Tuesday, October 5, 2010

October, Take 1

National Overview

What a fun week. Five top-25 showdowns, some great setups for the future in the Big 10, and a few monster performances by Heisman candidates. The big games went largely as I expected: Alabama smashed Florida, Oklahoma beat Texas, Iowa dominated Penn State, and Oregon knocked off Stanford. The only big game I guessed wrong was Michigan State – Wisconsin.

Still, there was some intrigue in how each of the winners got there. Oklahoma, in particular, seems to be hanging on by a thread. The Sooners have let their past three opponents hang around way too long and needed muffed punts in the last two contests to put things away for good.

Penn State was revealed to be pretty much what everyone thought they were – a decent team with a good defense that can’t score nearly enough to be considered great, let alone elite. Starting a true freshman at quarterback is always iffy. The same goes for Wisconsin – I said last week that we’ve seen this kind of Badgers team before, and I was absolutely right. Wisconsin hasn’t had even an average QB for years and it continues to cost them.

Oregon’s come-from-behind victory over Stanford was impressive, but the Ducks continued a couple of trends that could cost them later in the year; namely, falling behind early and playing too fast and loose with the football. That said, Oregon appears to be the fastest team in the nation and if they can put together a full game (against good competition), look out.

Not much needs to be said about ‘Bama, who routed Florida in a lopsided affair. What more do you want? The Gators were clearly overrated to begin the season, but the Crimson Tide are just really good too.

The BCS busters unsurprisingly continued their run against overmatched foes. TCU and Boise State demolished their opponents 27-0 and 59-0, respectively, while Utah got a bye. At this rate, it’s fair to start asking what will happen when, not if, BSU and TCU/Utah (the Horned Frogs and Utes play each other) go undefeated. I think the Mountain West champ will probably get the nod over the WAC champ, but we’ve got a lot of season left.

I won’t release a Heisman watch list for another week or so, but I have to give Michigan’s Denard Robinson some love. Sure, it’s been against average competition, but what he’s accomplished thus far has been simply astounding. He won’t do it, but at his current pace, Robinson would finish the 2010 season with around 2,500 yards passing and 16 touchdowns in addition to more than 2,000 yards rushing and another 17 TD’s on the ground. With two interceptions. Wow.

Top 25

1) Alabama

Yeah, that pretty much ended all discussion as to who should be ranked first. Florida has a mediocre offense, yes. But Alabama has a solid defense, and it did what good defenses do – hold the opposing offense out of the end zone. On offense, the Tide are physical like no one but Stanford.

2) Ohio State

Ugly win over Illinois, but I’m not quite ready to drop the Buckeyes out of the number two spot. It’s close, though. Another bad win, combined with blowouts by their peers, will cost OSU. Terrelle Pryor’s injury is not a good enough excuse.

3) Oregon

Facing a massive hole just 15 minutes into the game, Oregon responded in powerful fashion against the Cardinal. As always, these rankings can change each week, but for now the Ducks have done enough to jump Boise State.

4) Boise State

That noise you heard over the weekend was the collective groan emitted by Broncos fans when they saw the new polls. Everyone knew Boise’s schedule would end up hurting them at some point; it’s just that it wasn’t expected to be so soon. Now BSU has to pray for the top teams to lose.

5) TCU

The Horned Frogs’ four-TD victory over Colorado State was a little underwhelming, but they still got the shutout. They shouldn’t move down or up, as they took care of business essentially as expected. I’m excited to see them play the meat of their Mountain West schedule.

6) Nebraska

Unlike most actual voters, I will absolutely jump an idle team. However, this week the Cornhuskers got lucky because there was no one worthy of passing them. They’ll get a chance very soon to prove themselves – on the road at also-undefeated Kansas State this Thursday.

7) Oklahoma

But wait, you say. Oklahoma nearly blew their game with Texas and has been underwhelming for three straight weeks. How can they move up? Well, see what I said about Nebraska. The only teams I would consider moving ahead of them didn’t play. So the Sooners survive for another week.

