Wednesday, September 14, 2011

Well that was fun

Nothing earth-shattering in the top 25 this week, but the rest of the country sure made up for it. For the second straight week, there was a wild Friday night thriller, and that was before the outrageous shootouts that were Georgia-South Carolina, Mississippi State-Auburn and Notre Dame-Michigan. I mean, how absurd were those games? How much excitement can one weekend possibly supply? This last weekend epitomized what makes college football great.

At the same time, though, all of these crazy finishes left something to be desired. Namely, defense. It wasn’t just the football purists who shed tears for their sport this week. Seriously, can’t anyone even slow down an offense these days? I would hope that the results of the two aforementioned SEC contests would finally put to rest the myth that Southern teams play better defense than anyone, but we know that’s probably never going to happen. But how dense do you have to be to not see it? SEC offenses aren’t exactly known for their productivity. Here’s how many points those four teams gave up in their collective eight games thus far: 35, 45, 37, 42, 38, 34, 41 and 14. Some rock-solid SEC defense there, eh?

Or, rather, is it that elite SEC defenses – just like elite defenses around the nation – are better than the rest of their weaker conference counterparts? Yes, some SEC teams play outstanding defense. LSU and Alabama are probably the two best defensive teams in the country. But to apply their greatness freely to the rest of the conference without looking at the truth of the matter is to aggressively ignore reality.

By the way, my Georgia-South Carolina rankings prediction from last week unfortunately couldn’t come to be because Georgia really is that overrated. However, we got a perfect illustration of what I was referring to when (unranked) Auburn upset 16th-ranked Mississippi State and surprise, surprise! – both teams were ranked the next morning. Because God forbid we admit that MSU isn’t really that good. No, better for the voters to cover themselves by ranking both teams, even though Auburn definitively proved last week that they aren’t that good when they luckily escaped a terrible Utah State squad.

But I rag on the SEC enough (and truly, the SEC West is the best division in the sport). Besides, the “worst defense” award doesn’t go to any of those schools. No, the worst defense of the week – nay, the young season (and possibly of all time) – was on display in Ann Arbor, where Michigan and Notre Dame honored the first night game at the Big House in the most ironic way possible, donning throwback uniforms on the very evening both teams decided to not play any defense. Knute Rockne and Bo Schembechler would have been appalled.

Of course, at the expense of defense, we got to see one of the most exciting college football finishes in recent memory. It was as if both teams’ secondaries just lost their collective minds. Have you ever seen so many wide-open receivers running downfield? It was a monumental combination of errors and incompetence. But it sure made for great viewing.

Top 25

1) Alabama

The Crimson Tide’s defense is superb, but for the first time I’m worried about their offense. The complete lack of a reliable quarterback in Tuscaloosa is going to hurt at some point, just as LSU will discover. The difference is that Nick Saban is a very good coach.

2) Oklahoma

Seems a little unfair that Oklahoma got to take week two off to get ready for FSU, but the Seminoles will just have to deal. I considered moving the Sooners up to the top spot this week because of their vast QB advantage over Bama, but it didn’t feel right given that OU had a bye. If they hammer FSU, though, that might change.

3) LSU

LSU predictably sleepwalked through their first post-Oregon game. Next up: recently wounded Mississippi State, who blew their shot to make an important conference-opening statement. Though even the mediocre Chris Relf presents an upgrade over Tigers QB Jarrett Lee, I expect LSU’s defense to win the day once again.

4) Boise State

How much can you say about the Broncos? Unless there’s a huge upset or someone important gets hurt, there’s almost nothing to write about. BSU will probably continue to win and win big. There is an interesting challenge this Friday against a game Toledo team who took Ohio State to the brink, though.

5) Stanford

That 10-point halftime lead was a bit worrisome, but the Cardinal did put the hammer down in the second half. Andrew Luck throwing a pick-six was a little jarring too. No matter. This week the team starts their conference schedule with a school, Arizona, who they blasted last year.

6) Wisconsin

I was tempted to move the Badgers to number five for a minute. Then I remembered that unimpressive first-half showing against a bad Oregon State defense and decided it would be prudent to wait another week to make that call. If nothing else, the Beavers showed that anyone can sell out to stop the run and be competitive with Wisconsin.

7) Texas A&M

A&M will likely wake up sometime in the second half this Saturday to put down Idaho. The Aggies’ minds are going to be on next week’s opponent, Oklahoma State. I’m really getting amped for that game, as it will announce which team will be the front-runner to challenge Oklahoma for the Big 12 title.

8) Oregon

Dropping 69 on Nevada demonstrated that, once again, it’s only the best defenses that can keep Oregon down. Do I think the Ducks are anywhere near last season’s level yet? No. But fortunately for them, they’ve got another couple of weeks to work things out. Even the conference opener at Arizona should be easier than expected, because the Wildcats will be in the middle of a horrendous stretch against three straight top-10 foes.

9) Virginia Tech

So did the Hokies beat East Carolina more or less impressively than South Carolina did? Both of the bird-mascot schools trailed the Pirates at some point, though Tech won a slugfest while South Carolina won a shootout. In the end, I dropped VT one rung because I seriously doubt they could match up with Oregon.

10) Oklahoma State

I’m ready to believe, Cowboys. Now don’t do something stupid, like losing to dangerous Tulsa this week en route to that big showdown with Texas A&M. There a lot of potential for fireworks both of the next two games, given the nature of OSU’s defense. The offense just can’t afford to be off.

11) Florida State

I’ve been rather harsh about FSU’s legitimacy. Now they finally get a chance to show what they can do when they host Oklahoma this week. While there’s ACC pride on the line, I really think this is even a bigger game for the FSU program. The Seminoles desperately want to be the team they used to be, and they need this win.

12) Nebraska

The Huskers, like many BCS teams over the past dozen-odd years, took Fresno State too lightly and almost paid for it. Taylor Martinez was exposed yet again as a receiver playing QB, which might eventually be the reason Nebraska fails to win the Big 10. I don’t see how they can hope to beat Wisconsin with him.

13) Arkansas

I’m very fond of Arkansas, but it kind of feels like we’re just waiting until they play a decent team and get crushed to drop them in the rankings. As a sign of respect for the Razorbacks’ potent offense, I won’t move them down until that happens, but I don’t have a lot of faith that they can compete in the SEC West.

14) Ohio State

Some analysts said this week that Toledo is a very good team and the fact that they almost beat the Buckeyes demonstrates their legitimacy rather than Ohio State’s middling quality. I’m not buying it. I’m comfortable with the idea of Toledo being a good team, but there is just no way they should have been able to compete with OSU.

15) South Carolina

I left the Gamecocks right where I had them last week. The win over Georgia was certainly exciting, but Georgia isn’t that good. However, you can’t truthfully say the Bulldogs are a bunch of bums, and the game was on the road, so… South Carolina stays in the same spot. Seems fair to me.

16) Michigan State

I gave Ohio State a lot of credit for completely crushing Akron’s offense in week one, so I have to do the same for the Spartans. Of course, what MSU did defensively was even more impressive. Really? 48 yards and one first down? That’s unheard of. I know it was Florida Atlantic, but still. Next up for Sparty: Notre Dame.

17) Arizona State

Arizona State got to show off for the nation on Friday night, and they gave the most honest team performance I’ve ever seen. The Sun Devils’ abundance of talent and potential were on full display as they built a two-touchdown lead on Missouri. Then everyone got to see their propensity to make foolish mistakes and stupid penalties as they let the Tigers back in the game. This team can win, but they have to play smarter.

