Thursday, November 13, 2014

The Week of Truth

National Overview

That… was delightful. 2014 took another turn for the bizarre when Auburn, Team of DestinyTM, got a taste of its own medicine against Texas A&M, going down in a heap of fumbles and ineptitude. LSU very nearly ensured the SEC would only have one playoff entrant, only to leave the door open enough for Alabama to escape. Oregon presumably cleared its final regular-season hurdle, while Arizona State took a major step toward the playoff by ethering Notre Dame.

But the big noise came on Tuesday, when the playoff committee’s new rankings had… Oregon at No. 2, ahead of defending champion Florida State. TCU was also in for the time being, ahead of No. 5 Alabama. Gasp! While this makes for exciting TV, it’s also the right call to make at this point in the season for many reasons. More on this later.

Baylor is currently out of the playoff much to the chagrin of Bears fans. However, Baylor was probably the biggest winner of the weekend other than ASU. By blasting Oklahoma, the Bears eliminated potentially the biggest threat left on their schedule, with a home finale against Kansas State left to boost the resume. Baylor fans shouldn’t fret about being ranked behind the TCU squad their team beat; if the Bears win out, they’ll leap the Horned Frogs based on the head-to-head result. Count on it.

Speaking of TCU, it’s obvious why the Horned Frogs have the edge on the Bears right now. First, TCU’s loss was earlier, thus affording the team more time to make up ground. Second and more importantly, TCU has unquestionably played the more difficult schedule to this point. The Horned Frogs and Baylor both beat Oklahoma, while TCU beat West Virginia and the Bears lost to the Mountaineers. However, the clincher in TCU’s favor – for the moment – is the remainder of the schedule. TCU just dominated Kansas State AND crushed a decent Minnesota team out of conference, while Baylor had three mid-major cupcakes and has yet to play the Wildcats. Like I said, if both teams win out, the Bears will get the nod. But they have to actually do it first.

Ohio State’s victory over Michigan State should end any chance the Big Ten has of getting a team into the playoff. I say “should” because there’s already a minority group touting the Buckeyes as potential 12-1 conference champs deserving of an invite. However, there’s a lot of ball left to be played, and I still lean toward the Big Ten getting the cold shoulder when everything is said and done. While the win over the Spartans was impressive, MSU’s earlier (and worse) loss to Oregon hurts the Buckeyes significantly, as does the fact that OSU’s loss is to 4-5 Virginia Tech. It’s hard to see the committee taking a team who A) plays in a league as weak as the 2014 Big Ten and B) lost to a team with a losing record.

But I’m getting ahead of myself. There’s still loads more football to be played in the regular season, and I have a feeling things will sort themselves out. This week, there’s a whole lot of mid-major garbage during the week, then the good stuff. Ohio State is at Minnesota (who entered the standings at 25th this week), but don’t get your hopes up. Clemson and Georgia Tech, which are surprisingly both ranked, will battle in Atlanta.

Nebraska is at Wisconsin in a game the Big Ten desperately needs the Cornhuskers to win: with one loss, Nebraska could set up as the perfect foil for an Ohio State team on the playoff bubble. There’s also Auburn – Georgia, which has some potential, and FSU at Miami (FL), which has slightly less. Of course, the big one is in Tuscaloosa, where No. 5 Alabama welcomes top-ranked Mississippi State. We’re about to find out just how legit the Bulldogs are.

Playoff Poll

College Football Playoff

1) Mississippi State vs. 2) Oregon
3) Florida State vs. 4) TCU

I agree with the committee. I had the Seminoles first last week, but after another mediocre performance moved FSU back down, this time below an Oregon team that owns three better wins (Michigan State, UCLA, Utah) better than any the ‘Noles can boast. TCU, as I explained earlier, might be on borrowed time, but the win over K-State has to be rewarded.

Second Tier

Baylor
Alabama
Arizona State

Baylor rockets to the top of the “looking-in” list with a thrashing of Oklahoma. Alabama beat LSU, but I don’t think LSU is very good, so the Crimson Tide will have to wait until they beat Mississippi State this week to move up. ASU was off my radar for a while but leapt right back into the fray with a scary-good win over Notre Dame (a result that also factored into FSU’s drop).

Third Tier

Ohio State
Auburn

Does anyone really even belong in this conversation? OSU is the nominal third-tier favorite, but a lot has to go right for the Buckeyes to have a chance. Auburn is likely out after the A&M loss, but a 10-2 SEC West team could possibly have a case if, again, things break just right. We’ll see.

Pac-12 Report

Let’s start with the most important one. Arizona State, in one of the biggest games in school history, absolutely demolished a highly-regarded Notre Dame team hoping for an outside shot at the national championship. The turnovers helped, certainly, and ASU can’t expect that kind of luck every week. Just as in the similar game against UCLA the Sun Devils lost, though, at some point teams make their own luck. Credit ASU for forcing the Fighting Irish into mistakes, capitalizing with big plays and putting Notre Dame away when it came down to crunch time. Just a very, very big win for the program and the league.

Oregon’s 24-point win at Utah doesn’t tell the whole story, as any Utes fan will surely lament. Utah had the Ducks on the ropes early, forced two turnovers on downs and should have been up 14-0 in the second quarter… until Kaelin Clay happened. The play has been replayed over and over to the point it hardly seems worthwhile to recap it, but rest assured it will live in infamy. Dropping the ball before crossing the goal line has hurt teams before – it happened to Oregon this season against South Dakota, which could be why the Ducks were alert – but never quite in this fashion. The massive momentum shift propelled UO to a 24-7 lead, and when the Utes finally crept back into contention, Marcus Mariota buried them. It was in some ways a fortunate win, but as with ASU, credit has to go to the team that makes fewer mistakes. Oregon is now assured of a spot in the Pac-12 title game.

UCLA at Washington was a game I looked forward to before the season, but the teams’ play so far predicted a somewhat less-than-competitive matchup on Saturday. UW did a nice job hanging in there, but it’s clear this Huskies squad has some issues beyond just a bad offense. The Bruins, once left for dead, are still alive for the South title. It remains to be seen how realistic that goal is, but after the ugly way this campaign started 10-2 would be a nice accomplishment.

Washington State at Oregon State was the bad one. The Beavers seemingly had everything in their favor: home field, reason to play angry after a string of losses, a freshman quarterback making his first start. None of it mattered, as WSU took control in the second half and nabbed just its third victory all year. OSU looks done; needing two wins against the combination of Arizona State, Washington and Oregon is a tall order, and nothing the Beavers have shown recently evokes any optimism. The “Fire Mike Riley” brigade is back and getting louder. That’s not the best option for this team, but there are obviously some major problems at OSU.