8) Utah

Moved up by default after not playing. It should still be a while before the Utes are seriously challenged.

9) Arizona

See number eight. However, the Wildcats will get a very interesting test this week in Oregon State.

10) Stanford

Stanford jumped out to an unheard-of 21-3 lead at Autzen and looked unstoppable. But then Oregon responded, and the supposedly big, nasty Cardinal didn’t. It was actually a little shocking. That said, Stanford is still very good and should prove it this week by beating USC again.

11) Auburn

I just can’t reward a team very much for beating an FCS opponent in October. It’s bad enough that so many teams play these free-win games, but at least get them out of the way in the first month of the season. There still aren’t many 5-0 teams, though, so until they trip up they’ll hang around the top 10.

12) Arkansas

Moving a team up off a bye kills me… but once again, no one else deserves the spot.

13) Miami (FL)

A good win against a decent Clemson team. Jacory Harris is throwing way too many bad balls, but right now the Hurricanes just need to gut out some victories until the offense and defense both get stabilized. As I said before, a run at the ACC title is still well within reach.

14) Iowa

Iowa’s win over Penn State wasn’t unexpected, but it solidified the Hawkeyes as the clear number two team in the Big 10. Defense has won games for Iowa the past few years, so there’s not really a reason they need to change things up. But the big question is still whether they can get over the hump and win the conference. I don’t have faith in Ricky Stanzi.

15) Michigan State

I had to get the Spartans up here next to the Wolverines before their big showdown this Saturday. To the winner goes, unfortunately, just a single “W.” Both Michigan State and Michigan still have to face a number of good opponents in conference play, so obviously this week’s game is pretty important.

16) Michigan

Based on Michigan State’s win over Wisconsin I had to give the Spartans the nod over Michigan, but the two teams are very evenly matched. It’ll be a fun game to watch this week; I think MSU is better overall and their defense should slow Michigan a little. Can Denard Robinson carve up a real defense? Tune in and find out.

17) South Carolina

Idle and uninteresting. The SEC East has started to look really bad, so the Gamecocks have to step up if they don’t want to get left behind by other teams in the polls.

18) Florida

Well, that was enlightening. The Gator’s offensive issues are mind-boggling considering who their coach is. Everyone assumed Florida could just reload after back-to-back great seasons; obviously they were wrong. As I said, though, the division is so weak it might not matter.

19) Wisconsin

The Badgers were definitely overrated as well. I feel for Wisconsin, because I kind of saw this coming, but seriously, how difficult is it to get a single good QB? Until they can solve this problem Wisconsin is never going to contend in the Big 10 again.

20) Nevada

The opponents haven’t really been impressive, but Nevada keeps moving up thanks to their own consistency and the general ineptitude around them. You gotta love the original Pistol, but the attention given to the imitators is getting a bit annoying. Nevada should be 10-0 by the time that Boise State game rolls around.

21) Air Force

I’m loving Air Force right now. They’ve supplanted Navy as the service academy to watch, as seen by the Falcons’ 14-6 victory over the Midshipmen last week. If Air Force can upset TCU or Utah, who knows how the Mountain West might shake out.

22) LSU

Dear God. I’m not sure how LSU keeps winning games, or Les Miles still has his job, but it’s comforting to know that Tigers fans aren’t fooled. Despite a great defense, there’s just no hiding the fact that this offense is disgrace. There’s more on Miles’ incredible ineptitude coming up.

23) Kansas State

The Wildcats’ win over UCLA looks a lot more impressive now. With the Big 12 North in shambles, a single big upset over Nebraska could mean great things. K-State got a little rest this week, which they’ll need once the Huskers roll into Manhattan. This is shaping up to be an important contest, which no one would have predicted at the beginning of the year.

24) Oklahoma State

The Cowboys got the win versus Texas A&M, but the game exposed their flaws a lot more than it showed off their strengths. A good QB can tear apart the OSU secondary and the supposedly unstoppable offense can be stopped cold at times. Still, they’re a more complete team than many others across the country.

