Tuesday, October 15, 2013

The Double Stanzi! They said it couldn't be done!

We finally got the upsets everyone knew were coming. They just didn’t come from where we expected. LSU versus Florida? No problem. Oregon at Washington? No chance. Instead, a week ahead of a big showdown with UCLA, Stanford stumbled at Utah, while Georgia finally succumbed to its injury woes against Missouri. The rest of the top teams managed to win, though some in very dicey situations. Clemson was nearly caught looking ahead to Florida State by Boston College, while Texas A&M needed a whole lot of Ole Miss incompetence to escape Oxford.

While we were robbed of an eventual undefeated Oregon – Stanford pairing late in the year, we still get a classic dual this week in FSU at Clemson, which should be absolutely fantastic. The last two games between the Atlantic Division rivals have been barnburners and this one figures to be no exception. Playmakers abound on both sides, but the biggest matchup to watch is the one between the two quarterbacks. Jameis Winston and Tajh Boyd are dual-threat studs, future high draft picks and current Heisman short-listers. Death Valley will be rocking with the 8:00 p.m. (local) kick-off. This could be the game of the year.

Oregon notched the most impressive win of the weekend, on the road in a raucous Husky Stadium. Against the best squad Washington has fielded since the 2000 Rose Bowl year, UO never trailed and controlled the game nearly from start to finish. The Ducks had an answer for everything the Huskies did on both sides of the ball, racking up a 631-376 yardage edge despite playing without star RB De’Anthony Thomas. UW has clearly improved, but they’re still not in Oregon’s league.

The nation’s top team, Alabama, had another easy week with Kentucky. The rest of the SEC was more interesting, as LSU outclassed Florida, Texas A&M outlasted Ole Miss and Mizzou out-injured Georgia. Poor UGA. The Bulldogs are very good but have simply had no luck at all in 2013 and it caught up to them this week. You knew eventually the team would break down, but it was surprising to see it happen at home against the Tigers. Missouri is decent but hardly great and it’s hard to shake the feeling that with just a few of its crippled warriors back Georgia would have won the game.

Of course, Mizzou can hardly celebrate themselves after losing QB James Franklin for the season. In the ultimate twist of cruel fate, the Tigers finally got the validating SEC win they’d been seeking but saw their leader go down in the same game. I’ve moved the team into my rankings, but without Franklin it’s hard to imagine they’ll keep winning (next two opponents: Florida and South Carolina). The SEC East is wide open and it still might come down to whether Georgia can hold off the injury bug for a few more key contests.

The other big upset of the weekend was Utah’s win over Stanford. The Utes had been knocking on the door for a couple of weeks and were finally rewarded Saturday. However, even though Stanford is the more talented team, it’s hard to gauge how big of an upset this really is. The Cardinal looked pedestrian in several games this season and should have lost last week to Washington. In a Pac-12 North that features potentially five bowl teams, ‘Furd is in a tough spot after dropping this game (which, it’s worth noting, they still could have won despite being outplayed). Utah may prove to be a player in the South Division yet.

Among the other noteworthy games, USC was impressive in holding off Arizona’s late rally to win their first game post-Kiffin. As many commentators have noted, the Trojans just looked to be having FUN again as they demonstrated an ability to move the ball and play some solid defense (until the fourth quarter). This still isn’t a great team, but it’s one that, like Texas, may prove to be more tricky at the end of the season. Speaking of the Longhorns…

Texas is 3-0 in the Big 12. All those predictions of a Big 12 Championship could actually turn out to be completely accurate, which is crazy considering where this team was a few games ago. I didn’t include the Red River Rivalry in my earlier recapping because the Big 12 is less relevant on the national scene right now, but UT blowing out Oklahoma was absolutely stunning. I wasn’t under the impression that OU was some kind of powerhouse, but I certainly thought they’d have enough to handle a defense-less squad like the Longhorns. Instead, Texas did what every opponent of Oklahoma’s SHOULD do this year: force the Sooners to the air, where Blake Bell is barely competent. Nicely done, Mack. That’ll stave off the firing talk for another, oh, three games.

The rankings took another shakeup this week as Clemson’s second poor showing in a win this year cost them. The two most dominant teams have been Oregon and Florida State, but neither could quite unseat the two-time champs. Louisville’s middling win over Rutgers significantly hurt the Cardinals, while Wisconsin moved back into the rankings (to stay, if you look at the schedule) and the Baylor/Mizzou combo finally made it on the board. For now.

Top 25

1) Alabama

It’s telling that despite a 6-0 start that includes wins over Virginia Tech and Texas A&M (now the best two wins of any of the top teams) Alabama is still being questioned. It’s easy to get caught up in the flash of Oregon’s big win at Washington and Florida State’s annihilation of Maryland, but ‘Bama has still only allowed 11 points a game and won five of six games by at least 25. True, the schedule has been lacking since the trip to College Station and the offense has been a little less than stellar. This team still gets the benefit of the doubt until someone unseats them.

2) Oregon

The Ducks’ scorched the previously stingy Husky D and, outside of a 194-yard third quarter, completely shut down the new and improved UW offense. With Stanford’s loss, it appears the Pac-12 is truly Oregon’s to lose, but beware: in both of the past two seasons UO stumbled down the stretch – at home, no less – when it seemed a perfect conference record was in hand. The league has continued to rise to the Ducks’ level, so even with the potential Heisman winner leading the way this will not be an easy road. The second half of the schedule is a lot tougher.

3) FSU

Clemson’s little stumble against Boston College was worrisome (although considering how close the Eagles played FSU, perhaps BC is just good), which is why I’m currently predicting a Seminoles win in Clemson this week. Additionally, outside of the tremendous win over Georgia, Florida State has been the better team this year. My respect for Jameis Winston cannot be overstated – he should be no lower than second in any Heisman poll – and the ‘Noles are hitting opponents hard with an impressively balanced attack. They also got a week off to prepare for the Tigers.

4) Clemson

Clemson beat Georgia at full strength, a feat that may not get the respect it deserves if the Bulldogs’ injuries cause them to slide out of the SEC race. However, it’s also true that since opening week this team has not always looked great. Saturday’s close shave marked the second time Clemson nearly fell to a vastly inferior team. Even if the Tigers were looking ahead, it raises concerns about their focus. You don’t see that kind of slip-up from Oregon or Alabama. The heavyweight showdown this week will answer a lot of questions, though if Clemson wins they should be back at number one.

5) LSU

I had LSU eighth last week and after another quality win I’m prepared to move them in front of an undefeated Ohio State team that hasn’t played anyone as good as the best two (maybe three) teams on the Tigers' schedule. At the very least, dominating Florida is more impressive than close wins over Northwestern and Wisconsin. The offense continues to churn out yards and points, which makes up for the fact that the defense hasn’t been up to its usual standard. With just two threatening games left on the schedule (‘Bama and A&M), LSU is still in position to snag a spot in the SEC Championship.

6) Ohio State

After taking out the only two difficult teams on their schedule, the Buckeyes sat back this week to assess their handiwork. It wasn’t pretty, as Wisconsin destroyed the Northwestern team OSU had just barely beaten. The good news was the Buckeyes already had a win over Wisconsin; the bad news was Michigan losing to Penn State. That loss might prove to be Ohio State’s undoing, given the perception of how weak the Big Ten is this season. 12-0 is very possible, but it might come at the expense of one or even zero ranked teams. As talented as this squad is I see it as a cut below the top tier.

7) South Carolina

The Gamecocks obliterated Arkansas, righting a whole lot of tepid play the past month and setting up a fun showdown with Missouri in Columbia in late October (provided they can get past Tennessee this weekend). This is a quality team, but you can see the margin of error is smaller for them than it is for, say, Alabama or LSU. Of course, it’s also important to remember how the schedule gods paid Carolina back this season, which, coupled with Georgia’s injuries, could still lead the Gamecocks back to the top of the East. If they knock off Mizzou, the last four games are at home. I like those odds.

8) Texas A&M

We know what the offense can do. It’s the defense that, well, look at what I said last week. I didn’t expect Ole Miss to be the team that came out of nowhere to trip up the Aggies, yet it probably should have been, save for some atrocious clock management by the Rebels. Fortunately for A&M Johnny Manziel’s knee seems fine and they now get four straight home games, three against bad teams, to build on that record. The problem is that even weak foes can make a game of it against the sieve that is aTm’s D. At some point the offense is going to wear out from carrying so much of the load.

9) Louisville

With a chance to make a statement against Rutgers on the national stage the Cardinals fell flat Thursday. It’s nice to get four gift interceptions and hold a conference rival to ten points, but three of the Scarlet Knights’ previous four FBS opponents had scored the same or better against them. In fact, at 27 points per game allowed, the 24-10 loss actually lowered Rutger’s defensive average. UCF next week is the only team remaining for Louisville worth anything at all, so they’d better be prepared to do something special. Right now it would take two losses by every other BCS team to get the Cardinals to the title game.

10) Miami (FL)

The Hurricanes took the week off, though odds are they won’t need the rest to beat foundering North Carolina. Collisions with Florida State and Virginia Tech are still three weeks out, so right now all this team has to do is stay the course to ensure a run at the division crown. I will say this: Florida’s proved to be no great shakes, so the ‘Canes might be outclassed by the top teams in the improved ACC. For now they maintain their spot, but the schedule hasn’t really been that difficult (just one road game to this point). November will tell us how good Miami really is.

11) UCLA

Even in the 27-point win over Cal I found plenty upon which UCLA could improve. We know by now the Bears are awful; everyone scores on them. Comparatively speaking, though, the Bruins’ offense wasn’t great on Saturday. UCLA settled for way too many field goals and finished with fewer points than any other FBS team has against Cal. Now, this was offset by the fact that Utah, who nearly beat UCLA last week, knocked off Stanford. That buys the Bruins a break for the time being. However, with a road trip to Palo Alto this week, they won’t be able to celebrate for long.

12) Stanford

Well, you can’t say the writing wasn’t on the wall. Stanford, not an overwhelmingly dominant team at the best of times, ran out of luck against Utah. The Cardinal played a very un-Stanford-like game, getting beat at the line and looking a step slow. Make no mistake, the Utes did a nice job, but Stanford is the better team and didn’t play like it. They’d better figure some things out – UCLA comes to town this week, with a better offense than that of Utah. I expect a much more focused effort from the defense, though the fate of the very average offense is anyone’s guess.

13) Georgia

It’s just one of those seasons for Georgia, whose title hopes have been dashed in a tidal wave of snapped bones and shredded ligaments. The defense wasn’t going to be great even if things broke right this year and isn’t capable of stepping up to relieve the pressure on the undermanned offense. We can probably count on a few more shootouts this season. Though it’s entirely possible Aaron Murray can pull out most of them, the only one that matters is the early November date with Florida. Win, and UGA will likely still make an improbable run to the SEC Championship.

14) Texas Tech

I’m more than a little nervous after TTU gave up 35 to 1-4 Iowa State, but the Red Raiders survived to move to 3-0 in the wild Big 12 and still have West Virginia on the sked to iron things out before going to Oklahoma. Of course, the Sooners might not be that good, so maybe WVU (in Morgantown) is the bigger threat here. Or maybe it’s Oklahoma State, or Baylor, or possibly even Texas, lurking at the very end. This league has gotten too crazy to predict, so for now, I’ll stick with what I know: Tech is tied for the Big 12 lead a third of the way through the conference season.

