Thursday, September 10, 2015

Revenge of the Spartans?

Lovely though it was to have college football back, the early results were… underwhelming. The quickly-becoming-traditional kickoff game with South Carolina and North Carolina was a dud. The much-ballyhooed Utah-Michigan contest was boring, with the Wolverines getting outclassed. TCU was tremendously disappointing. Oregon and Baylor played no defense. Boise State played no offense. Even Alabama and Ohio State failed to really inspire.

So, who did look good? There weren’t many teams. Texas A&M beat Arizona State handily, although the Aggies did the same in last year’s opener against South Carolina and it turned out the Gamecocks were just terrible. Northwestern likewise got a big upset of Stanford, but it’s possible the Cardinal have simply regressed to also-ran status. Alabama defeated a ranked opponent in Wisconsin, but no partial observers thought the Badgers were actually on the Crimson Tide’s level.

Week One is tough. It’s easy to overreact to performances good and bad, and any attempt to cobble together a top 25 is laughable at this point. The upcoming week of action should provide a bit more clarity; however, drawing conclusions is still vastly premature until conference play begins in earnest. It’s why I never attempt to make rankings before the end of September.

Week Two promises a great deal more excitement. Programs have begun to grasp the new rules for the Playoff Era – nonconference games against quality teams good, lower-division patsies bad – and started to schedule accordingly. The always entertaining Utah State-Utah rivalry is on Friday (and for those inclined to look for Playoff busters early, keep an eye on Western Kentucky in Thursday’s match with Louisiana Tech).

The weekend begins with a game as interesting as a nonleague contest between unranked teams can possibly be: Oregon State at Michigan, featuring the return of Michigan Man Jim Harbaugh and the big-stage debut of new Beavers coach Gary Andersen. Later in the day in-state counterparts Oregon and Michigan State will meet in East Lansing for a rematch of last season’s barnburner in Eugene, but before that primetime matchup there’s a few nice footbally nuggets to be had.

The Battle for the Cy-Hawk Trophy is one of the Midwest’s more fun rivalries, and as neither Iowa nor Iowa State figure to be very good this season the game will allow viewers to check both teams off their college football Bingo watch list. A potentially sneaky-good tilt is in the works in Berkeley, where rapidly improving Cal hosts one of the Mountain West’s contenders in San Diego State. Oklahoma and Tennessee are somehow both ranked and playing in Knoxville, LSU is at Mississippi State, and Boise State is visiting BYU in a mid-major clash that has become deliciously contentious in recent years. Good contests abound.

Playoff Poll

As I’ve said, it makes little sense at this juncture to try to predict who will be in the playoff. Of course, that doesn’t stop the media from doing so, which means I might as well form some rough groupings of where teams stand right now.

First Tier

Ohio State
Alabama
Georgia
Clemson
TCU

I’m giving TCU the benefit of the doubt, because there’s a slight chance Minnesota might be good.

Second Tier

Baylor
Oregon
USC
Michigan State
Auburn

The winner of Oregon – MSU this week will vault into the top tier, if not the top spot overall.

Third Tier

Notre Dame
Georgia Tech
Florida State

We’ll see. Not a lot to go on yet. LSU gets left out after the Tigers’ opener was cancelled due to inclement weather.

Pac-12 Report

Ye gods. Well, so much for the Pac-12 challenging the SEC for conference supremacy. Utah got the season started out right by dominating Michigan on Thursday night (the final score was misleading; the Utes controlled from start to finish). From there, it was pretty much disaster after disaster. Arizona looked average pulling away from Texas-San Antonio. Colorado saw its faint bowl hopes go up in flames in Week One, falling to Hawai’i.

Oregon State defeated Weber State on Friday, but the Beavers clearly won’t be a factor in the Pac-12. OSU struggled for three quarters to put the Wildcats away. Washington was actually slightly more promising in defeat against Boise State. Still, that result said a lot more about Boise State (read: overrated) than it did about UW’s chances this season.

Then came the Saturday massacre. Stanford was back to doing Stanford things, such as giving its best effort to embarrass the league by losing a nonconference game with a piddling offensive performance. Washington State lost at home to FCS foe Portland State, probably knocking the Cougars from reasonable bowl contention. Oregon’s defense looked horrendous versus another Big Sky team in Eastern Washington, but at least the Ducks won. That’s more than Arizona State could say, as the Sun Devils dropped in a vintage ASU primetime choke job against Texas A&M. I thought we were past this, ASU! You turned the corner!

UCLA looked good against one of the worst teams in the Power Five conferences in Virginia, which means nothing. USC was excellent against Arkansas State, but that’s hardly something to crow about. Cal put in a nice offensive effort against Grambling… but it was Grambling.

As we stand now, USC looks like the clear favorite in the South, with UCLA the Trojans’ chief competitor. Oregon should win the North in a landslide unless Stanford shapes up in a hurry. At this rate, no team in the league will be good enough to seriously compete in the Playoff. Fortunately, there’s three months left to play, so between now and the start of December at least one squad should show sufficient growth to be included.

Utah State at Utah should be fun this Friday, even if the Utes’ continued evolution has made this rivalry somewhat one-sided. I expect Michigan to handle Oregon State with relative ease, but Washington and Colorado should be able to get into the “W” column with games against Sacramento State and Massachusetts, respectively.

Washington State has a chance for redemption against Rutgers, while Cal and Arizona face off against a pair of Mountain West squads (San Diego State, Nevada). USC and UCLA each get another meaningless tune-up (Idaho, UNLV) and Stanford has a now-intriguing home opener with UCF. Then there’s Oregon at Michigan State.

MSU had the Ducks on the ropes last year, and with Vernon Adams now behind center it’s easy to assume the Spartans have the upper hand. It’s a tough call and a game that could be won be either team, which usually makes home-field advantage that much more important. Still… MSU typically struggles in these big games. Forced to choose, I’ll go with UO; the Spartans have to prove they can knock off an elite team.

Random Thoughts and Observations

Please don’t make anything of Ohio State’s win over Virginia Tech. The Hokies are afforded a tremendous amount of clout for some reason, which is curious given just how bad this team has been the past few years. Season records for Tech since 2011: 7-6. 8-5, 7-6. Ohio State just beat an unranked team. It’s not impressive at all. TCU’s win over Minnesota carries more weight, and it remains to be seen whether the Gophers are any good whatsoever.

