Wednesday, December 10, 2014

The Playoff is set

National Overview

Oh, college football. How do I love thee? Let me count the ways. A glorious 2014 season wrapped up Saturday night with Ohio State’s absolute annihilation of Wisconsin in the Big Ten title game (although technically, Boise State’s Mountain West championship win came later). From the neutral-site Week 1 matchups to the indulgent conference championship games, 2014 was a delightful, wild ride from start to finish.

Now we have the inaugural playoff, which – for the time being – is restricted to just four teams. I’ll get to the lucky quartet in a moment, but let’s take a second to look at how those squads got here. After all the intrigue and chaotic scenarios everyone cooked up, the final weekend turned out to be pretty boring. Oregon throttled Arizona Friday night, easily clinching one spot. Alabama more or less did the same to Missouri midday Saturday. That left Florida State, which pulled away in the fourth quarter on Georgia Tech… and one question mark.

TCU, ranked third last week by the committee, led only 17-3 over hapless Iowa State at halftime, then raced to a 55-3 victory. Baylor controlled its game with Kansas State from the outset, winning by 11. Then Ohio State took Wisconsin to the woodshed, and burned the woodshed to the ground, and salted the earth with the tears of every Badgers fan’s firstborn (reenactment here). That’s when the discussion got very, very interesting.

Playoff Bracket

So, did the committee get it right? I don’t envy those people at all. Three slots were all but filled, sure, but that might have made things more difficult. If another contender had lost the committee would have only had the task of fitting three schools into two spots, instead of one. As it was, I think the committee went one-for-two. Ohio State is the right team at No. 4.

Baylor was the most deserving team, winning a stronger conference and defeating TCU, which had no business being in the discussion by not being true champions. However, perception matters, and the committee clearly believed – along with most of the country, including myself – the Bears looked like the weakest of the three on film. You could see that reflected in how the poll voters ranked the Horned Frogs in recent weeks; there was an overwhelming, unspoken belief that Baylor got lucky against TCU and was the lesser squad. I (and unfortunately for Baylor, the committee) agree.

That doesn’t mean OSU is some kind of juggernaut. The Buckeyes have by far the worst loss of any reasonably good team (by 14 at home to 6-6 Virginia Tech). The Big Ten is terrible, producing only one other team capable of playing with OSU (Michigan State). Lest we forget, Cardale Jones is the former third-string quarterback, and there’s no guarantee he’ll play as well as he did in the Big Ten Championship when he has to face a real defense with a month to prepare.

I also think the committee got Nos. 1 and 2 wrong. I had Alabama first after the win in the Iron Bowl, but it was close. Oregon’s obliteration of Arizona swung the pendulum back to the Ducks, and ‘Bama didn’t have a good enough opponent in the SEC title game to answer. Mizzou isn’t good, period. The Tigers were clearly the second-best team in their own awful division (losing 34-0 at home to Georgia) but had the good fortune of drawing easier interdivision foes than the Bulldogs. Missouri lost at home to 3-9 Indiana. Alabama beat Mizzou by less than Oregon did Arizona, and UO pulled its starters after three quarters.

Oregon’s overall resume is simply better, with a non-conference victory over Michigan State making up for a slightly easier conference schedule. The Ducks also got an opportunity the Crimson Tide didn’t with: a rematch with the team that beat them. By proving that October loss was a fluke, UO avenged its only black mark (also a better loss than Alabama’s, according to the committee) AND notched another top-10 win.

Moreover, putting the Ducks at No. 1 would have allowed the committee to match up the Pac-12 and Big Ten champions in the Rose Bowl and the SEC and ACC champs in the Sugar Bowl – perfect for soothing the irritated old guard who cared more about tradition than deciding a true national champion on the field. It’s the same teams, but a better bracket. This should have been an easy decision and the committee dropped the ball.

Pac-12 Report

Well… how about that? I wouldn’t have been surprised by anything from a close Arizona win to a medium-sized Oregon one, but I really didn’t expect what happened Friday. The Ducks did literally everything offensively I said they needed to do last week, and they did it with a cold, ruthless efficiency uncommon for this program. After some first-half jitters, it was near-perfection. Marcus Mariota completed all 11 of his passes after the break, wrapping up the Heisman in the process.

The defense topped the offense, flat-lining the Wildcats’ attack from before their first snap (UA fumbled the kickoff away on what would have been its first possession) and harassing Anu Solomon into one of his worst performances before an injury ended his night. As I said they must, Oregon dominated the point of attack, never allowing ‘Zona to hit those killer inside runs that opened the secondary up to play fakes in the previous two meetings. It was one of the best efforts by a UO defense in years, and it appeared to finally “complete” the Ducks as a truly elite squad.

For Arizona, it was another in a growing list of agonizing near-misses in championship scenarios. As good as Oregon is, it was pretty stunning to see how lifeless the Wildcats were in what would have probably been the biggest win in program history. Solomon’s previous injury hampered him some, but even his absolute best might not have been enough to make up for a defense that did nothing to slow an offense it had held to a total of 40 points in the last two games. ‘Zona still had a great season, but this result was obviously disappointing.

Heisman Watch

Any arguments at this point are ignorant or the work of huge homers. Marcus Mariota is the best player in the country by a wide margin and will win the Heisman trophy.

Random Thoughts and Observations

The Big 12 isn’t happy with the selection committee, but it should really be mad at itself. The “One True Champion” garbage was embarrassingly transparent; if the conference really thought that was the case, then why did it look down upon the Pac-10 for years when the west coast league was doing the same thing? Funny how things change when someone else is benefitting from the system you helped create (the SEC and Big 12 were the first two conferences to split into divisions and play conference championship games).