18) Baylor

No word yet on whether Baylor can really hang with the big boys in the Big 12 this season (I kind of doubt it, but we’ll see). What is clear through the first two weeks is that people are finally cottoning on to the greatness of Robert Griffin III. Any and all Heisman hype directed at a certain QB in Ann Arbor should be focused on RG3.

19) South Florida

I don’t think USF will really be tested until they go on the road for their first two league games against Pittsburgh and defending Big East champ UConn. Certainly Florida A&M and UTEP shouldn’t be too much to handle. The biggest challenge for the Bulls will be to stay healthy until October.

20) West Virginia

After an alarming halftime deficit to Norfolk State the Mountaineers got it going. That’s good, because their competition ramps up sharply in difficulty in both of the next two weeks: first against rival Maryland, then versus LSU. Any chance WVU gets out of September undefeated? Ask again once they play the Terrapins.

21) Houston

How in the world is Texas ranked and not Houston? The Cougars would destroy the Longhorns. BYU nearly beat Texas, and those Cougars are about half as good as Case Keenum’s crew. This is a travesty. Houston’s schedule doesn’t give them a whole lot of chances to impress voters, so people should give them some credit now.

22) TCU

Hmm. I wouldn’t have been shocked if Air Force had upset the shell-shocked Horned Frogs, but TCU clobbered the Falcons. Perhaps they were written off to the bottom half of the top 25 too soon. The Mountain West actually presents some decent obstacles, so we’ll find out if Boise State has a true challenger.

23) USC

I don’t know what to make of SC. They could have easily lost both of their games, yet here they stand at 2-0. The lack of playmakers on the Trojan offense is disturbing given their touted recruiting classes, but it could be that the extreme focus on Roberts Woods (which is understandable) has stunted the growth of other players.

24) Auburn

All right, I’m willing to concede that Auburn can be ranked. Somehow, despite fate’s best efforts, the Tigers just can’t seem to lose. I certainly don’t think they’re ready to take on LSU or Alabama, but having Gus Malzahn in your corner helps a lot. With time, and a continued propensity for lucky breaks, this team could become formidable.

25) Michigan

Big Blue has the same “never say die” attitude as Auburn right now. Though last week’s win was more about Notre Dame blowing it than what Michigan did, you have to give the Wolverines credit for not folding while there was still time on the clock. One problem, though: the new offense hasn’t gelled at all. That’s going to be an issue.

Pac-12 Thoughts

Checking in on all our friends out west… let’s start with the North. Cal did beat Colorado in that weird conference-game-that-wasn’t, but they needed overtime to do so and were outgained by 200 yards, mostly through the air. That bodes very badly for the Bears. Stanford curiously didn’t pull away from Duke until the second half, though it’s possible the Cardinal were holding back for their conference opener against Arizona. Oregon was explosive but struggled to run the ball on Nevada, which is a bad sign. The Ducks’ offensive line clearly needs some work.

Oregon State just got killed at Wisconsin despite a pretty good defensive performance, and now Mike Riley has switched QB’s. I don’t honestly have a clue about why he’s dropping Ryan Katz for Sean Mannion. It would make sense for the Beavers to give up on 2011 and have a “youth movement” if Katz was a senior, but he’s still got a couple dozen games left as an amateur and I don’t see how pulling the plug on him is a positive move. Mannion didn’t play any better against the Badgers. We’ll have to watch this controversy with bemusement – and believe me, it’s already a controversy.

Washington struggled to put away Hawai’i just as they did against Eastern Washington. The Huskies might have some defensive issues, but they won’t see another passing offense like the ones the Warriors and Eagles ran. That’s a positive – as is UDub starting the year 2-0 for the first time since 2007. Washington State is also off to a 2-0 start, which is a much bigger deal given how bad the Cougars have been in recent years.

USC got the first Pac-12 season started with a closer-then-it-should-have-been win over Utah. The Trojans may be the second best team in the South, but they’ve got to find some consistency on both sides of the ball if they want to be taken seriously. Utah looked decent in their first game in a BCS conference, but the Utes had no business being in position to tie the game. They’ll still be a bit player in the Pac-12 race, but losing the opener hurts.

Poor Colorado could have really used that win over Cal. This week will be the Buffaloes’ best chance all season, against Colorado State. They’d better get this one, because I don’t see a guaranteed win on the rest of their schedule. Arizona got waxed at Oklahoma State, but that’s not too embarrassing. OSU is quite good. Much more concerning was UCLA’s pedestrian 10-point win over San Jose State. Psst. Want to hear a secret? I think there’s a chance the Bruins aren’t very good…

So then we come to Arizona State. The Fork was feared on Friday in Tempe, but man, did the Sun Devils make it hard for themselves. Anyone watching that game could see that Missouri was simply overmatched, but as is their custom, ASU had to try to give it away. At this point, I don’t think you can write it off as immature play – I’ve seen too much of this over the years from Dennis Erickson-coached teams. More on this later.

Heisman* Watch

*As my last post explained, this list excludes Andrew Luck because the actual Heisman race is all but over. This is a “best of the rest.”

Robert Griffin III, QB, Baylor

I’ll keep him here until he falters. Griffin is a rare athlete for a player so gifted as a passer. Unlike Michigan QB Denard Robinson, he’s as good as the hype surrounding him. He just needs to avoid injuries.

Random Thoughts and Observations

Good thing the NCAA cracked down on those crooks from Boise. Handing out three years’ probation and scholarship losses sure beats having to deal with any of the real problems around the country at Ohio State, Auburn, Oregon, or Miami. I mean, have you even seen the rap sheet of “impermissible benefits” Boise dealt out? Come on, NCAA. People sometimes say the NCAA goes after the little programs upsetting the balance of power and covers up for the big-name schools. I don’t normally buy it, but how is this not a perfect example of the NCAA doing just that?

There’s a lot of hype around Michigan’s Denard Robinson again. It’s understandable – he just brought UM back from certain defeat against Notre Dame, and he ran for an NCAA-QB record 1,700 yards last season while also throwing for 2,500. He’s a great athlete. However, he isn’t particularly accurate, a fact his athleticism masks (just 11-for-24 last week). And while his fourth-quarter performance against Notre Dame was extraordinary, you can’t forget the fact that it was partially because of his three interceptions that Michigan was in that position in the first place.

Because of this, I’ve awarded Robinson my first “Stanzi” award. Named for late Iowa QB (he graduated, he’s not dead) Ricky Stanzi, “Stanzi-ing” a game refers to a player (generally a QB) who is responsible for putting his team into a huge hole and then receives the credit for bringing the team back. Stanzi was infamous for tossing multiple picks in a game, then going nuts in the fourth quarter and winning the game. Thus the phrase is born: Robinson “Stanzied it” against the Fighting Irish.

I liken this term to the phrase “Cougin’ it,” which arose after Washington State became famous for their late-game collapses. No season was more indicative of Wazzu’s ability to “Coug it” in winnable games than 2005, when the Cougars lost an astonishing six games in this fashion by a total of 27 points. The phrase has since spread to the general college football lexicon whenever a team “snatches defeat from the jaws of victory.” I think “Stanzied” is just as appropriate.