25) Northwestern

I always want to root for the academic schools, and the Wildcats’ win over Minnesota this week was thrilling. But let’s be honest – once the real schedule kicks in it’s unlikely they’ll stay undefeated. Enjoy it while it lasts, which is probably two more weeks, until the team plays Michigan State.

Pac-10 Thoughts

Oregon State appeared to save their season by beating Arizona State this past week. The Beavers’ habit of starting a season slow and finishing strong has been well-documented, but is probably a little overrated too. While OSU’s ability to regroup after tough losses has been impressive, the truth is that – with the exception of USC – the majority of the Beavers’ best opponents in the past several seasons have come earlier in the year. Losing early and winning late is just logical for a team that plays its tougher opponents first.

With that in mind, we’ll be able to take a lot from this week’s game at Arizona. Can OSU rebound from facing those two brutal non-conference foes and be a Pac-10 player, or are they simply not as good this year? Arizona has been very impressive thus far, and the ‘Zona Zoo is one of the hardest places to play in the conference.

Oregon’s offense was supposed to overwhelm Stanford’s defense, which it did. Stanford’s offense did the same… for about a quarter and a half. But what happened to the Cardinal after that? Sure, the Ducks adjusted to counter Stanford’s strategy of power runs and short/play-action passes, but why didn’t Stanford adjust as well? Once it became clear there was no stopping the Ducks’ offense, Stanford seemed to panic and overreacted by throwing deep and abandoning the running game, even though their original game plan could still have gotten them the victory.

Then there’s USC. Oh, how the mighty have fallen. Despite their troubling losses last year, most people assumed the Trojans could still be a Pac-10 power until they recovered from the NCAA sanctions. We all thought wrong. SC certainly has a good deal of talent left on the roster, but it’s clear that those halcyon days are gone for good. USC had lost before, but last Saturday’s choke job against Washington confirmed a most horrifying reality for the Trojans: they are no longer feared. Once on a 47-1 streak at home, they have now lost three of their last five at the Coliseum. They’ve got one more chance, versus Stanford this week, to redeem themselves.

Random Thoughts and Observations

What is the deal with Vontaze Burfict? The sophomore from Arizona State has been known as a hothead ever since he came into the league, but he’s taken things to a new level this season. After costing his team with several personal fouls last year (including three in one half against Washington) Burfict threw a near-punch in the 2010 opener against Portland State and led the Sun Devils’ fake injury charge against Oregon by going down an unofficial seven times – only to return to the field within two plays.

This weekend was his masterpiece, as he repeatedly dealt slaps to the faces of Oregon State players and even delivered a post-play headbutt to QB Ryan Katz that unbelievably didn’t get him ejected (YouTube has a collection of these plays). It’s amazing that Burfict has lived on the edge so long and not been suspended by the Pac-10. If he keeps it up, the league will eventually have no choice.

Every analyst in the country has blasted Les Miles this week, so I might as well get my two cents in. Quite frankly, it’s astonishing that Miles is still the head coach at LSU. The guy has no idea how to run a football team or manage a game. He was crowned the luckiest coach to ever win a national championship when his Tigers slipped into the title game in 2007 thanks to top-ranked Missouri and second-ranked West Virginia both losing on the final weekend of the season. But his late-game management alone should have already gotten Miles canned.

There was the inexplicable decision to throw to the endzone against Auburn in 2007 when an easy field goal would have won the game, though LSU escaped when their receiver made the catch with just one second left on the clock. Then there was the disastrous showing at home last year against Mississippi State, when an awful Bulldogs team unluckily failed to make the go-ahead score in the final seconds despite having four attempts from the Tigers’ one yard line. Also in 2009 was the utterly insane sequence at the end of the Ole Miss game, when LSU failed to call a play with 28 seconds left, then spiked the ball (at Miles’ instructions, no less) with no time left.

