Tuesday, September 14, 2010

Reflections on Week 2

National Overview

Well, that was fun. We’re only two weeks into September and we’ve already been treated to a boatload of upsets, surprises and rewarding intersectional matchups. Who can say they saw Virginia Tech losing to James Madison? Or, for that matter, who expected Oklahoma to hammer Florida State one week after nearly falling to Utah State? It’s the week-to-week wildness that defines college football, and so far 2010 has been as exciting as anyone could have hoped.

It’s been mostly bad news for fans of East Coast teams. The Big East and ACC, already under fire for their mediocre play in the past few seasons, have been embarrassed in the early going this year. Everyone’s Big East favorite, Pittsburgh, lost at Utah in their opener. Defending conference champion Cincinnati fell on the road at Fresno State and West Virginia was extremely fortunate to escape with a win against Marshall.

Of course, the ACC hasn’t fared much better. The handful of title contenders the league boasted at season’s start have all faced disappointing results already. For Florida State, it was the aforementioned whipping courtesy of the Sooners. Miami (FL) played horribly at Ohio State and went down. Defending champion Georgia Tech got shocked by Kansas, who only seven days prior had lost to North Dakota State. North Carolina had a disastrous offseason and lost their opener to LSU. And then there’s Virginia Tech. My oh my.

The silver lining (some) of these squads can focus on is that they played a lot of quality opponents, many of them on the road. In particular, I was struck by the Miami-Ohio State game. Afterwards, analysts were quick to sing to praises of the “dominant” Buckeyes; what game were these commentators watching?

Far from being overwhelming on either side of the ball, Ohio State was in fact fortunate to win by as many points as they did. It was still only a 12-point margin, lest anyone forget, amidst all the talk of a “blowout. I saw a Hurricane offense that moved the ball efficiently (more so than their opponent), only to sloppily give the ball away at every opportunity. Notice I said “give” rather than attribute the turnovers to the OSU defense as some people bizarrely did. Let’s be honest: Ohio State will never again see so many turnovers fall into their lap like they did on Saturday. I don’t want to take up too much space on this one game, but go back and watch the replay on ESPN3 (a fantastic service, by the way) if you can. There’s a tipped interception, a pick when a receiver thought the play was a run instead of a pass, an interception when the same receiver inexplicably let a defender rip the ball away after securing a catch and a goal-line interception by a defensive lineman. That’s more than good defense. It’s the definition of the ball bouncing your way.

To be sure, no one gave the Ohio State offense any credit, because it didn’t deserve any. With all the opportunities they got, it’s ridiculous that the Buckeyes had to attempt so many field goals. Terrelle Pryor was wildly inaccurate and third-down conversions were a big problem. Ohio State surely has the talent to win the national championship this year, but it will take a much more focused and efficient effort to beat a team like Alabama.

Everyone in the Pac-10 breathed a huge sigh of relief when Oregon performed about as expected against Tennessee. I can’t reiterate enough how devastating a loss in Knoxville would have been for the conference. However, this week provides a whole new slate of worthy challenges for the West Coast teams. Cal faces Nevada in a matchup of two explosive offenses, Washington plays Nebraska, Arizona gets Iowa at home in a top-25 collision and Arizona State heads to Wisconsin. A win over either of the Big 10 powers would be a big boost (although, for the record, I don’t think it happens).

The schedule this week is deceptive. There are a lot of under-the-radar inter-conference games that could prove to be quite entertaining. The Cal-Nevada game is one; others include the always nasty Maryland-West Virginia rivalry, Arkansas-Georgia, Georgia Tech-North Carolina and Nebraska-Washington. The most intriguing game I see right now, though, is Baylor-TCU. Don’t scoff – Baylor has improved by leaps and bounds in recent years. With that said, the Horned Frogs are a better team and should win. The wild card is Bears QB Robert Griffin, one the nation’s most deadly dual threats. Oregon State showed that TCU can be scored upon; the question is whether Griffin can make TCU pay. If there’s one player who can single-handedly beat TCU, it’s Griffin. Of course, this is important because TCU is eyeing a spot in the national title game. We’ll have to see if TCU can shut Griffin down.