The Oregon – Michigan State game promises to be very exciting, but it’s a contest that might not mean as much at season’s end as it will in the short term. If Oregon wins the Pac-12 again, the Ducks will be in the playoff, regardless of the outcome this week. MSU could lose to Ohio State and make a case it deserves to be included with a win over UO, but the Big Ten is viewed so poorly it’s hard to see it happening. The Spartans are going to have to beat OSU.

2015 Stanzi Awards

After last season’s thrilling Stanzi race, will 2015 be able to live up to the award’s rich history? I’m optimistic, as quarterbacks tend to always find new ways to amaze us with their poor decision-making and flair for the inopportune play. As a reminder, here are the rules for all the hopeful signal-callers across the nation:

1) Only QB’s are eligible
2) The QB must have multiple turnovers
3) The game must be close (defined as within two possessions)
4) The QB’s team must win the game

So let’s get things started! Here are the Week One winners, including a #doublestanzi in the first week of the year and old standby Dane Evans of Tulsa:

Jeremy Johnson, Auburn
Opponent: Louisville
Performance: Three INT, won by seven

Dane Evans, Tulsa
Opponent: Florida Atlantic
Performance: Two INT, won by three in overtime

Cody Clements, South Alabama
Opponent: Gardner-Webb
Performance: Two INT, won by 10

Max Wittek, Hawai’i
Opponent: Colorado
Performance: Two INT, won by eight

DOUBLE STANZI ALERT:
Michael Birdsong, Marshall
Opponent: Purdue
Performance: One INT, one FUM, won by 10
Austin Appleby, Purdue
Opponent: Marshall
Performance: Four INT (two for TD), lost by 10



That’s it for Week One. Return next week, when we’ll have results from games that start to have significance.

Thursday, September 3, 2015

Left Coast Bias

Onward to the Pac-12, the realm of football with which I am most comfortable. I love the Pac-12, as I loved the Pac-10 before it. The setup of geographically rivalled pairs is unequalled in the country, the locales are beautiful, and the on-field product has improved dramatically in the past five years. After years of Oregon and Stanford’s mighty rule, will the league finally see a new champion in 2015? Read on to find out.

Although the Pac-12 hasn’t had a national champion since 2004, that matters less than once did now that we're in the playoff era. The conference has respect now, as national analysts have said since last season that the Pac-12 and SEC are on essentially equal footing. The SEC’s top is still better, but the Pac-12 has a stronger middle class, and with one more strong push (or another slight slip from the SEC) the west coast’s only major league could assume the title of Nation’s Toughest Conference.

As usual, I’ve mapped out the season for each team, picking guaranteed (such as they exist) wins and losses to determine the ceiling and floor for each school. The remainder of contests form the “swing games,” in which a team will make or break its season. In 2013, every school fell into my predicted ranges. Last year, I missed two: Utah and Cal both finished one game ahead of my ceiling (5-7 for the Golden Bears, 8-4 for the Utes). I widened my ranges this season to better account for the unpredictability of the sport, but I have once again made concrete record predictions.

North Division

California
Floor: 3-9
Ceiling: 11-1
Swing games: at Texas, at Washington, Washington State, at Utah, at UCLA, USC, at Oregon, at Stanford, Arizona State

Cal is a real enigma this year. The Golden Bears have a lot of talent returning on offense and a lot of starters overall coming back (17 overall, nine on offense, eight on defense). Jared Goff is a good young quarterback who already ranks third all-time on the Cal passing yards list. He should blow away the career record this season in a triumphant follow-up to his 3,973-yard performance last year, which included a fantastic 37:5 touchdown-to-interception ratio. Joining him will be most of the offense from 2014 sans receiver Chris Harper, who should be easily replaceable in this system.

But oh, the defense. Cal fielded one of the worst units in the nation during Sonny Dykes’ first season, and it didn’t get much better last year. The Bears gave up nearly 40 points and more than 500 yards per game, which simply isn’t going to get it done. It doesn’t matter if a team returns a ton of starters if those starters aren’t good. I like this Cal team and wanted them to reach the postseason last year (it just missed out with a 35-42 loss to BYU in the finale). The Bears should be able to do it this season, but I can’t see much more than that unless the defense makes a drastic leap forward.

Oregon
Floor: 6-6
Ceiling: 12-0
Swing games: at Michigan State, Utah, at Arizona State, California, at Stanford, USC

What to make of the Ducks? Well, even with the loss of RB Thomas Tyner, Oregon returns an embarrassment of riches at the skill positions. Bralon Addison’s comeback from knee surgery, an injury that may have cost the Ducks a national championship, should ease the growing pains of new QB Vernon Adams. After a year of tremendous turmoil on the offensive line, UO should actually be better off. If Adams is the player for Oregon he was at Eastern Washington, this team could be very, very good.

There are concerns, though. Enough talent was lost from the defense that this isn’t exactly plug-and-play, which makes that Week Two visit to East Lansing pretty iffy. Oregon tends to rotate a lot of guys defensively, but how sharp will the team be on the road against a top-five opponent after just one tune-up? The Pac-12 is also no cakewalk, and even though the Ducks have only lost three conference games in four years there’s always a chance this could be the season the train finally gets slowed. We’ll see.

Oregon State
Floor: 2-10
Ceiling: 6-6
Swing games: San Jose State, at Washington State, Colorado, Washington

I don’t see much room for optimism in year one of the Gary Andersen era. Mike Riley didn’t exactly leave the cupboard empty, but transitioning coaches is always tough, especially when going from a pro-style offense to a spread. To make matters worse, the Beavers will be splitting time at QB between a redshirt freshman and a true freshman, which is almost never a recipe for success.

There are pieces here and there. Victor Bolden could be a nice playmaker in this system, as the speedy, undersized WR OSU has always loved. The O-line is talented and should finally help the Beavs end their ugly streak without a 1,000-yard rusher. But my goodness, this team is young. There are so many underclassmen littered throughout the two-deep, and the schedule does this squad no favors. How about a trip to the Big House in Week Two? Maybe hosting Stanford in the Pac-12 opener (after Stanford plays USC, no less)? This season could get grounded before it even begins.