Of course, the real culprit is conference commissioner Bob Bowlsby, who royally screwed the Big 12 by declaring the league wouldn’t name a single champion (really? Have you SEEN your conference’s tagline?), instead allowing the committee to decide whether Baylor or TCU was more deserving. The idea, obviously, was to potentially get both the Bears and Horned Frogs in the final four. The committee, thankfully, saw through this pathetic attempt to game the system and said, “no thanks.” The Big 12 would be best served adding two schools to get back to 12 and play a conference championship again. My suggestions would be: Marshall, a rival and eastern partner for West Virginia; SMU, a former Southwest Conference foe of the Texas schools, or… BYU. Why not, nothing is sacred in college football anymore.

Stanzi Winner

There was just never going to be any doubt. Jameis Winston ran away with the 2014 Stanzi. Of the 12 games he played for Florida State, 9 wins came by two scores or less. He picked up five Stanzis during that span, a remarkable 55 percent “success” mark that may stand forever. I’ll probably have to give it at least a few months’ thought, but the Stanzi award may have to be renamed. Here is our winner and the finalists.

Jameis Winston, Florida State: 5
Logan Woodside, Toledo: 4
Everett Golson, Notre Dame: 3
Justin Holman, UCF: 3
Dak Prescott, Mississippi State: 2
James Knapke, Bowling Green: 2
Fredi Knighten, Arkansas State: 2
Christian Hackenberg, Penn State: 2
Anu Solomon, Arizona: 2
Brett Hundley, UCLA: 2
Grant Hedrick, Boise State: 2
Davis Webb, Texas Tech: 2
Nick Mullens, Southern Miss: 2
Cooper Rush, CMU: 2
C.J. Brown, Maryland: 2
Michael Brewer, Virginia Tech: 2
Brian Burell, Fresno State: 2
J.T. Barrett, Ohio State: 2


The days grow short and the leaves disappear, but football season marches on. It’s time for the weird and wacky postseason of FBS football (and don’t forget Army-Navy). The Bowl Preview is coming soon.

Wednesday, December 3, 2014

Working 3-3-5

National Overview

What a time to be a college football fan. The system is changing from the inside out, there will soon be a fourth division consisting solely of power schools and the inaugural playoff is nearly here, while the level of play has, if anything, risen this season. A delightful rivalry week from sunup to sundown (and well into the night) delivered as the exclamation point on a remarkable 2014. Once again we got shocking upsets and emotional finales, and for the first time this year, some clarity.

Fact: The four playoff contestants will hail from four different leagues (as they should). The SEC’s hopes of squeezing a second team into the final four disappeared with Mississippi State’s Egg Bowl loss, and for a moment it seemed Alabama would doom the conference by going down as well. Ah, but the Crimson Tide survived the Iron Bowl and advanced, saving the SEC’s bacon (sorry, Arkansas) for at least one more week. More on this in a moment.

Florida State, once again, was awful, this time gagging out a 24-19 victory over hapless Florida. Oregon dominated Oregon State, but now must face a familiar foe – Arizona – after the Wildcats won the Duel in the Desert and UCLA flopped in face-palmingly familiar fashion against Stanford. Georgia also went down to Georgia Tech, part of an ugly 0-4 weekend for the SEC against traditional ACC rivals, but fortunately Missouri secured the East to save the SEC from total embarrassment.

The reason those contests were significant is because of the danger they now pose to their respective conferences. The Pac-12 is relatively safe; if Oregon avenges its earlier loss, the Ducks are a shoo-in, while Arizona would have a very strong case for the playoff with a second UO upset. The SEC and ACC are in a much more precarious position. If ‘Bama loses to Missouri or FSU falls to Georgia Tech, the underdogs wouldn’t make the playoff. I think one of those scenarios is much more likely than the other, and ultimately I’ll pick both the Tide and Seminoles to win anyway. Still, we’re two weird upsets from an apocalyptic shakeup that would rattle the committee to its core.

But what of the fourth spot? This is where things get very interesting. If Baylor beats Kansas State the Bears will be the undisputed Big 12 champions, regardless of whatever silly language exists in the conference’s tiebreaking rules. An 11-1 Big 12 champ would be hard to deny. So would a 12-1 Big Ten champ, if Ohio State knocks off Wisconsin. The Big Ten is weaker than the Big 12, but it’s not that big a gap, and the extra win could boost the Buckeyes’ resume. Of course, that’s assuming the committee still gives OSU the benefit of the doubt after quarterback J.T. Barrett’s season-ending injury. Wacky scenarios abound.

There are quite a few good games this week outside of the conference championships. It’s a shame UCF – ECU doesn’t have American championship implications, because the Knights and Pirates are both good teams. Catch that one on Thursday, it’s the only thing on. Friday has the MAC title game rematch of Bowling Green – Northern Illinois and the Pac-12 Championship, which should be a barn-burner. More on that in the Pac-12 section.

Saturday brings the good stuff, like the Conference USA Championship (Louisiana Tech – Marshall), another solid AAC matchup with Houston – Cincinnati and potentially the game of the week when Kansas State meets Baylor. There’s also Alabama – Mizzou in the SEC Championship, Florida State – Georgia Tech in the ACC Championship and Wisconsin – Ohio State for the Big Ten title. Lots on the line. Should be great.

Playoff Poll

It’s gotten harder in some ways to separate clumps of teams, but there are couple of clear delineations that can be made. Oregon and Alabama are 1-2 in some order, FSU is third, and the rest is a mess.

College Football Playoff

1) Alabama vs. 4) Baylor
2) Oregon vs. 3) Florida State

Gave the Tide the nod this week, as beating Auburn is a more impressive feat than round-housing Oregon State, even if ‘Bama was on the ropes for three quarters against a team that finished .500 in conference play. Oregon sits above the ‘Noles, who looked awful again in victory over a bad team. Baylor holds onto the coveted four spot, pending a K-State win this week.

Second Tier

TCU
Ohio State

TCU is praying for KSU to knock off the Baylor team it should have beat. At 11-1 with a true conference title, the Horned Frogs would be in. Ohio State still has just the one loss, but now has a huge asterisk. How will the committee view the team without its QB? What if the Buckeyes struggle, but still win the Big Ten? I think they’re on the outside looking in unless there’s an upset.

