Wednesday, November 16, 2011

The one where I rant about UCLA-USC

It was a decent day of football last Saturday, but overall I felt less than totally fulfilled. Maybe it was the excess of early Big 10 games (you like watching paint dry?) or the unappealing ranked matchups in the Big 12 and SEC. Maybe it was the fact that the MAC once again one-upped everyone during the week with another wild shootout. Maybe it was the sobering realization that the BCS is going to make people furious yet again.

The day’s later games offered some more fun – quadruple-overtime for KSU and A&M, Boise State shanking away another BCS bid, the underappreciated UCF-Southern Miss thriller – but in general the most-hyped contests failed to live up to their billing. Georgia annihilated overrated Auburn. Michigan shut down Illinois. USC crushed Washington. Oregon embarrassed Stanford. Unless you were rooting for one of those teams, there wasn’t much to get excited about.

I think the schedule should improve this week, which is why I’m so confused at ESPN’s proclamation that Saturday is a snooze-fest. Really? While the games involving good ranked teams are sprinkled throughout the day, the middle of November marks the beginning of rivalry games. This week features Boston College-Notre Dame, Vanderbilt-Tennessee, Arizona-Arizona State and Cal-Stanford. You may scoff at some of the teams there, but I respond, “For shame!” Rivalries are what make college football great, and the Territorial Cup/Duel in the Desert in particular is one of the sport’s nastiest. I think this has the potential to be a great week.

The potential chaos still to unfold is increasing each week. This season has run the gamut of crazy scenarios and isn’t even close to finishing. We’ve seen teams who look invincible suddenly lose (sorry, Stanford and Boise). We’ve seen teams who were seemingly down for the count rise back into the championship discussion (hello, Oklahoma and Oregon). Then there have been the constants, the stalwart squads able to ride out any challenge (obviously LSU and Oklahoma State). How the season will finish is anyone’s guess. All I know is it will be very interesting. And by the way, there are four MAC games before the weekend.

Top 25

1) LSU

A slow start was to be expected against Western Kentucky, but LSU did what they do best and turned it on after halftime to remain comfortably undefeated. After this week’s Ole Miss scrimmage the Tigers get Arkansas. I don’t see LSU having too much trouble with the Razorbacks, but there is precedent for an upset in the series.

2) Oklahoma State

Everyone expected the Cowboys to drop 50-plus on Texas Tech. No one expected them to shut out the Red Raiders offense. That was absolutely stunning. Tech has been a gold standard of offense in college football for a decade. Not allowing them a single point is incredible and speaks to the strides OSU has made in the past few seasons. The defense still isn’t elite, but for the first time I feel good about the Pokes versus rival Oklahoma.

3) Alabama

Guess who scored more on LSU than ‘Bama? Other than the obvious answer – everyone – the correct response is mighty Western Kentucky, just this past week. The Crimson Tide are clearly a team with a great defense and running back, but there’s nothing frightening about their offense. I sorely hope they don’t luck their way into the BCS title game.

4) Oregon

The Ducks had the most impressive win of the week, though Stanford made it look all too easy for them. Unfortunately, the fact that Oregon could have put up 65 on the Cardinal turned Stanford, in the eyes of the nation, into a fraud. That’s too bad, because there’s really only two teams I would pick to beat UO right now.

5) Oklahoma

Strange time for a bye, in my opinion. Coming off the nice victory over Texas A&M, the Sooners face Baylor and Iowa State before the Bedlam Game. I still like OU (they have a realistic outside shot at the BCS championship), but the loss of Dominique Whaley and Ryan Broyles could prove very costly.

6) Arkansas

It’s true that Arkansas could still win out and play their way into the championship game. But come on. Who is the best team the Razorbacks have beaten? South Carolina? Auburn? I don’t think this squad comes close to Alabama or LSU, which they should prove in just over a week’s time.

7) Clemson

I would have held the Tigers below Stanford (Wake Forest, after all, is no great win), but then I got to thinking about Stanford’s weakness: speed. Specifically, it’s offensive speed, the kind that Clemson has. No, they aren’t Oregon, but no one is. I’d wager the Tigers could score a decent amount on the Cardinal.

8) Stanford

When a team plays as well as Oregon did Saturday it’s unfair to punish the team they beat too harshly. I kept Stanford in the top ten because, let’s face it, the pickings ain’t too impressive this year. And after all, the Cardinal did win their first nine games. This isn’t a group of pushovers; just a team who got soundly beaten by an opponent whose greatest strength aligned with Stanford’s biggest weakness.

9) Boise State

Unbelievable. That finish in Boise? No, I’m talking about the fact that the minute I gave in and predicted an undefeated finish, the Broncos blew it again. You can take a lot of things away from TCU’s likely Mountain West-clinching upset, but the biggest one I saw was this: BSU’s back seven is mediocre. They do have an outstanding line, but an inability to stop explosion plays cost this team dearly.

10) Virginia Tech

Good win over Georgia Tech. Very solid. But as I look back at the Hokies’ schedule… eesh. The Yellow Jackets were the best squad VT has topped all season. The Coastal division will likely come down to the rivalry game with Virginia, but I would guess the Hokies have that one under control. The question now is whether the team can be more competitive with Clemson the second time around.

11) Houston

I moved the Cougars down a little from last week because I took a more critical look at their schedule. Obviously the Conference USA is no gauntlet, but I’d say it’s more challenging than say, the Mountain West. Even with a loss I’d take Boise State over Houston, but this is definitely the number two mid-major and they will play in a BCS bowl if they win out.

12) USC

Much like Houston, I took another look at USC and reevaluated my position. Then I went to ESPN.com the next day and read Ted Miller write about the same thing. Curse you, Ted. I’ll have to get these out faster. Although I’m picking Oregon to win this week, I had to move the Trojans up because I think they could smash a couple of these Big 10 teams.

13) Nebraska

I’m sorry, but isn’t it a little insulting that the BCS has Nebraska exactly one spot below Michigan State, a team they throttled? I’m on the record as a big Cornhusker-offense hater, but the overall talent of this team is undeniable and they are the best team in the Legends division. Unfortunately, the stumble against Northwestern will likely cost them a shot at the Rose Bowl.

14) Michigan State

Good one on you, MSU, for exorcizing those Iowa demons. The Hawkeyes aren’t world-beaters, but it was a solid victory. That said, I still see the Spartans in the same way I see Penn State and Michigan: teams who beat up on bad opponents and haven’t been seriously challenged by great squads. MSU has work to do yet to earn my respect.

15) Georgia

Let’s see… I had Auburn at a tentative number 25 last week, Georgia clobbered them… I had Georgia at 14… no, dropping the Bulldogs isn’t really fair. Thing is, they were only that high in the first place because I just didn’t have enough teams to put above them, and now I do (USC). Want to know how many teams with a winning record Georgia has beaten? Before last Saturday, the answer was none.

16) Kansas State

The magic semi-continues for K-State, who escaped with yet another single-digit win. The Wildcats have managed to beat some decent teams, so I have to give them some credit. Now for the bad news: they’ve given up 50 points in each of their last three games. I think Texas is very mediocre, but who knows how KSU will fare against the Horns after that grueling win over Texas A&M?

17) South Carolina

South Carolina survives for another week! The Gamecocks, um, gamely held off Florida to finish off their SEC slate. Considering Georgia has Kentucky this week, 6-2 probably isn’t going to get it done, which would be very embarrassing given how weak the East is this season. Spurrier is rumored to be on the way out as well. A changing of the guard may be coming to Columbia.

18) TCU

Jumping back into my rankings – and the Mountain West lead – is TCU, who has rebounded nicely after some nondescript play early in the year. Seriously, after that performance in the opener against Baylor, who could have seen this coming? Impressive that the Horned Frogs are in position to give the conference they’re leaving one last poke in the eye.

19) Michigan

The Wolverines could very well win out and play for the Big 10 title, but that scenario is extremely unlikely. It’s also possible that the defenses of Nebraska and Ohio State will humiliate UM in the next two weeks. I’m leaning toward the latter, though in any case I’m not looking forward to the Wolverines-Cornhuskers clash of offensive ineptitude we’re about to witness this Saturday.

20) Southern Miss

Survived a scare from UCF to climb to 9-1 and now face a pair of 2-8 squads to finish the season. I don’t want to jinx it, but I believe the Golden Eagles will play in the Conference USA championship. Though most mid-majors go the route of conference mate Houston to achieve success (all offense, air it out), USM has belied that formula in favor of solid defense. It’s working so far.