Stanford
Floor: 4-8
Ceiling: 12-0
Swing games: at Northwestern, UCF, at USC, Arizona, UCLA, Oregon, California, Notre Dame

Ah, Stanford. Bane of my attempt to make reasonable predictions. Last year was finally the season when the Cardinal took a step back. It’s a minor miracle it didn’t happen sooner, but somehow this team was able to weather the complete lack of a competent passer for the better part of three seasons before falling off. Kevin Hogan is back at QB yet again, and this is his swan song. Can he improve enough to save this offense from itself? The Cardinal will boast one of the nation’s best O-lines again, but the issue is the skill players. Stanford doesn’t have the backs it did a few seasons ago, and the receivers are decidedly average.

Generally this team leans on the defense to fix things, but it’s pretty tough to see that being the case this season. Just four starters return, including none along the front line. I doubt the Cardinal will repeat as the country’s second-best scoring defense (just 16.4 points per game) while moving on from those players. None of this is to say Stanford won’t be good; I expect quite the opposite. But it’s possible we’ve seen this team’s peak come and go.

Washington
Floor: 1-11
Ceiling: 5-7
Swing games: Utah State, California, at Oregon State, Washington State

I have a bad feeling about the Huskies this season. It seems like it’s going to take Chris Petersen a couple of years to sort things out in the Pac-12, and in the meantime UW fans might want to shield their eyes. There’s no QB. The top returning rusher gained less than 700 yards. The WR corps is middling. The O-line just lost its best player, Dexter Charles, to retirement. The defense returns one guy in the front seven, and Shaq Thompson bolted for the NFL.

Is there reason for hope? Not that I can see. The schedule doesn’t do the Huskies any favors, either, with inter-division road trips to USC and ASU, home visits from the Pac-12 title game teams (Oregon and Arizona) and an away contest on Boise State’s raucous Smurf Turf to start the year. Yikes. The secondary is pretty talented, I suppose. That’s about all the nice things I have to say.

Washington State
Floor: 2-10
Ceiling: 6-6
Swing games: at Rutgers, at California, Oregon State, at Washington

Things need to turn around in a hurry for WSU, which has gone a grand total of 12-25 under Mike Leach in three years. I like Leach a lot, but he’s got to put together a defense capable of stringing together a few stops. The Cougs are already replacing the program’s all-time leading passer in Connor Halliday, so now’s as good a time as any to revamp what works and what doesn’t in this system. First: establish the run as a legitimate threat. It doesn’t matter how well you throw the ball. This team cannot continue to average 40 yards a game on the ground as it has the past three seasons.

Defensively… I don’t know, try? This isn’t the mid-2000’s Big 12. You can’t expect to outscore everyone. The Pac-12 is really, really good; teams won’t let you do that. The Cougs have some playmakers on the outside (River Cracraft, Dom Williams), but it won’t matter if the team rushes for a total of 478 yards again this season and the defense allows another 38 points per game. Step it up, Wazzu. 

South

Arizona
Floor: 7-5
Ceiling: 12-0
Swing games: UCLA, at Stanford, at USC, Utah, at Arizona State

The Wildcats get a pretty generous schedule in their victory lap from 2014’s South title. I have them down for three wins without breaking a sweat. UCLA and Stanford are the first two conference tilts, but after that ‘Zona has a cakewalk all the way to the Nov. 7 showdown with USC. The back-loaded schedule will probably allow this squad to build up a nice ranking before the big boys show up.

Of course, it’s possible Arizona is one of the big boys now. QB Anu Solomon and RB Nick Wilson are both back, along with most of the talented receiving corps that got the ‘Cats all the way to the Pac-12 title game. I think a slip is likely, given the losses in the secondary, but UA does get back LB Scooby Wright. It will really all come down to the November games, as road trips to USC and rival USC are sandwiched around a home date with Utah.

Arizona State
Floor: 5-7
Ceiling: 12-0
Swing games: Texas A&M (in Arlington), USC, at UCLA, at Utah, Oregon, Arizona, at California

I’m high on the Sun Devils right now. I think the defense, which was surprising last year and returns nine starters, will be improved. ASU should have been undefeated going into the finale with rival Arizona last year, but a bizarre meltdown versus UCLA and a fluky loss at Oregon State hampered this team. Now is the time for this program to finally show what it can do on the big stage. The schedule starts with a bang against Texas A&M in Arlington, but ASU has no more excuses left.

Mike Bercovici proved to be a quality passer during his time in relief last season, so he’s really more like a returning starter. The Sun Devils did lose a big-time WR in Jaelen Strong, but the rest of the backs and receivers return. I expect the same kind of offensive production we’ve come to expect from this team under Todd Graham, and if the defense makes any kind of a leap, ASU could be in for a special year.

Colorado
Floor: 2-11
Ceiling: 6-7
The Buffaloes continue to play 13-game seasons, which baffles me. You do know you have to win seven games to make a bowl that way, right? No matter. CU won’t be returning to the postseason yet anyway. That’s a shame, because the team has improved a fair amount from the nadir of 2012’s 1-11 campaign. The Buffs will almost certainly start 4-0, which is really going to make things heartbreaking if they go 0-9 from there. Which is highly possible.

After opening with some traditional cupcakes, Colorado gets Oregon, ASU and Arizona before its next reasonable shot at a win (OSU, though the game is in Corvallis). Then it’s off to play UCLA, Stanford and USC before the final chance for a win, at Wazzu. The Buffs will not beat Utah in their finale. So let’s hope QB Sefo Liufau, who is pretty good, can lead his squad to a couple of tough road victories in the Pac-12. He does get WR Nelson Spruce back, which is huge, and the defense… can’t get any worse. So there’s a glimmer of hope.

UCLA
Floor: 6-6
Ceiling: 12-0
Swing games: at Arizona, ASU, at Stanford, California, at Utah, at USC

UCLA gets a ton of guys back, but the most important one is a mystery. Josh Rosen, a true freshman, was named the Bruins’ starting QB last week. It’s nice that so many people are throwing such high praise at the kid, but let’s see him in action before anointing him. UCLA also has the same issue a lot of teams with a great deal of returning starters seem to have: their skill players don’t scare anyone. UCLA does miss Oregon, which will help.