Colorado – Arizona was the last game on the list. As they have all season, the Buffaloes battled bravely… yet as they have all season, they lost again. The parallels to WSU a few years ago are strong – CU has to go from “laughingstock” to “mediocre” before becoming “good” – but it’s tough to see a team work so hard and achieve so little in the win column. Arizona survived and advanced with reasonable comfort and still has a shot to win the South, like almost everyone.

There are a surprising four teams off this week, so the slate is a little lighter. Cal is at USC for a Thursday matchup that could prove interesting if the Trojans don’t take it seriously. You’d expect SC to be able to bludgeon the Bears with a powerful run-pass combo and overwhelm the visitors with superior athletes, but Cal has shown it can score with anyone. The last thing the Trojans need is to get into a four-quarter shootout with a team seeking a crucial sixth win. I like USC, but beware.

The weekend pairings begin with Washington – Arizona, a matchup that, like many the Huskies have played, looked better at the start of the year. ‘Zona could get caught looking ahead to Utah but is the better team overall; barring an offensive meltdown against a talented but beleaguered D, the Wildcats should win. There is a scenario in which UW squeezes just enough out of Shaq Thompson on offense to take a slugfest, but you’d hope for the conference’s sake the ‘Cats don’t let that happen. At home, this is UA’s to lose.

Utah at Stanford is an intriguing game for the similar styles the teams play and the fact that the Utes upset the Cardinal last year. Utah has clearly been the better side this season, but things like that can get lost in the struggle of a 6-3 field goal battle. Both teams feature excellent defenses and offenses that dream of one day being pedestrian, so it wouldn’t shock me to see Stanford pull this out. Games like this are what the Cardinal are built for, games they’ve usually won over the past several years. Utah had better not look ahead to Arizona.

Finally, unfortunately, we have Arizona State – Oregon State. Frankly, I don’t see things improving for the Beavers. ASU is on a roll right now and knows the stakes here, while OSU has been inept offensively much of the season and has little hope of matching the Sun Devils in a shootout. The defense that buoyed OSU to a 4-0 start has also broken down (not unlike Washington’s), which makes this one pretty easy to pick. ASU should win comfortably.

Heisman Watch

There’s very, very little to say on the matter.

Marcus Mariota, QB, Oregon

Mariota has been the best player in the country by a wide margin. Barring a meltdown in the final two games or an injury (gods forbid), the award is his.

Dak Prescott, QB, Missisippi State

This is Dak’s moment. Run and pass all over Alabama, and the Bulldogs’ signal-caller has a shot. But it’s going to take quite a performance.

Random Thoughts and Observations

It’s hard to argue the advent of the College Football Playoff hasn’t increased interest in the sport – in a good way. While the BCS erroneously and inexplicably touted its controversial nature as a positive, the playoff debate has done nothing but improve the national conversation about what matters and what doesn’t for a team’s resume.

Take the committee’s new rankings, featuring one-loss Oregon at No. 2 and undefeated Florida State No. 3, with TCU ahead of Alabama at No. 4. In the poll/BCS era, this would have been unthinkable. No power conference team ever got jumped without a loss, barring highly unusual circumstances. The old, flawed line of reasoning was that since a team had accomplished something in its previous games, poor performances in victory had to be excused. That doesn’t make sense for multiple reasons.

College football teams play highly uneven schedules. Unlike in the NFL, where every team plays eight home and away games, including its entire division twice, college teams generally host seven to eight games per year. Powerhouse programs routinely schedule all of their non-conference games at home against mid-majors and FCS schools, a practice the playoff is designed to stamp out. Because of this, teams can go long stretches (in some cases, entire seasons) without facing an equal or near-equal opponent.

Additionally, teams change over the course of a season. Injuries, slumps, emerging players and the unpredictable schedules can make squads look invincible one week, then awful the next. The only way to properly rate teams is to evaluate them, from scratch, every week. That’s what the committee claims it has been doing, which is reflected in the current standings. Oregon is ahead of Florida State because:

Oregon has played a significantly tougher schedule than FSU
            The Seminoles’ best win (Notre Dame) just took a massive credibility hit
            FSU has played average in recent weeks, while UO has notably improved

All this means is the committee has been watching the same football as everyone else. FSU hasn’t looked good lately. Why should they deserve to retain a ranking that doesn’t reflect their current level of play? This is good for the sport. If Florida State wins out, it will be in the playoff. But the Seminoles are going to be forced to prove it in their upcoming games, which is how things should work when only four playoff spots are available.

Stanzi Watch

It was another small group of winners this week, but what these players lacked in quantity they made up for in name value. Yes, let us welcome back 2013 Stanzi winner Devin Gardner of Michigan! Gardner has sadly been absent on the Stanzi Watch list until now because the Wolverines are so bad this year, but at least he deigned us with his presence once this fair season. Hats off to you, Devin. We missed you.

The more relevant name this week? Jameis Winston. The Seminoles QB picked up his astounding fourth Stanzi of the year, all but assuring himself of a season victory. It would take a truly remarkable comeback to stop him now. However, I do worry about the validity of the award when performances like the one Notre Dame’s Everett Golson turned in don’t make the cut. Golson had a true Stanzi-esque outing against Arizona State with four picks and a fumble, but he Stanzied so hard he actually Stanzied himself out of Stanzi range, as the Sun Devils won by 24. Hmmm. Perhaps a special recognition is in store for Mr. Golson. Here are this week’s winners and the finalists.

Drew Hare, Northern Illinois
Opponent: Ball State
Performance: Two FUM, won by 14

Christian Hackenberg, Penn State
Opponent: Indiana
Performance: Two INT, won by six

Devin Gardner, Michigan
Opponent: Northwestern
Performance: Two INT, won by one

Jameis Winston, Florida State
Opponent: Virginia
Performance: Two INT, won by 14

Jameis Winston, Florida State: 4
Everett Golson, Notre Dame: 3
Logan Woodside, Toledo: 3
Justin Holman, UCF: 2
Dak Prescott, Mississippi State: 2
James Knapke, Bowling Green: 2
Fredi Knighten, Arkansas State: 2
Christian Hackenberg, Penn State: 2
Brett Hundley, UCLA: 2
Davis Webb, Texas Tech: 2
Nick Mullens, Southern Miss: 2
C.J. Brown, Maryland: 2

This is the end. Rivalry Week, part one, is next Saturday. We've come down to crunch time and there's no going back. Au revoir, Michigan State, Kansas State and Ole Miss. Your exclusion from the playoff doesn't mean you won't be in our hearts.

Thursday, November 6, 2014

Something has started today

National Overview

Ah, another full platter of drama and intrigue. What a season this is becoming. From Florida State’s narrow escape Thursday night to Arizona State’s late Saturday, Week 10 provided all the thrills, heartbreak and general insanity we’ve come to expect from 2014. Six ranked teams lost, including presumed Group of 5 leader East Carolina. Ole Miss and Georgia saw their conference title and playoff dreams go on life support, while UCLA revived its season with a huge win over Arizona.