21) Notre Dame

Notre Dame was never really in contention for a BCS game after that awful start, but if not for some unreal red-zone sloppiness we could be talking about a 10-0 Irish team right now. I don’t think they’ll go out and upset Stanford in the finale, but they deserve a bit more respect than they’ve gotten.

22) Florida State

Much like Notre Dame, the Seminoles went through a rough stretch that cost them a chance at glory and dominated their lesser opponents. Aside from last week’s close win over Miami (FL) – which was a rivalry game, so be nice – FSU has been outstanding since falling to 2-3 in October. The three games they lost were by a total of 20 points. This isn’t a bad team by any means.

23) Baylor

Coming off a lucky comeback over putrid Kansas and about to be hammered by Oklahoma, the Bears won’t last long in my rankings. But if you’re going to look at every game, it’s worth noting that Baylor beat Mizzou, who just last week knocked off a Texas team who is inconceivably still in the top 25. We know what the Bears are: a great offense and a horrendous defense. Doesn’t mean they still couldn’t beat a lot of people.

24) Tulsa

Here are 7-3 Tulsa’s losses: Oklahoma, Oklahoma State and Boise State. The final scores in those games weren’t close, but they all came in a brutal four-week stretch to start the season. The Golden Hurricane have won every other game by an average of more than three touchdowns, with just one victory in single digits. It’s likely their season-ending clash with Houston will pit two ranked teams undefeated in league play.

25) Northern Illinois

It pains me to rank a team who lost to Kansas. But that’s why NIU is number 25. And to be honest, this team is just fun to watch. The Huskies’ offense is crazy-good, averaging over 40 a game. Quarterback Candler Harnish is a scary duel threat who has an outside shot at the second-ever 3,000-yard passing/1,000-yard season in FBS history (he’s sitting at 2594 and 1203 with three games to go). This has been the MAC’s best team the last two seasons.

Pac-12 Thoughts

Well, Oregon-Stanford played out more or less the way I expected, but we knew all along that the North champion would be one of those two. A far more interesting situation developed last week in the South, where UCLA, fresh off a potentially program-changing upset of Arizona State, was blown out at Utah. This opened the door for ASU to get right back into the driver’s seat after that frustrating collapse against the Bruins. Naturally, the Sun Devils then blew another game in a 10-point loss in Pullman.

The North is now in the hands of Oregon, who can clinch this Saturday or, with a loss to USC, still clinch against woeful Oregon State. I don’t see the Ducks losing, but the Trojans certainly present some problems. They’re easily the best passing team UO will face this year and feature some athletes defensively who could frustrate Oregon. In the end, I think the Ducks’ superior depth will win out, but USC is quite capable of winning this game.

The South has fallen into that nightmare scenario for the Pac-12, wherein it’s likely USC will win the division but be ineligible for the championship game. All season it seemed as if ASU had turned a corner (they did beat USC, after all), but after the last two weeks I’m not sure if the Sun Devils will win again. Meanwhile, eminently average UCLA has crept their way to the top of the division.

Considering that ASU could very well lose to rival Arizona this week, UCLA would seem to be in good position, but the Bruins still have to lose to – I mean play – rival USC. I have no idea what’s going to happen. By the way, you’d think UCLA would at least have an easy win this week against Colorado, but guess who the Buffaloes’ lone conference win came over. Was it the Arizona team that beat UCLA by 40? Interesting indeed.

Speaking of rivalries, since it’s reached that time of year, I’d like to bring up some of the Pac-12’s and also mention something that’s been bugging me for a while. Most people recognize that Oregon-Washington is the most heated rivalry in the league. As I mentioned earlier, Arizona-Arizona State is very nasty, and probably the second. Then there’s UCLA-USC, which manages to worm its way onto seemingly every list of college football’s best rivalries but is WITHOUT A DOUBT the most overrated rivalry in the country.

I want to be very clear about this: the Battle for Los Angeles is a stale, passionless, one-sided (in football) “rivalry” in name only, a decrepit relic of the halcyon days of West Coast football when only UCLA, USC and Washington mattered. It interests none of the city’s infamously bad sports fans and deserves absolutely no attention (which is what it usually gets in L.A.). The Big Game (Stanford-Cal) is better. The Civil War (Oregon-OSU) is better. Heck, UCLA-Cal is better. Even the mythical “Northwest Championship” between the Oregon and Washington schools (which is the best thing Rick Neuheisel ever did, and really needs a trophy) is more exciting than the Battle for the Victory Bell.

Heisman Watch

Andrew Luck, QB, Stanford

Are we seriously having a conversation about this? Trent Richardson? Are you freaking kidding me? Luck had a single so-so game against a defense playing their best ball of the year and got zero help from any of his receivers. It is unthinkable that this kid would not be named college football’s best player. Richardson over Luck would only be slightly more insane than Ingram over Suh.

Random Thoughts and Observations

I don’t have a whole lot of extras this week, but I did want to call attention to ESPN.com blogger Chris Low’s condescending recap of the LSU/Bama game, which he wrote after my post last week. I generally don’t mind him, but in this case he clearly saw a different contest than any rational person did. In that game, I saw a pair of elite defenses cow a couple of very average offenses. It’s time to stop pretending. Tt’s possible to have this both ways. The defenses of LSU and Alabama are excellent. It just so happens that their offenses are mediocre. Admitting this may, in turn, help us work out why so many SEC defenses are good: it’s the QB play. The best one in the conference is Georgia’s Aaron Murray. Who’s the second best? There’s no consensus; it fact, you have to think hard to even name another passable QB from the league.

I thought about this a lot since last week, trying to figure where Alabama’s A.J. McCarron would rank in another conference. Here’s where he’d stack up in the Pac-12:

Andrew Luck, Stanford; Matt Barkley, USC; Nick Foles, Arizona; Darron Thomas, Oregon; Brock Osweiler, Arizona State; Keith Price, Washington; Marshal Lobbestael and Jeff Tuel, Washington State; Jordan Wynn, Utah, then McCarron. Tenth. Yikes.

How about LSU’s Jarrett Lee and Jordan Jefferson? I’d put them about seventh or eighth, right where Wazzu’s QB’s sit. Remember, these are the starting QB’s for unquestionably the best teams in the SEC. That is stunning, as well as a bizarre recruiting blunder. For years I’ve wondered why LSU couldn’t get a half-decent QB; now Bama is in on the action too. What’s with that? You’re telling me these powerhouses can’t land a single good signal-caller? (And if you say the name JaMarcus Russell, I will slap you in the face.)

A little trivia to end the day: I said Northern Illinois’ Chandler Harnish has a shot to become just the second-ever player to pass for 3,000 yards and rush for 1,000 yards in the same season. Who was the first? Don’t look it up, that’s too easy. Think about it.

As a hint, I will say this: the player who did it is often called the first player to go for 2,000/1,000 in one season, which both undersells our mystery player’s accomplishment and is also several years late on the 2,000/1,000 achievement. That was Woody Dantzler of Clemson in 2001. Come on, people.

Thursday, November 10, 2011

End of an era

First off, I know I missed last week, but it was unavoidable given my schedule. This post will be somewhat abridged as well, even though there’s much to talk about, with scandals breaking and we the people sitting between the two most important games of the season. Let the Facebook record show that I did eventually pick LSU over Alabama (and would have had them number one last week). As far as Oregon and Stanford are concerned, you’ll have to wait just a little longer.

On the field, the number of unbeaten teams can now be counted on one hand. Of those five, it’s likely that Houston and Boise State will be on the outside looking in when all is said and done, though Boise’s got a better shot than Houston (contingent on Georgia… but more on that later). Realistically, it’s LSU, Okie State and Stanford, with Oregon, Alabama and Oklahoma peering over their shoulders. LSU’s remaining road isn’t too treacherous. Oklahoma State’s is fairly tough. Stanford’s isn’t bad, except for this week.

This of course means that all three will lose and we’ll have ourselves another 2007-style madhouse. Every time you seem to think a team is untouchable, they go out and pull a West Virginia (lost to 4-7 Pitt) or an LSU (lost to 7-4 Arkansas). What I’m saying is that there’s a lot of season left; let’s see how it plays out.