15) Virginia Tech

Pittsburgh never seriously threatened, so the 10-point win is a little better than it looks. Really, that’s an accurate descriptor for this whole team, which has some offensive… issues… but plays good enough defense to usually make up for that. Sometimes ya gotta win ugly. With five straight victories by 10 points or fewer, no one can attest to that more than VaTech. Against a high-caliber opponent I’m pretty sure these guys would be toast, but guess what? There aren’t any on the schedule. Miami (FL) is the only ranked foe left and I’m not even sure the ‘Canes are that good.

16) Nebraska

The Cornhuskers did what they had to – beat down inferior teams like Illinois and Purdue. The upcoming opposition gets more difficult, but with an embarrassing eight home games it’s hard to see how Nebraska doesn’t squeeze at least eight or nine wins out of this schedule. I tend to think the Blackshirts’ defensive issues have only been hidden by the bad teams they’ve played the past couple of weeks, but in the Big Ten this team honestly isn’t likely to see that many offensive juggernauts. With Taylor Martinez on the mend, Nebraska is still very much in the mix for the Legends title.

17) Oklahoma State

OSU got a week off and now faces reeling TCU and Iowa State before a huge showdown in Lubbock with Texas Tech. However, if the Cowboys can notch those first two wins they’ll be in prime position to take down the Red Raiders, as TTU has to play at Oklahoma the week prior. I’ve been unable to get a good read on Okie State despite watching them several times; they look like BCS material one game, then average the next. In the 2013 Big 12, that might be enough. All they have to do is be good on the right days. That includes versus TCU this week.

18) Washington

If you believe, as I do, that Oregon is one of the best teams in the country (and possibly the best, period) Washington can’t be faulted for losing to the Ducks at home, even by multiple scores. I didn’t see anything in the game that shocked me. Oregon is just better. That doesn’t mean UW is bad, or even average. The back half of the schedule is easier, save two games. One is at Arizona State next week (the other is at UCLA). The Huskies are the better team and should win, but strange things have been known to happen in the desert. As long as this team is looking forward, not back, they should be okay.

19) Florida

The fact that Florida is still holding opponents to 13 points a game with an offense averaging less than 200 yards rushing AND passing is phenomenal. That’s what makes them worthy of a spot in the top 25. It’s obvious by now what the Gators are: a team that fights like mad to stay in games and has to because its offense is horrendous. That isn’t the same thing as being a bad team overall, though, and it definitely doesn’t mean UF is out of the SEC race. Mizzou is up next and it wouldn’t surprise me at all to see Florida win on the road and open this division up again.

20) Wisconsin

Yow. I called a Wisconsin win, but I can’t take credit for that one – I was expecting a two-score game, tops. Instead, Wisky flat-out embarrassed Northwestern, rolling up 527 yards (and allowing a mere 241) while holding the ball for nearly two-thirds of the game. The Wildcats have been unceremoniously booted from the Big Ten race. The Badgers, meanwhile, are still in it, but not really, given that they would need TWO Ohio State losses to make the conference championship game. However, with an incredibly winnable final six games, 10-2 is a distinct possibility.

21) Baylor

I’ll say this for Baylor: they got a win against a non-garbage opponent. Sadly, “non-garbage” is about is kind as I can get for Kansas State, who currently sits at 2-4 and 0-3 in the Big 12. The Bears saw their dominant offense held to less than 450 yards by a defense not ranked in the top 50 and needed two fourth-quarter scores to pull out the win. Iowa State and Kansas are bad enough that I’m still predicting a 7-0 start, but when the schedule gets real Baylor is going to have some problems. Despite what you may think, some Big 12 teams CAN play D.

22) Oklahoma

Don’t be fooled by this ranking: OU was spanked by a seemingly inferior Texas team from start to finish and deserves to fall out of the top 25 based on Saturday’s performance. That is, if you take for granted that UT is bad, which I don’t really think is the case. I think it’s much more likely the Longhorns simply had a couple of terrible games earlier in the year and were shamed into playing up to their talent level. Oklahoma will still be a factor in the Big 12 race and has earned a ranking based on their previous body of work. Unfortunately, like Texas before them, they had a complete meltdown this game.

23) Missouri

You can only play the team in front of you that day, so credit Missouri for capitalizing on Georgia’s… weaknesses and winning in Athens. Still, it’s hard to be overly excited about the win considering UGA significantly outgained the Tigers and had four turnovers to Mizzou’s zero. I’d be skeptical of the win even if James Franklin hadn’t been injured, and by the way, he’s out for the year (again). This is a top-15 team with a backup QB? Voters moving this team up eleven spots is one of the all-time overreactions in poll history. Florida is an extremely tough out this week.

24) Fresno State

Fresno will beat UNLV this week without incident, don’t let the records tell you otherwise. As I’ve said before, though, much of this team’s fate will come down to the defense. It’s terrible, even when playing bad teams. The Bulldogs will not be able to finish in the top 16 (required for BCS eligibility) if they can’t convince both the voters and the computers they have a reasonably good defense. This week would be a great time to start holding teams to fewer points and looking big-picture. The difference between 55-40 and 42-10 is huge; if Fresno can dial down the scoring a little to help out their own D it would be very helpful.

25) Oregon State

No, Sean Mannion is not one of the best QB’s in the nation and no, Brandin Cooks is not the best receiver in the nation. But what they are is good. Good enough to beat the middling competition OSU has faced to this point and certainly good enough to tear poor Cal a new one this week. Can you imagine this passing attack against the Bears’ last-ranked defense? This might not be suitable for children. Of course, the schedule gets MUCH harder after this, but give the Beavers credit for doing what they should have done – mostly – against inferior opposition. Seriously, though, can Storm Woods get some help?

Pac-12 Report

Not a bad week in the Pac-12 entertainment-wise, although it was not particularly successful in the way of advancing the conference’s best interests. Oregon beating Washington convincingly was nice and kept the Ducks in the title chase, but you know what’s better than one team capable of winning it all? That’s right, two! Stanford gave us a dud at Rice-Eccles, though, so we’re realistically down to UO or bust for the Pac-12. That’s got to be a tough one for some fans to swallow.

Long-term the Utah win was more harmful than helpful to the conference at large. The same cannot be said of USC’s win over Arizona Thursday night. That was both a short-term victory to get the team believing again and a long-term win for the Trojans and the Pac-12. It’s no secret that a good SC team makes for a stronger league and that’s exactly what the Trojans were, jumping out to a 38-17 lead before conceding two scores to make the game closer than it needed to be. The Trojans played fast, loose and aggressive – hardly hallmarks of the Lane Kiffin era – looking like the clearly superior team. We still have a lot of football to be played. I’d bet USC will play some kind of role in determining the South champion yet.

All three of the night games ended up as blowouts, though Oregon State didn’t pull away until late. Arizona State predictably squashed Colorado early. There isn’t much to talk about there. UCLA was never really in trouble against Cal, but the Bruins failed to pull away when they should have. They’ll need a better effort against Stanford. OSU and WSU played a tight, back-and-forth game for three quarters that abruptly ended on four consecutive Cougars turnovers, all of which the Beavers cashed in. That swing made the score look a little more lopsided than the game was, but I don’t think there’s any doubt the Beavs were the better team.

Now, about Stanford… I kept jumping back to the Cardinal – Utes matchup expecting a Stanford run. Some kind of long drive that crushed Utah’s spirits, or a big turnover to swing momentum, perhaps. I thought they had it on the opening possession of the second half when Travis Wilson made his only mistake, a pick in the red zone. Surely Stanford would tie the game (21-14 Utah at that point) and take control, right? It never happened. The reality is this: after the Cardinal scored on their opening possession and ran Utah’s kickoff back following the tying score, they only put points on the board one more time. Even that was a likely incompletion out of bounds in the fourth quarter with the Utes up 13. The offense simply wasn’t there for Stanford.

That’s nothing new if you’ve watched this team at all over the past two seasons. Stanford generally grinds things out and gets enough good play from its defense to win games. When they lose the turnover battle (as they did against Utah, with two fumbles) they have a hard time winning. Where would the Cardinal be without WR Ty Montgomery this year? He not only has two kickoff return TD’s in two weeks, he’s the offense’s only decent playmaker, with more than twice as many catches as the next closest player. Kevin Hogan has proved to be more game manager than star – which is fine if the defense and ground game are rolling. But he, and the rest of the Stanford team, will need to find last season’s spark to challenge for a Pac-12 title.

That’s not to take anything away from Utah, who played a marvelous game, particularly on defense The Utes held Stanford to just 143 rushing yards, denying the Cardinal the ammunition for their devastating play-action fakes. The semi-no-huddle Utah employs also gave Stanford problems, as defenders looked a step slower than usual. It’s obvious that frustrating close losses to OSU and UCLA to start the conference season pushed this team over the top in an emotional (and unusual) third consecutive home Pac-12 contest. The next two weeks the Utes visit South rivals Arizona and USC, so we’ll see if they can continue to be a factor in the division race.

Finally, there’s that Oregon – Washington game (side note: don’t call this the “Border War.” That’s Kansas – Missouri. Not every rivalry needs a nickname). First, the positives for UW. The Huskies are better this season than any other in the Sarkisian era. Past Washington teams would have folded against this Oregon squad. Keith Price is the best QB they’ve had in Seattle since Marques Tuiasosopo and, more importantly, the defense is no longer a liability. In fact, it’s actually pretty good. Offensively, the decision to copycat the spread trend seems to have been a great one; UW’s playmakers, while not on the level of Oregon’s, are better than the Ducks’ defense made them look.

However, what Saturday’s result showed was more or less what I expected from both teams. Despite clear improvement on offense, the Huskies still don’t have the horses to keep up with Oregon’s relentless pace. Against an exceptional defense, Washington was hemmed in by UO's superior secondary and forced to settle for short throws and a steady diet of runs. RB Bishop Sankey proved his mettle with a thoroughbred-esque effort, but there’s only a handful of teams Oregon can’t eventually force to the air and UW isn’t one of them. Defensively, the Dawgs had neither the front-line talent nor the depth to stop UO from eventually pulling away. Like many good units before them, they held tight for a half, then got gassed.

For Washington, it means an end to any realistic shot at the Pac-12 championship. For Oregon, it means the run is just beginning. The Ducks proved to have a better offense and defense than most analysts suggested heading into the game, though UW did have success with the power run. That’s the formula that’s worked against this team in the past and while it didn’t result in a win this week, that doesn’t mean it can’t in the future. UO also had some tackling issues that will need to be cleaned up. On the positive side (other than the win, obviously), Oregon did a great job through the air on both offense and defense. The Ducks had two receivers reach 100 yards and held the Huskies to 182 yards passing a week after looking shaky against Colorado. With a massive yardage edge and timely big plays, Oregon gave a fine performance overall.

All 12 conference teams are in action again this week, although this time there are a pair of non-league games. First, there’s Colorado, who scheduled Charleston Southern as a replacement for the flooded-out Fresno State contest. When I saw this announcement I just had to shake my head. Why, why, why would CU pick THIS team? The Buccaneers are 7-0 and ranked 24th in the FCS poll. They could very possibly come into Boulder and beat the Buffaloes. For a squad as desperate as Colorado is for a win, this is potentially disastrous. I hope they don’t regret the decision to play this game.