My last thought is regarding Arizona State Dennis Erickson. I think Erickson is a pretty good coach, though he hasn’t always succeeded in the face of great expectations. But it’s funny that people still can’t see how his coaching style works. What has Arizona State been known for since Erickson took over in 2007? Underachieving, thanks to sloppy, undisciplined play and tons of penalties, particularly personal fouls. What was Oregon State known for when Erickson was in charge? The Beavers featured a high-octane offense, a speedy defense, and… a reputation for unsportsmanlike play. I couldn’t find the data online, but I believe the 11-1 OSU team from 2000 led the nation in penalties. I do remember the 2001 Fiesta Bowl following that season, when the Beavs annihilated Notre Dame 41-9 and racked up 18 penalties for 174 yards.

All of this is before we even get to Erickson’s Miami tenure (the guy has coached a ton of places). I think everyone knows what the Hurricanes were famous for. My point is that this is not an isolated incident or a problem than can just get fixed. People have to realize that this is how Dennis Erickson teams play: fast, out of control and undisciplined. He has never put a premium on getting his players to win the mental game along with the physical one. That’s just the way he coaches. In the end, it’s a shame, because he’s ended up wasting a lot of potential.

So that’s it for week three. We should start getting some real definitive information this week about who’s for real and who’s not and how the conference races are going to shape up. See you next week.

Friday, September 9, 2011

Fun in Week 1

That was a marvelous opening weekend, no? From the succession of weather delays in the Midwest to the epic TCU-Baylor finish, each hour seemed to bring new surprises. Houston-UCLA also went down to the wire, and Utah State-Auburn was exciting, if not exactly satisfying. You expect to see a lot of offense (and a lot of sloppiness) in teams’ first contests of the new season because of nerves and broken plays, but LSU taught us once again the supreme importance of defense.

I don’t want to rehash a game everyone saw, but there were many telling stats when the Cowboy Classic was finished. Particularly, despite what appeared to be second-half rushing dominance, the Tigers only averaged 3.6 yards a rush – just one-fifth of a yard more than Oregon. That’s surprising before you even get to the passing numbers, where Jarrett Lee was expectedly anemic, completing less than half his passes for fewer than a hundred yards. But the sheer dominance of the Tigers’ defensive front compensated for all of that.

Ever since Super Bowl XLII between the Patriots and Giants there has been a greater public understanding of the importance of defensive line play. The high-profile games Oregon has played in the past few seasons have further proved this point. But this has been fairly common throughout the 2000s during the rise of high-scoring spread offenses. Spread offenses of all varieties emphasize one-on-one matchups, where superior athleticism usually wins out. When an elite defense can match that athleticism, the offense is in trouble, which is a problem all spread teams eventually face. So the LSU win wasn’t exactly shocking.

I do find it interesting that Oregon fell ten spots in the AP Poll. Really? For losing to what is now allegedly the second-best team in the country? I await the result of this week’s Georgia-South Carolina game with great interest, then. The Gamecocks are ranked 12th, whereas the Bulldogs are unranked thanks to their loss to Boise State.

Astute readers may recall that in 2007, the situations for the two teams were reversed, with Georgia holding the lofty number 11 spot in the AP while South Carolina was unranked. But lo and behold! – one upset later, South Carolina was ranked 17th and Georgia, disgraced… fell all the way to 23rd. So if the Bulldogs turn the tables on the Gamecocks this week (which I think might happen because I don’t have a particularly high opinion of South Carolina), where do both teams wind up in next week’s poll? Remember that these are SEC teams. Yet, if I recall, Oregon dropped from third to 13th just by losing to second-ranked LSU. What kind of precedent does that set? Or rather, what kind of quickly-forgotten-when-it-comes-time-to-rank-SEC-teams precedent does that set? Wait and see.

Top 25

1) Alabama

Bama almost broke a sweat against Kent State. They might do so at Penn State this week, but don’t expect much. The Crimson Tide are probably going to be on cruise control until the conference schedule starts. They’ll need the rest; the SEC West is a gauntlet.

2) Oklahoma

The Sooners’ defense was better than expected against the potentially dangerous Tulsa offense. I don’t expect Oklahoma to have trouble with Florida State, but at least it’s a battle of name programs. I don’t see this going much different than it did last year.

3) LSU

OK, so LSU passed the early test. The defense really is that good. But something has to be done about the offense. Every team isn’t going to gift wrap three fumbles to the Tigers. At some point the lack of a passing threat will kill them.

4) Boise State

Oh, did a football game break out last week in Atlanta? As expected, Boise State swatted Georgia away with little difficulty, building a 21-point lead in the second half before the Bulldogs made it respectable. Next up? No one. Seriously.

5) Stanford

Oh, poor Duke. The Blue Devils are sure to give Stanford a good effort, but this has all the makings of another 68-point outburst like the one we saw at Wake Forest last year. After this game the Cardinal dive right into their Pac-12 slate, so maybe there’s trap potential here. At least, that’s what Duke should tell themselves.

6) Wisconsin

It was only UNLV… but come on, Wisconsin looked great on opening night. Russell Wilson is the perfect spice to add to the Badgers’ traditionally flavorless ground n’ pound approach, mixing in pocket poise and deft play-action ability. This could be a carbon-copy of Stanford… but with a better running game.

7) Texas A&M

Say what you will about their conference fickleness, A&M looks good on the field. The Aggies turned back a decent challenge from SMU with ease. That Big 12 opener against Oklahoma State is starting to look really interesting.

8) Virginia Tech

Tech dropped a bunch of points on Appalachian State, which earns them as much respect as you can get for beating an FCS team. I know the 2010 Auburn similarities are there, I just don’t want to give this inferior team that much credit yet.

9) Oregon

The Ducks get two weeks to lick their wounds before starting Pac-12 play. The positive from the LSU game is that UO knows they can play with anyone if they don’t beat themselves, but to win a third straight conference title they’ll have to figure out what works and what doesn’t.

10) Nebraska

Nebraska faces a couple of respectable opponents in their next two games in Fresno State and Washington. If they dominate both teams, which they are capable of doing, the Cornhuskers could be in for a special year. Even close wins would not bode well for Big 10 success.

11) Oklahoma State

I suppose I cheated a little by releasing this after the Cowboys won their second game, but I expected them to knock off Arizona anyway. This team is as explosive as ever on offense, but we’ll need to reserve judgment until the defense faces an elite offense too.

12) Florida State

FSU ground out a solid, if sluggish, win over Louisiana-Monroe. With the rematch against Oklahoma looming on the horizon, the Seminoles have to careful. Not this week against Charleston Southern, but with ACC pride on the line. It would look really bad if the league’s most highly-regarded team got hammered again.

13) Ohio State

No, beating Akron doesn’t mean the Buckeyes are going to be as good as usual. It’s the way OSU won that makes them worthy of moving up. Do you realize how hard it is to hold any team to less than a hundred yards of offense? That’s impressive.

14) Arkansas

I stand by my prediction that even with Knile Davis the Razorbacks wouldn’t have been able to win their division this year. Until they play Alabama, though, we won’t know for sure. Troy and New Mexico shouldn’t pose too much of a threat.

15) South Carolina

Moment of truth, Gamecocks. Are you the team everyone thinks you are, or the team you want to be? A statement against Georgia this week would go a long way toward proving the latter. If you can’t win this game, you don’t deserve to play for a conference title.

16) Mississippi State

If MSU can beat Auburn this week they can be taken seriously. If they beat LSU next week, it’s a whole different story. Let’s start with the easier task. Auburn is an inferior, unranked team. Beat the first group of Tigers, then we’ll talk about if this team has a shot at winning the West.