Pac-10 thoughts

So Oregon got by Tennessee. In hindsight worrying about that contest seems foolish, but the way the game started had to choke the rest of the league with fear. The blueprint to beat Oregon hasn’t changed – Ohio State and Stanford demonstrated last year that you have to get out to an early lead, run the ball straight at the Ducks undersized front and keep yourself out of third-and-long situations. Seems like basic football strategy, but against Oregon’s lighting-fast offense it’s even more crucial. It keeps the Duck’s fleet-footed playmakers off the field and forces their defense to play both the run and the pass, as opposed to when UO has the lead and knows the pass is coming, which plays into their fast defenders’ hands.

It’s obvious that Tennessee watched film while game-planning for the Ducks, because that’s the exact strategy the Volunteers employed. The rest of the Pac-10 will certainly try it out this season, but few teams in the conference are geared to play that kind of football. Oregon State and Washington’s run games are a little more finesse-oriented and USC is in complete disarray. Stanford, however, absolutely can play that kind of game – it’s what the Cardinal are built for – and is shaping up to be the prime challenger to Oregon for conference supremacy.

Speaking of USC… well, what can you say? It’s amazing the difference a few months can have on a team. Stripped of victories, trophies and their brilliant coach, the Trojans look totally lost. A week after the defense surrendered more than 500 yards and 36 points to Hawaii, USC’s offense took a turn disappearing, scoring only 17 points on a bad Virginia team. What happened to the Trojans? I see two possible explanations: either all of USC’s top recruits turned out to be complete busts or Lane Kiffin is a mediocre-to-bad coach who has no chance at motivating a team who knows they aren’t playing for anything this season. Considering the talent still on the Trojans’ roster, I’m inclined to lean toward the latter. Heavily.

Random Thoughts and Observations

Listening to commentators, you’d think Boise State’s bid for title-game spot was dealt a fatal blow by Virginia Tech’s loss to James Madison. In the words of Lee Corso, not so fast my friend. Remember the only other ranked team to lose to an FCS opponent? That was Michigan in 2007, who also started 0-2 after losses to an FCS powerhouse (Appalachian State) and an elite team (Oregon). What people seem to forget is that the Wolverines ripped off eight straight victories after that poor start and played Ohio State for a shot at the Big 10 championship in the season finale. Then they went out and beat Florida and Heisman winner Tim Tebow in their bowl game to finish 9-4. So let’s not write off the Hokies just yet – and by association, the Broncos. By season’s end, it may yet work out that Tech looks solid again.

Watching the West Virginia-Marshall game, I thought back to when Mountaineers RB Noel Devine, now a senior, arrived on campus. He immediately stood out as an elite playmaker, even with WVU legends Pat White at QB and Steve Slaton (RB) already on the team. At the time, I along with most of the nation just thought of Devine as a promising small, speedy back. Now I believe we can mark Devine’s arrival as a start of an era – the era of the tiny, shifty back in college football. To be sure, smaller ball carriers have always been more effective in college than the NFL, but teams still favored what we call “NFL-ready” players: big, compact runners who could pound the defense 30-plus times a game.

However, looking at the most dominant running backs in the NCAA the past few seasons shows different results. Devine burst onto the scene in 2007, Oregon State’ Jacquizz Rodgers in 2008, Oregon’s LaMichael James and Pitt’s Dion Lewis in 2009. All are considered to be among the top ten at their positions. So why the shift to the little guys?

I see it as the natural progression of the perpetual offense-defense battle. Generally, offenses in football score more than usual for a few seasons with a new scheme before defenses adjust and the status quo is restored. Offenses leap forward, defenses catch up – it’s the accepted way of the football world. The West Coast offense was once unstoppable – that is, until the onset of the zone blitz. Shotgun spread offenses have taken the football world by storm in the past decade and smaller, quicker backs tend to operate better in them than traditional power schemes. But that’s not the only change.

The major problem for defenses is that while the formations in all shotgun spread offenses may look similar, every team runs it a little differently. Nowhere is this more apparent than in college football. Florida and Missouri run a motion-option scheme that mixes the run and the pass; Oregon and West Virginia run almost exclusively the zone-read option; Hawaii and SMU use the old Run and Shoot; Nevada invented the triple-option Pistol attack that UCLA recently adopted, and Arizona and Purdue run a very pass-heavy spread.