Again, though, I’m not sure why people are downplaying the losses this team suffered. Eric Kendricks was UCLA’s best defensive player last season, better than LB mate Myles Jack, and it wasn’t close. He’s gone, along with a highly talented DE in Owamagbe Odighizuwa. UCLA can't simply throw anyone in there to replace those players, who were all-conference talents. The Bruins will still be very good, but they’re not winning the South.

USC
Floor: 4-8
Ceiling: 12-0
Swing games: Stanford, at ASU, at Notre Dame, Utah, at California, Arizona, at Oregon, UCLA

I like USC a lot. Cody Kessler gives you pretty much everything you could want in a college QB, the skill players are the typical high school all-Americans, the line is big and nasty and the defense… is pretty good. No offense to the wealth of talent on that side of the ball, but this IS the unofficial college team of Hollywood. There’s enough here to win the conference and challenge anyone in the country in the playoff.

However, there are hangups. Talented though the new defensive starters might be, SC is going to have a little trouble replacing  DE Leonard Williams and LB Su’a Cravens. The schedule is unforgiving, with an October trip to rival Notre Dame, a late-season cross-divisional draw of Oregon (in Eugene, no less) and the usual Stanford/UCLA matchups. Something has to give here, and I don’t see the Trojans going undefeated.

Utah
Floor: 5-7
Ceiling: 12-0
Swing games: Michigan, at Oregon, California, ASU, at USC, at Arizona, UCLA

Utah is in an interesting spot in 2015. The Utes basically broke through last season, knocking off UCLA and USC and holding a lead on Oregon before a disastrous turnover swung that game around. Yet the team still finished 8-4 and just better than .500 in conference play, relegated to also-ran status. It’s unfair, because Utah has improved tremendously since joining the Pac-12, but it shows how much of a gap there is between the major and mid-major leagues. The next step is to actually win the South, but unfortunately the division seems to have collectively all gotten much better at the same time.

The Utes still have QB Travis Wilson, who delivered on his considerable promise in 2014 and will be one of the conference’s many passers vying for honors this year. I like RB Devontae Booker, and Utah still boasts one of the better collections of linemen in the conference. It’s just hard to see where the extra wins will come from and how this team can make a leap. There’s probably not enough on this roster yet to do that.


Those are my general feelings on each team. All that’s left is my actual picks, which I present now:

2014 Pac-12 final standings prediction

North

Oregon: 11-1 overall, 8-1 Pac-12
Stanford: 9-3, 6-3
Cal: 6-6, 3-6
Washington State: 5-7, 3-6
Oregon State: 4-8, 2-7
Washington: 2-10, 0-9

South
USC: 11-1, 8-1
Arizona State: 11-1, 8-1
UCLA: 10-2, 7-2
Utah: 8-4, 5-4
Arizona: 7-5, 4-5
Colorado: 4-9, 0-9

Pac-12 Championship Game: Oregon over USC



All that’s left is to play. See you on Saturday.

Even Better Than I Was The Last Time

And we’re back! The 2015 College Football season carries a sense of the unknown like few before it. The Playoff is securely in place. The last two superstars of the old era (Jameis Winston, Marcus Mariota) have departed. And aside from a certain team in central Ohio, the field looks as open as it ever has.

Every season there are roughly a dozen teams that will reasonably compete for the national championship. 2014 was an exception, as most analysts assumed Braxton Miller’s preseason injury would keep Ohio State out of the CFP. It was only by a highly unusual twist – the Buckeyes getting all-star play out of not one but TWO backups – that OSU went on to win the title, and even that result was aided tremendously by several other factors across the country (most notably, TCU’s slipup against Baylor).

2015 appears to once again have the requisite 10-15 legitimate championship contenders. After going over every power conference team’s depth chart and schedule, I selected the ones I thought fell into the “true contender” category, and unsurprisingly, they numbered 12. No Power 5 league had fewer than two, which bodes well for balance in the title race nationally. I prefer to separate these squads into two groups for the purposes of my preview: Genuine top-class elite teams and potentially-good-enough ones that will need a little help to reach the ultimate prize.

Group A

Alabama

We start again with the Crimson Tide, who will reload yet again thanks to another in a seemingly endless line of brilliant recruiting classes. Bama has to replace the tremendous Blake Sims (perhaps the first Tide quarterback in a generation with a personality) along with its top three receivers, which very nearly bumped the team down into the second grouping. However, the return of seven starters on defense along with the addition of a staggering nine recruits (nine!) ranked in the top 10 at their respective positions means that Bama will be a favorite once more to reach the College Football Playoff.

Georgia

I’ve ragged on Georgia fairly extensively in the past, but this time around I like the Bulldogs. Yes, Todd Gurley is gone, but he was hurt half the time anyway, and Nick Chubb is a more than suitable replacement at running back. UGA gets 13 starters back, but the big question is at QB. Solve that issue and this team will be off and rolling; despite road games at Auburn and rival Georgia Tech, the slate is pretty favorable. Thanks to the Jacksonville site versus Florida, the Bulldogs play only three SEC road contests, two of which are Tennessee and Vandy. A return to Atlanta seems likely.

Ohio State

Look upon OSU and tremble, mere mortals. With all three of their QB’s back plus 13 additional starters, the Buckeyes would already be a terrifying force if they didn’t play in the average Big Ten. Unfortunately for the rest of the college football world, they do, which provides the double bonus of ensuring a nice and easy path to the playoff and a significantly more rested team once they make it there. Look at this schedule. Who on earth is going to challenge this team? Michigan State is the only remotely well-equipped foe on the docket, and the Spartans have to come to Columbus. There’s a reason OSU is the prohibitive favorite to win it all.

Michigan State

MSU is in an interesting spot going into 2015. Sure, 14 starters return, including the linchpins of both the offense (QB Connor Cook) and defense (DE Shilique Calhoun). And it’s true that, even with the loss of their top three rushers, the Spartans will probably piece together a respectable ground game. But I’m just not sure this team is any better than last year’s edition, which bowed out in the second half to Oregon and Ohio State (to be fair, the two teams that played for the title). Both opponents are on the schedule again, which means it’s probably another year of playing runner-up for MSU. Still… get past the Ducks, and catch the Buckeyes on an off day, and it’s clear sailing to the playoff. The rest of the Big Ten stands no chance.