West Virginia very nearly doomed the Big 12 with an upset of TCU, but the Mountaineers fell apart in the second half in a flurry of turnovers and timid play calls. The Horned Frogs probably shouldn’t have survived, but lived to fight another week – this week, as a matter of fact. Kansas State, the last undefeated team in league play, visits Fort Worth this Saturday with first place in the Big 12 on the line. Baylor could still take the conference by winning out, but this game has the feeling of a heavyweight bout.

Oregon moved within one game of clinching the Pac-12 North by exorcising a few Stanford demons, thanks to tiebreakers over the Cardinal and Washington. The South got a lot more interesting when co-leader Arizona went down and ASU held off Utah in overtime. More on that later, but it seems possible the last few weeks in that division could be absolutely wild. Of course, nothing matches the sheer silliness of the SEC East.

The SEC West has too many good teams. This is not up for debate. When LSU is the third-best team in the division, you know things are rough. That’s good for the SEC, because the East doesn’t have a single good team. Toss aside Georgia’s No. 17 ranking. The Bulldogs aren’t good – they have zero wins over anyone of quality and proved to be frauds by getting slammed by a terrible Florida team. Now UGA, Florida and Missouri will duke it out (no Blue Devils) in a terribly depressing battle for the right to get annihilated by the West champion. Why can’t the two best teams from entire league play?

Mississippi State and Auburn could lay claim to those designations, though we won’t know for sure until the next few weeks play out. Auburn got yet another obscenely lucky break to beat Ole Miss and is still very much alive for the playoff, while MSU snuck by another bad team (Arkansas) and managed to stay No. 1. The fall is clearly coming for the Bulldogs, who needed an onside kick touchdown last week to escape lowly Kentucky. In two weeks MSU travels to Tuscaloosa, where it’s likely the charmed ride will end.

This week: we’ve got some good ones. Two huge Big 12 showdowns loom, with Baylor at Oklahoma and Kansas State – TCU. There are also two big games involving Pac-12 teams – Oregon at Utah and Notre Dame at ASU – along with the Alabama – LSU rivalry and Ohio State travelling to Michigan State. You know it’s not football season until the MAC starts playing on Tuesday… and we’ve reached that delightful point.

Playoff Poll

For at least one week, we have absolute clarity. The Kansas State – TCU game could serve as an elimination game, while Oregon faces its last real challenge of the regular season at Utah. The intrigue actually comes from the forgotten Big Ten, where Ohio State is at Michigan State in a game that will determine a division champion and potentially serve up a backup playoff contender if chaos unfolds in the SEC.

College Football Playoff

1) Florida State vs. 4) TCU
2) Mississippi State vs. 3) Oregon

I jumped FSU up because the Bulldogs have performed so poorly the past two weeks. I can’t shake the feeling that MSU is going to lose to Alabama. Oregon and TCU are next up, but Auburn is lurking right behind the Horned Frogs.

Second Tier

Auburn
Michigan State
Alabama

Auburn shouldn’t have beaten Ole Miss, but what else is new for the most fortunate team in the country? The Tigers get slumping Texas A&M this week, but must travel to Georgia and Alabama in the final three games. Michigan State could move up with a big win against Ohio State, while Alabama needs to make a statement at LSU.

Third Tier

Kansas State
Baylor
Notre Dame

Kansas State has been under the radar but could take a huge step forward by knocking off TCU this week. Baylor has been counted out since the West Virginia game but still has just one loss, while Notre Dame slides a little based on a weak performance versus Navy.

Pac-12 Report

Midway through the second quarter, with Washington trailing Colorado by double digits, things looked grim for the Huskies. For all the talk about tempered expectations in the first year of a new regime, there’s no denying UW has talent. Falling to the winless (in conference) Buffaloes would have been devastating. Fortunately, Washington got a TD before the break, then benefitted from an avalanche of CU turnovers in the second half to move to 6-3. As the Huskies play 13 regular-season games this year, they need seven wins for bowl eligibility. Sitting at 5-4 with UCLA and Arizona next on the schedule would have been dicey. For Colorado, it’s yet another heartbreaker in a season full of near-misses.

USC beat up Washington State and knocked out QB Connor Halliday with a broken ankle. It’s a sad ending to the career of one of the Cougars’ all-time prolific passers (and they’ve had a few), but in the long run the result will probably help the Pac-12. As I’ve written previously, having a couple of patsies for the rest of the league to pick up an automatic win is vital – it’s what’s sustained the SEC’s dominant run. With the win, SC stayed alive for the South title, creating a five-team logjam in the division that will take another month to sort out. WSU has to look to the future, which may not be a bad thing given how poorly this campaign has played out.

Oregon thrashed Stanford just like the old days, effectively ending any doubt about who will win the North. Only Washington and Stanford are still alive and the Ducks have wins over both. Now the focus for UO is Utah, which should be the last competitive game this team has in the regular season (Colorado and Oregon State remain). Should Oregon win, it would further the notion that great defenses aren’t kryptonite to this offense, making the Ducks more attractive to the playoff committee. Lose, and any shot at a national championship is gone.

Oregon State fell at home to Cal, a result I grimly predicted. The Beavers are now 4-4, in fifth place in the North and in very real danger of missing out on the postseason. Arizona State and Oregon are almost certainly losses, which makes the games against the Washington schools must-wins. WSU this week is doable – the Cougars will be breaking in a new QB – but on the road at Washington is tough. UW is a better team than OSU. Cal, on the other hand, got a huge break by playing BYU at the end of the season rather than the start, as the Cougars haven’t been the same since losing quarterback Taysom Hill. With USC and Stanford left on the docket, the Bears will likely need that game to hit the magic win total of six.

It seemed as if Arizona probably got too much credit for what’s looking more and more like a fluke upset of Oregon, but Saturday’s 17-7 defeat at the hands of UCLA was a puzzler. ‘Zona played unquestionably its worst game of the season against the most mercurial team in the conference, ceding control of the South in the process. Give credit to the Bruins for (maybe) turning their season around, sure. I just don’t know if the Wildcats are that good. They’ll beat Colorado and Washington, but the last two games (Utah and ASU) are doozies. At 7-2, UCLA has actually weathered the “overrated” storm pretty well. Although none of the final three (Washington, USC and Stanford) are gimmes, a 10-win finish isn’t as preposterous as it seemed a couple weeks back.