Teams realized that their defensive players had to be versatile to effectively defend offenses that spread guys around in such confusing fashion. Their solution, from my perspective, was to just find lots of speed. Fielding a whole defense full of players who can run seems reasonable, considering that the offenses were trying to force defenses to do just that. The miscalculation teams made, though, was that they assumed straight-line speed would be enough. You will constantly hear commentators praising how a defense “flies to the ball” and “has great team speed.” Those things are important, of course. But having speed and using it properly are two different things. USC’s 2008 defense, considered one of the greatest of all time, was incredibly fast. That didn’t stop OSU’s Rodgers from completely shredding it because he was just too small and shifty to tackle.

There are more mighty-mite running backs in college football now than I can ever remember. I think it’s a good thing; it makes games more exciting and it’s a nice change of pace from the traditional plodders of yesteryear. Just remember that it all began with Noel Devine, who made coaches realize they could utilize small backs in previously unprecedented fashion.

I won’t write a top 25 for at least another week, perhaps two. I’d like to get the majority of non-conference games out of the way before making any big judgments. Next week’s post will also probably be quite short, so I won’t have time for any extensive analysis.

Friday, September 10, 2010

Week One Review

News and Notes from Week One

Short blog this week, but that’s really because there was nothing to report from the opening games of the season. The biggest upset we saw was lowly Jacksonville State beating a weak Ole Miss team. There wasn’t a lot to learn from the scores because everything went essentially according to script: the powerhouses did as expected and crushed their respective patsies into submission, though TCU did get a bit of a scare from Oregon State. (I’m not counting Utah beating Pittsburgh because I thought the Panthers were overrated in the first place).

That all changes this Saturday, when the first of two consecutive weekends of great matchups kicks off. This week we get Penn State-Alabama, Florida State-Oklahoma, Georgia-South Carolina and Miami (FL)-Ohio State. These matchups will all have an impact on the national championship picture. However, it’s the Oregon-Tennessee contest that is actually the most important.

Although the other title contenders will also be fighting to avoid an early-season letdown, Oregon is playing for much more. The reputation of the entire Pac-10 is at stake in Knoxville and there’s truly not much the Ducks can gain from this game. If they win in a blowout, everyone will assume the Volunteers are terrible. If they win close, or Tennessee pulls the upset, the Pac-10 will take a beating in the polls not only for the rest of this season but probably next year as well. The effect such a loss could have on the conference is enormous and would only reinforce the SEC belief that the West Coast can’t play quality football. This week is a must-win for Oregon.

In other Pac-10 news, USC looked as awful as a team can in victory by giving up nearly 600 yards to Hawaii, Oregon State bumbled away a chance for a big upset against TCU and UCLA got run over by Kansas State. Both Washington schools couldn’t live up to increased expectations and the teams that did win (Cal, Oregon, ASU and Stanford) did so versus vastly inferior opponents. Only Arizona managed a decent win against a respectable team, knocking off Toledo 41-2. All in all it was not a good week for the conference, which has struggled mightily since the end of the 2009 regular season.

Boise State-Virginia Tech analysis

The best game of the week was fortunately saved for last. A massive national audience tuned in to see Boise State beat Virginia Tech 33-30 Monday night, solidifying the Broncos as a legitimate threat to become the first non-automatic qualifying-league team to play for the BCS championship. Skeptics will say BSU won their toughest game the season by only a field goal; more rational observers will acknowledge that Tech was fortunate to be in the game at all against a clearly superior opponent.

After their initial 17-point burst in the first quarter, Boise State was held in check for the rest of the half and led 20-14 at the break. The Hokies eventually took a 30-26 lead, aided not only by a pair of fumbles but also by a timely special teams penalty and a fortunate fourth-down conversion. By comparison, BSU’s scoring drives were long, consistent and varied, with nary a turnover to help. Overcoming a negative turnover margin to win is the sign of a good football team.

The most obvious indicator of the Broncos’ superiority, though, was a simple eye test. Name one player on the Tech offense who made a single good play, if you can. There was Tyrod Taylor... and no one else. Allegedly great running back Ryan Williams was stuffed to the tune of two yards a carry, no receiver for the Hokies stood out and even Taylor (who played the best game of his career) was repeatedly hit, sacked, or forced to scramble. Nothing Tech tried on offense worked as it was supposed to; their only successes came on broken plays.