TCU

Whoo boy, does TCU have the potential to be scary-good. The Horned Frogs return 10 starters on offense (15 overall), including my top preseason Heisman candidate in QB Trevone Boykin, who made the leap to god tier status last year. This will probably be the nation’s best offense, which, as we saw last year, makes for a rather terrifying combination when matched with TCU’s traditionally monstrous defense. Oh… and they get Baylor at home. The days of the Horned Frogs holding teams to less than 14 points a game might be done, but with how far the offense has come it doesn’t really matter. I see this team winning the Big 12 and making the playoff this season.

Group B

Auburn

What makes Auburn dangerous isn’t the number or quality of its returning starters. The Tigers have just 12 and will be breaking in a new signal-caller to boot. There’s plenty of talent on the defense and in the trenches, of course, but that’s par for the course on the Plains. No, Auburn’s biggest advantage in 2015 is the schedule. The Tigers kick things off with a high-profile (but probably pretty easy) neutral-site game with Louisville in Atlanta, then get to host Georgia, Alabama and Ole Miss. Wow. A lot would have to go this squad’s way to make the playoff, but we’ve seen that happen twice in the last decade. Don’t ever count Auburn out.

Baylor

The Bears were a meltdown in Morgantown away from a berth in the CFP, though they salted away some of the goodwill from their charmed season with that late collapse in the Cotton Bowl. Baylor now has back-to-back championship-caliber seasons that have ended with bowl embarrassment, which has to be corrected. With the team breaking in a semi-new QB in Seth Russell, I can’t rely on them to win the conference without a little help, and at some point the average defense is going to need to be addressed to view Baylor as a true contender. Still, the Bears remain eminently dangerous and could challenge for a playoff berth if everything breaks right.

Clemson

Clemson is the fringiest of fringe candidates on this list, but hear me out. The 10 returning starters are an issue, but Deshaun Watson is a tremendous talent and the ACC isn’t exactly a murderer’s row. The thing is, Clemson actually has the schedule to impress people despite that; drawing Miami (FL) and Georgia Tech out of the Coastal is a boon (provided they go down as wins), while the Tigers also get Notre Dame in the non-conference and host Florida State. To be sure, it’s a long shot, but that throttling of Oklahoma in the Russell Athletic Bowl only served to increase expectations.

Florida State

The shoe is on the other foot for the Seminoles, who will replace Jameis Winston with Notre Dame transfer Everett Golson. Laugh if you must, but Golson did show flashes of being a great college QB with the Irish, so if he can just keep his turnovers down – something that spiraled out of control quickly in 2014 – FSU should be fine against another paper-thin ACC. Outside of the late visit to Clemson (and perhaps the trip to Georgia Tech) there’s no team on the schedule remotely capable of hanging with the talent in Tallahassee. The return of RB Dalvin Cook is a big deal, while getting back five of the top six tacklers from last season won’t hurt.

LSU

The Tigers, as usual, have to be included in the conversation, though it annoys me to no end. Leonard Fournette did come on at the end of last season, and apart from a couple easily replaced linemen the offense essentially returns intact. The defense will be its traditionally stingy self, as LSU brings better athletes to the defensive side than just about anyone in the nation not named Alabama. But I still can’t take this squad seriously until it finds an above-average QB. Do you know how many times in the last decade LSU has thrown for 3,000 yards as a team? Three, including Zach Mettenberger’s performance in 2013 and the immortal Jamarcus Russell in 2006. This program desperately needs a top-flight QB to get over the hump, and there’s not one on this roster.

Oregon

The general consensus (shared by myself) on Oregon is that the Ducks will be a high-quality outfit again this year, but unable to reach the heights of the previous campaign. It’s not hard to see why; even a very capable replacement like Eastern Washington transfer Vernon Adams will have a tough time replicating Marcus Mariota’s value to this team. The schedule is rough, with a nonconference visit to Michigan State and Pac-12 showdowns with Utah, USC, at Stanford and at Arizona. It would be completely reasonable for UO to drop the MSU game, lose one league tilt and finish a respectable 10-2… that is, unless Adams is as good as people think. He might very well be, but we’ll have to wait and see.

USC

Unsurprisingly, USC is getting a lot of hype as a potential CFP entrant. Whenever the Trojans have any kind of chance at a quality year, the media tends to hop on the bandwagon. This time around, at least, the optimism is warranted (unlike in, say, 2012). Cody Kessler is the real deal, while the SC offensive line returns all five starters and the team overall is as talented as usual. Several young players who saw spot duty last season seem poised to break out in 2015, such as receiver Juju Smith and WR/DB Adoree’ Jackson. And yet… I have a hard time taking the Trojans seriously as a title contender. The schedule is brutal, with three road games (Arizona State, Notre Dame, Oregon) AND three home games (Utah, UCLA, Stanford) that could all prove to be SC’s undoing. I don’t see it happening.

It’s a short list of championship contenders, but I feel confident our winner will emerge from one of those two groups. Now on to the conference previews, in which I note the sleeper teams and important players to watch, analyze the schedule, and pick the division and league champs.


AAC

Projected Champion: UCF Temple Cincinnati over Navy Memphis

It’s an unfortunate place to have to start, but I’ll do what I can. The Zombie Big East – or ZBE, as I may refer to it in the future – has become a bewildering hodge-podge of castoff schools (Temple, East Carolina, Tulsa, Tulane), old guard programs (SMU, Houston, Navy), basketball schools (Cincinnati, Memphis, UConn) and new bloods (Central Florida, South Florida). The conference stretches from Texas in the west to Ohio and Pennsylvania in the north to Florida in the southeast. There’s not a single true power in the league, play styles range from ultra-futuristic (ECU, Houston) to prehistoric (Navy), and no one has any clue who plays in what division.