Last week’s Friday game wasn’t the best (USC-Colorado), but the MAC has generously picked up the tab for midweek madness… and jumped out of an exploding aircraft with it, a la Michael Bay. The last two weeks have seen a pair of shootouts in the mid-60s, including some of the most exciting football I’ve ever seen. No defense, but what are you gonna do? As it turns out, we really don’t need basketball.

Top 25

1) LSU

Would have been in the top spot last week if I’d gotten a post out, now has far and away the best resume in the country. Yet I still wouldn’t consider them a lock over any of my other schools in the top eight.

2) Oklahoma State

The schedule should (read: should) be manageable, but that defense always gives me cause for pause. Ask Oklahoma how well Texas Tech can move the ball.

3) Boise State

Three of the last four games are at home… I think we can go ahead and call it, the Broncos are going 12-0. Will it be enough? Not without Georgia winning out and beating LSU. It’s a shame there’s no playoff.

4) Stanford

Shaky performances the last two weeks: an indicator that the Cardinal are looking ahead to Oregon, or an ill omen? We’re about to find out.

5) Alabama

Yeah, they took LSU to overtime. The Tide also scored the fewest points of any of the Tiger’s FBS opponents this year (tied with Mississippi State). The defense is great. The offense is decidedly not.

6) Oregon

Oregon’s below ‘Bama because I fear the Tide’s defense would chew up and spit out the Ducks’ spread attack. However, if UO beats Stanford, the ranking will change.

7) Oklahoma

Unfathomable that OU is ahead of Oregon in the BCS. After Texas Tech’s collapse, that loss looks pretty bad. After the Sooners’ win over Texas A&M, though, I feel they may rebound to beat OSU.

8) Arkansas

Arkansas is a top-ten team this season because there aren’t enough good teams to put in front of them. That is not an endorsement on my part of the Razorbacks; this a highly flawed team with no quality wins.

9) Clemson

After their blowout loss to Georgia Tech, the Tigers got a week off, which I hope they’ll use to fix their issues and finish strong. As long as they beat Wake Forest this week, they’ll win the division. Problem? It’s possible their old rival Tech will be waiting.

10) Houston

This is probably too high for DIVISION I ALL-TIME PASSING LEADER Case Keenum and Co., but I have to ride this as long as I can. I’m glad to see Keenum rebound from his 2010 injury and become the rightful owner of multiple records.

11) Virginia Tech

The Hokies have just one loss, but I (and honestly, the voters) need more convincing. What have you done for me lately, VT? Beating Georgia Tech tonight would be good.

12) Nebraska

I’m also not that hot on Nebraska, who deserves to be ranked lower after getting upset by Northwestern. But the Cornhuskers decisively beat Michigan State and accordingly need to be ranked higher than the Spartans.

13) Michigan State

Yes, MSU reaped the benefit of the Nebraska loss and are now ahead of the Huskers in the Big Ten standings. But the teams have identical records and Nebraska waxed the Spartans. Do the voters use Earth logic when they send in their ballots?

14) Georgia

Everything rides on this week’s game against Auburn. Win, and the Bulldogs are likely in the SEC title game. Good thing it’s at home. A loss would send the East into chaos (not to mention ugly mediocrity).

15) Wisconsin

As the victim of two extremely unlucky last-second miracle plays, Wisconsin deserves to be ranked higher. But it’s also a fact that the Badgers simply haven’t looked the same since thrashing Nebraska. Until they pick it up, they stay down here.

16) USC

Even though SC got beat soundly by Arizona State, it’s become apparent that the best representative for the South in the Pac-12 championship would be the Trojans. Too bad they’re ineligible.

17) Georgia Tech

After a midseason hiccup, Tech righted the Ramblin’ Wreck with an upset of Clemson. If the Yellow Jackets knock off Virginia Tech tonight, they’ll likely see the Tigers again in the ACC championship. That’s some good motivation.

18) Kansas State

They gave up 50-plus to both Oklahoma schools, but at least the Wildcats were able to get into a shootout with the Cowboys last week. A Big 12 title (never realistic) is now out of the question; how will K-State react?

19) South Carolina

The Gamecocks’ record isn’t terrible, but it belies how bad they’ve looked the last month. This squad is in a major adjustment period, and I wouldn’t be shocked to see them go down to Florida.

20) Michigan

With Nebraska and Ohio State still on the schedule, last week’s loss to Iowa all but eliminated the Wolverines from Big 10 contention. Big Blue has been playing above their talent level this season and it seems to have caught up with them.

21) Penn State

I am so unconvinced by PSU’s record – accumulated against horrendous competition – I will call for them to lose all three of their remaining games (Nebraska, Ohio State and Wisconsin). That’s before you account for the impact of the scandal.

22) Cincinnati

After the way West Virginia has fallen apart, Cincy can lose to the Mountaineers this week and still win the Big East. Looking around the conference, though… I’m not sure if a single team should be ranked in the top 40, let alone the top 25.

23) Southern Miss

USM has calmly been disposing of their league foes with the kind of methodical devastation rarely seen outside of Boise State. The closest any Conference USA team has come to the Golden Eagles is 18 points.

24) Auburn

I don’t know what Auburn’s playing for at this point. The SEC and national titles are out of reach, they’ve been outclassed in their division, and they’ve got quarterback issues. Time to get ready for 2012.

25) Texas

Unfortunately, Texas Tech getting blown out by Iowa State the week before diminishes the win over the Red Raiders. However, there’s no denying that was Texas’ best performance of the season.

Pac-12 Thoughts

Yeah, there’s USC-Washington, but this week is about the game we’ve been waiting all year for. Stanford wants to avenge their lone 2010 loss and Oregon wants to prove they’re still the top dogs in the conference. It’s a big reason Andrew Luck came back to school. GameDay is in Palo Alto and Stanford-Oregon is finally here.

I thought for a while about how I wanted to frame my prediction for the game, but then ESPN.com’s Ted Miller went ahead and beat me to it. All season I leaned toward Stanford – the Cardinal’s imposing offense looked like a perfect match to grind down the Ducks’ average defense. I didn’t expect Stanford to shut UO down defensively, but I figured they wouldn’t have to.

Over the last month, though, my feelings swung the other way. I started really looking at the teams Stanford beat, particularly the last two games. USC is good, but not great, and the Cardinal was fortunate to beat them. Oregon State is just bad, and the Beavs were in the game late until Stanford put it away.

I also watched Oregon step up with backup players against Arizona State. Then I re-watched the 2010 game that decided the Pac-10 championship. What struck me was how Stanford – just as in 2009, when they upset the Ducks on the Farm – needed everything to go perfectly in order to build an early lead and hang on.

Last year Stanford had one nice drive, then benefitted from two sloppy turnovers by Oregon to go up 21-3. From that point, though, they were outscored 49-10, and the field goal was also the result of a turnover. Although their offense was (and still is) quite potent, the Cardinal managed only two sustained scoring drives in the entire game. The common thread from both 2009 and 2010 was that Oregon gave Stanford some breaks early in the game, then ran wild. Two years ago Stanford managed to wear down the Ducks just enough to win; last season they ran out of steam.

On the other side of the ball, once Oregon got rolling in 2010 Stanford had no shot to stop them. That was also the case in 2009. I’ve said before that I don’t think Stanford and Oregon are as good as last year, but I think they’ve both dropped off relatively the same amount. I don’t see how the Cardinal defense has improved enough to slow down the Ducks. Certainly Oregon isn’t great defensively, and Stanford should score. But with Stanford reeling a little from injuries and Oregon starting to get healthy, along with Stanford’s lack of any real receivers other than their tight ends, I think the Ducks will be able to hold off the Cardinal.

Heisman Watch

Andrew Luck, QB, Stanford

Let’s see what the future top draft pick can do this weekend.

Random Thoughts and Observations

I stand by my previous statement regarding a rematch: remember Ohio State-Michigan. It doesn’t matter if it’s a shootout or a defensive struggle; both games were decided by three points. I will not endorse a rematch until no other undefeated teams remain, it’s that simple. Yes, Alabama held LSU to three field goals, one in overtime. But their offense looked pitiful. The Crimson Tide do not have elite skill position players at any position other than Trent Richardson, which is inexcusable for a team that is supposedly a BCS title contender. ‘Bama got their shot. They blew it. End of story.

