma
Opponent: Tennessee
Performance: Two INT, won in OT

Maty Mauk, Missouri
Opponent: Arkansas State
Performance: Two INT, won by seven

Tanner Mangum, BYU
Opponent: Boise State
Performance: Two INT, won by 11


Mmm. That’s some good Stanzi. See you after Week Three.