Yet the AAC remains eminently watchable, for both its predictable unpredictability and its parity. No other league has as many legitimate contenders to take its crown, which should give the new AAC title game as extra boost of flair. Yes, Navy has broken its century-plus exile in independence to wreak havoc with the triple-option in a conference, and in doing so given the ZBE the requisite dozen members needed* to hold a conference championship game. Imagine the possibilities!

*A rule the NCAA just changed to benefit the shortsightedness of the Big 12

The West Division will be a three-team race between defending co-champion Memphis, Houston and Navy. I’m inclined to side with the Midshipmen and QB Keenan Reynolds, but I fear that’s probably my flexbone bias showing. The Cougars need to upgrade 2014’s surprisingly anemic passing production. In all likelihood, the Tigers will manage to scrape by due to the return of the majority of 2014’s offensive production.

In the East, it’s another trio of contenders – Cincinnati, UCF and Temple – who will battle for supremacy. Temple has the highest sleeper potential, as the Owls return 19 starters and should be formidable defensively. UCF reloaded impressively last season and probably should have won the league, while Cincy gets back its QB and top six receivers from a very strong passing attack. In the end, I’ll go with the Bearcats to win the East and the conference.

ACC

Projected Champion: Clemson over Georgia Tech

After watching FSU dominate the league for two seasons, the ACC is back on more equal footing. No, this conference still isn’t very good – it’s unquestionably the weakest of the Power 5 – but there’s enough quality now to at least make the first two-thirds of the season worth keeping an eye on. The expansion to 14 teams really didn’t add much, but fortunately it hasn’t watered the product down any more.

Clemson is the trendy pick to take the title this season and for good reason: the Tigers boast the ACC’s best QB in Deshaun Watson. If the talented sophomore can stay on the field, he’ll be an all-American and Heisman candidate. Joining Watson is a whole host of skill position talent that should be able to cover (relatively) for the reshuffling of the O-line and a lot of new starters on defense. Florida State figures to take a step back in the post-Winston era, while Louisville is probably still a year away. Nobody else in the Atlantic is a threat.

The Coastal is more wide open, with a varied triumvirate of teams ready to fight for the right to lose to the Tigers. Virginia Tech is viewed quite favorably right now, but as with LSU, I can’t take this team seriously until it finds a competent passer. The QB play in Blacksburg has been abysmal for years and even 16 returning starters can’t make up for that. Miami (FL) gets both Virginia Tech and Georgia Tech at home, and QB Brad Kaaya should build on his promising frosh campaign. However, the ‘Canes lose too much at RB and WR to be a true contender. Georgia Tech faces a nasty slate, drawing FSU and Clemson from the Atlantic Division and Georgia and Notre Dame in nonleague action, but the Yellow Jackets have the defensive chops to hang with teams and a QB in Justin Thomas who should rank among the most efficient in the nation. I’ll take the Yellow Jackets to win the Coastal.

Big Ten

Projected Champion: Ohio State over Wisconsin

This is probably going to be a repeat, right down to the beating we saw in Indianapolis. There simply isn’t enough quality in the Big Ten right now to challenge the few elite teams. Ohio State will run roughshod over the entire league, Michigan State notwithstanding. The Spartans will likely pose a nice test for the Buckeyes, but in the end that’s all that will matter in the East Division. No. Stop. Michigan and Penn State are not ready. Expectations for those schools need to be tempered.

The West will at least be a competitive race, with front-runners Nebraska and Wisconsin seeing challenges from Minnesota and darkhorse Northwestern. I still doubt Mike Riley will be able to get things going quickly enough in his first season in Lincoln to really make a push for the division, so the returning talent of the Badgers will probably be enough to take the West.

Roughly half of the Big Ten is objectively bad, which really hurts the perception of the league nationwide. While expansion was undoubtedly good for revenue purposes, it served no purpose for football, and as a result the conference faces a crisis of quality the likes of which are rather unprecedented. Ohio State can win as many championships as it wants; the Big Ten needs to perform in nonconference action this fall to prove it isn’t just the Buckeyes’ punching bag.

Big 12

Projected Champion: TCU

I waxed poetic about TCU earlier, so I don’t think a recap is really necessary. Rest assured, the Horned Frogs will be very, very good. I think the defense will actually surprise some people who expect TCU to be worse on that side this season. That train of thought points to the 19.0 points per game the Horned Frogs allowed in 2014 (down from 25.6 the previous year and 20+ the two season prior) and assumes the defense got significantly better in a fluky way. That’s actually not true – TCU allowed roughly the same amount of yards per game and opposing completion percentage that it had in each of the past five years. The only thing that changed was a slight decrease in points allowed, which is a lot more random than fans seem to realize. With the offense once again forcing foes into passing situations, the success on the defensive side should continue.

Baylor is the prohibitive favorite to upend the Horned Frogs, but I still can’t put my faith into the Bears until they prove they can play a little D. This program has reached unheard-of heights, but hasn’t been able to summit the mountain because of what happens in the contests when the offense stalls out. Oklahoma might actually be a sleeper given how most prognosticators have given up on the Sooners, though it’s hard to trust a team after so many disappointments. OU will get no love until it shows real improvement on the field.

Oklahoma State, Kansas State and Texas form a decent middle of the conference, but none is a legit contender. West Virginia and Texas Tech are facing make-or-break years, as both programs have flamed out in the face of actual quality competition on a week-to-week basis. Kansas and Iowa State make up the awful floor of the Big 12, with Kansas in particular looking like potentially the worst team in the Power 5.

Conference USA

Projected Champion: Western Kentucky over Louisiana Tech

I waffled on the winner of the CUSA Championship game, but not the participants. WKU and LTU are the clear choices in this odd transitional year for the league, which will play without UAB for two seasons after the Blazers terminated, then reinstated their program. For now, Conference USA will exist with 13 members, thanks to the addition of UNC-Charlotte. Realignment has been really weird, folks.

WKU is the pick to take the East simply because there is no other choice. Defending champion Marshall lost an all-timer in QB Rakeem Cato and there isn’t another squad in the division with comparable talent. The Hilltoppers have a ton coming back, including nine defensive starters, but the headliners are on offense. QB Brandon Doughty is back, along with all 4,830 of his passing yards and 49 passing TD’s. He’s joined by five of his top seven receivers, plus 2,000 yards rushing in the form of RB’s Leon Allen and Anthony Wales. Long story short: this is going to be fun.