And of course, there was Utah – ASU. In a near-perfect matchup of good offense vs. good defense and average offense vs. average defense, the Utes’ style prevailed. It was a low-scoring, contained affair, exactly as Utah would have wanted. Unfortunately, the Sun Devils won the game. Oh, how much might that loss to WSU hurt the Utes? We’re about to find out, as Oregon rolls into town this week. ASU, on the other hand, has to feel pretty good about things. With wins over the two most talented defenses in the conference in hand, the Sun Devils have just one game remaining against a good Pac-12 team. Now, Notre Dame comes to town this week, which is a different story. We’ll see just how good this squad is against the Irish.

Two huge contests loom this weekend, as the division leaders take the field for games that could decide their postseason fates. Oregon is at Utah in the Ducks last legitimate regular-season hurdle, while ASU hosts Notre Dame in an attempt to give the Pac-12 some clout AND knock the Irish out of playoff contention. UO should win. The Utes’ anemic offense shouldn’t be able to move the ball consistently enough to keep up, even against a D as spotty as Oregon’s. If Utah can make it a slugfest, though, anything is possible. ASU faces a stiffer challenge, but has the weapons to beat ND as long as the defense continues to hold up. Should be a pair of great games.

The pickings in the rest of the conference are somewhat slimmer. North cellar-dwellers WSU and OSU meet to determine which will be crowned king of the bottom of the division. Lose this one, and the Beavers will really be in trouble. The Cougars still have some nice receivers, but this OSU defense isn’t exactly bad, despite what a similar Cal offense was able to do last week. More importantly, Luke Falk will be starting his first game for Wazzu. Though he played admirably in defeat versus USC, road games are never easy for young QB’s. OSU should win.

UCLA is at Washington in a game that matches two teams a lot more similar than the rankings would have a person believe. Both sides have been disappointing offensively this year and average defensively, though the Bruins do have a much more settled player at the crucial signal-caller spot. The matchup is in Seattle, which is a fairly tough place to pull off a win, and the Huskies are definitely due for a breakthrough, “epiphany”-type performance. UCLA’s might have come last week against Arizona, though. I’ll go with the Bruins, because as bad as UCLA’s offense has looked, it isn’t nearly as devoid of playmakers as UW’s.

Colorado – Arizona, for some reason the last-night showcase for the conference, isn’t very promising. The Buffaloes have had their chances to get that first Pac-12 win and simply haven’t taken advantage of them; they’re on the road, at night, against an angry Wildcats squad determined to prove itself. This might be a massacre. There’s very little to give me reason to pause on this prediction.

Heisman Watch

Right now there’s essentially no argument, but I’ll list the top players in consideration.

Marcus Mariota, QB, Oregon

Mariota is the best passer in the nation in several categories. He’s unquestionably the best player in the country right now.

Dak Prescott, QB, Mississippi State

The MSU QB has been a little banged up lately and turned in a couple of “meh” performances, but as long as the Bulldogs keep winning he’s in good shape.

Everett Golson, QB, Notre Dame

Golson rebounded with six TD’s against Navy (three rushing, three passing), but he’ll be judged primarily on his performances in ASU this week and USC later this month.

Random Thoughts and Observations

It’s time to stop considering Jameis Winston a Heisman candidate. I haven’t from the start, because the obvious truth is that after all the drama surrounding the Florida State QB, voters will never let him near the thing again. The same was true for Johnny Manziel last season, and Manziel didn’t have nearly as large a cloud over him. The off-field issues – yes, FSU fans, there are plenty, and they go beyond Winston’s lawyer “leaking” the star player’s alleged victim’s name to the public in an attempt to smear her (months after Seminoles fans discovered her identity and did the same) – will certainly take care of that.

But Winston’s play on the field eliminates him as well. For some reason this isn’t getting any attention, but Winston’s performance has slipped markedly this year. His completion percentage, yards per attempt and QB rating are down from 2013. His touchdown-to-interception ratio is far worse, dropping from a stellar 4:1 (40-10) to a mediocre 4:3 (16:9). There are a whole lot of QB’s around the country that could throw 16 TD’s and nine picks with the talent of FSU around them. This should make the voters’ jobs a whole lot easier.

Stanzi Watch

I thought Everett Golson was going to run away with this. What can I say? Even the best of us get things wrong sometimes. The crop was small this week, but one big performance threw the race into disarray again. Here are this week’s winners and the multiple-winner finalists. It’s a quality list.

Jameis Winston, Florida State
Opponent: Louisville
Performance: Three INT, won by 11

Kyle Allen, Texas A&M
Opponent: Louisiana-Monroe
Performance: One INT, one FUM, won by five

Cyler Miles, Washington
Opponent: Colorado
Performance: Two FUM, won by 15

Dak Prescott, Mississippi State
Opponent: Arkansas
Performance: Two INT, won by seven

Jameis Winston, Florida State: 3
Everett Golson, Notre Dame: 3
Logan Woodside, Toledo: 3
Justin Holman, UCF: 2
Dak Prescott, Mississippi State: 2
James Knapke, Bowling Green: 2
Fredi Knighten, Arkansas State: 2
Brett Hundley, UCLA: 2
Davis Webb, Texas Tech: 2
Nick Mullens, Southern Miss: 2

C.J. Brown, Maryland: 2


We're rapidly approaching the first playoff in major college football! Where did the season go? It seems just yesterday we were asking whether the Big Ten was really all that bad (answer: yes), or if Ohio State would be fine without Braxton Miller (answer: no), or if the SEC West was really that great (answer: probably). It's been a delightful repeat of the madness of 2007, but this time we get a playoff to determine the champion on the field. How wonderfully decadent.

Friday, October 31, 2014

Halloween week: Spooky, scary

National Overview

Another contender goes down. I can’t say I’m shocked Ole Miss lost – the Rebels have looked ripe for an upset ever since that opener against Boise State. You can point to the Alabama win all you want, but history proves victories like that over the Crimson Tide are far more reliant on luck than skill. Bo Wallace, a remarkably average quarterback, was stellar against ‘Bama, throwing for three touchdowns and no picks. His performance eerily echoed that of South Carolina’s Stephen Garcia in 2010, when the Gamecocks’ QB completed 19 of 20 passes in an upset of the defending champs.

Saturday, we got the real Wallace – mediocre throughout the night at Death Valley, then blowing the game with a gross duck into double coverage. The Rebels’ defense is still dominant, but Ole Miss had no business winning that game. LSU turned the ball over four times and won 10-7. If the Rebs were really a top-five squad those turnovers would have led to an easy victory. However, the team will get a shot at redemption this week against Auburn, so let’s not bury Ole Miss just yet.

Mississippi State also got a scare, although getting pushed by Kentucky is a lot worse than falling in a dogfight (or catfight) to LSU. MSU remains No. 1, but the defensive flaws have become glaringly obvious. The Bulldogs are going to lose a game, almost certainly at Alabama in a couple of weeks. This may be our 2014 Cinderella, but I doubt MSU will enjoy the same kind of charmed existence last year’s Auburn team did. It’s really just a matter of time.