17) Arizona State

I moved the Sun Devils up because some teams ahead of them looked bad in their wins. Case in point, this week’s opponent Missouri. ASU desperately wants to be back in the top 25 spotlight and respected again. They need to win this game, or their season could unravel quickly.

18) Missouri

The 17-6 win over Miami (OH) wasn’t exactly mind-blowing. Arizona State’s defense is fast, physical, and features probably the nation’s best defensive talent in Vontaze Burfict. The beleaguered Big 12 could use this win, but I’m not about to predict a Tigers victory. They need to be ready for a battle.

19) Michigan State

I wasn’t high on Sparty to begin with, but yikes. I didn’t think MSU would get exposed this early in the year. And yes, holding a 14-6 halftime lead on Youngstown State does qualify as being exposed. The only thing that remains to be seen is whether this is the same bunch of plucky overachievers as last year or just a mid-level squad.

20) Baylor

Everyone saw it, but it bears (sorry) repeating: Did you see what Robert Griffin III did to a TCU defense? Unreal. Now, the defense is going to lose a couple games for Baylor this season, but you’ve got to think Griffin will win a couple by himself too. It was just one game, but it felt as though the Bears had finally broken through.

21) South Florida

I think Notre Dame is a good team, which makes what we saw out of USF last week very impressive. The Bulls shook off a poor defensive yards (yards-wise) and long weather delays to secure a solid win. The schedule isn’t exactly rough from here on out, so keep an eye on these guys.

22) West Virginia

Outside of a home date with LSU, the Mountaineers schedule is favorable. USF now looks like the top contender in the Big East, and the teams don’t play until the end of the season. And you never know about that LSU game… if WVU can force the Tigers’ offense into mistakes, they could make a game of it.

23) Houston

The Cougars are like Boise State, 2009. Or 2010. Or 2011. In any case, the one-game season is over for Houston after the opener against UCLA (at least BSU had the dignity to schedule some hard opponents). Houston shouldn’t play another team with their talent level until at least the Conference USA championship.

24) TCU

All is not lost for TCU, but what happened defensively against Baylor? Considering the Horned Frogs have led the nation in defense three years running. I think they’ll get it figured out. The offense also did a nice job coming back from the big deficit. TCU will be fine.

25) Utah

The opener produced a win, albeit an uninspiring one. Now the Utes get to jump right into Pac-12 play against USC. This should be fun. The Trojans were equally listless against Minnesota last week, so I’m expecting a good game. Can the Utes compete? We finally get to find out.

Pac-12 Thoughts

The Utah-USC opener is the foremost thing on the league’s mind, but the non-conference games this week will probably tell us a lot more about where this season is headed. Arizona State could announce they are for real with a win over Missouri and Oregon State could regain some pride against Wisconsin after falling last week to (gulp) Sacramento State. Arizona has already lost to Oklahoma State (no shame in that), and Washington has a huge trap game against Hawai’i. The conference’s reputation is at stake in many of these games after Oregon’s loss to LSU. It would be helpful if the Pac-12 could look good this week.

Heisman Watch

Because Andrew Luck is the best player in the country, this is a moot discussion. However, I am nothing if not fair, so I’ve decided to make a new award this year called the “wHo’s the bEst player who ISn’t Andrew Luck-MAN.” In this blog it will be referred too as simply the “Heisman,” with the understanding that Luck is by definition, ineligible. With that said…

Robert Griffin III, QB, Baylor

It’s a short list thus far, but it will expand as the year goes on. Griffin’s performance against TCU will go down in Baylor lore, and it announced him to the nation as a superstar. I look forward to seeing him in 2011; let’s pray he can stay healthy.

Random Thoughts and Observations

You can’t blame the SEC for taking the next step, though you can still blame Texas A&M for forcing their hand. As you should all be aware at this point, the conference has agreed to let A&M in if they just stop their whining. That’s more or less what the SEC said. There’s also this bit about how the Aggies have to make sure nobody in the Big 12 wants to sue them for leaving after every school in the conference signed a decade-long deal to stay together last summer.

This has all set off a wonderfully ridiculous and completely hilarious round of posturing and faux-indignation from Texas A&M and the various parties that would be must hurt by the breakup of the Big 12, including Iowa State, Kansas, Kansas State and Baylor, though in reality we’re really just talking about Baylor. The Bears stand the most (or tied for the most) to lose if they don’t have Oklahoma and Texas to hold them up in a major conference any longer. Rather than take it on the chin and go to the Mountain West, the school has moved in its best interest to try to block Texas A&M from leaving, or at least milking them of some cash if they go.

Both parties have valid arguments. I’m inclined to side with Baylor, but the most amusing thing about this debacle is Texas A&M’s bizarre theory that the school would be better off in the SEC, both “culturally” and “competitively.” How’s that again?

Culturally I can sort of buy, although I don’t see how playing against the SEC West is so different than playing the other Texas schools. Let’s be honest about the “culture” argument – A&M doesn’t like Texas and wants to get away. Part of the Aggies’ secession faction keeps repeating that Texas broke the Big 12’s agreement to hold the conference together by taking unequal revenue (plus the Longhorn Network), thereby dissolving any obligations Texas A&M has to the league. That’s somewhat true, but the problem is that the Aggies STILL signed on for the new Big 12. And as I recall, Texas invited Texas A&M to share in the LHN... and they refused.

However, that’s actually the stronger part of the argument, because the “competition” argument is so ludicrous you have to wonder whether the SEC West schools are behind it all to grab themselves an easier division foe. Texas A&M has one conference title in the Big 12 era, back in 1998. The Aggies have played in just two Big 12 championship games total (1997 was the other). They’ve been passed and dwarfed by the accomplishments of Texas and Oklahoma, they’re 1-9 in their last 10 bowl games, and they’re three games over .500 in the past decade. This ain’t the old Southwest Conference, guys. You’re not a powerhouse anymore.

To end on a lighter note, Oklahoma is now reportedly reconsidering their standing Pac-12’s invite. Curiously, the Sooners are reportedly the only Big 12 school that has not waived their right to sue Texas A&M. Why would that be? Perhaps because they don’t want to look like hypocrites when they announce for a new conference at some point this season?

We’ve been over this before, but Oklahoma joining the Pac-12 and A&M jumping to the SEC would set off another round of conference shakeups. As both leagues have said they would prefer to expand their respective TV and recruiting footprints in moving to 16-team superconferences, I believe things would end up looking like this:

Pac-16

(With renamed divisions, placing the old Pac-8 schools together in the West and the new schools, collectively referred to as the “heathen outsiders,” in the East)

West

Cal
Oregon
Oregon State
Stanford
UCLA
USC
Washington
Washington State

East

Arizona
Arizona State
Colorado
Oklahoma
Oklahoma State (OU’s obvious moving buddy)
Texas (LHN is an issue, but a workable one)
Texas Tech (The “hey, why not?” team)
Utah

SEC

(The division names should hold up fine if the right teams are taken)

West

Alabama
Arkansas
Auburn
LSU
Mississippi
Mississippi State
Missouri (A good fit for the region)
Texas A&M

East

Florida
Georgia
Kentucky
Louisville (Rival for WVU, Kentucky)
South Carolina
Tennessee
Vanderbilt
West Virginia (The Big East’s best)

West Virginia and Louiville might seem like odd additions, but there are reasons to choose them. For West Virginia, it’s that the SEC gets what is clearly the best and most consistent Big East team. For Louisville, I like it because there are already established rivalries with West Virginia and Kentucky. However, these schools also fit because of the lack of strings attached to them. For example, Virginia Tech, who would obviously be the best choice among all the east coast schools. But Tech is in a standing package deal with Virginia, who nobody really cares much about. Georgia Tech is a candidate, but the Yellow Jackets are solidly acclimated to the ACC, particularly as a basketball school. Miami and Florida are both power schools, but the SEC already has a team in the state and is looking to expand. The remaining options are fairly unsavory, such as USF (already in Florida, no history), Baylor (absolutely no way) or UCF (see USF).