So now we come to Penn State, dealing with the sudden and shocking news of sexual abuse of children by former defensive coordinator Jerry Sandusky. I can say very little about this developing story that hasn’t already been said. Joe Paterno and the school president have both been fired effective immediately, which is the only logical decision the board of trustees could have made. The support for Paterno from the student body isn’t surprising given how much of a mystique has been built around the man, but it ended up reflecting very poorly on the school when a minor riot broke out.

Obviously the allegations are horrifying, though what’s almost as shocking is the attempted backlash some Paterno supporters are trying to stir up. To anyone who would possibly not support his removal, read the indictment. If you still think Paterno did “enough,” there’s something seriously wrong with you. The whole affair is stunning and sickening, and speaks to the bubble within some universities operate. It’s likely that the majority of Penn State fans understand that the school and scandal are bigger than Paterno. But the ignorance of the minority, on display last night in State College, is what everyone will remember.

Wednesday, October 26, 2011

October, we hardly knew ye

Now THAT is why I love this game. Finally, a weekend full of nothing but entertaining, quality football. It’s been so long. There was an historic upset in Norman, a historic miracle in East Lansing and a historic moment for the record books in Houston. It was one of those magical Saturdays that make college football special. I can’t remember the last time in this sport that we got such a perfect day.

The greatness wasn’t limited to the weekend, either. We also got yet another exceptional Friday night, this time in Big East Country. West Virginia got absolutely spanked at Syracuse (really didn’t see that coming), which left Rutgers as one of just two teams still unbeaten in conference play. Naturally, the Knights then lost on the road to Louisville. What fun! This week there’s another potential barnburner when BYU travels to Fort Worth to take on former league rival TCU.

First, to the top ten, where a pair of teams went down. Neither Oklahoma nor Wisconsin went quietly, but when the dust had cleared both had lost control of their own destiny. Honestly, the Sooners were fortunate to even be in the game against Texas Tech, who suffered a mid-second half lull (probably assuming the game was over) that nearly cost them. The Badgers, on the other hand, were unlucky to lose to Michigan State on such a fluky play. However, it’s hard for me to have sympathy for Wisconsin after they made the unforgivable error of gifting the Spartans two timeouts.

With the BCS standings now in shake-up mode the questions have started rolling in. How soon until Boise State gets passed? What will happen if Stanford and Oklahoma State both win out? How does Clemson fit into the picture? Could Kansas State possibly make a run (I’ll nip that one in the bud right now – no)? Oklahoma’s loss does impact what I wrote before about the top three teams in the country, though now you can just plug in “State” after I wrote “Oklahoma” before and it all still works.

Top 25

1) Alabama

I had to think hard before giving the top spot to Alabama again. The poor first half against Tennessee was troublesome. At times, as I have expressly said, the ‘Bama offense just sputters. The skill talent outside of Trent Richardson is remarkably bereft of explosiveness. I’m truly not sure about how this team will put points on the board against LSU. During the week off before those two teams play, it’s highly possible I’ll decide to move the Crimson Tide down.

2) LSU

The defense is a hair behind Alabama’s, but the offense is certainly miles ahead of the Tide’s. As I said, it was tough for me to not move the Tigers up, but I do hold by my yearlong assessment that Auburn just ain’t that good. LSU proved that this week. Even so, I may be switching over to the Bayou Bengals in the LSU/’Bama argument. All year I’ve backed the Tide, but this is starting to feel like one of those seasons where everything breaks right for LSU. After all, it has been four years.

3) Boise State

It’s crunch time for Boise. After another uninspiring win, the Broncos have to start blowing people out to avoid being passed, and it still probably won’t be enough. If Oklahoma State and Stanford keep winning they will jump Boise. The schedule is just going to get too weak. But… there is still Georgia. The Broncos’ unimpressive Mountain West wins will be less noticeable if the Bulldogs can: a) best Florida this week, b) win the SEC East and c) …upset the West division winner? It sounds crazy, but you never know…

4) Oklahoma State

Strange as it sounds, I think the Oklahoma loss actually hurt OSU. The spotlight now shifts fully onto the Cowboys, which is something they’re not used to, and their win over OU in the Bedlam game would be diminished somewhat now that the Sooners have lost. Make no mistake, OSU still controls their own destiny, but the schedule isn’t easy and now their chief rival has gotten a wake-up call. The Cowboys have to hope they can match Oklahoma’s intensity from here on out, something they didn’t do for stretches against Missouri.

5) Stanford

That was easily the best Stanford has looked since beating Virginia Tech in the Orange Bowl. Washington was able to keep up with the Cardinal early but succumbed to an avalanche of power runs and sharp passes. So is Stanford just amazing, or was Washington overrated? You have to think the Huskies were in over their heads, but the Cardinal are probably better than I gave them credit for. It was the first time all year they had looked the part of a championship contender, though.

6) Oregon

Oregon coasted after the first quarter against Colorado and gets another weakling this Saturday when staggering Washington State comes to town. The game against the Cougs will be a formality as the Ducks prepare for their two-game road trip in Seattle and Palo Alto. Like Stanford, I’m still having problems judging the Ducks. They’re much better than their overmatched opponents, but it’s hard to say if they’re really elite. On a good note, depth doesn’t seem to be a problem.

7) Clemson

If LSU isn’t this year’s “team of destiny,” then it’s definitely Clemson. After receiving some marvelous 2010-Auburn-style luck against Maryland last week, the Tigers got some timely breaks against North Carolina this week to turn a close game into a blowout. At times this team can look unstoppable, though their reliance on a West Coast-type short passing game could possibly hurt them as teams look to build on the Tar Heels’ success using the all-out blitz.

8) Michigan State

I’m not going to say that last play wasn’t lucky, because it was. However, MSU acquitted themselves well in this game, far better than I expected them to, which means they might really be ready to take the next step. It starts this week against Nebraska, a game the Spartans should win. I probably still wouldn’t pick MSU against Wisconsin in a Big 10 title game rematch, but as the 31-31 score with four seconds left showed, Sparty is at least Bucky’s equal.

9) Wisconsin

I put the Badgers and Spartans back-to-back because of how even that game was played, with just a miracle pass all that separated the teams. It’ll kill Wisconsin fans to hear it because the BCS title just went up in smoke, but all is not lost. The Badgers have a manageable schedule that could very possibly result in a second chance at MSU in Indianapolis. They’ve got to correct those killer lulls like they had against the Spartans, though. After going up 14-0, Wisconsin was outscored 31-3 until late in the game.

10) Arkansas

Arkansas is lucky to still be in the top ten, but fortunately for the Razorbacks they beat my number 11 team. I don’t know what was going on for two quarters there against Ole Miss. 17-0? You know the Rebels are terrible, right? Luckily, Arkansas realized it and woke up in time to squeeze out a 29-24 victory. They didn’t fool the computers, though, who dropped the Hogs from ninth to 10th. I hope I’m not warming to the evil side of the BCS.

11) Texas A&M

The next three weeks are huge for the Aggies. After warming up against Mizzou this week, they go to Oklahoma and then Kansas State. That’s a fairly challenging trio. A&M is capable of winning them all, though. If they do get through that stretch, they could grab themselves a share of the conference championship if OU wins the Bedlam game. A&M’s season is far from over, and they could make a big statement to that effect against the Tigers this week.

12) Oklahoma

You can focus on the impressive comeback and the fact that the Sooners would have sent the game to overtime if not for a missed chip-shot field goal. I’m going to focus on the porous defense for the first three quarters and the fact that OU was lucky Texas Tech didn’t capitalize on all their opportunities and drop 60 on them. I mean, wow. When it was 31-7 it has hard to believe that was an Oklahoma team out there. The Sooners are going to have to regroup in a hurry if they want to win the league championship again.

13) Kansas State

I refuse to believe that this K-State team has been anything more than fortunate to scrape by with a bunch of close wins. I know that they have some quality victories, but it just feels like the Wildcats are due for a major thrashing. The schedule (Oklahoma, Oklahoma State, Texas A&M, Texas) gets brutal over the next month, so we’ll finally get to see what KSU is made of starting this weekend.

14) Nebraska

After a win over Minnesota in which the Cornhuskers appeared at times to be toying with the Gophers, Nebraska gets Michigan State at home in a huge divisional showdown. Win, and anything’s still possible for Big Red. A loss would pretty much end any Big 10 championship dreams and likely sentence the Huskers to a fairly unexciting postseason destination. The Big 10’s probably not getting two BCS teams this year, so this week’s game could be the difference between the Rose Bowl and the Outback or Gator Bowl.