In a less-watched but highly-significant development, West Virginia won at Oklahoma State, knocking the Cowboys out of Big 12 contention and moving the surprising Mountaineers to 6-2, 4-1 in league play. WVU’s rise is critical because it boosts Alabama’s non-conference resume AND gives the Big 12 another legitimate power. The ‘Eers still have to play Kansas State and TCU and could win the conference – or fall by the wayside, giving the Horned Frogs or Wildcats another quality win.

USC was eliminated from the playoff hunt with a close loss at Utah, a result that means the Utes still control their destiny. With one loss, it’s conceivable Utah could make the field, but running the table the rest of the way is a tall order. Not only do the Utes still have to play fellow South leaders Arizona and ASU, they also get Oregon AND Stanford in the regular season before facing one of them in the Pac-12 title game (were they to advance). I don’t see that happening.

Next week: Florida State is at Louisville, which is somehow ranked, on Thursday. Don’t get your hopes up there. TCU is at West Virginia in a huge Big 12 elimination game, Stanford is at Oregon and Ole Miss plays at Auburn in a de facto national quarterfinal. Late, Arizona get a shot to finally knock out UCLA in Pasadena and ASU tries to match its rival at home against Utah. Another good slate all around.

Playoff Poll

I don’t know that much really changed this week. Yes, Ole Miss lost, but because of the nature of the SEC West the Rebels will have their opportunity to climb back into the playoff. It’s unlikely more than one team from the same conference will qualify unless there’s some real chaos. And there just might be, but it hasn’t happened yet.

College Football Playoff

1) Mississippi State vs. 4) TCU
2) Florida State vs. 3) Oregon

The top two are easy. Oregon is currently most deserving one-loss team, as I stated last week. The No. 4 spot came down to a very tight decision between the Horned Frogs and the leading schools in the second tier, but I went with TCU because of how good the team looks right now. It took a collapse to lose to Baylor and TCU should be undefeated.

Second Tier

Michigan State
Ole Miss
Alabama
Auburn

The glut of SEC teams is intriguing, but the fact that they only have one quality win between them (Auburn at Kansas State, a game the Tigers should have lost) hurts their respective arguments. Ole Miss beating Alabama doesn’t count; the Crimson Tide don’t have any quality wins of their own. Michigan State is going to be let down by its schedule eventually, but as things currently sit the Spartans are just outside the top four.

Third Tier

Notre Dame
Georgia
Kansas State
Baylor

Notre Dame has the best loss of any team in the country but zero good wins. Georgia has a bad loss (South Carolina) and no good wins but has looked very good in recent weeks. Kansas State should be undefeated and has a victory over Oklahoma, but has yet to face the meat of its league schedule. Baylor’s West Virginia stumble looked bad, but could turn out to be respectable. All of these teams will have opportunities to improve their position in the coming weeks.

Pac-12 Report

It’s time to face facts: UCLA isn’t very good. The Bruins led by double-digits and still couldn’t prevent Colorado, the worst team in the conference, from forcing overtime. UCLA survived because it’s vastly more talented, but come on. This has gotten ridiculous. Arizona visits this week in a make-or-break game for this team. The Bruins have one last shot for relevance; this is their moment.

Washington State’s chance has already come and gone; the Cougars desperately needed a home win against Arizona last week to turn things around. The South leaders didn’t cooperate and WSU finds itself sitting at 2-6 with exactly zero guaranteed wins remaining. The Cougs could still qualify for a bowl by winning out, but the chances of that seem pretty remote. The defense simply isn’t good enough and the offense, though explosive, is one-dimensional to the point of being predictable.

The Oregon – Cal game played out more or less as I expected, with the Bears giving a decent effort but ultimately falling in a shootout. The Ducks’ defense is what it is – not that bad, but frustratingly erratic – which doesn’t make the 58-41 final that surprising (though UO did lead 52-28 midway through the third). The real test is obviously this week, when Stanford comes to town to try to ruin Oregon’s season for the third year in a row. The Cardinal have some problems of their own, making the outcome significantly murkier.

The disappointments of the weekend were Oregon State and Washington, which both fell in largely noncompetitive losses to Stanford and Arizona State, respectively. It’s hard to say if those results were the product of great performances by the Cardinal and Sun Devils, or if the Beavers and Huskies just aren’t that good. I lean toward the latter. OSU and UW have both been pretty anemic offensively this year and I don’t know that either will improve much as the season winds down.

The biggest winner was Utah, which edged USC in Salt Lake City thanks to a tiny bit of a pick play. The Utes are one fourth-quarter collapse (against WSU, of all teams) from being 7-0 and ranked in the top 10. Now the schedule gets nasty: Utah faces ASU, Oregon, Stanford and Arizona in consecutive weeks before the finale with Colorado. If the Utes run the table, they’re golden, but that’s asking quite a lot, especially now that their best player (receiver Dres Anderson) is out for the year.

The intrigue continues this week, when the North will (likely) be decided by Stanford’s visit to Oregon. The Cardinal aren’t what they have been the past few years thanks to a less dominant offensive line and an even larger dearth of playmakers at the skill positions. But the defense is still elite, and there’s the rub. Can UO, after getting ground to a halt the last two meetings, flip the script and return to the blowouts of 2010-11? The Ducks’ runaway victory of Michigan State this season would seem to indicate that, but Stanford knows Oregon better than the Spartans. It’s a game that has far-reaching implications.

Washington will look to end its two-game slide at Colorado, where the Buffaloes gave UCLA a fright one week ahead of schedule. You’d think the Huskies could similarly fix what ails them with a comfortable win over the league’s worst team, but that’s probably what the Bruins thought, too. CU has managed to battle several of the Pac-12’s middle class members admirably this year and owns a not-insignificant home-field advantage. UW should take this matchup seriously.

USC is at Washington State in what amounts to a last-gasp effort for the Cougars to save their season. I don’t see it happening; SC’s struggles have come against teams that could A) run the ball and B) out-physical them. WSU can do neither of those things, and while the Cougars will probably throw for 400 yards yet again, will it mean anything if they give up 50 points? Crazy things have been known to happen on the Palouse, but this feels like the end of the line for the Cougs in 2014.

Cal – Oregon State is another crossroads game, as neither side can afford another loss in the quest for bowl eligibility. OSU has a slightly easier road (and one more game remaining), but this is still pretty much a must-win for the Beavers. Given the teams’ similar records, this contest could also decide bowl pecking order. While Cal would be delighted to just be playing in the postseason, OSU fans would be more than a little miffed by another Vegas Bowl-type appearance. I think Cal’s explosive offensive will win the matchup with OSU’s strong D, forcing the Beavs into a shootout their offense can’t sustain.