The other non-conference game is USC at Notre Dame in the annual matchup of two disappointing teams. It’s very hard to know what to make of this game or the Trojans and Fighting Irish in general. We know Notre Dame isn’t that good – they lost to Michigan and Oklahoma and nearly went down to Purdue. Then again, the Irish did manage to beat both Michigan State’s great defense and Arizona State’s great offense. Notre Dame this year seems to be an amorphous jack-of-all-trades, capable of playing with most opponents but also always close to defeat. And which USC team will show up? The one embarrassed by WSU’s defense and ASU’s offense, or the one looking like a squad on the rebound after a coaching change? I could believe either side winning close or in a blowout.

The three games I feel reasonably comfortable picking is the trio of night matchups: Utah at Arizona, Washington State at Oregon and Oregon State at Cal. Arizona’s not horrible, but after watching Utah finally break through this week it’s hard to go against the Utes, even in Tucson. Zona has one of the nation’s best rushing attacks but is inept passing and won’t be able to simply run the ball down Utah’s throat all game. Although statistically the Wildcats have the superior defense the numbers are deceptive, as the Utes’ have come against one of the nation’s toughest schedules to date. Arizona has lost both games it played against moderately competent teams. The visitors should take this one.

Wazzu shouldn’t have lost to Oregon State by four scores, but that’s the risk you run when you play a style as aggressive as the one Mike Leach favors. Expect more of the same this week against the Ducks, who boast a stronger secondary (and overall defense) than the Beavers and get the benefit of playing at home. However, I wouldn’t be surprised to see the Cougars’ defense hang in there for a quarter or two; this unit is much improved and wasn’t to blame for the avalanche of poor field position the WSU offense put them in last week. Oregon will win the game handily, but Wazzu will put some points up.

Oregon State has to play a red-eye game for the second straight week on the road. Fortunately for the Beavs, it’s against Cal, so there’s not too much to be worried about. I have sneaking suspicion Sean Mannion’s school-record performance against Wazzu is going to last for all of one week, as this game matches the country’s number one passing attack with its worst scoring defense. Something’s gotta give. It’s not OSU. With their own strong passing game the Bears could conceivably keep this close into the fourth quarter like WSU did, but you have to remember that Cal’s defense is so much worse than the Cougars’. Oregon State should have this in hand fairly quickly.

The two afternoon games are the ones you need to keep an eye on. UCLA versus Stanford should make for great viewing, but don’t sleep on Washington at ASU. Arizona State is the only unranked team of the four and with a win, the Sun Devils would assuredly leap back into the top 25. So first, to Palo Alto. Stanford is rightfully bemoaning the missed opportunities they had that would have stolen a second straight conference win. However, with the way this team plays, such a slip-up was inevitable. By margin of close games, Stanford was the luckiest team in the country last year. Eventually that luck was going to run out. Back at home against a UCLA team I’m pretty sure is very overrated, though, I’m going with the Cardinal.

UCLA is tricky because of what the Bruins’ final scores have looked like. When you’re routinely putting up 35+ and holding opponents to less than 20 everyone thinks you’re world-beaters. But have you actually seen this team play? The scoring has dipped since entering conference play and the offensive line, while adequate to this point, is going to get devoured by a quality front seven (hello, Stanford). The skill players are also far less imposing than last year, when the likes of Joe Fauria and Johnathan Franklin roamed the sideline. The catalyst has been the excellent Brett Hundley, but as good as he is he won’t win games by himself in this league. While the defensive front has been stout, the secondary is highly questionable. Any QB worth his salt – remember, this is the Pac-12 – is going to have a field day with them.

Washington at ASU is more difficult to pick. The Huskies and Sun Devils are both significantly better at home and Tempe isn’t an easy place to play under any circumstances. With a 3:00 p.m. local kickoff and the forecast in the 80’s, the job gets even harder. I don’t think there’s any doubt UW is the better team. After all, the Huskies just went toe-to-toe with the two best teams in the conference and didn’t get embarrassed. However, as I’ve said before, the better team doesn’t always win, something ASU knows all about. The Sun Devils should have beaten Notre Dame and probably should have lost to Wisconsin this year. So how will this play out?

It’s fair to say U-Dub will be focused and angry after losing to the Cardinal and Ducks. What’s more, this is essentially the season for this team – lose three straight in league play and you can say goodbye to a quality bowl. With Oregon State and UCLA still on the schedule, Washington simply cannot afford to lose this game. ASU’s position is much more enviable: at 2-1, with Stanford already out of the way and no Oregon on the menu, the Sun Devils can lose this game and still control their destiny in the South. In fact, by winning out ASU would almost be assured of a spot in the Pac-12 Championship, unless you think UCLA is going to beat both Stanford AND Oregon on the road. Safe to say, there’s a lot more riding on this for the Dawgs.

In the end, I think UW is simply the better team. ASU scores more, but the offenses are basically a push and Washington’s defense is far better. After facing Oregon’s spread last week, ASU should feel like the JV. It’s not a lock by any means, but the Huskies are due to finally break through with a big road win. They’ve had home success under Sarkisian, now it’s time for it to extend out of Seattle. This team has a toughness we’ve not seen out of Washington squads in recent years and I’ll take UW in this game.

Heisman Watch

We’re still only halfway through the season, so it feels wrong to be tossing names out who may fizzle by year’s end. Still… here are the best candidates thus far for college football’s top honor. Keep an eye on the ACC showdown. It may end up deciding a league, a national title AND a Heisman.

Marcus Mariota, QB, Oregon

Mariota delivered in the first test for Oregon in 2013. His numbers are superb, but he makes out even better on the eye test.

Tajh Boyd, QB, Clemson

Don’t pin Clemson’s anemic effort against Boston College on him. Boyd went 30-44 for 344 yards and didn’t throw a pick.

Jameis Winston, QB, Florida State

Winston has completed 90 of his first 123 collegiate pass attempts (73 percent) with 17 TD’s and just two INT’s.
  
Random Thoughts and Observations

Given that we’ve now seen a wonderful seven weeks of football, it seemed fitting to go back and evaluate how accurate my big predictions or smaller feelings about the season have been. Some of these are still a work in progress, but I’ll look for as many as possible. I’ll start with my worst predictions and work up to the best ones.

My biggest miscalculation was assuming that FSU would be in (slight) rebuild mode with the loss of QB E.J. Manuel. I thought the Seminoles would be in for a rough time with a first-year player behind center. That clearly hasn’t been the case, as Jameis Winston has taken the country by storm. I also missed out on UCLA and Utah. I predicted both teams would be worse to some degree and said USC would win the Pac-12 South. That may still come true (and UCLA still could be overrated), but right now it seems less likely.

Staying in the Pac-12, I had Oregon State and Washington flipped. I expected OSU to pick up where they left off last year and they haven’t; UW has been the clear leader of the conference’s second-tier. It’s not a huge error considering I had the Beavers third and the Huskies fourth (in the division), but I was off. I had similar luck with LSU, whom I proclaimed a cut below the truly elite teams in the country. Once again I was close: LSU definitely IS an elite team, but their defense is not, which is what I thought would cost them a shot at the BCS title.

I said Stanford would be a good but not elite squad, which as of last weekend seems to be true. However, there’s still a lot of games left and the Cardinal may prove me wrong. My strangest call was picking Texas to win the Big 12 but lose multiple games. A few weeks ago the Longhorns looked ready to fire their coach and collapse. After the Red River upset, they’re leading the conference at 3-0. Who cares about those losses to Ole Miss and BYU now?!

Finally, my best call was that Florida would not be a contender. They wouldn’t have been even with Jeff Driskel still at QB, as the offense has been just atrocious. The Gators are ranked outside the top 100 in passing and are only in the middle of the pack in rushing. If not for their continued superb defense, this team would be in real trouble. My skepticism of the preseason top-15 ranking has been validated.

Whilst scouring the internet for fan reactions to Saturday’s results (always an important exercise to understand how teams are REALLY viewed), I came across many Washington fans whose position was that, because Stanford had lost to Utah, their close loss to the Cardinal the week before was invalidated. This is the kind of incorrect logic that is all too common in football. Teams don’t have a numerical value of quality that is the end-all in determining whether they win or lose. If that was the case Alabama would never lose. Matchups are far more important than people seem to realize. They explain why Oregon could beat Washington by 21 when Stanford beat them by three, or how Auburn could score 30 on Ole Miss when Alabama scored only 25. Auburn’s not better than Alabama. We know that.

What’s more, games don’t happen in a vacuum week-to-week. Washington’s close loss the week before exposed weaknesses in the Cardinal’s game and more than likely gave Utah’s coaches ideas for how to best attack Stanford. It’s no surprise the Utes capitalized on the same issues UW did. They had the benefit of a home crowd and useful game film to draw from. To assume Washington is a fraud because the team they softened up lost the next week is a fallacy. Stanford is better than both Washington and Utah, but not so much that they couldn’t have lost to either of them. That’s what we’ve seen the last couple of Saturdays. Stanford’s loss does not mean Washington is a bad team or that UW got “exposed” by affiliation. That argument doesn't bear out.

I apologize for teasing this in the headline and saving it for last, but the Stanzis were flying hot and fast this week! Week Seven had the most individual Stanzis in a single week to date as well as a sighting of the rare, nigh-impossible Double Stanzi! To clarify: a Double Stanzi doesn’t mean both QB’s get one, as the rules clearly state a player must win the game to be eligible. What it does signify is a contest in which both QB’s play poorly enough to be awarded a Stanzi, even though only one can win. That was the case when the Wolverines’ Devin Gardner (Two INT’s, one FUM) and the Nittany Lions’ Christian Hackenberg (Two INT) went toe-to-toe in Happy Valley. What a day for college football! I think I can die happy now. Here are all this week’s winners.

Trevone Boykin, TCU
Opponent: Kansas
Performance: Two INT (one for TD), led FG drive to put game out of reach

A.J. Doyle, Massachusetts
Opponent: Miami (OH)
Performance: Two INT, threw game-winning TD

Keith Wenning, Ball State
Opponent: Kent State
Performance: Two INT (one on goal line, one returned to 1-yard line), threw game-winning TD

Terrel Hunt, Syracuse
Opponent: North Carolina State
Performance: Two INT, led two fourth-quarter TD drives

Corey Robinson, Troy
Opponent: Georgia State
Performance: Two INT (one on goal line, one in red zone), threw game-winning TD

Christian Hackenberg, Penn State
Opponent: Michigan
Performance: Two INT, led tying drive to send game to OT, this

Johnny Manziel, Texas A&M
Opponent: Ole Miss
Performance: One INT (in end zone), one FUM, led game-winning FG drive

2013 Stanzi Awards
Devin Gardner, Michigan: 2
Keith Wenning, Ball State: 2
Connor Wood, Colorado: 1
Logan Thomas, Virginia Tech: 1
Braxton Miller, Ohio State: 1
Corey Robinson, Troy: 1
Johnny Manziel, Texas A&M: 1
Christian Hackenberg, Penn State: 1
Jake Heaps, Kansas: 1
Gary Nova, Rutgers: 1
Trevone Boykin, TCU: 1
Brett Hundley, UCLA: 1
Connor Halliday, WSU: 1
A.J. Doyle, Massachusetts: 1
Justin Worley, Tennessee: 1
Taylor Heinicke, Old Dominion: 1
Terrel Hunt, Syracuse: 1

Keith Wenning of Ball State has made his move! Gardner was oh-so-close to taking the lead again with his third award, but was turned back thanks to the determined effort of Hackenberg. I can’t wait to see what next week brings.