Third Tier

Arizona

At two losses it didn’t feel right to include ‘Zona with TCU and OSU, but the opportunity is there. With a win this week the Wildcats would be 12-2, Pac-12 champs and hold wins over Oregon (twice), Utah and Arizona State, with both losses (USC and UCLA) pretty forgivable. It would probably take one more upset (like Georgia Tech over FSU), but don’t count this team out. They backdoored their way into the South title and can do it with the playoff, too.

Pac-12 Report

Well, then. After all the preseason speculation about USC and UCLA, whether ASU could stay relevant, whether Utah could ever become relevant… Arizona is the South winner. Congrats to the Wildcats. They earned it, beating Oregon in Eugene and taking out their rivals in the finale to reap the benefit of UCLA’s choke job. This is the worst matchup for UO in the conference (which I’ll get into momentarily) and ‘Zona had to survive a gauntlet to get here. Job well done.

Oregon took a slightly less perilous path to the North title, clinching with two weeks to spare thanks to minor collapses by Stanford and Washington, ostensibly the Ducks’ most formidable division foes. UO wrapped up a dominant seven-game stretch with a 28-point win over Oregon State where the only real concern was health going into the Arizona rematch. The chance for redemption is pretty appealing.

Arizona State has to be kicking itself after dropping not one but two chances to return to the Pac-12 Championship. The Oregon State loss hurt, but the Sun Devils got another shot when UCLA went down to Stanford. Instead, it was Arizona that took advantage. That has to hurt. UCLA is in much the same boat, as the Bruins completed a massively disappointing 9-3 campaign that bounced up and down and ultimately went as far as their overhyped QB could carry them. Which is to say, not very far. Kudos to Stanford for rebounding and ending the year on a strong note, though. The Cardinal beat two of their traditional rivals, Cal and UCLA, to end the year.

Cal’s loss to BYU was painful on both a personal level (the Bears really deserved a bowl bid) and a wide-ranging level (the Pac-12 could have used another postseason squad), but fortunately Utah avoided a major upset to Colorado and USC represented the league well by shredding Notre Dame. Washington also helped out by thrashing Washington State to reach eight wins again. The conference finished the year in strong position and managed to get its two best teams to the title game (something not every league did).

So… about that Wildcats – Ducks rematch. It’s certainly a good matchup and should make for a great game. As I said earlier in the year, Arizona presents a special challenge for Oregon. The ‘Cats unusual 3-3-5 stack defense, a RichRod staple since his time at West Virginia, is the worst possible formation for UO to attack. The weaknesses of the 3-3-5 are in its front; the lack of bulk with only three linemen and three linebackers is exploitable by offenses that can effectively power the ball downhill. That’s really not Oregon’s specialty, as the Ducks like to spread defenses out and run laterally – or at least semi-laterally – with the read option game.

Unfortunately for UO, that’s exactly what the 3-3-5 (essentially a “spread defense”) is designed to combat. By throwing an extra defensive back on the field, Arizona can match up speed with speed and run with the Ducks (pretty effectively, I might add) while forcing individual skill players to beat their man, bringing pressure from all angles all the while. It’s a funky, rarely seen base defense, which adds to the confusion offensive players feel when facing it. Blocking assignments shift, coverages look different and a small mistake can lead to a blown-up play. It’s really not surprising that, down four O-linemen, Oregon looked bad against this defense in October. For more information, here are some helpful links about the 3-3-5.

However, that’s just one side of the coin, and the other offense/defense matchup is just as important. To be frank, ‘Zona has bludgeoned UO with the run game the past two meetings, primarily through the same zone-read concepts Oregon has used for seven years. There’s no excuse for it; UA has simply won at the point of attack more often than not and allowed its talented ball-carriers to reach the second level unmolested. That has to change if Oregon wants to win this game. The Ducks are too talented to let the same thing happen three straight times.

If Oregon can in fact slow the run game and make the Wildcats one-dimensional, its odds of winning will improve dramatically. Anu Solomon has had an excellent freshman season for Arizona, but he is still a freshman and has made plays from time to time that show his age and inexperience. Without a running attack to lean on, his job will become much more difficult, and he’ll be more prone to mistakes and turnovers. Oregon needs to force Solomon into that kind of game to control how he plays. If ‘Zona starts rolling on the ground, he can pick the Ducks apart. To win this game, UO has to set the defensive tone early and establish that nothing will come easy for the Wildcats offense.

Who wins? Oregon seemed to have a “Stanford problem” for a while, now it appears to have an “Arizona problem.” Both opponents presented a bad matchup stylistically for the Ducks, for more or less opposite reasons. There’s a very good chance Arizona comes out and has a repeat of its performance earlier in the year. The Wildcats are good, fast and matchup well with UO, which has a lot of injuries and will be missing at least a couple of important parts. It’s a recipe for disaster for the Ducks.

However, I will stubbornly pick Oregon to win. It’s hard enough to beat a team twice in one season; it’s even harder when that team is demonstrably better than you. The Ducks are better than Arizona. That’s a fact. They’re more talented, more experienced and have possibly the best player in country on their side. UO will have a healthier offensive line in this meeting (does anyone think Hroniss Grasu really won’t play?) and should be able to run the ball more consistently inside, where the Wildcats are weakest. It’s the perfect redemption storyline and I think the Ducks will fight tooth and claw to achieve it and accomplish the goals that have eluded them the past two years.

Heisman Watch

Marcus Mariota, QB, Oregon

The Pac-12 single-season touchdown record, the career record (in three years) and just two interceptions. Barring a meltdown against Arizona, Mariota will win.

Melvin Gordon, RB, Wisconsin

Gordon can still break Barry Standers regular-season record (although that will probably be after the ceremony, as he needs about 400 yards). If he does it against Ohio State, this becomes interesting.