But after all those gaffes, you’d think the LSU staff would have learned that Miles is not to be trusted to make even the most basic, high-school level decisions. Well, fool me once, shame on you, fool me twice… just watch.

It’s pathetic. How can a major college football coach be this inept? It doesn’t seem possible. Miles makes $4 million a season. I mean, are you kidding? And it’s not just the horrible game management – Miles has also failed to put together anything resembling a BCS-conference caliber offense despite pulling in top 25 recruiting classes every year. He can’t articulate a single clear thought about why he makes the decisions he does after games and looks as lost as if he just wandered onto the field. The fact that he is still employed boggles the mind.

Another big assumption everyone made before the season was that the SEC would continue to be the best conference in the country. The league has been the best for the past few years, though usually by a much smaller margin than their rabid fans would have everyone believe. However, anyone who knows football at all knows that such things are cyclical; the Big 10 was long considered the best conference until falling apart for a few years. Now the Big 10 is on the rise and the SEC is unquestionably on the decline.

Far from being dominant, the SEC in 2010 has actually appeared to be much closer to a one-team league than any other (except for perhaps the WAC). Florida was overrated. Georgia was overrated. LSU was overrated. The Eastern division went a stunning 0-5 last weekend, with the Gators getting blown out by Alabama, Tennessee blowing what should have been a win over LSU, Kentucky losing to hapless Ole Miss, Vanderbilt falling to Connecticut, and Georgia dropping to 1-4 after a shocking loss to Colorado (South Carolina didn’t play).

Alabama has been as good as advertised and Auburn has been impressive, but we still don’t know about Arkansas, LSU is a mess, and the Mississippi schools are unsurprisingly awful. Add to the mix the fact that the SEC continues to be a weak-scheduling league, and we could see a large power shift in college football in the next few years. The perception that the SEC is no longer as dominant could be huge.

I need to make note of a couple of websites I’ve been using recently. The first is a fantastic resource for fans who want to see how all the conferences stack up against each other over the last decade. For the record, Pac-10 fans, the Pac-10 has the best record of any conference in nonleague play. The Big 12 is the only league with a winning record against the Pac-10, and it’s a narrow one at 32-31. The Pac-10 is 10-8 against the ACC; 39-27 against the Big 10; 12-8 against the Big East, and 12-9 against the SEC (the SEC is the second best conference, with losing records against only the Pac-10 and Big East).

The second site is a great proposal for dividing the new Pac-12 by (as far as I know) just another blogger. He/she combines elements of both the leading proposals (“North/South” and “Zipper”) to make a very tempting “Cooler” model. In it, each school plays in a different division than their natural rival but still plays their rival every year along with their geographic rivals. So Washington would play Oregon, Oregon State and WSU each season, along with UCLA (an all-important L.A. recruiting trip) Colorado, and Arizona. Then the Huskies would get two games against the following four schools: USC, ASU, Utah and Stanford. The model works remarkably well; therefore I can conclude that it is all but certain that another model will be adopted.

We’ve reached the meat of the conference season. From now on non-conference games will be few and far between. As always, it will be great fun to see how things play out. College football is too crazy to expect anything less than the extraordinary. See you next week.

Wednesday, September 29, 2010

End of September musings

National Overview

I wish I could have gotten a post out last week, but I just didn’t have the time. I apologize to anyone who was hoping to see an update.

Crazy little weekend we had, no? It looked for about three quarters as if Alabama was going down, but Arkansas let the Crimson Tide hang around for too long and blew their chance to make a huge statement. TCU and Nebraska won, albeit unimpressively; Oregon prevailed in a bizarre, sloppy game, and Texas got absolutely hammered by UCLA.

Of course, sometimes the haves do exactly what they’re supposed to and pummel the have-nots into submission, a la Ohio State, Wisconsin and Iowa, who won by a combined score of 188-23. Granted, it was against a group of patsies, but that’s a topic for later. A blowout is still a blowout.