Speaking of, here’s what to watch: UCF – Louisville (Friday), Minnesota – Northwestern, Texas Tech – West Virginia, Florida – Mizzou, UCLA – Stanford, Indiana – Michigan, Auburn – Texas A&M, Washington – ASU, USC – Notre Dame and of course, Florida State – Clemson. That'll be a doozy.

Wednesday, October 9, 2013

Beware the AAC

A fun week for stats doesn’t always translate into great football. Case in point: the top three teams in the polls put up 45, 49 and 57, respectively, against patsies. At least Oregon and Clemson went on the road for conference games, unlike Alabama. Syracuse and Colorado are far from legitimate threats, but they’re still more respectable than a game against transitioning FBS member Georgia State. Really Alabama, Chattanooga wasn’t enough? You needed a second FCS team on the schedule? The Virginia Tech game only buys you so much leeway.

The question of the week is how to quantify quality wins. For example, both Ohio State and Stanford beat ranked opponents, but both teams were clearly better than then their counterparts. Obviously, beating a ranked team is more impressive than beating an unranked team, but the Buckeyes and Cardinal were favored – they were expected to win. Ultimately, it comes down to making the most reasonable, yet still subjective, judgment based on the facts we already know about other teams and conferences.

For example: the Big Ten is bad. Period. There’s no way around it. Among BCS conferences, which includes the American this year, it ranks at least fourth, possibly fifth behind the Big 12 (which has some issues of its own). We know this is a fact because of the Big Ten’s performance all last season and the first month of this one in non-conference and bowl games. The Big 12 has weakened since last season. We also know this to be true because of the league’s pitiful showing in September compared to the quality it demonstrated in 2012.

Despite some bumpy contests and noticeable chinks in the armor the SEC is still the most powerful league. No other conference has as many legitimate BCS title threats (that would be three – Alabama, Georgia and LSU) or as strong a second tier (Texas A&M, South Carolina, Florida). The Pac-12 is the clear runner-up. Oregon and Stanford are a very respectable ruling class, while Washington and UCLA (and possibly Oregon State and ASU) make up a solid middle.

As such, a Pac-12 win has to count for more than a Big Ten win when the defeated teams are of a relatively similar standing – as Washington and Northwestern were. Stanford gets more points this week, even though their win was at home. The Big Ten hasn’t done enough to earn trust in that regard. What’s more, we’ve seen this movie before: in 2012 Ohio State escaped multiple times against mediocre conference foes and ran the table. If the Big Ten is just as bad as it was last season – which it seems is the case – then we have to stay skeptical about OSU’s credentials.

Regardless, there was a lot of good football outside of the scattered blowouts. Both the aforementioned Washington – Stanford and Ohio State – Northwestern games were a lot of fun (and showed that perhaps the winning teams have some work to do). Oklahoma State won a wild, back-and-forth affair with K-State, while Miami (FL) survived a shootout with Georgia Tech. However, for the second week in a row it was Georgia who played – and won – the most exciting game in the nation, this time on the road at rival Tennessee in overtime. The SEC also saw Auburn outlast Ole Miss and Mississippi State throw a scare into LSU. Big 12 front-runner Oklahoma also barely escaped another conference opponent in TCU, while Notre Dame, the team the Sooners beat last week, topped Arizona State in a thriller in Arlington.

As the conference season matures we’ll get a better idea of how the final standings will shake out. That starts next week with several key matchups. Rutgers meets Louisville on Thursday night in a game that could decide the AAC. The Red River Shootout (not letting it die) kicks off Saturday morning. Florida at LSU headlines the midday slate, which is chock-full of greatness: Northwestern – Wisconsin, Baylor – Kansas State and Oregon – Washington. The day ends with some lesser, but still important conference showdowns in Texas A&M at Ole Miss and Oregon State at Washington State.

The top 25 needs a few adjustments after the most recent games. Remember that regardless of whether teams keep winning they also have to show improvement and impress in relation to other teams. That’s why this week sees the first significant changes in my rankings.

Top 25

1) Clemson

Clemson’s hold on my top spot hasn’t changed, even though the victory over Virginia Tech is looking more like a quality win every week for Alabama. The fact that Ole Miss lost again took the air out of that win, but the main culprit is the Crimson Tide’s own schedule. Clemson’s win over Syracuse doesn’t go down as a big feather in the Tigers’ cap, but the Orange are significantly better than the Georgia State team ‘Bama beat. Clemson’s win over Georgia is still the most valuable victory by any team. They remain on top.

2) Alabama

Ole Miss’ loss at Auburn didn’t do much to instill confidence in the Tide, who continue to give off a very subdued air. I remain convinced this is the most talented team in the country, but they’re not really playing like it. Nick Saban would be the first person to say nothing is handed to anyone, even Alabama. The Tide’s next three opponents are pitiful, so it’s going to be hard to move them up even with impressive wins. Perhaps ‘Bama should focus instead on the allegations of illegal benefits to players.

3) Florida State

FSU only has wins over Maryland and Pitt to really boast about, but it’s how good the Seminoles have looked outside of the stats that earns them this spot. This team hasn’t been held to fewer than 40 points by any opponent, sure. They’re third in both scoring and scoring defense, which is great. However, FSU has simply looked fantastic, like one of the great Seminoles teams of old, dominating at every level en route to the current 5-0 record. Jameis Winston has been a revelation, providing a definitive answer to the only significant question the team had entering the year.

4) Stanford

I don’t think Stanford is the fourth-best team in the country, but the blowout of Arizona State and win over Washington have to be rewarded. At the very least those are better teams than any Oregon has played. Even though the Cardinal haven’t been overly impressive, the schedule has to count for something. Moving forward, this squad needs to show an ability to move the ball a little more consistently, something that was a problem against UW. I don’t expect the trip to Utah this week to be particularly dangerous, though.

5) Oregon

The Ducks have been the nation’s most impressive team but have played a very weak set of opponents. As great as UO has been, there’s a legitimate fear that the dominance won’t continue once the schedule ramps up, which it will this week at Seattle. Unlike Stanford, the Ducks don’t get all of their toughest games at home. Trips to Washington and Palo Alto will test the mettle of this team far more than the meager competition to this point. Now, if the Huskies are just another blowout, we’ll have something to talk about.

6) Georgia

Whew. Though the Bulldogs did come out ahead on the scoreboard against Tennessee (thanks to some very timely and fortunate plays), it’s hard not to look at the rivalry game with the Vols as a net loss. UGA lost RB Keith Marshall and WR Justin Scott-Wesley for the season after having already lost multiple other players for significant time. The SEC season might very well come down to a game of attrition for this team. While I don’t foresee losses to Mizzou (overrated) or Vandy, just winning the East is going to be a major task for Georgia.

7) Ohio State

First, congratulations are in order to the Buckeyes. Beating a top-25 team on the road is no cakewalk. However, the result won’t end up helping OSU much in the polls. It shouldn’t Everyone saw the same thing in Evanston: Ohio State played pretty much evenly by a team who should not have had the horses to keep up. At times the Bucks struggled to move the ball and most of the game the Wildcats had no trouble shredding the OSU defense. For a team that’s allegedly one of the nation’s elite, the performance wasn’t convincing.

8) LSU

Georgia hangover or not, those first three quarters against Mississippi State were… troubling. The same Bulldogs who managed merely a field goal against Oklahoma State piled up more than 450 yards and 26 points on the LSU defense despite a fourth-quarter shutout. It’s good to see the Tigers racking up the passing yards for once, but come on. This game shouldn’t have been close. Florida’s defense is a lot better than MSU’s and LSU will need to play a lot better to beat the Gators this week, even in Death Valley.

9) Louisville

Temple’s terrible, so… 30-7? Eh, I’ll allow it. It wasn’t as if the Owls were ever capable of really making it a game. To the unending relief of college football fans, Louisville finally plays an opponent worth something this Thursday. No, Rutgers (at home) isn’t the same as Alabama or Oregon coming to town, but at least the Scarlet Knights are better than the garbage this team has been cleaning up every week. The next game against UCF might actually prove to be more significant for the AAC standings, though.

10) South Carolina

South Carolina is tough to rank, because I really want to punish the Gamecocks for winning close against subpar competition. However, the key word there is “win,” and that’s what this team has been doing. The whole Jadeveon Clowney situation is a bit strange, but it honestly might not matter if he is hurt (or not) against upcoming opponents Arkansas, Tennessee, Mizzou and Mississippi State. Late-season matchups with Florida and Clemson seem a little ominous at this point, though, so it’d be good for everyone to make nice while the schedule is still forgiving.

11) Texas A&M

I remain unconvinced that A&M is an elite team, though given Ole Miss’ struggles I’m not predicting much trouble with the Rebels this week. It’s the 30 points per game allowed that worries me; relying on the offense to bail you out every week is not a sustainable football plan. The fact that the Aggies are playing a cupcake schedule (eight home games in two four-week stints) will help. The most likely scenario is still around nine or ten wins, but with that D playing the way it is I think someone will trip this team up along the way.

12) Oklahoma

The Sooners probably should have been able to put TCU away a little earlier. OU dominated the Horned Frogs for much of the game but still only led by three with two minutes left. If this is the Big 12’s best team the conference is in potentially disastrous shape. I like the Sooners, but TCU is playing with a backup quarterback and has been somewhat of a disappointment in 2013. The Red River Shootout is going to be very fun this week given that OU might be able to get Mack Brown fired. Is that what they really want, though?

13) Miami (FL)

Give credit to the Hurricanes. Down 17-7 after the first quarter, Miami responded, holding Georgia Tech to only six more points until a meaningless garbage-time touchdown. This was the kind of performance I needed to see from the ‘Canes, who couldn’t coast on the Florida win forever. Winning by double digits despite four turnovers? That’s impressive. The North Carolina game no longer looks like the showdown it promised to be in the preseason, though Miami must still keep winning to keep pace with surging Virginia Tech in the division race.

14) Washington

I was impressed with the Huskies’ performance at Stanford and not because I think the Cardinal are world-beaters. Independent of the opposition, Washington looked good, dominating on offense and defense. Ah, but those special teams. UW got killed in the crucial third phase and lost the game because of it. I would be surprised to see the Huskies beat Oregon this week because of the difficulty of playing two top teams in a one-week span. Nevertheless, Washington appears to clearly be the third-best squad in the conference.

15) Florida

The trip to LSU this week will probably mark the beginning of the end for any kind of SEC run. I’d be surprised to see this limited team knock off the Tigers in Death Valley and even if they did they’d still need to beat Georgia AND South Carolina in November. There is reason for hope – Georgia did just struggle to beat the same Tennessee team the Gators already handled – but with this offense you can’t realistically expect UF to repeat the double-digit wins they reeled off in 2012. Even overrated Mizzou might give this team problems.

16) UCLA

The Bruins’ performance at Utah Thursday night was very disappointing. People with blinders on will point to a road conference win against a decent foe as a positive, but the reality is this game was anything but. UCLA looked out of sorts on offense and didn’t really do anything defensively to engender optimism. The six interceptions were, quite frankly, a lie: five of them came on fluky deflected balls that went straight to defenders. Even with the giant turnover margin, the Utes nearly sent the game to overtime. This team isn’t great.

17) Michigan

A dominant second half against Minnesota has the Wolverines thinking big once again. They should, as Saturday’s game seemingly got Big Blue back on a collision course with Ohio State. However, as promising as that game was, it doesn’t erase memories of the previous two games. Michigan has to earn its way back into my trust one game at a time, not in one quick (but impressive) stroke. The Minnesota game was a great start. This week’s road trip to a maybe-worse-than-we-thought Penn State squad will tell more.