The Arizona schools feature heavily in the nightcap, with Arizona at UCLA and Utah at ASU. The surprising Wildcats sit at 6-1 but outside the top 10, an indication voters and the playoff committee aren’t convinced the Oregon win was anything but a fluke. ‘Zona gets a chance to prove the doubters wrong this week by officially turning UCLA’s season from “disappointing” to “nightmarish.” UCLA has more next-level talent and could, in theory, still turn things around. But the ‘Cats 3-3-5 defense tends to give spread offenses fits (see Ducks, Oregon), and the Bruins are far less explosive than UO. Unless UCLA rediscovers its running attack, Arizona should win this game.

Finally, we have Utah – ASU. The Utes have lived a charmed existence this year, outside of that fourth quarter with Washington State. The trouble now is sustaining it, something I don’t think they’re capable of doing. The biggest issue for Utah this season has been QB play and now the biggest playmaker for this team is gone for the season. This is going to look like Stanford East: all defense and running game. The Sun Devils have been more competent defensively than they were supposed to be and still boast a very dangerous dual-threat attack. The QB situation is a bit unsettled, but both Taylor Kelly and Mike Bercovici have proved they can win games. I think ASU probably has the edge at home.

Heisman Watch

With the news that Georgia RB Todd Gurley has officially been suspended four games, his campaign is over. Reigning winner Jameis Winston has recused himself both for his off-field antics and his mediocre on-field performance (16 TD’s, nine interceptions). That leaves precious few players with a reasonable shot.

Marcus Mariota, QB, Oregon

Here we are again, facing Stanford, with the conference title and a Heisman trophy on the line. If Oregon keeps winning and Mariota plays well, he will win the award. Period.

Dak Prescott, QB, Mississippi State

Prescott means a whole lot to MSU and has gradually improved as a passer throughout his career. In the unlikely event the Bulldogs go undefeated he could become the favorite.

Everett Golson, QB, Notre Dame

Golson’s got his chances to move up against ASU and USC, but it might take a fall from one of the other candidates to really make him a contender.

Trevone Boykin, QB, TCU

Dude threw seven TD’s against Texas Tech. Boykin has really matured as a passer and while he’s not as accurate as some of his peers his yards-per-attempt is outrageous.

Random Thoughts and Observations

A pair of Pac-12 passers make the news this week. First, Washington State QB Connor Halliday, who sits exactly 2,000 yards short of the NCAA FBS single-season passing record of 5,833 (5,336 in the 12-game regular season) set by Texas Tech’s B.J. Symons in 2003. Barring injury, Halliday will assuredly surpass at least the latter figure, and he has an outside shot at the overall record. But will it be an empty accomplishment? Just as with his single-game record of 734 against Cal earlier this year, Halliday’s numbers could come largely in defeat. The Cougars sit at 2-6 and will probably miss a bowl (which would make the 5,833 mark much more difficult to match). Symons at least went 8-5 during his campaign – how much would Halliday’s record be worth if it came during a 4-8 season? It’s not his fault the WSU defense is terrible, but it’s still a question worth pondering.

Oregon State’s Sean Mannion will likely set a new record this very week against Cal. The Beavers’ signal-caller needs a mere 195 yards to become the Pac-10/12’s all-time leading passer. Going up against the worst pass defense in the conference, he could have that by halftime. It’s nice for fans that Mannion will do it at home, but once again I question the validity of the record. Mannion started nearly all of his disastrous 3-9 freshman season in 2011, tossing 16 TD’s to 18 INT’s but padding his career total with 3,328 yards because OSU was always behind. His sophomore season he started hot, got hurt and wasn’t the same after, throwing for 2,446 with 15 TD’s and 13 INT’s. This season, Mannion’s numbers have again been pedestrian – 1,698 yards, seven TD’s and five INT’s to this point – leaving us with one year, 2013, when he actually put up impressive totals.

Last season, with the Beavers force-feeding future first-round NFL pick Brandin Cooks the ball (128 catches, 1730 yards, 16 TD’s) and OSU devoid of any type of running game, Mannion threw for 4,662 yards, 37 scores and 15 picks. That’s an pretty resume, and he probably should have capitalized on it by declaring for the draft. But people who have watched Mannion’s entire career see a different player, a guy a who has an outlier season that looks great and otherwise boasts a 38-36 TD-to-INT ratio. He’ll get the record. But he won’t really deserve to be mentioned with the greats the Pac-12 has seen at the position.

Stanzi Watch

It’s time to cut the list to just the finalists, AKA the multiple-time winners. Everett Golson is no longer the unquestioned leader, as Logan Woodside has made yet another push toward the coveted Stanzi. Who will notch one this week? Here are Week 9’s winners and the finalists.

Logan Woodside, Toledo
Opponent: Massachusetts
Performance: Two INT, won by seven

Cooper Rush, Central Michigan
Opponent: Buffalo
Performance: One INT, one FUM, won by six

Cole Stoudt, Clemson
Opponent: Syracuse
Performance: Two INT, one FUM, won by 10

Anthony Jennings, LSU
Opponent: Ole Miss
Performance: Two INT, won by 3

J.T. Barrett, Ohio State
Opponent: Penn State
Performance: Two INT, won in overtime

Everett Golson, Notre Dame: 3
Logan Woodside, Toledo: 3
Jameis Winston, Florida State: 2
Justin Holman, UCF: 2
James Knapke, Bowling Green: 2
Fredi Knighten, Arkansas State: 2
Brett Hundley, UCLA: 2
Davis Webb, Texas Tech: 2
Nick Mullens, Southern Miss: 2
C.J. Brown, Maryland: 2



And there you have it. We’re approaching the end of it all, but there’s no end in sight to the fun! Week 10 will surely provide more of the same.

Wednesday, October 22, 2014

To Zi or not Stanzi

National Overview

Two more down. Baylor and Notre Dame exited the ranks of the unbeaten Saturday, one in a blaze of glory and another in a blaze of... awful defense. It shouldn’t be hard to figure out which team was which. The top five wasn’t the only place to see shakeups, though. Oklahoma – the ostensible Big 12 favorite – was almost assuredly eliminated from playoff contention after a second loss (to Kansas State). Dark horse Oklahoma State suffered a similar fate, getting thrashed by TCU. Stanford was also knocked out of the title chase after another offensive flop, leaving the SEC essentially unchallenged at the top of the polls.

The week started with a bang on Thursday (not counting Tuesday’s Louisiana-Lafayette – Texas State game) when Oregon State took Utah to double-overtime. The Utes are still a wild card in the Pac-12 South with their quarterback situation unsettled but could end up having a huge impact before everything is said and done. Saturday morning saw the two Big 12 upsets, as Baylor wilted in Morgantown and Oklahoma fell apart at home. Alabama annihilated Texas A&M 59-0 to stay relevant, while UCLA kept its slim hopes alive by narrowly edging Cal.