Random Thoughts and Observations

I’m not sure what the committee’s fascination is with TCU. The Horned Frogs are good, no doubt. But leaping to third over Florida State seems a step too far. TCU is not in the same category as Alabama and Oregon, and while the Frogs should have beat Baylor, they didn’t. The Bears hold that tiebreaker and there is absolutely no way TCU’s non-conference win over Minnesota makes up for that head-to-head result. We’ll see what happens this week, because if Baylor struggles with a Kansas State team TCU trounced, things become harder to dissect. As it stands right now, though, the Bears should definitely have the edge based on that win in October.

I understand that Alabama’s Amari Cooper has been outstanding this year, but the Heisman talk needs to go away. Voters are not going to give a receiver the award in 2014. It would take a record-breaking season, which, by the way, Cooper does not have. His numbers are comparable to Oregon State’s Brandin Cooks last year. Cooks won the Biletnikoff as the nation’s best WR, but he wasn’t remotely in the Heisman discussion, because that would have been ridiculous. What’s the difference with Cooper? That’s right, he plays for Alabama. Sorry, but it’s not happening. That doesn’t mean Cooper isn’t great and the best receiver in the country, but being the best player on a No. 1 team that just doesn’t have any other candidates isn’t enough.

Stanzi Watch

Double Stanzi! Western Kentucky’s Brandon Doughty threw two picks to go with his absurd eight TD’s, but was nearly eclipsed by Marshall’s Rakeem Cato, who had four interceptions and seven scores. What a game! We had another nine Stanzis this week, bringing the competition more or less to a close. But wait! Some of the winners this week had won previously, so the finalists have to be updated again. In the end, no one is catching Jameis Winston, though. The FSU QB incredibly picked up his fifth Stanzi of the season, blowing away all the competition. This award might need to be renamed. Here are this week’s winners and the finalists.

J.D. Sprague, Ohio
Opponent: Miami (OH)
Performance: Two INT, won by three

Tommy Armstrong, Jr., Nebraska
Opponent: Iowa
Performance: Two INT, won in overtime

Brandon Doughty, Western Kentucky
Opponent: Marshall
Performance: Two INT, won in OT

Justin Holman, UCF
Opponent: USF
Performance: One INT, one FUM, won by 16

Michael Brewer, Virginia Tech
Opponent: Virginia
Performance: One INT, one FUM, won by four

Jameis Winston, Florida State
Opponent: Florida
Performance: Four INT, won by five

Josh Dobbs, Tennessee
Opponent: Vanderbilt
Performance: Two INT, won by seven

Christian Stewart, BYU
Opponent: Cal
Performance: One INT, one FUM, won by seven

Brian Burrell, Fresno State
Opponent: Hawai’i
Performance: Two INT, won by seven

Jameis Winston, Florida State: 5
Logan Woodside, Toledo: 4
Everett Golson, Notre Dame: 3
Justin Holman, UCF: 3
Dak Prescott, Mississippi State: 2
James Knapke, Bowling Green: 2
Fredi Knighten, Arkansas State: 2
Christian Hackenberg, Penn State: 2
Anu Solomon, Arizona: 2
Brett Hundley, UCLA: 2
Grant Hedrick, Boise State: 2
Davis Webb, Texas Tech: 2
Nick Mullens, Southern Miss: 2
Cooper Rush, CMU: 2
C.J. Brown, Maryland: 2
Michael Brewer, Virginia Tech: 2
Brian Burell, Fresno State: 2
J.T. Barrett, Ohio State: 2

I don’t even know what to say at this point. 2014 has brought such an embarrassment of riches. I can’t wait to see what will happen in the final week of the season. There’s potential for so much more to come.

Wednesday, November 26, 2014

You can get anything you want

National Overview

This is it. The conference championships are still a week away, but there are several key rivalry games around Thanksgiving that might decide things a bit early. Or not. The fun started on Thursday in Week 13, when Kansas State added to the intrigue of this wild season by holding off West Virginia and North Carolina annihilated Duke, clinching the ACC Coastal for Georgia Tech.

Minnesota introduced a small measure of uncertainty to the Big Ten West by coming back to beat Nebraska, setting up a winner-takes-all match with Wisconsin next week in Madison for the right to take on Ohio State. The Buckeyes briefly looked as if they might lose to woeful Indiana, but survived and advanced yet again. Florida State did much the same, squeaking by Boston College on a late field goal.

Arizona moved a step closer toward real respectability by crushing Utah on the road, while Ole Miss dropped all pretense of any in a 30-0 loss at Arkansas. The only other ranked team to lose was USC, which came out curiously flat in the second half and got embarrassed by UCLA. More on this in the Pac-12 section.

Unfortunately, most of the top 10 was on some kind of break, so we were denied any real drama. That will change this week. Even the non-ranked matchups hold intrigue. Thanksgiving Day has LSU – Texas A&M and TCU – Texas (a massive upset alert for the Horned Frogs). Central Florida – South Florida is Friday, along with Stanford – UCLA, the Duel in the Desert (Arizona State – Arizona), Colorado State – Air Force and the Commonwealth Cup (Virginia – Virginia Tech).

Saturday? The Battle for the Palmetto State (South Carolina – Clemson). Clean, Old Fashioned Hate (Georgia Tech – Georgia). Kentucky – Louisville. Michigan – Ohio State. Purdue – Indiana. NC State – UNC. The Rumble in the Rockies (Utah – Colorado). Notre Dame – USC. The Egg Bowl (Mississippi State – Ole Miss). Florida – Florida State. The Battle for the Land Grant Trophy (Michigan State – Penn State). The Battle for Paul Bunyan’s Axe (Minnesota – Wisconsin). The Sunflower Showdown (Kansas – Kansas State). Tennessee – Vanderbilt. The Iron Bowl (Auburn – Alabama). The Civil War (Oregon – Oregon State). The Apple Cup (Washington – Washington State). The Battle for Nevada (Nevada – UNLV). This is the reason college football is better than the NFL.