18) Texas Tech

I have to take a bit of a leap of faith with Texas Tech. Everyone knew the Red Raiders would put up a million on Kansas and they’ll likely have no trouble with Iowa State or West Virginia. Can they play with Oklahoma, though? Oklahoma State? That’s the big question for this team. Unfortunately, we won’t really have any indication until the actual games. The Big 12 is too much of a mess to make sense of this year. The good news for TTU is that Baker Mayfield should return at some point, as his injury has not been deemed season-ending.

19) Virginia Tech

The horrendous offense being played in Blacksburg scares me. There’s always potential for VT to lay an egg when only one side of the ball is producing. The Hokies are close to being 3-3 and a completely lost cause. Yet there’s a method to the madness of Beamerball and it’s worth noting that, regardless of the close calls, Tech has reeled off five straight after the opening loss to ‘Bama. This is a legitimate contender for the Coastal Division in an ACC that has beefed up seemingly overnight. With no Clemson or Florida State on the schedule, watch out.

20) Nebraska

Virginia Tech’s polar opposite lies in Lincoln, where the Cornhuskers are all about offense. Nebraska loves all forms of offense, including that of its opponents, which explains why the ‘Huskers defensive philosophy amounts to a merry wave as ballcarriers go speeding by. To be fair, the team did play well versus Illinois last week and should have a decent time this Saturday against hapless Purdue. After that the sked gets a tad trickier, with Minnesota, Northwestern and Michigan. Taylor Martinez’ health will be critical as the season moves along.

21) Oklahoma State

You can make the argument that Okie State is a bad game against West Virginia from being undefeated… but that would leave out the other side of the coin, last Saturday's great escape from Kansas State. Honestly, OSU hasn’t been great either of the past two weeks. The only difference was the venue; playing the Wildcats at home versus the Mountaineers in faraway Morgantown makes for a striking change. This is a very good week for the Cowboys to be idle and address some issues, such as why a QB is leading the team in rushing.

22) Northwestern

Give the Wildcats credit for nearly beating Ohio State, but even though the 10-point margin wasn’t indicative of the competitiveness of the contest it was quite clear which team had the edge in talent. The Buckeyes self-destructed with critical mistakes, fumbled in both red zones and still had enough to pull out the victory. While I’ll keep Northwestern in my rankings, I don’t this this game showed the Wildcats are near OSU’s elite level; instead, it showed Ohio State is actually a lot closer to Northwestern than we thought. More on this fallacy later.

23) Fresno State

For the first time in 2013 the Bulldogs managed to hold a giant lead. Granted, it was against Idaho, but a small victory is still a victory. The rap on Fresno is that it’s an air-it-out all-the-time offense, but that’s not really accurate: the team averages a respectable 164 yards per game on the ground. The only major weakness – which I’ve mentioned before – is the D, ranked in the bottom quarter of the country even after holding the Vandals to 14 points. The road trips to San Diego State and Wyoming (in particular) are the biggest stumbling blocks remaining.

In all honesty, no other teams deserve to be ranked. To fill out the last two spots in my top 25, I offer this melting pot of awfulness:

Notre Dame

The Fighting Irish generally manage to win games, even when they shouldn’t. Close victories over Purdue, Michigan State and ASU attest to that. The argument in favor of the Irish is that both their losses (Michigan, Oklahoma) came to good teams. The argument against is that none of the teams they’ve beaten is good. MSU has a great defense and ASU a solid offense, but neither is close to a complete squad. The best praise I can give is that I would take ND over the rest of the teams here, because they would find a way to win.

Baylor

Baylor is one of the greatest teams in the history of college football. The Bears are leading the country in scoring and passing and are second in rushing, while the defense is 14th in points allowed. QB Bryce Petty and RB Lache Seastrunk are both going to win the Heisman and it’s likely Baylor will go undefeated. Now, for reality: Baylor has played three FBS teams. They haven’t faced a top-75 offense or a top-85 defense (West Virginia: 79th in offense, 89th in defense; Louisiana-Monroe: 99th in offense, 93 in defense; Buffalo: 101st in offense, 101st in defense). Ouch.

Oregon State

The Beavers continue to find new ways to subvert expectations. I’m not saying this is a great team, because it clearly isn’t. The running game is still atrocious and the defense is less than a work in progress. And yet… I kind of like them to go into Pullman and beat WSU, then beat Cal and have a six-game winning streak when Stanford rolls into town. Don’t tell me it wouldn’t be just like the Beavs to kill the Pac-12 by upsetting the Cardinal and losing to USC the next week. Curse you, Riley! Curse youuuuuuuu!

Wisconsin

The winner of the Northwestern showdown in Madison will likely emerge as the only ranked team of the two. The Badgers are in decent shape, thanks to a week off to prepare and a style the Wildcats haven’t seen all season. While people will talk about Wisconsin’s problems defending the fast spread, I think the bigger question is whether Northwestern will be able to handle Bucky’s power. Remember, this team already saw a spread in Ohio State that features much better players than the Wildcats can boast – and the Badgers outgained the Buckeyes.

Auburn

It doesn’t feel quite right to say this, but… Auburn… isn’t… bad. There’s not much of a passing game, but the Tigers run the ball well and play decent defense. I wouldn’t put a ton of stock into Saturday’s victory over Ole Miss, but it’s more than most teams have accomplished. Wazzu isn’t terrible either, so the opening win counts for something. What’s more, the LSU loss (35-21) was respectable. With eight home games (SEC scheduling: Wheeeeeeee!), Auburn could be one big upset away from actually becoming a player in the West race.

Pac-12 Report

Hey hey! First the first time in 2013 we get all twelve conference teams playing a league opponent in the same week. Colorado at Arizona State! Cal at UCLA! Okay, those aren’t that exciting. But still: Stanford at Utah isn’t bad, OSU at WSU could be entertaining and Arizona at USC (Thursday) promises to be very interesting. The big one is Oregon at Washington, but we’ll get to the upcoming games in a moment. First, a rewind.

I’ll reiterate what I said earlier: UCLA’s win was very disappointing. You can point to the 13 penalties and the fact that it was a midweek game in a hostile environment, but that’s no excuse for turning six interceptions (including five in the second half) into just 17 points. After going up 14-7 the Utes looked dead in the water, but the Bruins never put the game away. I was actually hoping for overtime to teach the team a lesson. As for Travis Wilson, the Utah QB should actually be given a break. It sounds crazy, but of his six picks only one or maybe two was his fault. UCLA got some bizarre tips and deflections, including at least one that went straight off a receiver’s hands. The Utes are probably feeling very frustrated starting 0-2 in conference play, but they shouldn’t be ashamed of their performance against UCLA or Oregon State.

I don’t want to waste time on how ASU managed to blow the Notre Dame game – did I call that or what? – so let’s quickly recap the least competitive game of the week. Oregon gave up several big pass plays early against Colorado, then dominated the rest of the way. As good as the final margin was, the defense in the first quarter was alarming. UO should not feel satisfied with that kind of effort against an overmatched opponent. Other teams (for example, Washington) can and will exploit those lapses far more effectively than the Buffaloes. The Ducks have to play better this week.

Wazzu at Cal was an interesting, competitive game with a deceiving score. Neither team could run the ball whatsoever, but neither cared, so the result was a 1000-yard combined passing effort by the two Air Raid offenses. It’s easy to look at the 22-point win and assume WSU won going away, but that's not the case. Cal outgained the Cougars and had five turnovers, including a pair of awful first-quarter fumbles on the goal line. There’s definitely not a huge gap between the teams, best seen in their collective failure to run the ball with any competency in short-yardage situations. It’s great to be able to throw it all over the place, but at times you need to be able to pick up a couple yards here and there on the ground. Neither the Bears nor Cougs are at that point yet.

The UW – Stanford game was a thing to behold, even if only one offense showed up. It’s actually pretty amazing to think about where Stanford would have been in this game had Washington not allowed a complete meltdown on special teams. That’s not to take away from the win – special teams are as vital as offense and defense – but it needs to be said that UW probably should have won the game. Now, just because they should have won doesn’t make the Huskies the better team. I still think the Cardinal are more talented and match up better against Oregon. What I do think this game showed, though, is that Stanford is closer to Washington that we thought – not the other way around. More on that later.

The easy pick in the Thursday game is USC over Arizona. Teams usually play better in their first game after being “liberated” from a coach and SC’s defense had been superb up until that second-half collapse in Tempe. I’m still not sure the rest of the Trojans’ team is any good at all, however, those fears are negated by the knowledge that Arizona is terrible. At least, their passing game is, which is what the Wildcats will need to stop the Trojans from literally putting all eleven defenders in the box and daring B.J. Denker to complete a pass longer than five yards. Pssst! He can’t!

Surprisingly, the Oregon – Washington showdown is the first Pac-12 game on Saturday. The Ducks are currently favored by two TD’s, which seems high. I certainly have much more respect for UW than I have in a long time. The Huskies offense finally seems to have both competent skill players AND linemen, while the ugly defense has been radically improved under Justin Wilcox (traitor!). The improved recruiting since the Dark Days of Tyrone Willingham has also obviously ratcheted up the talent level of the program, creating defensive depth and allowing UW to competently run an up-tempo offense in 2013. However… I believe UO is still the superior team and find it exceedingly unlikely that the Ducks will lose to a team that is essentially a lower-octane version of themselves. Throw in the fact that Washington is coming off a difficult, emotional game with Stanford and it makes more sense to take Oregon by a couple scores.

Stanford and Utah makes for a fun matchup of teams opening up their offenses this season. The Cardinal have started tossing the ball downfield consistently for the first time in several seasons (Andrew Luck doesn’t count, his WR’s were awful), while the Utes have finally found a triggerman who can stay healthy for their spread. I like this Utah team, which is a couple of bad breaks from being 5-0, but Stanford is too imposing to pick against, even on the road. Although several of the turnovers against UCLA were fluky, at some point you make your own luck. Stanford’s D is much better than UCLA’s. It’s going to take some major mistakes by the Cardinal (something they usually excel at avoiding) for Utah to pull the upset.

Colorado at ASU is relegated to an evening kick-off on the Pac-12 Network because, let’s face it, no one wants to see this game. Arizona State is better than CU, but not in a very impressive or entertaining way. The Sun Devils have also been very sloppy this season, as opposed to the clean and efficient way they started the Todd Graham era. As I predicted before the season, Colorado is improved, but not so much that it really shows on the scoreboard. I don’t have a lot of faith in ASU right now, but I have even less in the Buffaloes. In Tempe this should be a comfortable win for the Fork.

Cal and UCLA is another late game, although for some reason it's taking place on the ESPN family of networks (presumably because East Coast insomniacs love bad football). After last week’s semi-exposing, I’m tempted to say the Bruins are on upset alert. But Cal is so bad. I can’t do it. I do expect the Golden Bears to be able to move the ball after watching Utah do so fairly regularly, but the question is whether Cal will turn it over like the Utes did last week (and they themselves did versus WSU). In the end, it’s doubtful the Bears' defense will be able to slow down UCLA for too long. Despite some nagging questions from the Utah game, UCLA is a safe bet.