15) Houston

Case Keenum was marvelous against Marshall, completing 24 of 28 passes for six touchdowns. He broke Timmy Chang’s all-time total yardage record, with Chang’s passing yardage record and Graham Harrell’s passing touchdown record within reach in the next few games. Houston seems to have finally broken out and become the BCS-busting kind of team I expected them to be, though I don’t know what took them so long. That early-season slump they went through was dreadful.

16) Arizona State

Good time for a bye, Sun Devils. ASU was in danger of waking up on Sunday tied with UCLA in the South division. Then Arizona reminded us how silly that idea was when the Wildcats obliterated the Bruins. Strangely enough, it’s ASU’s rival ‘Zona who may pose the biggest threat to the Sun Devils’ chances of winning out, a concept that would have sounded ludicrous a couple weeks ago. Now I think Arizona will be ASU’s hardest remaining test.

17) Virginia Tech

A decent win over a really bad Boston College team – seriously, what happened to the Eagles? – didn’t do much to sway me on the Hokies. I’m looking at the rest of their schedule and don’t see a whole lot there that scares me (Georgia Tech possibly, but the Yellow Jackets are in free-fall), but the ACC is just so thoroughly average that it’s hard to get excited about even a one-loss Tech squad.

18) Texas Tech

Have I not been saying that Texas Tech is a good team? Validation is a great thing. The win over Oklahoma probably won’t go down as the biggest victory in program history – that honor still goes to the win over top-ranked Texas in 2008 – but it should go down as the biggest upset in Red Raider history, considering the game was in Norman and Tech was unranked. Seth Doege is just another in a long line of brilliant Air Raid system quarterbacks.

19) USC

I was completely ready to dismiss USC’s 5-1 record because they hadn’t really beaten anyone, but that was an eye-opener. Even at 4-3 I think Notre Dame is decent, but the Trojans played outstanding football and beat the Irish by two TD’s. A very impressive performance. Could SC knock off Stanford this week? It’s not out of the question, but after the Washington game I’m not about to pick against the Cardinal.

20) West Virginia

I’m banking on the Syracuse game being a fluke more than anything else, because that was awful. WVU showed some chops against LSU this year, so I know the Mountaineers aren’t just a bunch of overrated scrubs, but they’ll have to shape up if they want to win the Big East. It’s a true wild-card conference, and while the ‘Eers are good, they’re not good enough that they can coast each week and still walk away with the title.

21) South Carolina

Now we see what the Gamecocks did on their bye week. The three remaining SEC opponents – Tennessee, Arkansas and Florida – all have flaws. Some significant. Even with the loss of their starting QB and RB, it’s possible that South Carolina could go 2-1 (I’m not holding out hope for that Arkansas game). But if they collapse in the wake of losing their two stars, 0-3 isn’t out of the realm of possibility at all. Georgia’s probably going 2-1 at least, so the Gamecocks need to beat Tennessee this weekend.

22) Baylor

I want to still have faith in Baylor. I want to believe their losses are the result of a difficult schedule and a tough conference. It’s undeniable, though, that the Bears have been sliding the past couple of weeks. In all likelihood, they’ll lose to Oklahoma State this week and drop out of my rankings, then return two weeks later after beating Kansas and Missouri. But I also want to keep the faith in Robert Griffin, who poses some interesting problems for that average OSU defense.

23) Penn State

I really don’t think Penn State is any good, but I ran out of teams to rank. The Nittany Lions are 7-1, but look at their wins. They haven’t beaten a single FBS team (not counting Eastern Michigan, and I won’t) by more than 10 points, and the 10-point win was last week against 2-5 Northwestern. The seven teams they’ve beaten have a combined 15 total wins over other FBS schools, most of those coming against the MAC. The Nittany Lions only average 23 points a game. Yet they sit at 4-0 in Big 10 play, so more power to ‘em, I guess.

24) Southern Miss

Scoff if you will – I certainly did when I saw the Golden Eagles in the Coaches’ Poll – but USM’s record isn’t any worse than Penn State’s. At 6-1, this team has wins over Virginia (Georgia Tech couldn’t do that) and a red-hot SMU team who had previously won five straight. Put it this way: Navy has four losses by a total of eight points. Their other loss was to Southern by 28. By most metrics I use, this seems like a pretty solid team.

25) Georgia

Georgia is not a team I’m fond of. As with Penn State, I think they’ve beaten absolutely no one to justify being ranked. To see what I’m talking about with the schedule, here you go: after losing their first two, the Bulldogs beat… Coastal Carolina. A really terrible Ole Miss squad. A bad Mississippi State team. A below-average Tennessee team. And Vanderbilt, yet again the SEC’s whipping boy. Boy, looks like a top-25 worthy team to me! Unfortunately, once again I’m pretty much out of teams, and I’ll be damned if I’m going to hand over an inflated ranking to Texas or Florida.

Pac-12 Thoughts

Looks like all Arizona needed was to get that angry baboon off their backs, eh? That Thursday night performance against UCLA was off-the-charts awesome. True, UCLA’s weakness (no offense) played right into the Wildcats’ hands. Er, paws. But that shouldn’t demean the effort by ‘Zona, who led 48-7 midway through the fourth quarter in a game that very likely will get a second Pac-12 coach canned. I know the Bruins’ AD gave Neuheisel a vote of confidence, but if UCLA doesn’t get to a bowl he’s gone.

Oregon State, USC and Cal all also put up nice wins, even if some of the competition wasn’t top-notch. For OSU, getting the blowout over Wazzu was, at the least, a big confidence builder in a revenge scenario. Cal only beat Utah, but the Bears were so starved for a victory that even a win over an injury-riddled team who appears to have lost hope was a cause for celebration. Then there was USC, who broke open their tight contest with Notre Dame with a hilariously ill-timed (for the Irish) defensive TD and rode the ensuing momentum to the game’s end. I can’t stress enough how badly the conference needed that win.

Of course, the semi-shocker was the ease with which Stanford dealt with Washington. Speaking as someone who was foolish enough to think the Huskies had a chance to be competitive, whoa. As I said last week, I wasn’t totally sold on UW, but I thought the Cardinal’s paper-thin resume to this point warranted some healthy skepticism about the players around Andrew Luck. Stanford apparently knew there were doubters, because they abused the Dogs back to also-ran status. The only remaining issue I have is the fact that Washington’s defense is really bad… but let’s not taint this. An impressive showing by the Tree.

This week we finally get to see all 12 conference teams in action against each other for the first time. There’s an interesting hodge-podge of games both competitive and ugly. Oregon and Arizona State are at home facing bottom-feeders WSU and Colorado, respectively. Not a lot of excitement there. On the other hand, Oregon State-Utah and Cal-UCLA are two intriguing contests where I don’t see a whole lot of difference between the opponents. And how about Stanford-USC? Can I talk myself into a Trojans upset? There’s no way the Cardinal stumble here, right? But… it is in the Coliseum, at night… USC has been playing well lately... no. I can’t do it. Not after what Stanford did last week.

The final game of the day is in Seattle, where newly humbled Washington meets Arizona. The teams have opposite records (UW’s 5-2 to ‘Zona’s 2-5), but I could see this one going either way. The Wildcats are coming off an emotional win, the Huskies off an emotional loss. Even with suspensions, Arizona should be able to move the ball on Washington’s beleaguered D. Then again, everyone’s been able to move the on Arizona, so there ought to be a lot of scoring on both sides. Should be a fun game.

Heisman* Watch

Robert Griffin was off, Kellen Moore had a so-so outing and I don’t want to jinx Case Keenum. No one deserves to be mentioned in the same category as *Luck this week.

Random Thought and Observations

Missouri is continuing their “will-they-won’t-they” dance with the SEC, which is reportedly ready to admit the Tigers. Everybody around this relationship is tired and embarrassed at this point and just wants to see the two get together already. By all accounts the Big 12 has made preparations for life without Mizzou (gasp) and is ready to invite West Virginia immediately, along with a couple of the Mountaineers’ current league members. Kinda spreads the conference out, but whatever. At this point, anything that just finishes off the Big East and ends the “we can still save this thing!” charade is fine by me. Really, it’s a shame the Big East is dying. Just not in football.