The Big 12 avoided total disaster when Oklahoma held off Cincinnati’s upset bid, but that Texas loss stung. UCLA looked horrible in their first two games, and despite their upset last week of Houston no one thought they had a shot against the Longhorns. Texas was clearly overrated and the Big 12 will probably suffer for it. I don’t know if the league can handle Nebraska being the sole national title contender.

Still, the Big East would have gladly swapped places with the Big 12 if it could have. I don’t recall ever seeing a conference start a season as poorly as the Big East this year, and it continued this week as top contenders West Virginia and Pittsburgh fell to out-of-conference foes. At least WVU kept things close against LSU, though; Pitt looked atrocious against Miami (FL). The argument that the Big East is too weak to be a BCS conference seems to finally be true, and with the rise of the Mountain West it will be interesting to see if the league can keep its automatic-qualifying status.

The play of the Pac-10, on the other hand, has been very impressive. After a 2-5 bowl record last year it was assumed that the conference would be down in 2010, but thus far it appears that the overall depth of the league was underrated. It’s not clear yet if there are any truly elite teams, though the middle third of the Pac-10 has proved to be good enough to compete with most of the country. But be warned, fans of Pac-10 schools: this will likely cause every team to finish with multiple losses.

Top 25

As I stated before, I wanted to wait a few weeks before making any kind of ranking because we simply don’t know enough about the teams after week one or two, let alone before the season starts. I compiled these rankings after watching as many different teams as possible, as many times as possible. My list is relatively similar to the regular polls, but the advantage I have is that I can radically change teams’ position based on a single game from here on out, unlike the generally slow-to-react AP and Coaches polls. With that in mind, here is my initial top 25:

1) Alabama

Impressive? Yes. Overwhelmingly so? No. But given that the Tide are the defending champs and return so much talent, perfection is not required. Wins over Penn State and Arkansas are acceptable proof that ‘Bama is still the nation’s number one team.

2) Ohio State

I’m on record as saying the Buckeyes win over Miami (FL) didn’t impress me much, but OSU deserves to be ranked highly for now. They’ve clobbered the cupcakes they played, as great teams do, and will get a chance to really prove themselves in conference play. Tons of home games help too.

3) Boise State

Two wins over teams with top-25 talent is solid, even if those teams are going to spend the next month or so working their way back into the rankings. Nothing about Boise to this point has been anything less than advertised. The problem will come in the next two months, when the Broncos’ strength of schedule starts to really hurt them.

4) Oregon

Three blowouts and one shaky conference opener later, the Ducks are pretty much where people thought they would be before all the offseason issues. But is Oregon a true contender? We won’t have to wait long to find out. Championship caliber teams respond against top competition like the Ducks face Saturday in Stanford.

5) TCU

Before the SMU game I would have had the Horned Frogs fourth, but their sloppiness and defensive problems trumped those of the Ducks (and against an inferior opponent). TCU fans needn’t worry, tough: their team will have ample opportunities to impress voters through the Mountain West season. Going undefeated would even give them a better resume than Boise State.

6) Stanford

The most impressive team in the nation thus far despite some offensive struggles against Notre Dame. The Cardinal are on a roll – a big, physical roll – and come into this week’s showdown against Oregon with a lot of confidence. They absolutely have the ability to pull the upset and take control of the Pac-10 race – can they capitalize on the opportunity?

7) Nebraska

Nebraska managed only a strange 14-point win over South Dakota State, but now faces a very favorable conference schedule. Texas is the only currently ranked team the Cornhuskers will face, and everyone saw what happened to the Longhorns last week. The Big 12 North is also very weak, so there shouldn’t be any potential pitfalls on the way to the conference title game.

8) Oklahoma

The Sooners have survived a pair of very close calls recently, but at 4-0 with wins over Florida State, Air Force and Cincinnati you really can’t fault them too much. I still like this team, but they need to improve their play to become a real contender. We’ll know more after this week’s Red River Shootout (I refuse to use the new, politically correct “Red River Rivalry.” Give me a break).