The final night game sees Oregon State take on WSU in Pullman for the first time since 2009. The matchup features a battle of the 121st (OSU) and 122nd (WSU) rushing attacks in major college football, so get ready for around 150 pass attempts Saturday. Mike Leach has done a nice job improving the Cougars in a short time frame, particularly the woeful defense. Still, I’m surprised to see Wazzu favored in this game. I have a healthy respect for the nastiness of the Palouse and the game will likely be played in near-freezing temperatures, but… Oregon State, despite the rocky start to the season, is simply better. The Beavers are getting a few guys back from injury, are rested after a bye and generally play THIS kind of spread very well. Cougs QB Connor Halliday doesn’t scare anyone with his feet, so the OSU kryptonite isn’t in play here. I don’t expect Wazzu to be shut out, but I’ll go with Oregon State.

Heisman Watch

With a dearth of dominant, game-changing defensive linemen and versatile, every-down backs, this list has unfortunately become a roll call of power-program QB’s. I have to call it like I see it. On that note, I think it’s best if I leave Texas A&M’s Johnny Manziel out this season, not because he’s not going to produce, but because there’s just no way the Heisman voters are going to let him near the award again. Fair or not, those folks are sticklers about certain things. I want to be realistic about this.

Tajh Boyd, QB, Clemson

Boyd’s numbers against Syracuse: 20-27, 455 yards, five TD’s. He threw two picks, but dang.

Aaron Murray, QB, Georgia

Given how decimated UGA’s offense is, Murray might be the most deserving player by the end of the year.

Marcus Mariota, QB, Oregon

Mariota threw five TD passes, ran for two more and hasn’t turned the ball over this season. Incredible.

Jameis Winston, QB, Florida State

My choice for the Heisman to this point, Winston has actually outperformed his outlandish hype.

Random Thoughts and Observations

We’ll start with the Stanzis this week.

Taylor Heinicke, Old Dominion
Opponent: Liberty
Performance: Two INT, led game-winning TD drive

Braxton Miller, Ohio State
Opponent: Northwestern
Performance: Two FUM, one INT, led game-winning TD drive

Brett Hundley, UCLA
Opponent: Utah
Performance: One INT (for TD), one FUM (recovered himself), ran for game-winning TD

(As with Justin Worley last week, Hundley’s performance wasn’t a “true” Stanzi in that he recovered his own fumble. However, he was called for grounding on a play that turned a potential clinching TD into a FG and threw a horrendous pick-six that tied the game late. He deserves to be on the list.)

2013 Stanzi Awards
Devin Gardner, Michigan: 2
Connor Wood, Colorado: 1
Logan Thomas, Virginia Tech: 1
Braxton Miller, Ohio State: 1
Keith Wenning, Ball State: 1
Jake Heaps, Kansas: 1
Gary Nova, Rutgers: 1
Brett Hundley, UCLA: 1
Connor Halliday, WSU: 1
Justin Worley, Tennessee: 1
Taylor Heinicke, Old Dominion: 1

It was looking like a banner week for the maligned Pac-12 refs through most of the weekend’s games. Faced with several tough calls in the UCLA – Utah game, the crew (I can’t find out which one it was) unflinchingly upheld a couple of wacky interceptions and a crucial onside kick. The rest of the weekend passed by without incident until… the incompletion that ended the Washington – Stanford game. It was a hard call, no question. I personally thought the ball did hit the ground. However, for a pass that was ruled a completion on the field, the replays shown certainly did not provide conclusive evidence that the call should have been overturned. It was the one sour note in an otherwise very good weekend for Pac-12 refs. Try again next week, guys.

An interesting part of the SEC’s recent run of dominance has been the league’s de facto classes, which have divided the conference into tiers that all help it maintain its reputation. The SEC has seen an unusually long period with a distinct lower class, one of the secrets to its success. This is represented by teams like Vanderbilt, Kentucky, Ole Miss and (usually) Mississippi State. These squads are not just bad; they’ve also served as punching bags for the rest of the teams. It helps a conference immensely when three or four teams every year don’t have a single league win outside of their own weak group. This allows the middle tier of the conference to load up on cheap wins while still losing, in turn, to the upper class, which carries the reputation of the league. It’s no shock that when the Pac-12 became the second-best conference last season, it featured a trio of teams – Colorado, Cal and Wazzu – that went a combined 1-22 against the rest of the league. You want your conference to be strong, but the truth is that the best-case scenario is actually to have a class of terrible teams for everyone else to beat up. The SEC's run has been buoyed by a strangely consistent bottom tier for the past several seasons.

There's a logical fallacy based on assumption that tends to pervade college football. This was never more evident than this weekend, when Washington played at Stanford and Ohio State went to Northwestern. The belief is that Ohio State and Stanford are both elite teams, therefore Washington and Northwestern must also be very good for competing so closely with them. However, this quickly becomes a circular argument: Team A is good because it lost a close game to Team B, and Team B is good because it beat Team A. What if neither team is good? That’s the scary thing for which the polls cannot account. We have zero evidence that the Buckeyes and Cardinal are great teams – though they very well might be – so we can’t know the Huskies and Wildcats are, either. The problem is that the wins all four schools accumulated to this point were essentially in a vacuum, as none of them has a win (prior to this week) against a currently ranked opponent. I’m less skeptical of the Pac-12 duo because the Pac-12 is simply a better conference, but there’s still the possibility that all four schools are overrated.

After hearing Washington coach Steve Sarkisian complain that Stanford was faking injuries, Cardinal coach David Shaw fired back with some fightin’ words: “We don’t fake injuries. We never have and we never will.” All right, maybe “fighting” was too strong a term. It does seem like the start of a delightful new rivalry in the Pac-12; fans of both schools are well on their way to crackin’ wise about each other's mommas. In general, I dislike coaches criticizing other teams, but Sark does have history on his side in this case. I don’t think Stanford should be getting the benefit of the doubt on this subject, regardless of how indignant Shaw gets.

However, the “fake injury” epidemic is merely a side effect of the NCAA’s failure to properly monitor such activities. My favorite response to faking injury is the one not seen in the Oregon clip above: immediately after Thomas returned to the game, Stanford was hit with a mysterious 15-yard penalty. The refs never explained who the foul was on. The NCAA could mandate that a player who has to leave the game due to injury must sit out the rest of the series. This would be a very fair way to ensure the cheating (because that’s what it is) tactic of faking injuries stops AND would promote player safety for the coaches who say the no-huddle causes injuries (still waiting for a shred of proof on that one). Forcing an injured player to sit out would solve both problems at once, but of course, that’s not what the coaches who dislike the no-huddle are actually after. They want the rules of the game changed to suit their style, a pathetically transparent ploy that, fortunately, the NCAA has seen through.


Next week: The Ohio State – Northwestern – Wisconsin muddle will be figured out, as will the question of whether Washington is “back.” More importantly, though, we’ll get some clarity on how close the AAC is to becoming the worst BCS conference of all time! Current record against non-AAC teams: 18-19. Current record against other BCS teams: 3-12, with wins over Purdue, Kentucky and Penn State (the big one!). Current record against the FCS: 5-3. I knew it was bad, but I didn’t know it was THIS bad. 

Thursday, October 3, 2013

The Thick of It

Mark Saturday, September 28 on the calendar, because it was a day to remember for college football. It wasn’t just about the great games last weekend; the weather, injuries, statements made and initial coaching changes of the season all combined to make one of the most exciting days the sport has seen in a while. Even though some of the expected showdowns failed to materialize into shootouts – cough, Ole Miss – Saturday still culminated with some very entertaining material. In USC’s case, this was enough to make a move that will have repercussions throughout college football.

I’ll have more on Lane Kiffin’s firing later, but the most important thing is that USC is now looking for a new coach. That might seem like an obvious point, but I really can’t overstate it enough. USC is the second-best head coaching job in America behind Texas. Only Alabama, Michigan and Notre Dame can equal the Trojans’ tradition and none can match SC’s recruiting footprint. Even more important, none of those schools has the aura of USC (Alabama is the only one that comes close): in L.A., acting as “Hollywood’s franchise”, and utterly, utterly cool.

It’s a high-profile, high-pressure job that will have no shortage of applicants. I’d be shocked if USC doesn’t offer the position to Oregon State’s Mike Riley as it did in 2010 when Pete Carroll left, though they’ll likely be rebuffed again. In any case, the man who winds up in charge of the Trojans will probably leave some other school in the lurch (if he doesn’t come from the pro ranks), which could set off a chain reaction of hirings across the country. It’s certainly going to be interesting to see what happens.

On the field, no team did more than Georgia this week (and in turn, Clemson) by defeating LSU in a classic shootout. Yes, there’s the whole “M.I.A. SEC defenses” angle, but that’s really what we’ve seen from the conference on the whole this season. No one is immune to change and it appears offenses in the South have finally caught up to the defenses. Not coincidentally, this is the finest crop of SEC quarterbacks we’ve seen in quite some time. As it turns out, having competent players behind center really does improve your offense. This is something I’ve been saying for years: despite their greatness, SEC defenses have been fortunate to face a long line of mediocre-to-abysmal passers. You CAN have this both ways and the 2013 season is proving it.

With that said, defense isn’t dead in the SEC – see Alabama 25, Ole Miss 0 – or anywhere else. The teams that play the best defense will generally have the best opportunities to win championships. I would actually argue that defense is more important than ever in this age of high-scoring offense. The AFL is an exellent example. I’ve long had a soft spot for the goofiness of Arena Football and have always half-jokingly argued that defense is more important there than any other football league.

That sounds ridiculous given that all you see from the AFL is points, but it’s a completely different game. An Arena field is half the length and width of a regular field – of course there’s going to be more scoring. Lost in all the touchdowns and craziness of the Arena game is how vital defensive stops are. Every offense expects to score every time it possesses the ball. A single stop by the defense can mean the difference between winning and losing. Regular football isn’t at that point yet, but it’s undeniably trending that way and the best NFL offenses have already changed both offensive and defensive game planning. College football has moved in that direction as well. Gone are the days when teams could run the table allowing only one or two TD’s a season. Sometimes even the best defenses get beat. It’s just a matter of finding a way to get that one stop.

Keeping defense in mind, look at what some of the highest-ranked squads did this week. ‘Bama’s shutout was impressive, sure, but so was the way Stanford and Oregon shut down WSU and Cal, respectively. The main selling point for the overmatched Cougars and Bears was their quick-strike offenses. Neither was allowed to get going by the Cardinal and Ducks’ defenses. That’s the sign of a quality team. Also, look out for Virginia Tech. The Hokies have struggled through games post-Alabama but have still managed to stay at one loss. After stuffing a good Georgia Tech offense on Thursday night, VaTech is now in the driver’s seat for the Coastal Division title.

Other things I was impressed by this week: West Virginia bouncing back from that humiliating loss to Maryland by beating the Big 12’s top team was awesome. Okie State didn’t know what hit them. Oklahoma, on the other hand, showed a whole lot of fortitude (the kind conspicuously absent in 2012) by taking down Notre Dame in South Bend. South Carolina powered through the loss of Connor Shaw and beat a quality UCF team on the road. All of these results are taken into account in my rankings.

Top 25

1) Clemson

It was very difficult to decide whether Georgia’s win over LSU or Alabama’s win over Ole Miss should count for more. I went with Georgia’s win – it gives the Bulldogs two wins over top-ten teams, more than any team in the country. Clemson beat that team. Ole Miss is good, but not as good as LSU, South Carolina or Georgia. The Tigers also did what some teams don’t – took care of business – against a bad opponent in Wake Forest. Clemson should remain the number one team for now. With Syracuse and Boston College on the schedule, though, that might change.