Perception isn’t always reality in sports. How else do you explain upsets? But perception can mean something, and rarely is it more important than in college football. In football, terms like “soft,” “slow,” “undisciplined” or “scared” can become entrenched in both the public mindset and in a team’s psyche. When Texas A&M started to give up a huge halftime lead to Arkansas last month, everyone on the sidelines, in the stands and around the country was thinking “Here we go again.” The Aggies, fresh off their embarrassing meltdown against Oklahoma State, clearly felt it too and fell apart again.

The Big 10 has been mocked for years as a slow conference because of its playing style, which is not reflective of the actual team speed of the league’s members. The Pac-10 was often called soft in the early 2000s, even though several high-profile bowls proved that the West could play just as physical as anyone. The Big East… well, the Big East has proved itself to be pretty bad lately, but has also had some huge BCS upsets as well.

My point in bringing this up is to put the spotlight on one team. This team has been touted as nigh-unstoppable in the regular season multiple times and has been defeated multiple times in BCS bowls against elite competition. Because of this, this team has gained a paper tiger reputation, unable to win when it really matters. I’m talking of course, about Ohio State. Just kidding! I’m talking about the new Ohio State, Oregon!

As much as Oregon fans won’t want to hear it, the truth is that there are some striking parallels between the two schools. Ohio State was nationally trashed from 2006 to 2009, not coincidentally a span in which the Buckeyes lost to Florida in the BCS Championship Game, lost to LSU in the same game and lost to Texas in the Fiesta Bowl. Looking back now, it’s obvious Ohio State ran into some really good teams and just got beat, which is nothing to be ashamed of. But at the time, the nation’s fury was directed at OSU for being “overrated.” I should know; I said it too. Often. In the end, the Buckeyes didn’t regain their reputation until they won a BCS bowl, also not coincidentally…

…against Oregon. Beating the Ducks in the 2009 Rose Bowl was a huge step for OSU, who then went on to defeat Arkansas in the Sugar Bowl last year. Now, there have been some extenuating circumstances with the Ohio State program since, but that doesn’t mean they didn’t increase national respect for their play (and hey, Oregon’s got off-field issues, too. More parallels! Parallels for everyone!). The point is, Oregon has now suffered the exact same amount of high-profile losses as Ohio State, if you count the loss to LSU. If Oregon is on the same trajectory as OSU – and after what happened to Jim Tressel, let’s hope to God they’re not, but play along – at the end of this season the Ducks could be in line to pass along the “overrated” label to another team.

So who’s it going to be? Nebraska or Michigan State, whom Oregon could potentially see in the Rose Bowl? I suppose UO could make an at-large BCS bowl by running the table but losing to ASU in the Pac-12 title game, which could mean anyone – Clemson, Okahoma, or even a rematch with LSU (don’t think the bowl-makers wouldn’t jump on that in a heartbeat). If the Ducks do make a BCS bowl again, though, they’ll be due. Their opponent had better be ready to bear the nation’s “overrated” wrath. Until they win, though, Oregon is new Ohio State. And they’ll have to live with that stigma for at least a little while longer.

Brief notes: The brawl in the Arizona-UCLA game was tacky and could get people fired, but I think it was probably just what the Wildcats needed to prove to themselves that they weren’t going to lie down against teams anymore… The “Boston Globe” apparently reported that the Big East was looking to invite the entire Mountain West/Conference USA conglomerate to create a 30+ team bizarro-league that stretched across the entire continent. I hope the Big East wasn’t that desperate, because it would be really pathetic… Yes, Oregon could play LSU again, I just didn’t want to explain it in detailed fashion above, so here goes: Alabama beats LSU for the BCS title game spot, Oklahoma State runs the table and joins the Tide. LSU gets a Sugar Bowl invite, Oklahoma goes to the Fiesta Bowl (replacing Oklahoma State), Clemson runs the table but settles for the Orange Bowl and ASU upsets Oregon for the Pac-12 title and the Rose Bowl. The Big 10 sends Wisconsin to the Rose Bowl after the Badgers beat MSU in a rematch, leaving Big East champ West Virginia (automatic bid), Oregon and undefeated Boise State to fill the last three spots. The selection order this season is Orange, Sugar, Fiesta, so the Orange Bowl takes West Virginia for a regional battle with Clemson and the Sugar Bowl delightedly takes UO against LSU so that Boise can battle Oklahoma in the Fiesta Bowl again. Fun stuff, see you next week…

Tuesday, October 18, 2011

What was life like before the ultraconference?

There were some good upsets this weekend despite the void of interesting matchups, but overall I still found last Saturday to be lacking in real drama. Really? Michigan isn’t that good and lost to the first decent team they played? Shocking news. Virginia knocking off Georgia Tech was surprising given how bad the Cavaliers have been recently, though their clock-killing final drive was impressive.

Other than that not much fun was had. The back-to-back kickoff returns for touchdowns in the Oklahoma State-Texas game provided an exciting moment in a contest that largely consisted of Texas staving off the inevitable (although give the Longhorns credit for hanging around). Oklahoma let Kansas do the same for WAY longer than the Jayhawks had any right to, whereas Stanford came out of halftime against Washington State and put the hammer down.

Oregon-Arizona State was a pretty good game for a half, but early in the third quarter it became apparent that the Ducks were going to pull their patented second-half landslide move. Considering that Oregon played without LaMichael James and lost QB Darron Thomas, the final score was pretty impressive. However, ASU showed in that game that they might only be the fourth-best team in the conference, so both Washington and Stanford should prove to be bigger tests for UO.

Coming up this week there aren’t a lot of matchup that blow me away on paper, but the schedule is certainly better than it has been lately. Oklahoma State on the road at Missouri has potential, as does fellow early timeslot game North Carolina-Clemson. After losing to Miami (FL), a team I thought they should beat, the Tar Heels will probably be out to prove themselves against the Tigers. Speaking of Tigers, Auburn plays at LSU, though I’m not optimistic about the visiting team’s chances in that one.

In the evening the schedule really gets going, with the annual USC-Notre Dame game, Texas Tech and Oklahoma (a good test for the Sooners’ defense) and a pair of primetime top-25 matchups. Wisconsin plays at Michigan State (I think the Spartans will get killed, but you never know) and resurgent Washington plays at Stanford in a game that suddenly has huge Pac-12 implications. Stanford seems like the better pick at home… but the Huskies have been pretty good this year. I’m not sure. More on that game later. To the top 25!

Top 25

1) Alabama

Nothing that happened this weekend did anything to change my opinion of the Crimson Tide. They played a bad Ole Miss team and whaled on them. Though the lion’s share of the media attention has been on LSU’s defense, I still think Alabama’s unit is the best in the country. It’ll be fascinating to see the two on the same field in November. I’m not expecting a whole lot of points. At least, not from the offenses.

2) LSU

Tennessee isn’t an impressive win by any standard, but LSU moved up because Oklahoma failed to put Kansas away early. After ‘Bama this is undoubtedly the best defense in the nation. What has been – and continues to be – surprising about the Tigers is their QB play. Jarrett Lee has been consistent and turnover-free, the two things that he could never seem to be in past seasons. Playing with a good running game and elite defense helps, but Lee has still been a pleasant surprise.

3) Oklahoma

It’s hard to fault a team for winning by 30, but Kansas is terrible and OU was only up by 13 early in the fourth quarter before tacking on some meaningless touchdowns. The score was 27-17 at halftime. I can’t reward the Sooners for that kind of effort. It doesn’t make much of a difference because they still control their own destiny, but this team does tend to go flat at times. I know I wouldn’t pick them to beat either LSU or Alabama at this point.

4) Boise State

Boise State chalked up another predictable blowout win against weak competition as they entered Mountain West play. The Broncos’ schedule is just pitiful from here on out, but they did get a nice break when South Carolina lost star running back Marcus Lattimore for the year. This dramatically improves Georgia’s chances to win the SEC East, which Boise will need to garner any late-season respect.

5) Wisconsin

I don’t want to talk about Russell Wilson as a Heisman Candidate because I think he stepped into a remarkably beneficial situation with the Badgers. However, that doesn’t mean that he isn’t quite good, or that Wisconsin’s offense isn’t just as physically intimidating – if not more so – than in 2010. My only reservation is regarding how that line might perform against a great defense. Wisconsin hasn’t played anyone yet who comes close to elite.

6) Oklahoma State

I love the Cowboys’ offense and would like to pull the trigger on jumping them ahead of Wisconsin. But we’ve seen this kind of OSU team in the past, and they generally struggle when they play good defenses or are forced to actually play good defense themselves. This year seems pretty much the same to me. The defense is still average and could easily cost the team a game. The good news is that Oklahoma is the only opponent OSU has who can bring that killer combination of offense and defense.