So that’s where we stand after week one. The season’s just begun and already there’s universal madness. May the best team win.

Tuesday, August 30, 2011

2011 Season Preview


Another season is upon us. The football-starved have been foaming at the mouth for months, and now the wait is only a few more short days. This year’s opening weekend slate is far meatier than what we usually have, which will only slake fans’ ravenous appetite from the get-go. There are the marquee matchups (LSU-Oregon, Boise State-Georgia), to be sure, but a number of other games have potential as well. TCU-Baylor on Friday should be entertaining, South Florida-Notre Dame could be very good, and Tulsa-Oklahoma will likely see a lot of points scored. Personally, I want to watch Virginia Tech take on Appalachian State, who has been placed on permanent must-watch status since their epic takedown of Michigan in 2007.

Sadly, no offseason is complete without off-field turmoil, and 2011 saw both the most and worst offseason turmoil of all time. The lingering questions about Auburn were upstaged by Ohio State, then Oregon. LSU would have probably come into the season with the largest spotlight by virtue of being the last team to face public embarrassment, but Miami (FL) was having none of that. “Scandal? We’ll show you what a real scandal is!” scoffed the Hurricanes, who collectively participated in the greatest Death Penalty-worthy activities since, well, SMU. Yeesh.

With everything fans were forced to suffer through the past few months, it will be wonderful to get back to the game. I’ll start with my customary top 25, and go from there to my conference picks.

Top 25

1) Alabama

Right now the polls say it’s Oklahoma. I can’t buy that yet. I watched the Sooners play a lot of close games last year against very inferior teams, and Bama is almost without a doubt the SEC’s best. Last time I checked, that qualified a team for number one status. The defense is nasty and Trent Richardson is scary good.

2) Oklahoma

Of course, with that said, Oklahoma does have an embarrassment of offensive talent and should take the Big 12 without too much difficulty. The non-conference matchup with Florida State is intriguing, but the Sooners will be favored in every game this season. Can they actually come through in a BCS bowl against a worthy opponent?

3) Oregon

…I guess. The question mark regarding the offensive line is huge. Does Oregon have it in their nature to tangle physically with the nation’s other elite squads? The way the team is built is antithetical to the way championship teams have been built for decades. Chip Kelly is a brilliant offensive mind, but he hasn’t solved this yet. We’ll see.

4) Boise State

The Broncos won’t get a chance to prove this ranking during the season, unfortunately (and no, I’m not forgetting about the Georgia game). At this point it seems reasonable to give them the benefit of the doubt and wait until they win their league to evaluate them. Averaging a single loss over the last five years earns you that.

5) LSU

This was a hard team to figure even before the suspensions. I wasn’t buying the national title talk originally, but with all the hype around the Tigers you were led to believe they were going to be good. Now? I really don’t know. I can at least say the defense will be solid, and that tends to win you games.

6) Stanford

I actually think Stanford has been overrated this offseason, but there’s not another team to put ahead of them. Andrew Luck is outstanding, but the truth is that it’s hard to have sustained success on the Farm. They have the same line problems as Oregon, and less skill position talent.

7) Texas A&M

I’m a believer in the defense that’s been built in College Station, and Ryan Tannehill is a good quarterback. I doubt they can beat out Oklahoma for the conference crown, but the Aggies should still be a quality team and a tough out for anyone. The schedule sets up nicely for them to make a statement against some quality teams.

8) Wisconsin

Wisconsin got a little exposed in the Rose Bowl last year, but now the Badgers finally have something they haven’t seen in years: a game-changing QB. NCSU transfer Russell Wilson is the real deal, and he gives Wisconsin a dimension not seen for at least a decade. Watch the offensive line turnover, though.

9) Virginia Tech

Tech in 2011 might cause pollsters to reevaluate their definition of “good.” How well can you really judge a decent team that plays such a paper-soft schedule? But… the ACC is still the ACC, and the Hokies still have Florida State’s number. At minimum, this is a 10-win team.

10) Nebraska

I’ll say it up front: Taylor Martinez is a laughable excuse for a passer. But that’s how they’ve been doing it in Lincoln for decades, so you can’t begrudge the Cornhuskers for anointing Martinez as a savior. I say Nebraska makes the first Big 10 (sorry, B16) title game.

11) Florida State

Yes, FSU has finally made some strides back towards national relevance. But, but, but… this team is just flat-out overrated. The Seminoles got waxed by every good squad (and a couple average ones) they saw last year. I’ve said it before and I’ll it again – FSU has to prove it on the field before I’ll buy in. We’ve heard this song too many times before.

12) Oklahoma State

This is one of those teams people seem to fall in love with as a “darkhorse.” It’s understandable; the offense is explosive and the skill talent has some big names. But for all their recent improvement, the Cowboys still can’t A) put together a real defense or B) beat Oklahoma. Some things never change.

13) TCU

Losing QB Andy Dalton is a big deal, but there’s such a serene feeling regarding the well-being of the TCU program that I just can’t help but believe. Gary Patterson runs the best defensive scheme in the country, and the Horned Frogs shouldn’t suffer a huge drop-off from where they’ve been the past few seasons.

14) Arkansas

Poor, poor Arkansas. If only the Razorbacks didn’t play in the SEC West. I really wanted this to be the year the team broke through, but losing stud running back Knile Davis crushed those hopes. New QB Tyler Wilson should be very good, but it isn’t going to be enough.

15) South Carolina

This is the perfect ranking for the “other” USC, who won the watered-down SEC East last year but impressed nobody outside their own fan base. They’ll have a great chance for a repeat this season, but there’s no chance the Gamecocks can match up with the might of their league’s other division.

16) Notre Dame

It kills me to say it, but Notre Dame will probably deserve to be ranked this year. The team has finally put together an all-around quality squad. However, the Irish really could have used one of their patented creampuff schedules – instead, they’ll face a nasty slate that includes some of the top non-BCS schools along with their traditional rivals.

17) Ohio State

After the nightmare offseason they saw, I’m sure the Buckeye players are ready to take it to every team they face. Unfortunately, this is simply not the caliber of OSU team we’ve seen in the past decade. They’ve still got a lot of talent, but there’s no way the off-field stuff doesn’t bother them a little.

18) Michigan State

Let’s be honest. Despite their gaudy record last year, did anybody really think the Spartans were that good? Outside of a quality win over Wisconsin, MSU beat no one of note and was completely humiliated against Iowa and Alabama. This team can compete in the Big 10, but there is a talent gap there.

19) Missouri

Mizzou has carved out a nice niche over the last few years as a top-20-ish team who can regularly stay ranked, win the easy games and occasionally upset the big boys. Case in point: 2011’s consecutive victories over the two best teams in the conference, Texas A&M and Oklahoma. The Tigers won’t be elite, but they should be just fine.