Marshall blasted FIU to remain the only undefeated mid-major. The Thundering Herd will likely finish 12-0 but be left out of the playoff because the schedule strength just isn’t there. Oregon pounded Washington yet again to remain the North’s leader, while Notre Dame fell to FSU in a result that will probably doom the Fighting Irish’s playoff bid. If ND finishes with one loss there’s a chance, but the Irish face a fairly daunting slate in the next month and a half.

The pickings are rather slim this week, considering where we are in the season. Michigan is at Michigan State, but that rivalry has taken a turn for the worse in recent years. West Virginia is at Oklahoma State in a surprisingly meaningful Big 12 contest. We’ll get to see if Ole Miss’ upset of Alabama was a fluke when the Rebels travel to LSU, while Auburn hosts South Carolina in another test for the Tigers. The Pac-12 has a good night lineup, featuring USC at Utah and Arizona State – Washington. Unfortunately, that’s about it.

Playoff Poll

I’m not sure how we got here this fast, but the discussion has already shifted to which one-loss team is the most worthy. The top three teams are easy. It’s where we go from there that makes this confusing.

1) Mississippi State vs. 4) Oregon
2) Florida State vs. 3) Ole Miss

The Mississippi schools are obvious, although I anticipate at least one loss for both of them – at Alabama is the most likely candidate for MSU, while Auburn’s visit to Ole Miss could be the Rebs’ undoing. FSU is probably safe for the remainder of the regular season, considering the dearth of talent in the ACC. Oregon is the tough one, beating out a host of other one-loss schools.

Second Tier

Michigan State
Alabama
Auburn
TCU

The Spartans are still hiding in plain sight, waiting for the smoke to clear. Alabama finally looked like Alabama against Texas A&M. Auburn was off, but TCU made a statement that the collapse against Baylor was a fluke. Oregon beats out these teams by virtue of “best win.”

Third Tier

Notre Dame
Georgia
Kansas State
Baylor

Notre Dame acquitted itself well in Tallahassee and deserves to stay in the conversation, if only peripherally. Georgia has crept back into contention, but I’m skeptical of the Dawgs chances given how much better the SEC West is than the East. Kansas State and Baylor both have one loss and would need to win out to garner any support for the playoff.

Pac-12 Report

I guess I was right about Utah – Oregon State. The Beavers certainly had their chances, holding the Utes to 62 yards passing and still losing in double overtime. You can’t blow opportunities like that in the Pac-12 and expect to have a successful season. Utah is good – the defense, in particular, is powerful – but not elite. OSU’s offensive issues are no longer a matter of “fixing” something that’s broken. The Beavs simply don’t have very many playmakers. To have any chance at a bowl they’ll need to rely on the D, which has been excellent to this point. Without a reprieve from the offense, though, things could spiral out of control quickly.

UCLA managed to survive a back-and-forth affair with Cal to remain relevant in at least the conference title chase, but it wasn’t pretty. Good though the Bears may be offensively, there’s no excuse for a team with the Bruins’ talent to need all 60 minutes to put the game away. There’s something just off about this squad. It’s hard to tell if it’s the coaching, the players or the difficult schedule, but UCLA hasn’t looked right all season. Cal, on the other hand, has looked solid. It’s a shame the remaining schedule is so tough, because this team deserves to go to a bowl.

As expected, USC crushed Colorado, knocking the Buffaloes down to 0-4 in conference play. It’s no surprise CU is still the doormat of the South, but the performance since the 2-2 start is a little troubling. The Trojans, meanwhile, have moved to 4-1 and sit atop the division, at least until Arizona State wins again. Could that Hail Mary be the difference between a Pac-12 title and a second-place South finish? Gulp. SC is still in good shape, but not controlling one’s own destiny is a little scary.

Oregon clobbered Washington yet again in a series that has increasingly begun to look routine. UO has beaten the spread each of the last 11 meetings and won by an average of just more than 25 points – exactly what the difference was Saturday. It doesn’t seem to matter where the game is played or even if the Huskies have advantages (such as their great defensive front this year), the result is the same. At 1-2 with losses to Oregon and Stanford, UW is firmly out of the North race for the time being. The Ducks appeared to be back in form… but we’ll only know for sure if they can keep this up.

Lastly, there was the oddity that was Stanford – ASU. It never felt like the Cardinal were particularly engaged with the game or even really in it, but they weren’t mathematically eliminated until the final minutes. The defense, at least, is still mostly there. The offense is another story. Stanford has been so bad it’s surprising there haven’t been more calls for a quarterback change, although I’m not sure anyone could move the ball with the way the O-line has been playing. ASU is trending up, Stanford down.

Oregon and Cal play Friday in Santa Clara to start the Pac-12’s weekend off. There should be points in this one. UO looked good against Washington’s anemic attack but the Bears are a different story. Fortunately for the Ducks, Cal’s defense is so terrible one or two stops should do it. I don’t see the Bears holding Oregon to less than 40, and even with some of UO’s defensive concerns it’s hard to imagine the Ducks giving up that many points. It may take a while to pull away, but it’ll happen.

Surely UCLA wouldn’t continue to struggle at Colorado, right? This has the feel of the perfect kind of get-right game the Bruins could desperately use. If not… nearly losing to Cal was bad enough. The voters put their trust in you, UCLA! You’re back in the top 25! Don’t let those good* people down. The Buffs have a shot if they return to the scrappy play that defined them in September, but I’m not optimistic. UCLA will finally put together a complete game in Boulder and look like the team that got so much hype in the preseason.

*Debatable

Oregon State is at Stanford in an increasingly tight series that has seen its past two games go down to the wire. The argument can be made that the Beavers should have won both of the last two years and they’ll surely be out for some revenge. Unfortunately, OSU’s offense might make that a bit difficult. Unless the Beavs can find some magic solution this week, the Cardinal’s stout defense figures to make like miserable for QB Sean Mannion again. Of course, the same could be said of Stanford’s offense, and the OSU defense is no slouch either. This contest has the potential to be very, very ugly.

Arizona is at WSU in what I would have absolutely called a trap game had the Wildcats not fallen to USC last week. The Cougars can play with almost anyone – it’s just the winning thing they have trouble with – and that will be true against UA. The Air Raid should do its Air Raid-y thing at home, which could lead to a shootout. Wazzu has struggled against good offenses but is still very dangerous. The ‘Cats had better beware. I’ll take Arizona, but it’s not a lock.

Raise your hand if you thought Utah would be ranked higher than USC when the teams met in Salt Lake City. I’m thinking no one saw that coming. The Utes have impressed so far, playing great defense and moving within one fourth-quarter collapse of a 6-0 start. They have to be considered a South player. However… I think SC wins. The Trojans typically do well when matched up with similarly pro-styled teams (like Stanford) and the Utes’ QB situation is beyond a mess. This feels like a “take back the power” game for the visitors.