2) Alabama

25-0 is hard to turn down. Ole Miss clearly wasn’t ready to face the big boys. It’s for that reason I decided to keep ‘Bama second. Mustering only three first-half field goals didn’t impress me. Of course the D was great, but the Rebels aren’t exactly a point-a-minute offense. The schedule is surprisingly soft for a while, so it’s going to be hard to score points with the voters until the big game with LSU. In the meantime, the Crimson Tide need to shore up that offense. It’s hard to be afraid of a team that can’t score. All the skill talent in the world can't do anything with average blocking.

3) Oregon

The Ducks waltzed past a sloppy Cal team in the Northwest rainstorm, but a test for the secondary might have actually been more beneficial. UO was always going to beat the Bears; what we still don’t know is how the D will fare against an aggressive attack. There’s one game left (Colorado) before the first difficult matchup, at Washington. I’d say the Ducks are still out of the Huskies league, but… it’s honestly hard to tell. Fortunately, there's UW - Stanford this week to clear things up. As good as Oregon has looked, the competition hasn’t been great. That sticks in my mind.

4) Stanford

Stanford gets points for shutting down the Cougars’ aerial assault and doing so without the benefit of the weather. FSU was also a little shaky, so this week sees the Cardinal making a leap into my top five. As for Arizona State… the Sun Devils did score effortlessly on USC a week after getting shut down in Palo Alto. I still don’t think that’s a top-25 team, but it makes Stanford look better. Beating Washington this week would also do that. At home, I don’t think the Huskies have a very good shot. With a win, the Cardinal would probably jump Oregon.

5) Florida State

The Seminoles took a while to take control against Boston College. Bottom line: BC isn’t very good. FSU should be better. They’ll need to be against Maryland. It’s possible this team got caught looking ahead. Understandable, though I can’t see the Terrapins really having a shot. The ‘Noles are just too talented. However, if the defense allows another opponent to hang around, I might need to rethink that position. The BC game wasn’t close because of bad plays by Florida State, it really was competitive. The ACC has improved and FSU better be ready.

6) Georgia

UGA should move up ahead of a couple of undefeated squads. The Bulldogs have proved to be an excellent team and should not be punished for playing a tougher schedule than other powers. Even though they’re flawed, I’d take the Dawgs over Ohio State in a heartbeat. The SEC schedule now allows this team quite a lot of room to breathe. If they can take advantage of it, they’ll be back in Atlanta with a chance to get revenge on the West champion (I’ll say it: Alabama). The biggest potential pitfalls left are all weaker than the teams UGA faced in the first month.

7) Ohio State

A one-score win over a Wisconsin team I don’t deem to be top-25 material isn’t good enough. The Buckeyes had a chance to make a statement and failed. OSU was outgained and allowed a mediocre passing team to notch nearly 300 yards through the air. The return of Braxton Miller, who does seem to be healthy, is a good thing. Even as I pick OSU to blow out Northwestern this week I have questions. How good is the defense, really? Would it hold up against a team capable of both running and throwing? How good is the passing attack (ranked in the bottom third of the country)? Stanford is ranked ahead of this team in passing right now.

8) LSU

It’s hard to dock the Tigers too much for losing a back-and-forth game they easily could have had. This is the SEC and the season isn’t over by a long shot. With four ranked opponents remaining all LSU has to do is win out to play in the BCS Championship. Granted, that’s easier said than done, but you had to be impressed with the offense Saturday. It’s been years since a Tigers’ QB slung the rock like that. This squad is formidable. Even with some defensive woes (which I believed I predicted before the season) there’s no reason why LSU can’t beat A&M, beat ‘Bama and climb back into a rematch with Georgia. What a game that could be.

9) UCLA

All I have to say is, the Bruins better not stab me in the back here and lose on Thursday night at Utah. I’ve been skeptical of this team to this point because of this program’s history but I’ve decided to make a leap. UCLA undoubtedly has a better win than Louisville, now it’s a matter of proving that ranking every week. Last season the Bruins won this game by a TD; they might be better this year, but so is Utah. Even with my newfound faith, UCLA is on upset alert in Salt Lake City. The Utes are not to be taken lightly. Please don’t make me look foolish.

10) Louisville

The ‘Ville took Saturday off to prepare for… Temple. Sigh. First, the good: Louisville is eighth in scoring offense and first in scoring defense. That’s unlikely to change against the Owls. Now, the bad: the schedule. Come on! You gotta give me something, Cards. In all likelihood UL’s fate will be decided after this week, in the ensuing pair of Thursday night games with a decent Rutgers squad and a pretty good Central Florida team. That’s all the league has to offer, unfortunately. UCF could have done the Cardinals a big favor by beating South Carolina, but they didn’t. Now it’s up to the other power schools to lose and give this team an opening.

11) South Carolina

Considering the Gamecocks lost their QB to injury and completed fewer than half their passes, they have to feel pretty good about their trip to Orlando. UCF is not bad. I’ve been beating that drum for weeks. As such, it’s only fair to reward this team. I had Texas A&M higher than SC before because of the eye test – A&M just looked more impressive. But both teams have one quality loss and only Carolina can boast a decent win. The Aggies can get back to me when they beat a good team. Right now the Gamecocks deserve the spot more.

12) Texas A&M

I said the Aggies would need to win meaningful games to keep their spot, though I didn’t expect it to come to fruition quite so soon. We know what aTm is: a great offense paired with a bad defense. It’d be nice to hold Arkansas to less than 30, though. The next game (Ole Miss) will be very interesting, as the Rebels have a pretty decent D but lack the offensive firepower – you’d think – to keep up with the Aggies. However, if Ole Miss can turn it into a slugfest we might actually learn something about this team, i.e., can they win if the offense isn't clicking?

13) Oklahoma

I was close to jumping the Sooners over A&M… then I thought about that Cotton Bowl last year. No, these aren’t the same teams as they were in 2012, but a beating like that stays with you. To Bob Stoops’ credit, OU appears to have really moved on from some of the disappointments of last season, embracing the running-game-and-defense philosophy that won him his title in 2000. Now, is it dangerous to have faith in a team whose best win is over Notre Dame? You bet. Doubly so because the Big 12 has been so bad this year (and Oklahoma State’s loss didn’t help). For whatever reason, I’m buying it. “Culture change” may be too strong a term, but something feels different around this team.

14) Washington

The Huskies got the important first conference win against Arizona and have risen to 15th in the polls. I think that’s about as good as it’s going to get this season. Unfortunately for UW, the next two weeks feature Stanford and Oregon. As improved as this team looks, I didn’t see anything in last week’s game that showed Washington is ready to unseat the kings of the Pac-12. ‘Zona isn’t good. The Wildcats’ passing game is a joke and they’re still not very good defensively, despite what the stats from the early-season cupcakes say. The Huskies snuck up on Stanford last year; they won’t do so this season with a Cardinal team looking for revenge in Palo Alto.

15) Miami (FL)

The Hurricanes can effectively remove Georgia Tech from the ACC race with a win Saturday and narrow the Coastal field down to themselves and Virginia Tech. They should be able to handle that at home. The next challenge will be Florida State, which could be a matchup of top-10 teams. It would be exciting to see that rivalry rekindled with, you know, good teams, but first the ‘Canes have to stay healthy (looking at QB Stephen Morris) between now and the start of November. Take care of the Ramblin' Wreck and then we’ll talk.

16) Florida

It wouldn’t surprise me to move Florida ahead of Miami (FL), even though the Gators lost the head-to-head. Why? Because I believe Florida will be better with Tyler Murphy than Jeff Driskel. Last week’s win over Kentucky doesn’t count for much, but everything I’ve seen from Murphy indicates that he’s already showing more potential than Driskel ever did. Running prowess is nice, but I like my QB’s with the ability to complete passes, thanks. Does that mean Murphy is going lead the Gators to an East title? I doubt it. But that was never going to happen anyway.

17) Michigan

All right, Michigan. I’ve had a week to cool off. So have you. You’ll be facing a motivated Minnesota team, coming off its first loss, in a storied rivalry game (with one of the silliest trophies in sports). You’re also at home and clearly the superior team, so try not to screw this up. The Big Ten is going to get very ugly if the Wolverines can’t win this game. Hopefully the bye was put to good use and Devin Gardner won’t be making any more appearances on the Stanzi List. But be warned: for a good, even great team, Michigan is surprisingly average statistically on both sides.

18) Nebraska

The defense isn’t good. I said it. However, the offense is. Illinois is in town this week, followed by trips to Purdue and Minnesota sandwiched around an idle date. Nebraska is better than all of those teams and should go 3-0. That would set the Cornhuskers up at 6-1 with a home game versus Northwestern – in my opinion, also inferior to Nebraska – before the Division-deciding showdown at the Big House. The ‘Huskers can make the Big Ten Championship even with this defense. There might be some shootouts along the way, but they’re more than capable.

19) Texas Tech

Kansas. Iowa State. West Virginia. Ah, to live the charmed life of Kliff Kingsbury. His Red Raiders coaching career will, in all likelihood, begin with seven straight wins. However, Texas football fans know this game and they know it will be what happens after that point that makes this season. Three ranked squads lurk on the back half of this schedule and it’s not as if Kansas State and Texas are gimmes. I like TTU, but I’m skeptical that they can keep this thing going into November. If they do, Kingsbury will be a frontrunner for Coach of the Year. But I’m getting ahead of myself. Let’s get to 7-0 first.

20) Oklahoma State

It’s probable that Oklahoma State just suffered a meltdown at the worst possible time, on the road against a team that had been embarrassed the week before and a coach that kind of knows their offense front to back. Furthering this theory is the negative turnover margin in the WVU game along with the fact that the Cowboys outgained the Mountaineers. Let’s be honest: OSU is still going to win nine or 10 games this year. However, it’s also true that this game gave critics of Okie State plenty of ammunition. They’re going to have to earn their way back into the voters’ good graces.

21) Northwestern

This is it for the Wildcats. They’ve been lauded as underrated for the better part of two years. Time to prove it against Ohio State. Northwestern gets the Buckeyes at home and is going off a bye, so anything less than a very competitive game would be an indication this team isn’t as good as its hype. I don’t think Northwestern wins this game. OSU is simply stronger across the board. If Wisconsin couldn’t run the ball on the Buckeyes, why will the Wildcats fare better? I was surprised at how the Badgers played last week, but that team is probably superior to this Northwestern squad.

22) Maryland

Just to get it out of the way: no, I don’t expect Maryland to beat Florida State this week. I’m not even expecting the game to be particularly close (though FSU’s close win over Boston College gave some reason to pause). However, Maryland has looked good this season and will make another appearance in the top 25 after probably tumbling out after Saturday. Last year the Terps burned through five QB’s thanks to a rash of injuries and stumbled to a painful 4-8 record. This year C.J. Brown is back, completing two-thirds of his throws with a 7:1 TD-INT ratio and the team is 4-0. Injury luck is important, folks.

23) Virginia Tech

I contemplated moving the Hokies ahead of conference foe Maryland, but if I’m right Saturday’s result with FSU should do that for me. VaTech is another squad we pretty much have figured out after a month: they’ll struggle to move the ball, but their defense will stifle most opposing offenses. Logan Thomas is never going to be an NFL QB, but his size and mobility can more or less get the job done against the majority of Tech’s schedule. The Coastal Division, once considered wide open, is close to becoming a two-team race. Will old Big East rival Miami (FL) knock off the Hokies? I don’t think North Carolina still has a shot.