20) Arizona State

This is a best-case ranking. Before all the preseason injuries, I would have gladly anointed the Sun Devils as the team to beat in the Pac-12 South. Now it’s all very iffy. With USC ineligible, this should be ASU’s division to lose… but this team has seen high expectations in the past, and it hasn’t ended well.

21) Mississippi State

I think this is generous. MSU has definitely gotten better under Dan Mullen, but the fact remains that the Bulldogs beat absolutely no one last season. And oh yeah, last time I checked, they still play in the SEC West, so let’s hold off on giving these guys anything before they earn it.

22) West Virginia

The Big East is lousy, but WVU still represents its most respectable argument against losing automatic-qualifier status. Much has been made of the marriage between an already-decent offense and new coach Dana Holgersen, who previously oversaw explosive and innovative attacks at Houston, Texas Tech, and Oklahoma State.

23) USC

Once again ineligible for the postseason and playing for pride, the Trojans face a difficult road in 2011. After losing the biggest game on the schedule last year against Oregon, SC seemed to shut it down. They have to guard against that this year, but I still see them as a top-25 team talent-wise.

24) Houston

If Case Keenum has fully recovered, look out. Houston has been nigh-unstoppable with their star QB at the helm for multiple seasons. If things break right, this could be the best non-BCS team outside of Boise State. If not… at least the Cougars should score a lot. They always do.

25) Utah

This might be a stretch. However, I have a lot of faith in the culture at the “original BCS buster,” now playing the role of defector. The Utes will surely be surprised by some of what they see in their new conference, but I have a feeling that some of the Pac-12 teams will get a little surprise too.

There are also several teams I considered for the top 25, but rejected for various reasons. Some of them are in the AP or Coaches’ rankings. The most notable absences are:

Georgia

I get the idea that a team can improve coming off a down year. But really? The Bulldogs were 6-7 last season, going out with a whimper in a 10-6 loss to Central Florida in the Liberty Bowl. This team can’t hope to compete with the higher-end SEC squads, and the lofty preseason expectations that have been placed on them are unfair.

Florida

The Gators were mediocre last year, playing in a January bowl game only because of the SEC’s marvelous postseason tie-ins. A coaching change is also going to hurt any hopes of consistency from last year as the team switches to new schemes. The fact that Florida is ranked in the preseason is only slightly less appalling than the voters’ ranking of…

Texas

To be fair, only the Coaches’ Poll includes Texas, but the difference is insubstantial because the Longhorns are 26th in the AP. Either way… what? Did anyone actually watch Texas last season? What was most impressive? The 2-6 conference record? The three-touchdown home shellacking at the hands of 4-8 UCLA? Perhaps the defection of longtime head-coach-in-waiting Will Muschamp to Florida? Ridiculous.

Penn State

Speaking of ridiculous, how about the Nittany Lions? I can’t remember the last time Penn State had a halfway decent QB. The problem is that college football is increasingly becoming a quarterback-dominated sport, and JoePa still thinks he can plug in any random athlete at the position and win. This would be an issue even if Rob Bolden wasn’t already doing the world’s worst impression of Taylor Martinez.

Auburn

And finally, Auburn. Yep, the 2010 champs are nowhere to be seen in my top 25. As with the other snub-ees listed here, that doesn’t mean they couldn’t become one in time. But with the personnel losses the Tigers saw, along with the buzzsaw that is the SEC West, there’s no way any rational person could rank these guys right now.

Conference Outlook

ACC

Predicted champion: Florida State over Virginia Tech

I know I ranked VT higher than FSU. I also said the Noles couldn’t beat the Hokies. While I do consider Tech the team with the better pedigree, I also think Florida State could improve over the course of the season to the point that they could win the title game. There’s very little doubt that these two teams will win their respective divisions, despite the extreme parity in the conference.

Big 10

Predicted champion: Wisconsin over Nebraska

Ohio State would have been the obvious choice, but now… not so much. Wisconsin shouldn’t really have a whole lot of other competition in the Leaders division. Michigan State might challenge Nebraska for the Legends title, but the Spartans were really exposed last year in the big games they played and I don’t see them as a real threat. As a sleeper pick, Michigan might be a surprise, but changing coaches and schemes doesn’t bode well for the Wolverines’ league title chances.

Big 12

Predicted champion: Oklahoma

The new-look Big 12 ought to be pretty exciting without a conference championship game. There’s no longer the same room for error in interdivision play, which will hopefully make each contest more meaningful. You also have to tip your cap to the league for expanding to a nine-game conference schedule. In the end, though, I still don’t see Texas A&M or Oklahoma State (the main challengers) unseating Oklahoma.

Big East

Predicted champion: West Virginia

Yes, there’s USF and Pittsburgh too, but I’d prefer to stick with the team I know will consistently perform. The Mountaineers haven’t had a sub-.500 conference record in a decade, and only once have the ‘Eers finished with fewer than five league victories (4-2 in 2004). Pitt has disappointed many times when burdened by expectations, and USF is just schizophrenic. Geno Smith is the best QB in the conference. Argument over.

Conference USA

Predicted champion: Houston over UCF

The CUSA, as I like to call it, is actually kind of stacked this year. There are a half-dozen good teams vying for the title, split pretty evenly between divisions. Houston (if the Cougars can return to form) is the obvious pick in the West, but Tulsa and SMU are also really solid. In the East, you’ve got Central Florida, Southern Miss and East Carolina. I like a lot of these schools, but my respect for Case Keenum overrides all. This should be the year the Houston finally breaks through.

MAC

Predicted champion: Northern Illinois over Ohio

This league can be excruciating to pick because the best team tends to get upset every year in the title game. I’m taking NIU mostly out of spite because they were the MAC’s best squad last season and predictably blew it in the championship game. Toledo is the most formidable challenger to the Huskies in the West thanks to star receiver Eric Page. In the end I say it’ll be NIU. Miami (OH) probably won’t repeat last season’s magical run, thus I’m taking Ohio out of the East.

Mountain West

Predicted champion: Boise State

Air Force is a scary sleeper and TCU should still be a tough out, but you just can’t pick against Boise. Say what you will about their opposition. In the past five years, the Broncos are 51-5 with a pair of undefeated seasons. They should go undefeated again this year. TCU claims they’re looking forward to one last hurrah in the MWC, but I don’t see how the looming move to the Big East doesn’t have an impact on their play. The Horned Frogs will also likely take a slight step back from last season.

Pac-12

Prediction champion: Oregon over Utah

My in-depth Pac-12 preview is below.

SEC

Predicted champion: Alabama over South Carolina

There’s been a lot of hyperbole around this Alabama squad, some of it including the phrase “best defense of all time.” That remains to be seen (Florida heard the same praise in 2009 and came up short), but it’s pretty clear that Alabama is the best team in the West. As there are probably four teams in that division superior to anyone in the East, that makes the Tide the obvious pick. Auburn is coming down hard after their charmed 2010 season, LSU has some off-field concerns, and Arkansas still isn’t quite there. If Steve Spurrier retains one iota of his former coaching genius, the Gamecocks should take the East. They’ll prove a lovely sacrifice for boys from Tuscaloosa.

Sun Belt

Prediction champion: Troy

Ah, the good old Sun Belt. Easily the worst conference, though they’ll have competition once the WAC gets gutted in 2012! I see Middle Tennessee State, Troy and 2010 champ Florida International (who came out of nowhere) as the legit contenders, and all three teams have a solid shot. However, MTSU lost all-purpose, all-everything star Dwight Dasher, and FIU is new to success at this level. Troy has won or shared the SBC title for five years running, so this seems a pretty safe choice.