Playoff Poll

Nothing happened to change the rankings from last week. If anything, Florida State’s newest near-loss provided even more proof the Seminoles are right where they should be.

College Football Playoff

1) Oregon vs. 4) Baylor
2) Alabama vs. 3) Florida State

Baylor doesn’t play Kansas State until next week, but I’m still giving the Bears the benefit of the doubt as a one-loss team. The top three are unchanged. Once again, Oregon has wins over No. 8, 10 and 25, with a loss to No. 11; Alabama has a win over No. 4 with a loss to No. 19, FSU has wins over No. 21 and 22. How exactly is Oregon’s resume not the strongest? Going by the committee’s own rankings, the Ducks should be first.

Second Tier

TCU
Mississippi State
Ohio State

I swapped the Bulldogs and Buckeyes based on the latter’s struggles with a terrible Indiana team. Really, OSU? TCU’s fourth-quarter defense against Baylor might cost the Horned Frogs a title shot, although that game with Texas this week might do them in anyway.

Third Tier

UCLA
Georgia

This is where things get iffy. Even if both schools win out it would take a lot of chaos ahead of them to justify a top-four spot. We’ll see what happens.

Pac-12 Report

The first full conference slate in three weeks didn’t disappoint. In the early game, Washington State raced out to a 21-7 second-quarter lead before Arizona State brought the full fury of the Fork down on the Cougars, outscoring WSU 31-0 in the second half until a touchdown with just 24 seconds left. The Sun Devils can still repeat as South champions, but will need UCLA to lose this week.

In contrast, Arizona wasted no time putting Utah’s faint South aspirations to bed, blasting the Utes 42-10 in Salt Lake City. The Wildcats also still have a shot at the Pac-12 Championship, but like their rivals will need UCLA to lose to get the opportunity. Poor Utah has improved by leaps and bounds since entering the league in 2011, but still looks doomed to suffer another 5-4 conference record.

Stanford showed some offensive ability against Cal, clinching a bowl bid as Pac-12 higher-ups exhaled in relief. It would not have been a good look had the defending conference champs failed to qualify for the postseason. The Bears dropped to 5-6 but can still make a bowl with a win this week. They deserve one, hopefully they’ll get it.

Oregon predictably routed Colorado in the Ducks’ home finale in a game that was probably more notable for being quarterback Marcus Mariota’s last appearance at Autzen. The Buffaloes have lost some of the promising fight they showed in the first half of the season, but that’s somewhat to be expected after a year full of woulda-shoulda-coulda games. CU is better than a two-win team, but couldn’t close against several conference foes.

Both of the night matchups proved to be slight duds. USC and UCLA battled to a draw midway through the second quarter and the contest appeared headed for a classic finish. Instead, the Bruins stepped up, the Trojans wilted and UCLA ran away with a three-score victory. If the Bruins can hold serve against Stanford, they’ll win their third division title in four years.

Oregon State was within striking distance for three quarters at Washington, but once again sputtered offensively with the game on the line. Credit the Huskies for taking control and reaching bowl eligibility before the Apple Cup, but the Beavers have been disappointing all season. OSU’s win over Arizona State now means nothing, unless the Civil War turns out a massive upset.

The Black Friday games are delightful and will decide the South winner. Arizona State and Arizona will meet in Tucson with identical 9-2 records with the division title on the line, pending the result of UCLA – Stanford. This is going to be a good one. ASU has been the better team much of the season, but the stumble in Corvallis gives me a lot more reason to pause. Arizona certainly didn’t look great against USC or UCLA, but the Wildcats have been a more consistent bet of late. The Sun Devils’ losses are actually worse – the blowout to UCLA was terrible, while their showing at OSU was awful – which makes me want to lean toward UA at home. However, the health of QB Anu Solomon is a problem. The freshman left the Utah game in the second quarter and didn’t return. With him, I think ‘Zona wins. Without, I’ll take ASU.

Stanford – UCLA should be a simple coronation for the Bruins as they move toward a rematch with Oregon. I can’t shake the memory of just how dominant Stanford was last year, though. This isn’t the same Cardinal team, but is UCLA really that good? The Bruins seem to have turned things around since the whipping at the hands of the Ducks, but it’s also possible the schedule just got a lot easier. In the end, Stanford’s utter ineptitude offensively makes this a no-brainer, but the fact that I even questioned the outcome is a bad sign for UCLA. I need to see something this game from the Bruins.

Utah should have little trouble beating Colorado to finish 8-4, which would be a nice accomplishment in the loaded South this season. It’s hard not to feel like it could have been even more, which has to sting a little, but a chance at a nine-win campaign shouldn’t be sneered at in Salt Lake City. As I said before, CU has improved so much, but the long year of near-upsets that just never materialized has to have had a demoralizing effect.

Notre Dame is at USC for a matchup I would have said the Trojans should win… until this week. The no-show in the second half at UCLA was troubling. Both teams are 7-4 and dealing with the disappointment of lowered expectations after starting the season strong. Will one side sleepwalk through this game? It wouldn’t shock me. For the Pac-12’s sake it’d be nice to see SC be SC again, but we’ll have to wait and find out. I’m worried about the mental makeup of this squad.

Cal can get back to the postseason with a win over BYU. At the beginning of the year that would have been outlandish, but the Cougars haven’t been the same team since losing QB Taysom Hill. Overall BYU is still quite talented and absolutely has the ability to come into Berkeley and win. I’m going to go with sentiment, though, and predict the Bears will come through to get their embattled program into a bowl again.

As with UCLA – Stanford, the Civil War should be little more than a walkthrough for the Ducks. However, that should have been the case last year, when the Beavers really had UO dead to rights in Autzen before giving up a last-second TD. The Ducks aren’t any better as a team this season and OSU always plays better in Corvallis. However, the Beavs are clearly a worse team in 2014 and have been wildly inconsistent week-to-week. It’s tough enough to trust them to make this a game, let alone pick the upset.