The West is a two-team race in my estimation, as upstart Rice attempts to topple defending division champ LTU. These two schools each have one division title the past two season and shouldn’t face too much of a challenge from the likes of UTEP and North Texas. The Owls have the edge at QB, with Driphus Jackson a significantly more reliable option than the Bulldogs’ Florida transfer Jeff Driskel. However, Rice returns little else, especially on the defensive side, whereas Tech has 13 total starters back.

MAC

Projected Champion: Northern Illinois over Bowling Green

Some things just become ingrained in American life. In MAC country, it’s NIU winning the West Division. The Huskies have done it five straight seasons, with a host of different QB’s and different head coaches. This year, NIU faces one of its stiffest threats yet, in the form of Toledo. I’ve liked the Rockets for some time and even picked them to upset the Huskies once or twice, but NIU hasn’t gone down in more than five years.

This season could be different. Toledo flat-out gave last season’s game away, which cost the Rockets a shot at the MAC crown. That has to sting and serve as motivation for this year’s matchup, which will be at the Glass Bowl. Yet I can’t bring myself to pick Toledo this time around. I’ve been burned too often picking against the obvious choice in this conference, which NIU rules with an iron fist (at least, during the regular season).

The East is pretty simple as well. Bowling Green, winner of the past two division titles, should have enough to return to Detroit. The 2015 Falcons have depth at QB, a position that saw several injuries as the team tried to defend its MAC title a year ago. The defense should be much improved after last season’s disastrous finish, which saw the team allow more points per game than it had in the previous two seasons combined. Finally, the Falcons get Akron (their biggest competitor) at home.

Mountain West

Projected Champion: Boise State over San Diego State

The MWC will duel with the AAC again for the title of “Best Group of 5 Conference.” I’d say the AAC is stronger in the middle, but the Mountain West is better at the top. Did you know there were four 10-win teams in the Mountain Division alone in 2014? The league probably won’t see that kind of success again this year, but the improved West should make interdivisional play much more interesting.

Of course, as the college football world changes, so too does it stay the same. Barring a tremendous collapse, Boise State will win the Mountain and the conference. There’s simply too much talent in Boise to think otherwise. The Broncos return 17 starters from the squad that held off Arizona in the Fiesta Bowl, and though they need a new QB and RB, it’s hard to imagine them not taking the division. Utah State poses the largest threat if QB Chuckie Keeton can manage to stay healthy for a whole year, but he’s sadly been unable to do so since 2012 (when the Aggies went 11-2).

The West is more wide open, with San Diego State, Fresno State and Nevada vying for a spot in the MWC title game. I like the Aztecs, with their strong defense (eight returning starters) and cupboard full of skill position talent. Plus, they get AMAZING new uniforms this season. It’s meant to be! Nevada has to replace one of the best signal-callers in program history in Cody Fajardo, which to me indicates the Wolf Pack need a year to put things together. Fresno is intriguing, as the Bulldogs return a mishmash of parts from the team that gave Boise not one but two scares last season… but I’ll still go with the Aztecs.

SEC

Projected Champion: Georgia over Auburn

Oh, this feels weird. I’m not sure how long it’s been since I picked someone other than Alabama to win the division, much less the conference. Yet here we are. ‘Bama under Nick Saban has seemingly been able to get above-average QB play from anyone off the street… but now they’re in for a new test. The Crimson Tide have never had to replace their QB at the same time they replaced essentially the rest of the offense. Sure, the defense will be great, but we’ve seen a shift in this league the past couple of seasons that indicates you can’t just win on defense alone anymore.

So who wins the West? As I said earlier, LSU once again has everything necessary to make a run except a competent QB. The Tigers are as talented as anyone but a question mark at the most important position (though they do have a favorable schedule). I’m not buying the Mississippi schools (I think last year was a fluke) and Arkansas, while good, shouldn’t quite have the ability to topple the big boys just yet. So that leaves Auburn, a team I see as maybe the third- or fourth-most talented in the division, but the one with the best schedule. More importantly, Gus Malzahn has proved to be a savant at getting the most out of his middling QB’s.

As for the East, well, the East also exists. Georgia is the pick sort of by default, though that’s not really fair to the Bulldogs. This is a very good team; Nick Chubb is a worthy successor to Todd Gurley at RB, the O-line is solid, and the defense should be pretty decent as usual. Tennessee has been getting a lot of press, and for good reason: 18 returning starters (including 10 on offense) will do that for you. My issue with that metric is that it matters less if those players aren’t stars. Sure, the Volunteers get back virtually every WR and RB from 2014. The problem is that none of those guys are very good. The same applies to the defense, which is experience but wasn’t anywhere near elite last season.

I doubt Florida will make much of a run in  Jim McElwain’s first year, so the final contender is two-time defending East winner Missouri. I like the Tigers, but they lose a lot of quality skill talent and were throttled by the “true” division winner at home versus Georgia last season 34-0. The big thing going in the Tigers favor is the schedule – Mizzou draws the West doormats and plays its first two real conference games (excluding Kentucky, of course) at home.

Sun Belt

Projected Champion: Georgia Southern

The Sun Belt, the forgotten league of the FBS, had one of the most exciting storylines in football last season that no one cared about. Georgia Southern, a perennial FCS power that upset Florida to end the 2013 season, entered the higher division and proceeded to lay waste to its enemies, scoring nearly 40 points per game while going 8-0 against its new conference. The Eagles nearly upset North Carolina State and Georgia Tech, only to be denied a waiver to play in a bowl because of the NCAA’s transitional year rules.

This year, the Eagles are back and ready to get to the first bowl in their history, and I think they’ll do it as two-time defending SBC champs. The top four teams in the league should remain the same: Georgia Southern, Appalachian State, Louisiana-Lafayette and Arkansas State are the favorites again, and for good reason. Each one returns a lot of talent. App State had a rough introduction to FBS football in 2014, starting 1-5, but the Mountaineers rallied for 6-0 finish that had them looking like the giant-killers of old. ASU returns an astounding 20 starters – 10 on each side – to a potential SBC championship squad. Arkansas State has the most dynamic QB in the conference in Fredi Knighten, and the Red Wolves get back eight starters around him on offense. It wouldn’t be surprising at all to see this team back on top of the league.