WAC

Predicted champion: Hawai’i

I have some reservations about selecting the Warriors. Fellow 2010 co-champ Nevada is still around, and Fresno State has put together another decent squad. However, you have to figure losing QB Colin Kaepernick will hurt the Wolf Pack at some point. Fresno is probably the lesser threat, but they do have David Carr’s younger brother at the helm… maybe the Bulldogs can conjure up some 2001 magic? Possible, but I’m a sucker for the Run and Shoot, and Hawai’i runs it as well as anyone.

Pac-12 Preview

To the Pac-12! New teams, new coaches, new TV contract! The champion, though, will be one we’ve seen before. It’s really a toss-up between Oregon and Stanford, who are hands-down the two best teams in the conference. Before I get to the superior North division, however, I’d like to look at the South.

As most analysts have noted, the South is wide open. USC would likely be the favorite, but there’s that little issue of a postseason ban. From there we turn to Arizona State, a team I said all along should be the division champ. However, ASU has seen an unbelievable amount of preseason injuries and as such I’m hesitant to tab them to play in the inaugural Pac-12 title game. I think the Sun Devils are certainly more talented than Utah, who I’ve picked to actually win the South. The reasons for the pick are these: the Utes should adjust reasonably well to their conference move (far better than Colorado, to be sure); they draw an impossibly favorable schedule, missing Oregon and Stanford and hosting ASU; their home-field altitude advantage is very underrated, and the other Pac-12 schools will potentially view them as less of a threat because it’s their first year in a BCS league.

The only other South team that might challenge Utah is Arizona, who has an impressive array of talent at the skill positions. But have you seen the line situation? ‘Zona replaces all five starting lineman, returning just one start along the entire front. No team ever excels in those circumstances. As for UCLA… I don’t think so. The Bruins haven’t seriously challenged for the conference crown in a decade. That leaves Colorado. Where to begin? The Buffaloes might have been in line for a decent season with a halfway accommodating schedule. Instead the Buffs face what is likely the nation’s most difficult slog, with nine Pac-12 games, a let’s-not-count-it-as-a-conference-game-even-though-it-is matchup with Cal, and oh yeah, three nonleague away games at Hawai’i, Ohio State and rival Colorado State. Did I mention the Buffs play all 13 games without a bye? Lord have mercy.

So that brings us back around to the North, where realistically we’re talking Oregon, Stanford, and everybody else. Washington State will continue to improve (I’m going out on a limb with three wins this year!), Cal will continue to be an enigmatic mess (but a talented one!), and Oregon State will continue to valiantly battle the gods of attrition in the hopes of fielding the first team in NCAA history without knee ligaments. Just kidding. But not really. I’ve read a lot about how Washington will manage to get better without Jake Locker somehow and I can’t really say I buy it. Chris Polk is a monster, sure, but there is still a definite talent gap between the Huskies and best teams in the conference.

In the end it comes down to Oregon and Stanford, one of which will win the North and the Pac-12. It’s been very difficult to decide which team will prevail. Much has been made of Oregon’s need to replace multiple starters on the offensive line, but for some reason no one has mentioned that Stanford is facing the exact same problem. In fact, I would argue that the Cardinal have a tougher job in this respect, because they have to replace an All-American center in Chase Beeler. A much more important factor is going to be the fact that Stanford hosts the Ducks this year. The last time Oregon went to Palo Alto they lost, and without their home-field edge last season it’s highly likely the Ducks would have been unable to come roaring back from an early 18-point deficit. Or quacking back, if you like. It’s for this reason that I long felt Stanford would win this game… but I finally decided that Oregon’s athletic advantage would be just enough for UO to pull through. It’s going to a fantastic game, though.

Random Thoughts and Observations

There’s not much more I can say about this offseason. The news just seemed to get worse and worse with each week. How can anyone really focus on the game with the clouds hanging over the sport right now? Well, we will, because that’s what we fans do. But I stand by what I wrote in July regarding Oregon (and any team in that situation, really) and hope that the NCAA’s new policies will prove a stronger deterrent to the blatant rule-breaking we’ve seen of late. And if schools are found guilty… there might never be a better time to bring back the Death Penalty. If a school ever deserved it, it would be Miami (FL). If the NCAA hit the Hurricanes with a complete football ban, would it finally serve to put everyone on notice that the days of cheating and corruption are over? Something to ponder.

The SEC is everyone’s favorite bad guy these days, but the member schools’ presidents and regents made a hugely important and wise decision to decline Texas A&M’s pathetic “look at me” plea to join. The national landscape had already been shaken by the conference changes we saw in the last year, even if some (such as the Pac-16) turned out to be only a mirage. A&M’s cowardly abandonment of the Big 12 would have turned those seemingly earth-shattering shifts into mere tremors. If the Pac-16 had formed, it would have eventually forced the other power conferences (Big 10, SEC, ACC) to expand to 16 teams as well, ushering in an exciting new era but simultaneously crushing any chance of a truly even playing field for all time. I wrote about the implications of such a system last summer, fearful for the well-being of the sport.

However, the transition the Pac-16 would have ushered in would have seemed calm and cautious compared to what Texas A&M’s selfish move might have wrought. For the SEC to take the Aggies as its 13th school, it would have required, at minimum, a 14th school to even the divisions. But let’s be honest – the SEC would never have stopped there. 16 teams makes much more sense than 14, and the conference would have seen that Pac-12 commissioner Larry Scott’s dream of a superconference was firmly within their grasp. And who would turn down an invite to the SEC? It would have set off another round of desperate conference leaps and short-sighted decisions based solely on greed.

I call Texas A&M’s actions selfish because that is absolutely what they are. The Aggies have long abhorred being in rival Texas’ shadow, and their lack of success in the past decade has only inflamed a proud fanbase that can still remember the glory days of the Southwest Conference. To that I say, too bad. In sports things are cyclical, in college football even more so. A&M improved last season, and could possibly win the Big 12 this year. But that’s clearly not enough.

Texas A&M is jealous of Texas’s TV deals, and rightfully so. Texas has long held an unfair advantage in TV revenue, and part of their deal to stay in the Big 12 included making sure the school would continue to receive more an unequal portion of the pie. On top of that, there’s the new Longhorn Network, which many people believe should be a violation of NCAA rules because of which games the LHN planned to broadcast, including conference matchups and high school contests. The LHN treads in ethically murky water and undoubtedly creates an unfair advantage for Texas.

Too which I say, again, too bad. There are unfair advantages in TV revenue and recruiting all over the country. Other schools have just decided to play by the rules that exist and not whine about it. A&M’s childish attempt to take their ball and go home so that the entire Big 12 suffers is outrageous and beyond selfish. Everyone already knows the Big 12 is doomed. That writing was on the wall as soon as Colorado and Nebraska jumped ship. But by leaving the league just one year later, A&M is potentially throwing the entire country into disarray. For what? For their own satisfaction?

Thankfully, the SEC turned down the Aggies’ laughable request for at least a year, which will at least give everyone a chance to think about how they want to proceed with conference expansion in the future. As I write this, A&M has already declared its intention to leave the Big 12, and the school may yet join the SEC as its 13th member. But not today. I’m critical of many decisions the SEC has made, such as jump-starting the silly “conference championship game” era and promoting the welfare of the entire league over actual school affiliation. But for once, the SEC saved college football from itself.