The same is true for Washington State, but at least the Cougars have the excuse of injuries. Crazy things have been known to happen on the Palouse and it wouldn’t be a total shock to see the Air Raid drop 500-plus through the air on the Huskies. Unfortunately, it’s also all too easy to imagine UW controlling the clock and forcing multiple turnovers in an ugly blowout. Washington seemed to get right with the OSU win last week and I expect they’ll continue that kind of play in the Apple Cup.

Heisman Watch

There’s no sense in messing around.

Marcus Mariota, QB, Oregon

Mariota is the national leader in several passing categories this season and currently holds the highest TD-to-interception ratio of any player in NCAA history. He’s the best QB in the country and helms the offense of a team that appears headed for the inaugural playoff. Sounds like a Heisman winner to me.

Melvin Gordon, RB, Wisconsin

In many seasons Gordon’s 2,000-plus rushing yards would be enough to make him the leader. In this Big Ten, with this competition, he might have to settle for second place. It’s also possible the preponderance of Wisconsin running backs putting up huge yards could cause voter fatigue.

Random Thoughts and Observations

Poor Melvin Gordon. After sitting out the fourth quarter last week with the new FBS rushing record in hand, the Wisconsin back had to watch as Oklahoma’s Samaje Perine broke the mark just six days later. The true freshman bowling ball (Perine is listed at a generous 5-11 and 243 pounds) went for 427 on his second play of the fourth, leaving Gordon with “only” a potential FBS season rushing record to strive for. Oh, well.

The two-man Heisman race has a very interesting subplot going on as we enter the final weeks of the season. Melvin Gordon has a real chance to break Barry Sanders’ single-season rushing record if he plays in the Big Ten Championship. That mark has always been viewed as untouchable, so it seems Gordon should be a shoo-in for the Heisman if he gets there. But Marcus Mariota of Oregon has been so impressive, as well as the national leader most of the season. Should Gordon pass him on the strength of his 408-yard performance against Nebraska?

The knock on Mariota is that Oregon’s system makes all QB’s look good. That is unquestionably true. From Dennis Dixon to Jeremiah Masoli to Darron Thomas, the up-tempo spread has worked wonders for the Ducks’ signal callers. Yet Mariota is unquestionably the most talented player Oregon has had at the position; and more importantly, what is Wisconsin’s offense, if not a RB-friendly system?

As this Rolling Stone article points out, Badgers backs have been putting up huge numbers for a long time, thanks to a tradition of developing massive, homegrown offensive linemen that pave the way for easy yards. Just as few UO passers have made much of an impact at the next level, few Wisconsin runners have accomplished much in the NFL. Look at the list of Badgers RB’s in the past 15 years. Ron Dayne. Michael Bennett. Anthony Davis. P.J. Hill. John Clay. Montee Ball. James White. I watched every one of those guys. They all put up great college numbers and did little in the pros.

The fairest way to look at it seems to be to acknowledge that both teams run offenses that maximize their players’ abilities; they simply choose to emphasize different positions. With that in mind, Mariota’s efficiency and Gordon’s productivity come from a similar place. Both players have had excellent seasons and will likely be in New York for the ceremony, but only one can win. Because QB is an inherently more valuable position than RB, the edge still goes to Mariota.

Stanzi Watch

I’m not really certain how it’s possible, but Old Dominion gave us two Stanzi winners this week in a three-point win over Louisiana Tech. Taylor Heinicke threw two picks along with his two TD’s, while apparent backup Jordan Glover contributed two picks in two attempts. Unfortunately there’s no detailed box score for the game, but as it stands Heinicke and Glover each earn a Stanzi. There was also a delightful Double Stanzi in the FIU – North Texas game, where the Panthers Alex McGough tossed three picks to the two of the Mean Green’s Andrew McNulty. UNT won 17-14. And look who’s back! Toledo’s Logan Woodside, who moved into a tie for the lead with his fourth Stanzi of the year. Here are this week’s winners and the finalists.

Logan Woodside, Toledo
Opponent: Bowling Green
Performance: Two INT, won by seven

J.T. Barrett, Ohio State
Opponent: Indiana
Performance: Two INT, won by 15

Taylor Heinicke, Old Dominion
Opponent: Louisiana Tech
Performance: Two INT, won by three

Jordan Glover, Old Dominion
Opponent: Louisiana Tech
Performance: Two INT, won by three

Zach Terrell, Western Michigan
Opponent: Central Michigan
Performance: Two INT, won by 12

Andrew McNulty, North Texas
Opponent: Florida International
Performance: Two INT, won by three

Patrick Mahomes, Texas Tech
Opponent: Iowa State
Performance: One INT, one FUM, won by three

Jameis Winston, Florida State: 4
Logan Woodside, Toledo: 4
Everett Golson, Notre Dame: 3
Justin Holman, UCF: 2
Dak Prescott, Mississippi State: 2
James Knapke, Bowling Green: 2
Fredi Knighten, Arkansas State: 2
Christian Hackenberg, Penn State: 2
Anu Solomon, Arizona: 2
Brett Hundley, UCLA: 2
Grant Hedrick, Boise State: 2
Davis Webb, Texas Tech: 2
Nick Mullens, Southern Miss: 2
Cooper Rush, CMU: 2
C.J. Brown, Maryland: 2
J.T. Barrett, Ohio State: 2

I never would have imagined we’d have 16 finalists. What a season it’s been! From the mountains, to the valleys, this game was made for you and me.

Friday, November 21, 2014

Darkness Approaches

National Overview

Could this season be any more 2007? The last year of true chaos saw a top-five team lose to an unranked opponent 13 times and the No. 2 team in the nation lose seven times as the BCS crowned its first (and only) multiple-loss champion in 11-2 LSU. It was an insane, wonderful ride (as long as you weren’t an Oregon or Ohio State fan). 2014 is shaping up to be the closest imitation of that wacky season we’ve had since, and I’m excited to see what things will look like when the dust settles.