7) Stanford

In the first half against Wazzu Stanford looked pretty overrated. Then the second half began and Andrew Luck set out to remind everyone why the Cardinal are in the top 10. That was a good showing. At the same time, though, this week seemed to reinforce what I – and now some national commentators – have recognized: Stanford just isn’t that good. The offense can be great at times, but it’s nowhere near as explosive as it needs to be for the Cardinal to cover their defensive deficiencies.

8) Oregon

Oregon has played two opponents better than anyone Stanford has faced, but because the Cardinal are undefeated I won’t disrespect them by moving the Ducks ahead. That second half against the Sun Devils was pretty nice, though. The issue now seems to be health – with LaMichael James and Darron Thomas in the lineup, I think Oregon can easily beat both Washington and Stanford. The backups played well Saturday, but without their starters the Ducks won’t win the North.

9) Clemson

Wow. That was the “Clemson” game everyone was waiting for. That game when a highly touted Tigers team flops against a middling opponent and loses, dragging the season into ruin. But this time, somehow, Clemson managed to come back. Getting into a shootout with Maryland isn’t something to be particularly proud of, but the bottom line is that the Tigers are still undefeated. Now they have to avoid doing the same thing again.

10) Arkansas

After getting through a rough stretch the Razorbacks got a much-needed bye. Now they begin preparing for LSU. It sounds crazy, given that Arkansas doesn’t play the Tigers until the regular-season finale, but there’s truly not another team left on the schedule that should be able to beat this team. Ole Miss? Vandy? South Carolina, sans Lattimore? Don’t make me laugh. Barring a massive setback, the Hogs will be 10-1 when they face LSU.

11) Texas A&M

A&M is a lot better than the voters seem to think. This is where people need to look past the record (which at 4-2 isn’t even that bad) to focus on who the Aggies have played and how they lost. If not for a couple of very close losses this team would be in the top five. Last Saturday’s big win over Baylor proved that A&M isn’t going to just go away. They’ve got a couple weeks to get ready for Oklahoma, who they beat last year. There’s no reason they can’t do it again.

12) West Virginia

The Mountaineers had a week off and reaped the benefits of having teams ahead of them lose. Now comes the hard part – oh, wait. This is the Big East. There is no hard part. As long as WVU takes care of business, I don’t see any reason why they don’t win out. They’ve got the best offense and QB in the conference, and in this league that’s literally all you need.

13) Nebraska

Nebraska had the same good bye-week fortune West Virginia did. This week the Cornhuskers get Minnesota, so chalk that one up in the win column. From there, the schedule gets a little tricky. Michigan State, Northwestern, Penn State and Michigan isn’t exactly a murderer’s row, but it’s not a stretch when you want to be playing less than your best ball, either. I’m guessing the division title will come down to that Michigan State game.

14) Michigan State

So it turns out Michigan wasn’t any good. Again. Sparty put the Wolverines in their place for the fourth straight season (ouch) and in the process alerted the rest of the Big 10 to watch out. The next two games against Wisconsin and Nebraska will probably decide the season for MSU, so it’s a good thing they built some confidence this week. Question is, will they be feeling so happy after they face the Badgers?

15) Kansas State

This is, in all likelihood, far too high for this team. The record is sterling at 6-0, but have you seen the wins? 10-7 over Eastern Kentucky. 28-24 over Miami (FL). 36-35 over Baylor. What I’m saying is that the Wildcats are lucky to be unbeaten. This is the Michigan State of 2011 – decent and plucky, but with little real talent. At some point, one of the Big 12’s elite is going to drop 50 on them.

16) Houston

The Cougars were lucky to have the week off, because without teams ahead of them losing I wouldn’t have been able to move them up in good conscience. Houston now faces a Boise State-esque conundrum: how can we prove that we’re good against the competition we play? The answer is to throw it. Don’t stop until Case Keenum holds every last NCAA passing record. Come on, Cougars, don’t let me down.

17) Arizona State

For about 20 minutes of game time against Oregon, Arizona State looked great. The offense was tossing the ball all over the place, the defense was stuffing the run… and then the Ducks decided to remind the Sun Devils why they’ve won the past two conference titles. The loss was disheartening, but not damaging, as it’s still almost guaranteed ASU wins the South. They will need to make some changes if they face Oregon again, though.

18) Washington

Yet another team who got a well-timed bye. I hope the Huskies used it well, because the get to go to Stanford this week. I know that UW still hasn’t beaten anyone of note, but I do think they’re improved. The question is, how much? Just a normal improvement after last year’s promising campaign, or a real jump? Stanford will provide the answer. It’s entirely possible that Washington is about to get a huge reality check. The extra week couldn’t have hurt, though.

19) Notre Dame

I’m taking a leap on this because I haven’t seen Notre Dame play in two weeks. But the truth is that the Fighting Irish should be 7-0, not 5-2, and they’ve put up some nice offensive numbers recently. With the USC defense a question mark and the offense inconsistent, I feel fairly confident that Notre Dame will beat the Trojans this week. I hope the BCS bowl talk doesn’t start, because they don’t deserve it. But this is a pretty good team.

20) Virginia Tech

Tech should be able to rest this week given that they’re playing Boston College. The schedule the rest of the way includes teams that could all possibly present problems for the Hokies but probably won’t be too difficult to handle. Georgia Tech is the exception, but I don’t love the Ramblin’ Wreck as much as I did after their loss to Virginia. I think Virginia Tech has a solid shot to get to 10 wins, if not 11.

21) Georgia Tech

The loss to Virginia was disappointing, but even more troublesome was the play of QB Tevin Washington. It’s not easy to run the option and Tech has had their share of QB problems in the past, but two of eight passing with two picks? Ugh. Fortunately, most teams won’t be able to defend the Yellow Jackets as well as the Cavaliers did, but that game still raises questions about how the Ramblin’ Wreck will do the rest of the season.

22) Auburn

Auburn’s back again! At least, until they drop out after losing this week, right? It’s likely, because they’re playing at LSU. I’ve finally seen QB Barrett Trotter prove that he’s not that good (it took longer than expected), but what does a loss to LSU really mean? Nearly every team in the country would do the same. I’m looking for Auburn to show something this week that would give me a reason to keep them ranked with a loss.

23) South Carolina

I dropped the Gamecocks because it’s very likely they’re about to fall apart. In consecutive weeks South Carolina has lost their starting QB (dismissed) and starting RB (knee injury). I have no idea how they can hold it together and still win the East. If Steve Spurrier still has any of his old coaching acumen – which he honestly hasn’t shown a lot of in Columbia – he might be able to cobble together a division title. But I really doubt it.

24) Illinois

I expected to see Illinois drop a game a few weeks ago, then when the Illini got to 6-0 I felt good about them. Serves me right for trusting such an unproven team, I suppose. It all goes back to Arizona State, because I wouldn’t have had nearly the amount of respect I did for Illinois if ASU had just taken care of business. I finally moved the Sun Devils ahead of the Illini because, let’s face it, Oregon is a way better loss than Ohio State. And Illinois is going to lose again, unlike ASU.

25) Baylor

I had to drop Baylor for losing, but I also don’t think it’s fair to punish them too harshly for losing to a good Texas A&M team. The Bears are still a quality team; the problem is just – as I feared – that they don’t have the same kind of across-the-board talent as the other teams in the Big 12. The remainder of the schedule isn’t easy, though I still see Baylor picking up seven or eight wins. In this year’s Big 12, that’s an accomplishment.

Pac-12 Thoughts

ASU is the only Pac-12 school not playing this week and now we’re getting into the meat of the conference schedule. UCLA and Arizona kick things off on Thursday night in a game that’s actually more meaningful than it appears at first glance. Did you know UCLA is only one game behind division leader ASU in the South? With a win, the Bruins would move up to a tie for first with the idle Sun Devils. For Arizona, it’s a chance to start the post-Stoops era off right at home.

Oregon and Colorado play the only weekend league game before primetime (12:30 PST), which should be a walk in the park for the Ducks. The poor Buffaloes have now lost their best player (RB Rodney Stewart) for significant time and their leading tackler (LB Douglas Rippy) for the season. The only intrigue for this game is whether Oregon will sit their entire first-string backfield with the hope of getting healthy.