24) Fresno State

For the third time this season the Bulldogs built a double-digit lead and watched a team scythe through their atrocious defense to make things interesting. They did well to make sure it didn’t cost them against Boise State; last week versus Hawai’i was another story. The Rainbow Warriors should not have been able to chop a 42-3 deficit down to five in less than a quarter of football. I nearly had to make the entire Fresno team eligible for an unprecedented collective Stanzi. The D is what’s probably going to keep these guys from rising any higher.

25) UCF

South Carolina deserves points for beating UCF, who isn’t bad by any definition. It’s baffling that this team could lose by three to the Gamecocks and tumble almost entirely out of the rankings (in terms of “others receiving votes). That was a competitive game! Central Florida could have won! The Knights aren’t done, not in the American. The top half of the league is decent while the bottom half is terrible. That means UCF is destined for at least another five wins. The one that really matters, though, is next Friday at Louisville. Buckle up.

Pac-12 Report

Stanford’s throttling of WSU was the most impressive win Saturday. Oregon State’s swatting of Colorado was the most important one. I expected the Cardinal to win (although a lot closer). I expected OSU to struggle. They didn’t. Now, I know it was Colorado, but… I can’t shake the feeling that we’ve seen this before. The Beavers get off to an ugly start. They win games they should lose against bad teams. They drop at least one game in embarrassing fashion. Yet despite all that, this team has managed to get to 4-1 and 2-0 to lead the conference with Stanford. Classic Beavs, classic Mike Riley.

To be clear, it’s not as if OSU is suddenly elite. Even in their best years the Beavers have been outclassed by Oregon and Stanford. But the next two games are WSU and Cal and it’s hard to see them dropping either of those. As for the Cougars, well, it was fun while it lasted. Wazzu is no doubt improved, but it might not make a difference in what’s shaping up to be a nasty North Division. Cal is in somewhat the same position – though you can throw out the horrendous game the Bears played in Eugene – of having to play catch-up to division rivals who have gotten better, faster.

There’s not much to be said about the Oregon – Cal matchup I didn’t cover earlier. It would have been nice to see UO tested, but the weather and the Bears’ ineptitude didn’t allow it. The game was over within five minutes, which sounds like a weak complaint but could have relevance later in the season. I need to see an opponent play its “A” game against Oregon. I need to see how the Ducks respond. Call me crazy, but I don’t think Colorado provides that this week. Washington will be a different story.

The Huskies prevailed in similar conditions as Oregon: hard, driving wind and a torrential downpour. It’s tough to know what to make of the game with Arizona because of the weather, but I’ll admit I was hoping to see a little more from Washington. It became clear very early ‘Zona didn’t have a chance. While the score never got out of hand, UW was never going to lose. In that storm, it’s possible the Huskies just tried to keep things safe and get away with a win. Given how bad the Wildcats looked, though, I would have expected the game to be put away sooner than it was.

The only competitive game of the week was USC at Arizona State, where for the second time in two visits to Tempe the Trojans saw a tight game in the third quarter get completely out of hand. This was actually a good contest – SC led 21-20 after Tre Madden’s early third-quarter TD run and had the ball back after going down 27-21. That’s when things got silly. Cody Kessler threw a pick-six, the Sun Devils erupted for four straight scores and Lane Kiffin wound up out of a job. The USC defense, so good in the first four games, suddenly broke. (The Trojans’ offense wasn’t bad, although ASU’s D isn’t great.) When the dust cleared, USC had an interim head coach, an injured Marqise Lee and the entire conference to look up at in the standings. Wow.

This week we gets things kicked off right with UCLA’s visit to Utah Thursday night. I have high hopes for this game. The Utes are a heartbreaker against Oregon State from being nationally ranked and coming off an emotional win over rival BYU. They and their fans will be out for blood. UCLA has only played three games but looks to be the clear leader of the South Division. The Bruins should win… but as I’ve said in the past, this is a hard team to trust. UCLA hasn’t seen a good defense yet. The Utes aren’t great but they’re competent and have a balanced offense that could potentially could give the Bruins trouble. This is the definition of a trap game.

Wazzu and Cal meet in Berkeley for a matchup of North bottom-feeders. This is a must-have for the Cougs if they want to get to six wins. Cal is probably a lost cause, so fans of the conference should be rooting for WSU to sneak into a bowl. Both teams had disheartening setbacks last week, but the opposition was elite. You can’t rebuild overnight. I hope the Cougars win this game for the Pac-12’s sake, but I’m afraid the defense might give up a ton of points to the “Bear Raid.” In any case, this has the potential to be a shootout as teacher (Mike Leach) meets student (Sonny Dykes).

Since there’s not much to say about Oregon – Colorado, I’ll skip right to the only non-conference game being played this week: Arizona State versus Notre Dame in Arlington. This odd mid-season neutral-site game has a lot of potential given the good but highly flawed participants. I think Arizona State is the better team – the Sun Devils certainly have the superior offense and more playmakers – but Notre Dame might win. The Fighting Irish play better defense and are more accustomed to the spotlight, for whatever that’s worth. Of course, it would help the Pac-12 if ASU could take care of business here at the tail end of a rough four-game stretch that saw them take on a who’s who of football powerhouses: Wisconsin, Stanford, USC and now Notre Dame.

The night game on The Farm is the big one: Washington at Stanford. The more I think about this game, the more I want to talk myself into the Huskies. UW has shown an admirable commitment to running the ball this season. Keith Price is playing like his 2011 self. The offense is balanced and the defense is giving up only 10 points a game. This team has finally arrived, right? Well… I may prove to be wrong, but I don’t think they’re quite there yet. Stanford brings a physicality I need to see UW match before I can trust the Huskies. The 2012 upset in Seattle doesn’t have a lot of relevance this year; that game took place before the Cardinal made the switch to Kevin Hogan at QB (by the way, if David Shaw is so brilliant, why couldn’t he see that Josh Nunes sucked?). Stanford is so good defensively I don’t think Washington will be able to use their newfound tempo effectively. It will come down to how well the Huskies can defend the improving Cardinal offense. On the road an upset seems unlikely.

Heisman Watch

The Heisman is a tricky thing, because it always goes to a skill-position player on a highly-ranked team. That doesn’t always fit my definition of “best college player” but it’s how the award has operated for most of its 70-odd year existence. Quarterbacks are derided as the guys who get all the glory, but the truth is that QB is the most important position in all sports. It’s understandable they dominate the award.

As with the polls, most Heisman votes before the 1950’s are a complete joke, rife with regional bias and politicking. Technological constraints also hurt voters in the past, as they rarely even saw most teams play. There’s no excuse for that any more. The players who make the biggest impact and mean the most to their programs should win. In no particular order, here are the players who currently deserve to be considered.

Tajh Boyd, QB, Clemson

Boyd has led the Tigers to a 4-0 start and a win over Georgia and fellow Heisman candidate Aaron Murray. He has become a complete player and runs the Clemson offense flawlessly.

Aaron Murray, QB, Georgia

No player has faced a gauntlet like the one Murray has so far this season. His resiliency and leadership are the reason Georgia is 3-1 and not 1-3.

Marcus Mariota, QB, Oregon

Mariota has become so good I feel comfortable nitpicking at his completion rate, down from last year. He’s exceptional but will need to show more accuracy in Pac-12 play.

Jameis Winston, QB, Florida State

Winston is the difference between FSU being very good and great this year. QB was the only big issue for the Seminoles this offseason and Winston has more than answered the call.

There are several other players on the radar, namely QB’s Derek Carr (Fresno State), Johnny Manziel (Texas A&M), Teddy Bridgewater (Louisville) and Brett Hundley (UCLA). I didn’t include them right now because I’m unsure how much of their teams’ success rides on them or because their wins to this point aren’t enough to be Heisman-worthy.

Random Thoughts and Observations

I’ve never been a big fan of Lane Kiffin, but that’s hardly atypical of a college football fan. I do think he’s a decent coach whose playcalling became extremely predictable (last year) and strangely, overwhelmingly conservative (this year). The NCAA sanctions on the Trojans’ program obviously hurt him. He is in no way solely responsible for USC’s downfall, regardless of how the school will try to frame it. However, there’s no denying the team needed to make a change. The Trojans weren’t getting better. It’s just strange he was brought back at all after 2012’s second-half collapse. When Kiffin was hired I assumed he’d be the fall guy while the program was dealing with the NCAA. That seems to have come to pass, though he didn’t do himself any favors with his ethically murky tactics and failure to deliver wins.

It would be a real shame if the service academies were unable to play this week because of the incompetence of the U.S. Congress. Air Force and Navy are supposed to meet in Annapolis, while Army is scheduled to go to Boston College. Current reports indicate the games may take place after initially being in limbo. The academies add great tradition and flavor to the game and they’re one of the things that elevates college football over the NFL. Here’s hoping those teams get to play this week.

Stanzi time! It was a rather quiet week for Stanzi-ing as a couple of new players entered the fray but we saw no repeat offenders. Here are the awards for Week Five.

Justin Worley, Tennessee
Opponent: South Alabama
Performance: Three INT (two in USA endzone, one returned to UT 5-yard line), escaped with 31-24 win

(A note on Worley: his performance didn’t fit the exact description of a Stanzi, given that Tennessee led most of the way. However, his turnovers kept South Alabama in the game – which should have gone to overtime – where he would have been eligible for a Stanzi. I’ll give it to him.)

Keith Wenning, Ball State
Opponent: Toledo
Performance: Two FUM (one for TD, one recovered by Ball St.), one INT (led to tying TD), led game-winning TD drive

2013 Stanzi Awards
Devin Gardner, Michigan: 2
Connor Wood, Colorado: 1
Logan Thomas, Virginia Tech: 1
Keith Wenning, Ball State: 1
Jake Heaps, Kansas: 1
Gary Nova, Rutgers: 1
Connor Halliday, WSU: 1
Justin Worley, Tennessee: 1

Finally, a word on quarterback play. When I started watching college football over a decade ago, I was confused by how passing statistics were judged. If a QB threw for 300 yards and three TD’s with a positive completion percentage, he was considered to have had a great day. However, if a QB had upwards of 400 yards and four or five TD’s, he was often called a “system” guy. At the time, few offenses ran exclusively from the shotgun or spread defenses out. Purdue under Joe Tiller, Texas Tech under Mike Leach, Hawai’i under June Jones – these teams would routinely put up tons of passing yardage, yet their QB’s seemed to receive few accolades and the offenses would dismissed as “gimmicky.”

I think time has shown such prejudice against new-age offensive scheming was flawed. All passing stats are not created equal, that’s true. A team that passes the majority of the time will undoubtedly accrue more passing yards, but that doesn’t – and didn’t ever – mean that pass-first offenses lift up only average QB’s. Drew Brees’ success in the NFL attests to that. The pro game is more pass-happy now than it has ever been. It is funny, though, to hear the names of Johnny Manziel, Marcus Mariota, Teddy Bridgewater and Tajh Boyd spoken with such respect. 10 years ago these players would have been criticized as “running QB’s” who didn’t have the ability to make it in the NFL. Now they’re considered the top prospects for next year’s draft

What to watch this week: BYU – Utah State (Friday night), Maryland – FSU, Minnesota – Michigan, Georgia Tech – Miami (FL), WSU – Cal, TCU – Oklahoma, Arizona State – Notre Dame, Ohio State – Northwestern and Washington – Stanford. It’s a pretty solid lineup.