The biggest reason for the 2007 parallels is parity. There was no truly great team in 2007; even LSU fans would probably say they revere the 2003 BCC championship team or the 2011 squad that lost to Alabama in the Rematch of Death more than the flawed ’07 group. We’re at the point now where we can safely say the same about 2014 – although I’ve been saying it for months – that there simply isn’t a truly elite, dominant team. The standings in the SEC West and Pac-12 South reflect that.

Alabama took down Mississippi State in Tuscaloosa, because MSU was clearly not that good and the Crimson Tide are much better. The Ole Miss loss still looks bad, but ‘Bama is slowly rounding into top form once again. That’s bad news for the rest of the country. The good news is that this Tide squad, even at its best, can’t compare to the juggernaut teams of 2009, 2011 and 2012. There’s still a possibility ‘Bama could get knocked off by another good team.

The shocker of the week was Arizona State losing in wintry conditions in Corvallis. Strangely, even though I predicted ASU would win handily, I had a last-second change of heart about the game that I dismissed as foolish. Ah, to have the benefit of hindsight! It makes sense that the Sun Devils, a warm-weather squad that had played above its ability for a month, would have a comedown game in a contest played on the road, at night, in the cold and swirling wind. Oh well. Oregon is now the Obi-Wan Kenobi of the Pac-12.

Ohio State survived in even worse conditions, winning in a minor snowstorm at Minnesota in a game that really shouldn’t have been as close as it was. The Buckeyes will move up thanks to ASU’s stumble, but are probably still on the outside looking in to the playoff until one more contender falls. OSU has certainly improved since that awful Virginia Tech game, though.

TCU very nearly provided a more terrible collapse than ASU, squeaking by Kansas thanks to a punt return touchdown. Even the close win over the Jayhawks, one of the worst teams in the nation, will probably be enough to hurt the Horned Frogs’ playoff chances. Fortunately for TCU, Baylor was idle, but if the Bears can beat Kansas State it’s only a matter of time before they’ll pass the Horned Frogs.

Wisconsin quite literally trampled Nebraska, as running back Melvin Gordon set a new NCAA Division I record with 408 yards on the ground. Gordon is now impossible to ignore as a Heisman candidate and Wisconsin looks to be the favorite in the Big Ten West. At the very least the Badgers could prove a decent opponent for Ohio State in the championship game. Lord knows the conference needs one.

Georgia also officially eliminated Auburn with a 34-7 trouncing that really wasn’t even as bad as it could have been. The Bulldogs finally got Todd Gurley back, only to see the star running back tear an ACL in the second half. UGA would need a significant amount of help to get into the playoff and losing Gurley is the wrong way to start. Auburn, on the other hand, can only hope to ruin Alabama’s season.

It’s rivalry week! Or at least, rivalry week part one. Since the college football season has been extended so far into November, the original year-ending “rivalry week” has been split across the final two weeks of the season, and in a few cases, the final three. It’s not the worst thing to happen, as it allows for more of these wonderful ancient hatreds to be televised in all their glory. This week, we get North Carolina at Duke (Thursday), Stanford – Cal, USC – UCLA and Syracuse at Pittsburgh. Let us not speak of the SEC, where five teams will host FCS schools in a disgusting and brazen attempt to game the system.

Playoff Poll

This is the toughest decision yet. Alabama, Oregon and Florida State are the top three. But in what order? Does FSU’s unblemished record hold the most weight? The Crimson Tide’s superior conference? Oregon’s superior wins? Here’s how I see this:

If Florida State was third last week behind Oregon, did the Seminoles do enough against Miami (FL) while UO was idle to jump the Ducks? The answer is an emphatic “no.” If anything, FSU’s umpteenth great escape showed why voters (and the committee) have soured on the Seminoles. But should Oregon be rewarded for not playing? That’s the kind of faulty logic that tainted the polls for decades. Alabama notched a great win against a very good, if clearly inferior, Mississippi State team. Is that one good win enough to boost the Tide three spots?

College Football Playoff

1) Oregon vs. 4) Baylor
2) Alabama vs. 3) Florida State

Using this week’s committee rankings to compare schedules is the most logical way to break things down. The ranking a team has when it loses has no relevance; many, many teams are vastly overrated and get exposed. This is how the resumes of the top three compare:

Oregon has wins over No. 11 Michigan State (home), No. 9 UCLA (away) and No. 17 Utah (away), none by fewer than 12 points, with a loss to No. 15 Arizona (home)
Alabama has a single win over a top 25 team: No. 4 Mississippi State (home), with a loss to No. 8 Ole Miss (away)
Florida State has wins over No. 22 Clemson (home) and No. 24 Louisville (away) and no losses (though it’s worth noting neither the Tigers or Cardinals are ranked in either traditional poll)

Which overall body of work is the strongest? It’s rather easy to tell. Baylor slips into my top four because of TCU’s struggles with Kansas (ugh) and the expectation that the Bears will win the Big 12.

Second Tier

TCU
Ohio State
Mississippi State

TCU is in trouble if it can’t impress people more in the next two games. Ohio State shouldn’t really have a shot because the Big Ten is terrible, but there’s definitely some building sentiment for the Buckeyes. Mississippi State certainly isn’t out of it, but the Cinderella magic seemed to dry up against a much better Alabama squad.

Third Tier

Nobody.

There isn’t anyone else remotely deserving of being included in the playoff conversation right now. A couple teams could make a case with a strong closing kick, but I doubt anyone other than the teams listed about will be taking part.

Pac-12 Report

Thank goodness for Arizona and Utah. The Pac-12 took a giant hit when Arizona State flopped at Oregon State. It would have been catastrophic had three ranked teams gone down. Instead, thanks to clutch late-game play from the Wildcats and Utes, five conference members sit in the AP top 25 this week. I already covered the ASU – OSU game earlier, but suffice it to say that was the other shoe dropping for the Sun Devils. ASU had miraculously covered all its deficiencies for three-quarters of the season and finally had that killer misstep. The win could save the Beavers’ season, provided they can get one more at Washington this week to become bowl-eligible.