The Broncos’ offense, on the other hand, spread the ball to talented receivers like Austin Pettis and Titus Young and split carries between a trio of backs in D.J. Harper, Jeremy Avery and Doug Martin. None of it would have been possible without their triggerman Kellen Moore, who is now 27-1 as a starter.

Boise State played faster and more physical all night and deserved the win. Now, the question is whether the team should play for the national title if they go undefeated, which is highly likely. Oregon State is the only formidable opponent left on the Broncos’ schedule and I just don’t see the Beavers pulling the upset in Boise. It’s a difficult question to answer, but given how much respect the pollsters have awarded BSU it’s tough to argue against it, provided there are not two undefeated teams out of the BCS conferences. If the Broncos do manage to get there and win it all, at the very least it could have a crippling effect on the unfair system we use today to determine a champion. And that’s an idea everyone should be able to get behind.

Thursday, September 2, 2010

End of Summer Thoughts

Overview

Here we are. The 2010 college football season is just hours away. Campuses are buzzing with anticipation and players are surely chomping at the bit to start meaningful games again. It’s the most wonderful time of the year.

I’ve said before that predictions are pointless. I think it’s arrogant for sportswriters to tell people what should happen, and as it turns out it’s even less of a science than was previously believed. A recent study found that sports predictions are actually correct less than 50 percent of the time, meaning that fans could pick the home team in every contest and still beat the average of the so-called experts.

Nevertheless, I know that as a person who writes about a sport I’m expected to make some solid predictions for the future. I’ve decided against a preseason top 25 because such polls have several detrimental effects. The most notable of these are how they do a disservice to “surprise” teams who defy predictions (hello, Oregon State) and how they reward bad teams who begin the season over-ranked (Florida State, for about ten years).

For the same reason I won’t be making a national champion prediction. It’s just too difficult to pick one team out of 120 to win it all and it’s lazy to just pick a favorite like Alabama or Ohio State. Despite my attempts to absorb every bit of information about college football I can, it just isn’t credible for me to make predictions that grandiose.

So I’ve decided to limit myself to picking the conference champions and a Pac-10 preview (the final Pac-10, as a matter of fact), which has been taxing enough in itself. I’ve agonized over how the conference will play out and I’m sure people will disagree with me. I might even change my mind a week from now. But that’s the beauty of this sport.

Before I get to the predictions, though, I have to mention the latest round of conference musical chairs. In short, Nevada and Fresno State have shockingly defected from the WAC to the Mountain West, which combined with Boise State’s exit should effectively gut the WAC, if not destroy it. But BYU has abandoned the Mountain West in favor of an independent schedule starting in 2011. In the end, the WAC will only have six remaining teams and the Mountain West will have a round ten.

I feel for the remaining WAC squads. I really don’t know what they’ll do, because none of them is high-profile enough to merit an invite from another conference. San Jose State, Hawaii, New Mexico State, Utah State and Idaho are in deep trouble. Only Louisiana Tech has a chance as a future conference member (logic would say the Bulldogs join the much-closer Sun Belt).

I dislike the idea of independents in general, but if any school was to suddenly go that route it makes sense that it would be BYU. Reports indicate the Cougars intend to become “Notre Dame West,” which is logical. Both are private schools with religious affiliations. The only difference is that BYU has actually been good lately. So maybe Notre Dame should become “BYU East.”

Conference Champions

ACC: Miami (FL)

I mentioned in a previous post that I saw North Carolina as a possible national title contender, but I’m backing off that prediction. I don’t like what I’ve read about the Tar Heels off-field issues of late, which could be a big distraction. Any of four teams from the Coastal Division could beat the best team from the Atlantic Division.

Big East: Pittsburgh

Not exactly going out on a limb here, but that’s because the Panthers should breeze through the suddenly rather weak Big East. West Virginia will pose a threat, but that’s about it. Pitt still needs a quarterback, though.

Big 10: Ohio State

I don’t buy Iowa and I don’t buy Penn State. The Buckeyes are the best team in this conference and regardless of my feelings about Terrelle Pryor they should continue their dominance in the final year of the 11-team Big 10.

Big 12: Oklahoma

The Sooners rebound from their injury-plagued 2009 season and return to form. I said before that I like Oklahoma as a potential national champion and I’m sticking with it. Texas should take a little step back and I don’t think Nebraska will be as good as advertised.