The 2011 season has begun with a cloud of bad press and scandal. Here’s one person who hopes to see this sport ride out the tumult for the better. There are a few short days remaining before the celebration begins. Let the play on the field this season make it even better than the last.

Oh, and I suppose you want a Heisman Watch list. By all means:

Andrew Luck, QB, Stanford

Any questions?

Saturday, July 2, 2011

Programs Gone Wild Edition

The jig, as they say, is up. Done. Over. Gone. There seems to be so much to say, and at the same time so little. On Friday, Yahoo! Sports reported that advisor/mentor/quasi-booster/all-around shady guy Willie Lyles had admitted to sending the University of Oregon his pathetically outdated and useless “National Recruiting Package” for 2010 only after the school frantically pressed him for it in February. As in February 2011. Head coach Chip Kelly reportedly OK’d the $25,000 payment himself. Oh boy.

While there still isn’t a smoking gun on the level of the Jim Tressel email variety, there is now more than enough circumstantial evidence against the Ducks’ recruiting practices for the NCAA to deliver a stern reprimand. Anyone who thinks otherwise is a fool. College athletics’ governing body may be slow, outdated and bizarrely inconsistent with its rulings, but when there’s this much of a trail, heads tend to roll.

Everyone who follows college football has noticed Oregon’s meteoric rise over the last few seasons. True, the Ducks have had success before, but never at the high, sustained level seen at the end of the past decade. Oregon’s roster has been getting faster, stronger, deeper. Opposing coaches have seen it. Analysts have praised it. Duck fans have bragged about it. How did this medium-sized school out west with only a decent football tradition get so talented? Now, it seems, we have an answer to the question no one wanted to ask. Oregon decided to play with fire. And to paraphrase one of my favorite television characters, they burned the house down. While they were still in it.

The problem for Oregon is that Lyles’ confession ties everything up so neatly. The covering up. The backtracking. The shifting stories and stony silences. All are explained far too conveniently – and logically – by this new story. Yes, Lyles has now changed his own story multiple times, but dismissing him completely is a reaction of only the most ardent homers and likely only a defense mechanism.

The truth is that every Oregon fan’s hair stood on end when the initial reports of Oregon’s relationship with Lyles surfaced in the winter and spring. Despite the hard line from the school that “[it] had done nothing wrong,” there was understandable doubt. As the rumors, substantiated or not, began to grow, Ducks all over grew uneasy. But after a period of relative calm (during which the school released the now-obviously transparent attempt at damage control in Lyles’ recruiting package), the heat began to simmer. Despite the universal feeling that something shady had probably gone down, it appeared the NCAA would have no hard evidence, no real proof that showed Oregon had paid Lyles to directly steer recruits.

Until now.

I know what Lyles says in the Yahoo! interview. He claims that although he overstepped his bounds as a recruiting service and mentor, he never steered any player to Oregon (or any other program, for that matter), nor did Oregon ask him to do so. That all sounds well and good, but will be worth about as much to the NCAA as Jim Tressel’s explanations at Ohio State’s hearing in August. Even if Lyles never specifically told a recruit to go to Oregon, he did enough to act as a booster for the school that the NCAA won’t really sweat the specifics. In principle, he was paid for delivering players to the Ducks. That’s all that matters.

Of course, much of this depends on whether you think Lyles is telling the truth now. Or whether he has any proof of his own that everything he’s admitted to actually occurred. But I wouldn’t bet against him, and I sure hope Oregon isn’t either. Getting into a staring contest with the guy you’ve been dealing with under the table? The only thing more stupid would be doing business with him in the first place.

I know what some Oregon fans will say to all the allegations. These people aren’t shy. Open any blog, listen to any sports radio show. You’ll find them. Oregon is the victim of a conspiracy to weaken the Pac-12. The coaches in Big 12 country – specifically, Texas – couldn’t stand losing out on good players from their home states. They want to bring Oregon down in their jealousy. The football traditionalists in the Big 10 and SEC don’t want to see a West Coast school have any success. That’s why USC got nailed and Ohio State and Auburn went free.

Then, when that runs out of steam…

Lyles is a liar and can’t be trusted. He changes his story daily. Other schools paid him, what about them? If he helped lots of recruits go to different schools, Oregon can’t be punished. Oregon only paid $25,000, that isn’t really that much in the recruiting world. You can’t get a good player for that much anyway – just look at what Cecil Newton was asking for ($180,000. Allegedly).

Doesn’t it all sound hauntingly familiar? We hear the same thing from each fan base every time a new school gets in trouble:

“Not us! We’d never cheat!”

“They’re jealous of our success!”

“There’s no proof. We’ll be fine once the facts come out.”

“This is all made up by (insert rival here) because we beat them every year.”

Funny how these situations tend to work out. I recall these exact arguments being made by USC fans… and Ohio State fans… and Auburn fans. One went down and another's on deck. It will be fascinating to see how all three of those schools come out of their respective entanglements. But it’s worth noting that in these scenarios, the old adage has usually proved to be correct: where there’s smoke, there’s fire. And if the NCAA actually does decide to come calling, there’s usually an inferno.

The West Coast Bias does exist in the polls. But the NCAA, despite what some people might think, isn’t biased; it’s just kind of incompetent. It tends to take more time than it needs to address cases. Ohio State got off easy before as a first-time offender. Just wait until they get burned for everything that’s come out in the last few months, particularly now that it’s been proved the school lied to the NCAA. That’s a major no-no. USC-type sanctions, anyone?

It’s true that Lyles is a slimy guy. He’s even admitted to it. But that doesn't mean he can’t tell the truth. His story just fits too well with what we already knew and confirms all of the conjecture that had been speculating around his role. It’s not as if he’s some unique figure in the college recruiting landscape. Remember the Bryce Brown saga? Some of the mentor types hanging around high school athletes are already three-quarters of the way to being agents. This is in no way a problem that’s isolated to Oregon, but that doesn’t really matter at this point. Lyles just said what everyone was thinking.

I was born a Duck. Both of my parents went to Oregon, I have other family and friends who attended, and I am a recent graduate myself. Nothing would make me happier than to see all of this bad news go away: Lyles exposed as a liar, a scoundrel desperate for media attention, or a tool of some sinister conspiracy to ruin the new Pac-12. I have always and will always want to see Oregon succeed. But I also have the awareness to recognize what is right in front of me. And I sure don’t like what I see now.

I’m also in the business of being fair. Last year I savaged both Auburn and Cam Newton for their painfully obvious pay-for-play scandal. I would be remiss to let the opportunity to do the same to Oregon pass by without a word. It would be better for college football if both teams went down, as opposed to both teams walking free. I still believe Auburn was guilty, as does 99 percent of the country outside Alabama. But the Tigers’ time will probably come, just as USC’s did. Just check out the aforementioned fan arguments.

The NCAA will likely never wield the fabled “Death Penalty” against another program. The catastrophic effect it had on the SMU program has virtually guaranteed that (a story that was chronicled fantastically in the ESPN 30 For 30 Documentary “Pony Excess”, by the way). The NCAA never wanted to use it, and I strongly doubt it will do so again. But if the allegations about Ohio State, Auburn and Oregon are true, no mercy should be shown. Loss of scholarships, postseason bans, it doesn’t matter. Short of the “Death Penalty,” the NCAA must do everything it can to send the message that cheating will not be tolerated. And there’s really only one way to do that.

Burn the house down.