Cal at USC Thursday night was an odd one. The Trojans dominated the first half, but never really seemed to be knocking out the Bears. Sure, there were a whole lot of passing yards, but everyone throws it on Cal. SC never got the ground game going, and it showed in the final margin. Cal isn’t terrible enough anymore to be beaten by three-quarters of a good game. It was an expected loss, but the signs still seem to point to the Bears getting that all-important sixth win in one of the last two games. More on this in a moment.

Washington, Washington. So close. The Huskies are 6-5 with the two games left and are possibly the most average team I’ve ever seen. The offense has been below-average, the defense above-average, and the team overall has no players anywhere that scare anybody. Another seven-win season, anyone? Yeesh. At least Sark is gone. Arizona, on the other hand, continues to improve under RichRod and is now 8-2 (albeit with two tough games left). The South is still up for grabs, people.

Utah – Stanford was a matchup to tell your grandchildren about – if you want them to have nightmares. The game featured no scoring for the final 36 minutes and less than 550 yards of combined offense despite going into double-overtime and having a single turnover. Dear lord. Thankfully for the Pac-12, Utah survived, setting up a nice elimination showdown with Arizona this week. As for the Cardinal, well, it’s not looking too good.

Speaking of Stanford… I’ve been wondering if/when Cal could get that sixth win. Could it come against Stanford? I would have dismissed the notion as absurd as recently as two weeks ago, but now I’m less sure. The Cardinal have been awful offensively and the once-stout defense now looks more like above-average. It’s not as if Cal can’t move the ball on pretty much anybody. What’s more, both teams sit at 5-5, the game will determine which finishes higher in the North AND it’s in Berkeley. There’s a lot pointing toward a Bears win. I would think (hope?) Stanford’s D would ultimately save the day, but I’m certainly not sure about it.

Another thing I’m not sure about: the quality (or lack thereof) of Oregon State and Washington. The Beavers are in Seattle this week for a titanic struggle between teams with identical 2-5 conference records. It’s another late game and the weather in the Pacific Northwest promises to be appropriately cold and wet. Do the Beavs have another win in them? They’ll probably need it heading into the Civil War. The Huskies can also claim a bowl spot with a win in either of their last two games, but UW’s finale is the considerably easier Apple Cup. As bad as OSU has been at times this season, I think they get the win this week thanks to a much-needed confidence boost at the expense of ASU.

The Sun Devils host Washington State in a contest that should be no big deal, but then again, that’s what everyone thought last week. The circumstances are different here, though. ASU is much better at home and won’t have to battle the elements and a late start like in Corvallis. I fully expect the Sun Devils to run the Cougars’ defense ragged and get more than enough stops for a comfortable win.

Colorado – Oregon is the biggest mismatch of the day, pitting possibly the conference’s worst team against its standard-bearer. We know the drill here. UO runs up a ridiculous score, pulls its starters in the third quarter and coasts from there. At least, that’s what should happen. The Pac-12 has gotten a little crazy this year. Anything less than total dominance would be a surprise, though.

A pair of big South matchups headline the weekend. First up is Arizona at Utah, a game both teams must have to stay alive in the division race. The Wildcats have the better offense, the Utes the superior D. I like what Utah has done this year a lot and Rice-Eccles is a tough place to play… but I think ‘Zona is just the better team. It could go either way. I’ll take UA in a relatively close one because of the ‘Cats’ ability to consistently generate offense.

The delightful primetime matchup is USC at UCLA in a rivalry that’s finally started to heat up again after a decade-plus of mediocrity. As with the Arizona – Utah tilt, the loser is out of the South race. I’ve been down on the Bruins all year, but they seem to be rounding into form late in the season. SC has looked fantastic at times and awful at others. What to make of this game? UCLA is at home, but neither the Rose Bowl nor the Coliseum really provide that much of an advantage. I’m taking the team with the better quarterback… USC’s Cody Kessler.

Heisman Watch

Let’s be real. Dak Prescott is out. Ameer Abdullah, out. This is a two-man race.

Marcus Mariota, QB, Oregon

Mariota is still the front-runner, leading the nation in several passing categories. The award is his to lose.

Melvin Gordon, RB, Wisconsin

Gordon made this interesting by setting a new FBS record for single-game rushing yards, but he still needs to make up ground after going under the radar most of the season.

Stanzi Watch

Two more players joined the finalists, but it was an otherwise uneventful week. There are only a few games remaining. Can anyone catch Jameis Winston? Here are this week’s winners and the short list.

Blake Frohnapfel, Massachussetts
Opponent: Ball State
Performance: Two INT, won by 14

Cooper Rush, Central Michigan
Opponent: Miami (OH)
Performance: One INT, one FUM, won by seven

Trevor Simian, Northwestern
Opponent: Notre Dame
Performance: Two INT, won in OT

Cody Thomas, Oklahoma
Opponent: Texas Tech
Performance: Three INT, won by 12

Anu Solomon, Arizona
Opponent: Washington
Performance: Two INT, won by one

Grant Hedrick, Boise State
Opponent: San Diego State
Performance: Two INT, won by nine

Sean Mannion, Oregon State
Opponent: Arizona State
Performance: One INT, one FUM, won by eight

Jameis Winston, Florida State: 4
Everett Golson, Notre Dame: 3
Logan Woodside, Toledo: 3
Justin Holman, UCF: 2
Dak Prescott, Mississippi State: 2
James Knapke, Bowling Green: 2
Fredi Knighten, Arkansas State: 2
Christian Hackenberg, Penn State: 2
Anu Solomon, Arizona: 2
Brett Hundley, UCLA: 2
Grant Hedrick, Boise State: 2
Davis Webb, Texas Tech: 2
Nick Mullens, Southern Miss: 2
Cooper Rush, CMU: 2
C.J. Brown, Maryland: 2

The rivalries are upon us! Let the games begin!