Conference USA: Houston

Houston all the way. The Cougars melted down in their last two games but have a lot of firepower. How’s this for offense? The team returns their top four rushers and top four receivers, including three 1,000 pass-catchers. There’s also QB Case Keenum, who could challenge the NCAA’s all-time passing record.

Mountain West: TCU

Tough choice over Utah, but the Horned Frogs are almost the same team as the one that went 12-0 in the regular season last year. You can’t pick against them. BYU seems unlikely to put up much of a fight in their last season in the league.

MAC: Temple

The Owls should have won the conference last year and this year I have them winning it out of the West. I do like Northern Illinois in the East, but Temple’s the team to beat.

SEC: Alabama

I’ve heard good things about Georgia as a possible surprise team in the East, but odds are good that Alabama, the league’s most talented squad, will repeat. They’re just way too powerful.

Sun Belt: Middle Tennessee

The only conference I know little about. Troy is also a favorite and I have seen them play a few times, but Middle Tennessee is my choice. The Sun Belt has traditionally been the SEC’s whipping boy, but individual teams (like Troy) have proved that they can play with top teams on a game-by-game basis.

MAC: Boise State

It’ll be Boise State by a lot. The poor, dying WAC will get one last BCS bowl berth (its fourth in five years) before its remaining teams get sent to football purgatory. The Broncos face major non-conference tests versus Virginia Tech and Oregon State, but an undefeated WAC season is a foregone conclusion.

Pac-10 preview

I mentioned in my last post the significance of starts lost to injury and turnover margin. However, in the Pac-10, I believe there’s an even more important metric for determining success.

Quick, when was the last time the conference champion had a quarterback who was A) an underclassman and/or B) a first-year starter?

Sorry, Oregon and OSU fans, but this is an ugly reality that no one – not talk radio nor columnists nor TV personalities has addressed. Let’s look at the signal-callers for the previous year’s league champions (with team in parentheses):

2009: (Oregon) Jeremiah Masoli, junior, second-year starter.

2008: (USC) Mark Sanchez, redshirt junior, first-year starter (but saw significant time in 2007 due to injury).

2007: (USC, ASU) John David Booty, redshirt senior, second-year starter; Rudy Carpenter, redshirt junior, first-year starter.

2006: (USC, Cal) John David Booty, redshirt junior, first-year starter; Nate Longshore, redshirt junior, first-year starter.

2005: (USC) Matt Leinart, redshirt senior, third-year starter.

2004: (USC) Matt Leinart, redshirt junior, second-year starter.

2003: (USC) Matt Leinart, redshirt sophomore, first-year starter.

2002: (Washington State, USC) Jason Gesser, redshirt senior, third-year starter; Carson Palmer, senior, fourth-year starter.

2001: (Oregon) Joey Harrington, redshirt senior, third-year starter.

2000: (Washington, Oregon, Oregon State) Marques Tuiasosopo, senior, third-year starter; Joey Harrington, redshirt junior, second-year starter, Jonathan Smith, redshirt senior, second-year starter.

That's seven seniors and seven juniors, almost all of which had also redshirted. There's a single underclassman, and you may recognize him as one of the greatest college football players of all time in Matt Leinart. That is astounding (though it does fit my belief that veteran QB = wins) and does not bode well for young Darron Thomas and Ryan Katz of the Oregon schools. If a quarterback is starting for the first time, underclassman status is almost a death knell for conference title hopes.

So who are the veterans who fit the profile this season? The two most high-profile quarterbacks are Washington’s Jake Locker (redshirt senior) and Stanford’s Andrew Luck (redshirt sophomore), two teams that have been touted by some commentators as potential darkhorse champions. There’s also Kevin Riley at Cal, a guy who’s been around a while but never put it all together – yet.

Will one of those teams win the Pac-10? It seems unlikely to me. Cal has disappointed for the past three seasons, as it appears defensive coordinators have caught up with former offensive genius Jeff Tedford’s system. Riley does have some weapons, though - like running back Shane Vereen - and the Bears have a lot of talent on the roster. Cal is still dangerous, but I doubt they win it all.