Utah and Cal play in this week’s version of the Desperation Bowl. Both teams are 3-3 but 0-3 in conference play and badly need a win. Utah’s road win last week over Pittsburgh was a major gut-check for the Utes, so getting their first Pac-12 victory this week could really build some momentum for them. Cal is a disaster right now, looking completely unfit for league play. With an 0-4 conference start, I wouldn’t be surprised to hear about a hot seat under Jeff Tedford.

The USC-Notre Dame rivalry is always a nice game to watch, but it has held little national relevance in the past few seasons. This year I think the Irish are a better team, so it would help boost the Pac-12’s sagging reputation if the Trojans could get a win in South Bend. SC did look very good against Cal last week, which is a good sign, though it’s also possible that the Bears are just terrible.

The best game of the week by far is Washington at Stanford, where the young but talented Huskies will really get a chance to prove how far they’ve come. When I look at Washington’s wins the team doesn’t look very impressive. It could be that the reason UW has looked so good on offense has been a lack of good competition. But Stanford’s schedule has been even weaker. I would categorize four of the six teams the Cardinal have beaten as bad-to-terrible. The only marginally respectable wins are Arizona and Washington State.

Washington’s defense has been pretty bad at times this year, so you’d think Stanford could take advantage of that. But Stanford has also been listless offensively at times. See: 16 points in the first half against Arizona. 17 at halftime against UCLA. 10 against WSU. By comparison, Oregon had 35 at halftime against the Wildcats. I’m not saying that the Huskies have a shot because they’re better than everyone thinks – near the bottom of the top 25 is about right. They have a shot because Stanford isn’t as good as everyone thinks. I’m still picking Stanford at home because I see the Cardinal as a deeper team, but UW should make this a good game.

The nightcap is Oregon State and Wazzu in Seattle, a game that I actually really wish was televised. This series has gotten interesting with the two teams apparently headed in opposite directions (although the Cougars’ last two games would tell you otherwise). Oregon State is still smarting from giving WSU their only Pac-12 win last season and is frustrated at coming up short last week against BYU. The Cougs are really angry after playing awful second halves against Stanford and UCLA and probably have a lot of confidence against the Beavers, having beaten them last year. Both teams are 1-2 in conference play and want to keep ahead of Cal in the North division cellar.

Heisman* Watch

*Luck

Robert Griffin III, QB, Baylor

The Bears lost, but Griffin has already tied his own school record for touchdown passes in a season through just six games. Unreal. His efficiency has dipped ever-so-slightly, but come on. He’s still completing 14 of every 18 passes and has thrown a mere two interceptions against 22 touchdowns.

Kellen Moore, QB, Boise State

Anything less than a stellar effort would have led me to drop Moore from the list temporarily. So naturally, he went 26-for-30 with four TD’s and no picks. His efficiency is creeping closer to Griffin’s, though the difficulty of their opponents is rapidly traveling in the opposite direction.

Random Thoughts and Observations

The initial BCS rankings came out on Sunday and were thoroughly boring. There was little to differentiate the computers from the polls except for the computers giving a little extra love to Oklahoma State. Yes, Texas was ranked and probably shouldn’t be, while Arkansas over Oregon was a little surprising, but those things weren’t exactly scandalous. As many analysts have explained by now, several of the top teams play each other, so it’s impossible for there to be more than a few undefeateds. Yawn.

I was delighted to see that Texas gave Texas A&M the coldest of shoulders regarding their annual (and very long-running) rivalry series when the Aggies tried to set up a yearly nonconference showdown with the Longhorns. After whining, complaining and even trying to evoke popular sympathy through a “patriotic defense,” it was astounding that Texas A&M had the gall to ask Texas for a continuous series.

If you don’t know, Texas replied that it wasn’t possible because their nonleague schedules were filled until 2018, which is of course a filthy lie. Schools do love to schedule nonconference games years in advance, but the truth is that future matchups are ever-changing. Conference realignment, teams chickening out of hard games (looking at you, SEC) and even the prospect of a better payoff can affect a school’s schedule. Just look at the last two season-opening Cowboys Classics: Oregon-LSU and Oregon State-TCU weren’t settled until less than a year before those games were actually played. If teams want to play each other, they can find a way. Texas doesn’t want – or need – you, A&M. Now enjoy the SEC.

There were some more realignment rumblings this week, though nothing concrete has materialized… except for the big one. BYU-to the Big 12 continues to be a hot topic, which would be funny after the Cougars made such a big deal about going independent but isn’t a bad fit football-wise. Temple is rumored to be a candidate for the Big East (crawling back to Temple, eh boys? The Owls don’t look so bad now that you’ve lost half your conference, hmm?). Missouri, whom everyone in the Big 12 must just loathe at this point, has yet again pledged undying love to the SEC, if only the SEC will have them. This is after the Tigers previously begged to be let into the Big 10, so I think everyone takes Mizzou only half-seriously nowadays. Still, the SEC will eventually get at least 14 teams, and Missouri is probably the best option out there.

The “big one” I was referring to was the amazing and not-at-all ridiculous merger between the Mountain West and Conference USA. I absolutely love this move because it’s just so off-the-charts crazy. Hey, ACC! You thought you’d steal the spotlight by jumping to 14 teams? Try 22! That’s where the proposed superconference would sit once the MWC increases to 10 schools next season. Although I’m not sure “superconference” is even the right term for this, because we’ve been using it to refer to 16-team leagues. This is a good deal more, so… ultraconference? Until someone comes up with something better, that’s what I’m sticking with. What will be even more interesting is what the 22-team behemoth will be named. I’ll have to think on that.

I had fun giving a little history lesson last week, so I thought I’d have another go at it. This week’s lesson came about because of my own curiosity and the continuing national unease over how well superconferences will function if we get to that point. To preface, however:

Last year when the Pac-10 nearly became the Pac-16, there were questions about how a league of such size would work. The 8-team split was easy: the old Pac-8 on one side, the Arizona schools and former Big 12 teams on the other. However, to ensure schedule balance, many people thought the conference could create four four-team “pods.” Teams would play each team in their own pod and two of the four teams from the other three pods on a rotating basis. This was logical because it would mean no school would go more than two years without playing every other team in the league.

Well, there’s a reason the “pod” system was popular: it had been used before. I always knew the Mountain West was a very young league that had formed out of the dissatisfied members of the older WAC, but I was fuzzy on the details. I looked it up, and here’s what happened

In the nineties, with the Southwest conference crumbling and other schools looking to move up to D-1A (now FBS) status, the WAC ballooned to 16 members – the first superconference. The members of this league were, to put it lightly, a bit scattered. Geographically, the WAC ranged from Hawai’i in the West to Texas and Oklahoma in the East. The conference arranged its schools into four-team quadrants or pods within larger divisions, with the division winners facing each other in the conference championship game.

To rotate opponents, however, the WAC made two of the pods “locked” with the other two free. Hawai’i, San Jose State, San Diego State and Fresno State (Pod I) would always play in the Pacific division. Tulsa, TCU, SMU and Rice (Pod IV) would always play in the Mountain division. The two other quadrants – UNLV, Air Force, Colorado State and Wyoming (Pod II) and BYU, Utah, New Mexico and UTEP (Pod III) – would switch divisions every two years.

The system was complicated, but rather ingenious. Back when playing only seven conference games was normal, these quadrants did a good job of ensuring that no school would go too long without playing most of the others. Since the Pac-10 took the step of moving to nine conference games in 2006, though, such a system would be less effective. It’s also hard to evaluate the WAC because the pods only lasted three years before half of the conference took off to form the Mountain West. Travel costs, understandably, were part of the problem. But in general I think the WAC’s solution to a superconference was admirable.

So who should conferences of the future emulate? The ACC will soon play with 14 teams, which has also been done before (the MAC had 14 members from 2002-2005, and will again starting next season). 14 teams isn’t too hard to figure out: two divisions, six divisional games, and either two or three cross-division games, depending on whether the league wants to man up. 16 is a whole lot harder. The old rotating WAC model would work as long as the conference played nine league games, because teams would once again only go as long as two years without playing each team. But the proposed Pac-16’s system made sense, too.

In the end, I’d prefer to stay with the traditional smaller conferences. But as the MountConf Westerence USA ultraconference has proved, we’re way past that point now. 22-team leagues for everyone! Why stop there? Let’s go to 30! Full steam ahead, I say! See you next week.