The second half of the nightcap features Arizona State at Washington in a huge game for both sides. ASU needs to stay ahead of USC and can’t afford to stumble in one of its easier remaining games (crazy, but true). UW has already lost to the two presumed North heavyweights and has to win to have any faint hope of a backdoor division title. The Sun Devils romped in Tempe last season, but both teams have seen enough turnover to make that fairly irrelevant. ASU is probably just the better squad, but like Oregon has the potential to struggle when its spread gets disrupted by a dominant front. Washington can win here. I’m not sure they will.

Heisman Watch

It’s still pretty much a two- or three-man race at this point. Off-field troubles are going to exclude at least two expected finalists, so the field isn’t particularly compelling. If the unbeatens are eliminated, we’ll see things get interesting.

Marcus Mariota, QB, Oregon

Mariota is on another long interception-free streak and has been his usual stellar self all year. It would take a lot – like a couple more losses and poor play – to knock him out of the running.

Dak Prescott, QB, Mississippi State

Once again, Prescott is a very nice college player that has absolutely no hope of succeeding at the next level. As a Heisman candidate, though, he’s practically perfect. The QB of the top-ranked team is always a favorite.

Everett Golson, QB, Notre Dame

Golson acquitted himself well in the FSU loss. If the Fighting Irish run the table the rest of the way and move back into playoff contention, odds are Golson will end up in New York.

Trevone Boykin, QB,TCU

He’ll have his shot against Kansas State and West Virginia. Voters are probably a little reticent about Boykin at the moment given his spotty history, but he definitely has the ability to put together some great numbers.

Random Thoughts and Observations

Brian Kelly can complain about the offensive interference penalty that ended the FSU game all he wants. It doesn’t change the fact that it was absolutely the right call. “Pick” plays, which have become increasing common during the rise of the spread, are shady territory at best and quite often completely illegal. The degree to which receivers turn to actually look for a pass is tantamount to the success of the play; it has to at least appear that the WR’s are running routes.

That wasn’t the case at all on the overturned touchdown. Two Notre Dame receivers clearly blocked defenders out of the play before the ball was thrown. That’s the definition of offensive pass interference. Kelly has come out with two bizarre statements on the call, saying that officials “changed their mind” about the player who committed the penalty and that the Irish “ran the same play earlier” and the officials didn’t call it. It doesn’t matter which player was flagged – they were both committing the same infraction. Additionally, the idea that because the team cheated before to score, it should allowed to do so again is ludicrous. Kelly should be happy it was only called once.

Baylor’s flop on the road at West Virginia wasn’t exactly unprecedented. The Bears had a similar performance to end an undefeated season last year at Oklahoma State. What was surprising was how much better the Mountaineers looked. WVU outgained Baylor 456-318, held the Bears to a paltry 95 yards rushing on 42 carries and actually lost the turnover battle 3-0. To still win by double-digits implies some pretty impressive domination on both sides of the ball. As a bonus, the two teams combined for 32 penalties for an outrageous 353 yards, including a Big 12-record 215 for Baylor.

Special recognition needs to be made for Missouri, which napalmed Florida at the Swamp 42-13 (in a game that was 42-0 in the third quarter). Mizzou scored on a kickoff return TD to start the game and a punt return TD, sack/fumble TD AND interception return TD in the third quarter. The Tigers should be happy. Such a feat probably won’t be duplicated for decades in Columbia. Will Muschamp should be looking for a new job. This has gotten out of hand.

Stanzi Watch

In either one or two weeks’ time, depending on how the weekly awards shake out, I’ll apply the multi-winner cutoff. Players will still be able to leap onto the semifinalist board, but I won’t waste space listing each of the one-time winners. This past week saw another great crop of Stanzi performances, including a remarkable five players (out of eight) who notched their second award of the season. Stunningly, none of them was our two leaders. Here are this week’s winners and the standings:

Chad Voytik, Pittsburgh
Opponent: Virginia Tech
Performance: One INT, one FUM, won by four

Kendal Thompson, Utah
Opponent: Oregon State
Performance: One INT, one FUM, won* in double-OT

*Note: Thompson was benched after his second turnover and thus doesn’t really fit the Stanzi criteria… but he was bad enough I think he should get one anyway

Justin Holman, UCF
Opponent: Tulane
Performance: Two INT, won by seven

Clint Trickett, West Virginia
Opponent: Baylor
Performance: One INT, one FUM, won by 14

C.J. Brown, Maryland
Opponent: Iowa
Performance: Two INT, won by seven

Brett Hundley, UCLA
Opponent: Cal
Performance: One INT, one FUM, won by two

Davis Webb, Texas Tech
Opponent: Kansas
Performance: One INT, one FUM, won by 13

Nick Mullens, Southern Miss
Opponent: North Texas
Performance: Two INT, won by 10

Everett Golson, Notre Dame: 3
Jameis Winston, Florida State: 2
Justin Holman, UCF: 2
James Knapke, Bowling Green: 2
Fredi Knighten, Arkansas State: 2
Brett Hundley, UCLA: 2
Davis Webb, Texas Tech: 2
Nick Mullens, Southern Miss: 2
Logan Woodside, Toledo: 2
C.J. Brown, Maryland: 2
Kevin Hogan, Stanford: 1
Blake Decker, UNLV: 1
Nick Arbuckle, Georgia State: 1
Sean Maguire, Florida State: 1
Patrick Towles, Kentucky: 1
Connor Halliday, Washington State: 1
Tanner Lee, Tulane: 1
Trevone Boykin, TCU: 1
Reggie Bonnafon, Louisville: 1
Grant Hedrick, Boise State: 1
Greg Ward, Jr., Houston: 1
Taysom Hill, BYU: 1
Jared Goff, Cal: 1
Bryce Petty, Baylor: 1
Chad Voytik, Pittsburgh: 1
Tyler Jones, Texas State: 1
Garrett Grayson, Colorado State: 1
Clint Trickett, West Virginia: 1
Anu Solomon, Arizona: 1
Michael Brewer, Virginia Tech: 1
Christian Hackenberg, Penn State: 1
Wes Lunt, Illinois: 1
Hutson Mason: 1
Gunner Kiel, Cincinnati: 1
Sefo Liufau, Colorado: 1
Dak Prescott, Mississippi State: 1
Brian Burell, Fresno State: 1
Angel Santiago, Army: 1
Kendal Thompson, Utah: 1
Grayson Lambert, Virginia: 1
Dane Evans, Tulsa: 1



That’s 10 multi-Stanzi guys! 10! Through eight weeks of action! I can’t imagine how this could possibly get any more entertaining – which is why it will, of course. We’re starting to hit attrition season, when teams’ depth exposes who they really are. Should be fun.