9) Utah

Does it seem a little high? Possibly, but then again there haven’t been a whole lot of consistently great squads this year. The big win over Pitt in the opener now seems worthless, but the Utes have still comfortably blown out their other opponents. I just don’t think many teams could beat these guys in a one-game scenario.

10) Arizona

Another pleasant surprise of the early season has been the overall excellent play of the Wildcats. Completely dismantling a decent Toledo team was one thing, but the signature win over Iowa could be the gift that keeps on giving for Arizona. With national respect now in their pocket, the Cats just have to avoid a letdown (like they almost suffered last week) until they face the Pac-10’s heavy hitters.

11) Florida

I’ve seen nothing so far to support the idea that the Gators should be ranked in the top 10. Ugly victories over weak non-conference foes and a tenuous quarterback situation have made UF a sell so far this year. A post-Tebow hangover has definitely hit this team, and what’s with that center snap problem?

12) Wisconsin

The Badgers got lucky to beat Arizona State and plowed through the rest of their nonleague slate with only mild difficulty. Their record looks impressive, but we’ve seen this before when Wisconsin gets out to a hot start against bad teams. I can’t take Wisconsin seriously until they beat some good teams, starting this week against Michigan State.

13) Auburn

This is a very tentative ranking. Auburn was fortunate to beat both Mississippi State and Clemson and we still don’t know if the win over South Carolina was a quality one. But it’s hard not to get excited about the Tigers’ 4-0 start. I think at some point they’ll get exposed, but for now I’m willing to give them the benefit of the doubt.

14) Arkansas

Oh, talk about missed opportunities. The Razorbacks had the Alabama game won and just let it slip through their fingers. You can’t drop them too far for a four-point loss to the nation’s top team, but it’s clear that the Hogs’ offseason issue – defense – is a legitimate one. They simply couldn’t stop the Tide in crunch time.

15) Miami (FL)

The Hurricanes have been really sloppy so far, and it cost them against Ohio State. The good news is that The U won’t see anyone as talented as the Buckeyes again all season. Great teams beat inferior competition handily, which Miami did against Pitt. I still see the ‘Canes as the most likely team to win the ACC.

16) LSU

LSU has been solid on defense and special teams but just awful offensively. The Tigers have been looking for a QB for three years and still haven’t found one. It’s killed them in conference play the last few seasons and it will again this year. The saving grace is that aforementioned defense, which will keep them in games.

17) USC

The wins have been uneven and have come against weaker opponents, but USC is still undefeated and, well, USC. The talent is there and some people have questioned whether the Trojans are just biding their time as other Pac-10 teams get attention. While this team does appear to have taken a step back, they could still definitely contend for the conference title.

18) South Carolina

The “other” USC missed a golden opportunity to move up in the SEC world last week, but all is not lost. The Gamecocks have been the most consistent squad in their division thus far and could surprise everyone by making the SEC title game. A renewed commitment to the run has been very beneficial for this team.

19) Iowa

I think Iowa has gotten very lucky in several games the past few seasons, but these things always even out, as seen by the Arizona loss two weeks ago. This year the Hawkeyes have been appropriately dominant versus bad teams, but they now face four consecutive ranked Big 10 opponents. It’s not a question of “if” they’ll lose; it’s a question of “when,” because wins over the right teams could still position Iowa for a run at the conference crown.

20) Michigan

Michigan is the kind of team everyone really wants to like: they’re young, talented and exciting. But despite the Wolverines offensive brilliance the truth is that they still haven’t played anybody of note. It’s possible that they could start strong and wilt once they get into conference play, though they should at least play a role in determining who win the Big 10.

21) Nevada

I’ve long admired the Pistol offense coach Chris Ault invented, which curiously has just now begun to make waves in the media. To be honest, though, Nevada is a typical mid-major; good enough to run through a weak conference like the WAC and upset a BCS team or two, but not anywhere near top 10 material. They probably don’t have a chance of unseating Boise State atop the conference, but it’ll be fun to watch them for most of the year.