Washington has improved dramatically since the arrival of Steve Sarkisian, but going from 5-7 to conference champs is just such a huge step for a team to make in one season. Locker, while supremely talented, has still yet to become a complete quarterback, and the Huskies defense is way behind their offense. They’ll have to win a lot of shootouts, and there’s no question they’re still only third best in the Northwest.

That leaves Stanford, who ESPN’s Kirk Herbstreit (and the magazine’s survey of Pac-10 players) picked to win the league. Of the three, I’d have to say Stanford has the best shot. They’re still too slow defensively and they lost stud running back Toby Gerheart, but Luck is probably good enough to compensate for a lot of that. Not all of it, though. They're scary, but I still don’t think the Cardinal win the Pac-10.

If you count out WSU, ASU and UCLA (which I will, with confidence), that leaves the usual suspects and top teams from last season: Oregon, OSU, USC and Arizona.

Arizona has received the largest range of predictions from analysts, from as low as seventh or eight to as high as first. The Wildcats do return a lot of offense and junior quarterback Nick Foles, who should be even better in his second year at the helm. But there are several defensive starters to be replaced. For me, the issue is the Holiday Bowl. The last time anyone saw Arizona, the team was getting wiped off the map and humiliated by Nebraska, 33-0. I just can’t shake the feeling that this team is not mentally or physically tough enough to win the conference (for more evidence, see the choke job at the end of the Oregon game).

USC is likely the most talented team in the league again, but the whole NCAA sanctions thing is a problem. The Trojans are ineligible for the postseason for at least 2010 and thus the Pac-10 title. Even if they finish first, they won’t be declared champions. Also, Lane Kiffin has yet to prove that any part of his head works properly except for his mouth.

Thus, even though it goes against everything I’ve said, we’re back to Oregon and OSU. As I said, this is maddening stuff. Oregon State returns a ton of starters, including all-stars James and Jacquizz Rodgers and NFL-ready tackle Stephen Paea, whom I think is the best lineman the state has seen since Haloti Ngata. The Beavers also face a brutal early schedule, with road trips to Arlington to face TCU at Cowboys Stadium and in Boise versus dreaded Boise State. However, if OSU manages a decent early record for the first time in years (say, 2-1), they could head into their Pac-10 schedule with a lot of confidence. The Beavers conference dates are favorable; they get Oregon, USC and Cal all at home.

Oregon returns even more starters, including their entire offensive line (a very underrated situation for a team). Running backs Kenjon Barner and LaMichael James are scary fast, and the entire defense (which has about 18 rotation players) has speed to burn as well. The Ducks non-conference schedule is easy despite a potential trap game at Tennessee, but they face their three toughest opponents on the road at OSU, Cal and USC.

Which Oregon team will it be, then? It’s a tough choice, but I’m going with Oregon for a few reasons. First, there’s no denying the Ducks have as much or more talent than any of the (eligible) teams in the league. Second, the Ducks are the defending champs and know how to win big games. Third, Oregon does have a fifth-year senior quarterback on the roster in Nate Costa, so the veteran quarterback rule technically won’t be broken. And given Oregon's recent history, Costa may end up seeing some playing time yet. Finally, there’s just not a compelling enough reason to pick someone else. The Pac-10 seems really tight this year, and every team has a significant question mark somewhere. I’m taking the team that won the league by two games in 2009 to win it again in the Civil War on December 4th.

My final standings:

1) Oregon

2) OSU

3) Stanford

4) Washington

5) USC

6) Cal

7) Arizona

8) UCLA

9) ASU

10) WSU

Let it begin.

Friday, July 23, 2010

National Preview (mid-summer)

July Musings

Well, what a wild and eventful offseason it’s been. I picked up my copy of Phil Steele’s 2010 magazine a couple of weeks ago, which gave me a lot of things to think about. You know college football is on the horizon when Steele’s publication, which I consider the best in the business, comes out.

Conference expansion is the big issue on everyone’s minds, but plenty of other noteworthy events have taken place recently. There’s been player-related turmoil, scandal and embarrassment. Several household coaching names left the college football scene, including Pete Carrol, Mike Leach, Charlie Weis, Bobby Bowden and (briefly) Urban Meyer. Texas Tech is facing a massive, probably deserved lawsuit from Leach, while USC was slapped with sanctions by the NCAA because of Carrol’s activities.