Lafayette returns nine offensive starters from the team that won nine games and represented the SBC as its unofficial champion in bowl season, so the Ragin’ Cajuns have a lot left. However, they do lose QB Terrance Broadway, one of my favorite non-power school players of the past few years. Georgia Southern is my choice to repeat thanks to eight returning starters on defense, even though the Eagles lost the majority of the offensive line that paved the way to nearly 400 yards rushing per game in SBC play. I think the line will get sorted out enough to make due, allowing the improved defense to cover for the slip in production.



And there are the conference breakdowns. The next post will include my full Pac-12 analysis, as we begin the season in just a few hours.

Sunday, January 11, 2015

College Football Playoff Final

This is it. Did the season really go by so fast? Let us not speak of my bowl record, which started 8-3 and finished… less impressively. I did manage to get most of the big games right, but the whole affair is probably better left untouched. This is why I hate (and love) bowl season!

It seems incredible that after all the anger, frustration, fighting and clawing to get to this point, we’re mere moments away from the first playoff championship game in major college football history. Don’t feel bad, though; most sports already figured out a playoff is the best way to finish things. It just took FBS-level football, erm, 145 years.

Yet here we are. It took a lot to kill the BCS, but the old system really did it to itself. Miami (FL)’s snub in 2000. Oregon’s in 2001. USC’s in 2003. The LSU-Alabama rematchpocalypse of 2011. The BCS had more cringe-worthy moments than it did triumphant ones, and that’s what ultimately did it in (well, that and the money. Never forget the money). A true playoff – albeit a small one – has arrived and it’s here to stay.

So who wins this most celebratory of contests? Both Oregon and Ohio State arrive in Arlington… not exactly underdogs. Every preseason prediction had the Ducks and Buckeyes somewhere in the top 10, if not the top five. These are no Cinderellas. Of course, neither side took a traditional route to the playoff, either. UO and OSU both felt the agony of several key personnel losses along the way and suffered brutal, seemingly title-killing home defeats. However, the teams rebounded impressively, regrouped and managed to find their way to this game.

First and foremost, Ohio State is not the same team everyone saw getting manhandled by Virginia Tech in Week 2. The Buckeyes have adjusted to the weaknesses the Hokies exposed and gotten tremendous production out of their ground game, particularly on the inside zone runs for which Oregon is famous. That’s not surprising, given Urban Meyer’s background as a spread architect. The Buckeyes have evolved in the passing game as well, though. J.T. Barrett was making his second career start in place of the injured Braxton Miller against VT and turned in by far his worst performance. The rest of the season he was superb, putting up Heisman-like numbers before breaking his ankle in the finale against Michigan.

And here’s the crucial element of this game. Cardale Jones, the former third-stringer, is now making his third straight start in relief of Barrett. Jones is a tremendously physically talented, former five-star prospect, but he’s still green. Inexperienced quarterbacks tend to be a liability, but to this point Jones has been excellent. Can he continue his streak versus Oregon? Forcing the Ducks to play both the run and pass is crucial. More on this momentarily.

With apologies to the defenses, which are both good and boast quality players, this matchup will be decided by offense. That’s why I’m forgoing a detailed breakdown of either defensive unit in lieu of more relevant offensive analysis. Rest assured that where it is important, defense will be mentioned. On to Oregon!

Little needs to be said about the Ducks’ attack. Oregon has been doing this for several years now: a quick, mobile offensive line, speedy playmakers on the outside and a QB to act as point man for the whole operation. Rinse and repeat. But the 2014 UO squad has made some key changes to the formula that have ultimately proved highly beneficial, such as a larger, more physical offensive line, a power tailback to go with, and of course the nation’s best QB in Marcus Mariota. Mariota has been fantastic, but credit must go to the line as well; without the added flexibility from the power run game, the Ducks would likely not be here.

A key factor, unfortunately, is injuries. Ohio State has had to weather adversity at the most important position, but ultimately the Buckeyes’ losses pale in comparison to Oregon’s. The Ducks lost four offensive tackles at different points throughout the year, their best tight end and two most talented receivers and their best cover corner. That’s a brutal storm of injuries and it’s a credit to UO that they’ve managed to keep plugging along in spite of all that. Now comes the ultimate test.

Ohio State has a more talented roster, top to bottom, than Oregon. That’s a fact. However, the teams match up pretty evenly. Both front sevens can clog running lanes well and force offenses to the air, which you can be assured they will do. That leaves the passing games to do some of the heavy lifting, which is where Oregon’s trump card lies. Mariota is the best passer in the country and one of the best in college football history. Jones, for all his talent, is still only making his third start.

It’s extremely impressive what Jones has managed to do against Wisconsin and Alabama. However, it’s hard to argue that the Badgers were vastly outmatched in the Big Ten Championship, which took all the pressure off Jones. And as good as he was versus ‘Bama, it’s one thing to play well coming off a three-week prep period. It’s another to turn around and do it a week later, especially against a team that tries to make you play catch-up.

This is why Oregon’s run defense is the most critical part of this football game. If OSU can smash the Ducks inside – like they often did against the Crimson Tide – Jones will have time to operate, get comfortable and make good reads. Oregon this season has played a great deal of soft shell coverage, perfect for dealing with a deep-ball threat like the Buckeyes’ Devin Smith. However, that only works if the opposing ground game isn’t tearing things up for six yards a carry. If UO can force Jones to air a reasonable amount of the time, they have to like their chances. Meanwhile, OSU can and will try the same thing, but Marcus Mariota is a whole different animal than Blake Sims.

After the 2010 season I didn’t believe Oregon was as good as Auburn. I knew the Tigers had the best offensive (Cam Newton) and defensive (Nick Fairley) players in the game. I picked Oregon anyway. This time, I think UO is the better team. The Ducks have played both better offenses and defenses this season than Ohio State. OSU has been outstanding since that early loss, but hasn’t faced an offense of this caliber... and when all else fails, there’s still Mariota. I’ll take Oregon to win the program’s first national championship.