22) Michigan State

The gritty Spartans have done a great job the past couple of seasons moving up in the Big 10 pecking order. Now they need to take the next step. MSU gets Wisconsin and Michigan in the next two weeks and can legitimize themselves in the eyes of voters with victories. Both games are quite winnable, so it’s up to the team to take advantage of this situation.

23) North Carolina State

The big surprise so far out of the ACC (excluding Virginia Tech – we’re not counting bad surprises) by far has been the Wolfpack. They’re sitting in a great position right now as the last undefeated ACC team and don’t have a single currently ranked opponent on their schedule. If they can avoid a letdown this week against a still-dangerous Tech squad, they could really start to dream big.

24) Penn State

Whether Penn State deserves any credit at all as a top 25 team will be decided this week. The Nittany Lions have lost back-to-back upsets to Iowa and have done nothing so far this season to prove they are for real. I was suspicious of PSU when the year started, and this week could be the final strike against them if they get beat by the Hawkeyes again.

25) Air Force

The Falcons are leading the nation in rushing and are three points from being undefeated and having an upset of Oklahoma on their resume. But the academy will probably take 3-1 at this point given how they hammered BYU. Air Force is going to have some nice warm up games before they face the Mountain West’s twin-headed monster of TCU and Utah, so don’t be surprised if the Falcons pull an upset somewhere down the road.

Pac-10 Notes

Oregon’s clash with Stanford this week will obviously go a long way toward deciding the Pac-10 title. But might Arizona’s last-gasp victory over California last week play a role as well? I’m not suggesting that Cal is going to contend for the conference crown – we’ve all seen this movie before, and it ends with a boatload of failed expectations and a 7-5 record – but the Wildcats could end up quite thankful that they got the W.

Why? Even though Oregon plays both Arizona and Stanford at home, it will still be a tall order for the Ducks to go undefeated in league play. Remember, no team has yet gone undefeated in the Pac-10 since the league expended to a nine-game conference schedule in 2006. If ‘Zona goes 1-1 against the Cardinal and Ducks, their avoidance of a nasty second loss on their resume could end up being huge.

The Oregon-Stanford showdown will capture the nation’s attention for good reason; both teams are 4-0 and ranked in the top 10 (in the only respectable poll). Can Stanford go into Autzen Stadium and unseat the defending champs? The Cardinal appear to be even better than last year’s squad that upset the Ducks in Palo Alto, with a solid ground game and a dynamic passing attack led by maybe the nation’s best QB in Andrew Luck. Defensively Stanford is much improved from 2009’s sieve-like model, allowing around two touchdowns a game, despite playing with most of the some personnel.

Oregon is about as different a team from Stanford as is possible. The Ducks are small and speedy; the Cardinal are big and physical. That’s not to say both teams don’t have some of the other’s characteristics, but the general philosophies of the schools are not at all similar. Both offenses have the edge over the defenses they will be facing, so it will be very interesting to see which style wins out.

Random Thoughts and Observations

The Big 10 did post an impressive record last week, but the opponents were decidedly not. People tend to rag on the SEC for its teams’ timid scheduling, but check out this slate of whipping boys: Austin Peay, Ball State, Bowling Green, Northern Colorado, Central Michigan, Toledo, Eastern Michigan, Temple, Akron and Northern Illinois. That’s two FCS squads and eight teams from the exceedingly weak MAC. Justice was served in a couple of cases, though; Minnesota and Purdue certainly didn’t expect to lose to NIU and Toledo, respectively.

But let’s not pretend the SEC’s non-conference games have gotten any more respectable. The league is still a leader in padding schedules with creampuffs, playing an average of eight games a year against FCS foes over the past decade. Playing most or all of the non-conference games at home, or against inferior competition, is a cowardly strategy college teams have long employed to inflate their rankings. Much was made of Georgia’s 2008 game at Arizona State, the first contest outside the South in decades for the Bulldogs. However, Florida has been nearly as bad – the Gators’ last non-conference game outside just their own state was in 1989. That’s ridiculous.