Still, no school felt the sting of bad publicity more than Oregon, which saw its team members commit stupid mistake after stupid mistake, culminating in the season-long suspension and subsequent dismissal of star quarterback Jeremiah Masoli. Masoli’s rags-to-riches-to-rags story should become a cautionary tale for all future athletic stars who see themselves as above the law and can’t grow up. For their part, the Ducks will forever wonder just how good this year’s squad could have been with Masoli at the helm (sadly, probably national title good).

But the Oregon situation is no longer the foremost issue on the mind of the national audience, even if it did create the most important position battle in the sport this upcoming season. No, the questions now shift to who the legitimate championship contenders are.

Defending champ Alabama? Certainly. The Tide return three outstanding offensive weapons in quarterback Greg McElroy, receiver Julio Jones and last year’s Heisman winner Mark Ingram at running back. The offensive line is powerful and the special teams are solid, which should make up for the losses the Tide suffered on defense. They won’t be as dominant on that side of the ball but the offense should be more explosive.

Ohio State is a contender, even though I’m not at all sold on Terrelle Pryor yet. The rest of the team is stacked with elite playmakers, particularly on defense, where the Buckeyes look to once again be among the nation’s best. Defensive end Cameron Heyward and cornerback Chimdi Chekwa should lead another lockdown unit for the Scarlet and Gray.

Oklahoma will rebound after a tough year with injuries in 2009 and be a player again. I don’t think OU will win the title, but they’ve definitely got the offensive power to come close with guys like receiver Ryan Broyles and running back DeMarco Murray. The question is whether the young players who had to step up last season, like QB Landry Jones, have learned enough to be great this year.

Tim Tebow’s departure should open up the Florida offense more to suit new quarterback John Brantley. It might be a bit soon to proclaim the Gators championship material, but the fact remains that this team has gone 13-1 in three of the past four years. They’re just very, very good. Along with one of the most hyped recruiting classes in NCAA history, this Florida team will be completely capable of winning the national championship.

So that’s the usual suspects. But everyone will have those teams down as potential championship winners. What’s difficult is finding which of those under-the-radar schools will come out of nowhere and thrust themselves into the race. There’s always a couple every year; some even go on to win it all, such as Oklahoma in 2000 or Ohio State in 2002. While both schools are traditionally powerful, neither was expected to challenge for the title.

Virginia Tech is going to receive a lot of preseason hype, but I just don’t see it. The Hokies will be packing their usual strong defense and running game – both hallmarks of a championship-caliber team – but too much of their potential is based on quarterback Tyrod Taylor. Everyone envisions Taylor as the second coming of Michael Vick, but he’s not a real quarterback yet. Taylor is even less a passer than Terrelle Pryor, and that’s saying something.

Like VT, USC will get a lot of respect based on their name, but they’re just not what they were a few years ago. While Oregon’s off-field issues will certainly open the door for the Trojans to take the Pac-10 again, they aren’t good enough to go undefeated, which is what it will take to make the title game out of that conference. Reasons? First, USC’s overall talent level is down from what it was; second, Lane Kiffin isn’t half the coach Pete Carroll is.

However, I do like a pair of teams out of the ACC, which is a surprise in itself given how weak that league has been of late. I’ve ragged on the conference as much as anyone, but now I can really get behind a couple of squads (and no, it’s not Georgia Tech, who will probably come back to earth a little after their great 2009 run).

I like Miami (FL) a lot based on their personnel. Jacory Harris is a great quarterback, they’ve got some big, speedy, traditional Hurricane wideouts and the defense should be more than adequate. The caveat is their schedule, which is Fresno State-like in its ambitiousness. The Canes travel to both Ohio State and Pittsburgh before October, then face a decent South Florida team at season’s end. In between, they get Virginia Tech, Florida State, Clemson and Georgia Tech in conference play. If they win all or nearly all of those games, they’ll be worthy of championship consideration, but that’s quite a feat. Of course, they also have to play my other surprise team, North Carolina.

Butch Davis is a very good college coach, as he proved at Miami. In just a few short years he’s made North Carolina relevant again, building the Tar Heels into a team that looks suspiciously similar to his powerful end-of-the-decade Hurricane squads. UNC was better than their 8-5 record last year indicated and they return all but three starters, including nine players from what was already the ACC’s best defense. Their offense held them back at times last season, but I firmly believe the maxim that “senior quarterback = wins” in college football. With T.J. Yates back behind center and a running game that can only improve, North Carolina is my biggest surprise pick for 2010.