I was surprised by Auburn’s victory over South Carolina last weekend, as it seemed the Gamecocks had finally turned a corner under Steve Spurrier. Alas, it wasn’t to be. However, the question now is how good the Tigers can be with freshman QB Cam Newton. I’ve made my position on young quarterbacks very clear, but there have been a pair of guys this season who have bucked usual trends (Newton and Michigan QB Denard Robinson). Newton has been impressive thus far, but no one in the country has come close to producing like Robinson.

However, Robinson’s play is somewhat less surprising when you consider the coach and scheme he is following. Recall, if you will, that Rich Rodriguez’s West Virginia teams featured a very similar player heading the offense in Pat White. White burst onto the scene in 2005 as a true freshman, running Rodriguez’s zone-read to perfection. He finished his career as one of the greatest quarterbacks in NCAA history. So there is some precedent to Robinson’s play. The scary thing is that Robinson has thus far outperformed White in his first season as a starter. With a little more experience under his belt, Robinson could potentially lead the Wolverines out of their current dark period, saving Rodriguez’s job in the process.

Speaking of offenses and schemes, there’s been an issue that’s been brought up a lot lately that really bothers me. You’ll see this mostly on blogs and internet comments, but the gist of the argument has been used by even national commentators. The idea is as old as the shotgun formation; that shotgun-based offenses are somehow “gimmicky,” “tricky,” or “not real football.” The explosion of spread offenses at the collegiate and high school level has made the shotgun much more visible to the average fan.

Skeptics argue that spreading players all over the field and dropping the QB into shotgun simplifies reads so much that the QB no longer has to make decisions like in a normal formation. This point of view is then justified by making vague claims such as that spread offenses are too finesse-oriented to last long-term and that said offenses “lack football fundamentals.”

To me, this demonstrates a fundamental lack of understanding of how football works (not unlike the argument I recently got into with an OregonLive poster who claimed only two tight ends could be on the field at the same time, and proceeded to lecture me about pass-catching eligibility rules. My response was a two-minute Google search that yielded pictures of both college and pro teams using such formations. For some reason my adversary continue to argue the point. LOOK AT THEM! THEY’RE EVEN CIRCLED FOR YOU!). But I digress.

Claiming a team lacks fundamentals implies that they don’t block or tackle well, or get lucky by throwing deep every play. I’m not sure how that argument can ever be made considering what spread offenses have done to improve the running attack of so many teams in the past few years. Does anyone think Florida is a finesse team? I think defenders who had to bring down 230-pound Tim Tebow would disagree.

In fact, the spread has brought an unprecedented balance to offenses, forcing defenses to account for both the run and the pass as well as forcing players to tackle one-on-one in space. I would argue that this is in fact the most fundamental football skill there is, yet it has been neglected in recent years as players go for the big hit rather than wrap up properly. The spread has increased emphasis on important skills such as tackling, footwork and good route-running; mistakes in any of these areas can mean a big play for either side.

The only legitimate problem with the shotgun is that it has allowed QB’s to get away with awkward throwing motions and dropbacks more than in traditional offenses. However, this is a coaching flaw, not an inherent issue with the offense itself. Too many spread-loving coaches have failed in their job to teach their signal-callers proper QB mechanics. That’s just laziness. The top three QB’s on the planet – Tom Brady, Peyton Manning and Drew Brees – all primarily operate out the shotgun and each has excellent mechanics.

Moreover, it should be an obvious fact that football is always changing. Would the Wishbone-heavy offenses of the 1970s scoff at the West Coast offenses of the 1980s for the latter’s pass-heavy philosophy? Certainly. I see the spread as a natural progression for offenses. It’s reasonable to think that the game will shift in this direction; almost every offense now incorporates some form of the spread anyway. And it’s not as if we’re all switching to the A-11 this season.