From the non-BCS conferences, it’ll be a couple of traditional powers making their case to be included in the championship talk. TCU is pretty much the exact same team they were last year and their only tough game is their opener against Oregon State, which traditionally gets off to bad starts. They have a great chance to have an undefeated regular season again.

Boise State is in a similar situation, as they’re just much too powerful for any of their league opponents. The Broncos schedule is once again laughably weak, but it’s not really their fault that the WAC is so bad. BSUhas a chance to make their biggest statement in years by getting Oregon State (home) and Virginia Tech (neutral site) to face them this season. In their last year in the WAC, you can’t say they’re not trying. If they beat Tech and OSU they’ll go undefeated, too.

Pac-10 thoughts

It wasn’t just Oregon who saw off-field issues this year. Oregon State had a couple of embarrassing incidents as well (including one for which potential starting quarterback Peter Lalich was given the boot), UCLA recently had three incoming recruits arrested and USC received a two-year bowl ban and scholarship reductions from the NCAA. All in all, not a strong offseason for the Conference of Champions.

You might have noticed that I also didn’t include a single Pac-10 team as a contender for the national championship. None of them deserve it, at least right now. Oregon blew maybe its best chance ever, USC is on a bit of a downswing and Oregon State will be breaking in a new quarterback. As exciting as it is to see the Oregon schools in the same breath as Southern Cal, the truth is that the Pac-10 is full of very good but not great teams this year. Oregon, OSU and USC are likely the top three in some order with Stanford, Cal, Arizona and Washington making up the middle. Arizona State and UCLA are a step below those teams and everyone is miles ahead of Washington State. But teams one through seven all have potential to be the league champ and it’s hard to predict which one will come through. Since 2006, when the league changed to a nine-game conference schedule, there has never been an undefeated team in Pac-10 play (USC and Cal went 7-2 in 2006, USC and Arizona State went 7-2 in 2007, USC went 8-1 in 2008 and Oregon went 8-1 last year). A one-loss conference champion is almost certain, and a two-loss team could clearly still have a shot.

So how to pick a winner? One of the most important aspects of a successful college football team is experience. As I’ve said, a multiple-year starting quarterback is almost always a must, but experience at other positions – particularly along the offensive lines – can never hurt. Even without Masoli, Oregon returns a lot of starters. The Ducks are second in the conference at seventeen and also return both kickers. Washington returns eighteen starters and both kickers, while Oregon State, Stanford and Washington State all return fifteen starters plus their specialists. These numbers generally indicate that a team will perform at least as well as they did the year before. However, returning starters don’t tell the whole story.

Two other very important stats to predict a team’s success are starts lost to injury and turnovers, and both depend to some degree on luck. If a team is lucky, losing very few players to injury and getting a big edge in turnovers, they usually have a good season and will trail off the next year when their luck evens out. For example, last year’s champ Alabama was +19 in turnovers, Rose Bowl winner Ohio State was +17 and undefeated Boise State was +21.

No Pac-10 school reached that kind of extreme, with most schools flirting with about a .500 mark. Unsurprisingly, WSU “led” the league with -7 turnovers, while conference champ Oregon surprisingly had only +2 turnovers. The best rating went to UCLA at +6, followed by Oregon State and Cal at +5 and +4, respectively. Such a small edge shouldn’t mean those teams lose any more than one additional game next year, so the injury factor becomes relevant in predicting how the league will finish next year.

Oregon State had the fewest starts lost to injury in the nation in 2009 with just two (out of a possible 264). The next closest Pac-10 team was UCLA with 14, while the rest of the conference averaged around 20. This is where Washington State fans will shake their heads in dismay: the Cougars had an astonishing 67 starts lost to injury, which led the nation by a wide margin. For reference, the most starts lost in 2008 was Utah’s 51. If you think injuries don’t matter, just look at the tales of the two teams at the top and bottom of that list. WSU went 1-11, with their only win against lowly SMU, and was outgained by a ridiculous 260 yards per game. OSU went 8-5 and just missed the Rose Bowl, finishing second in the conference at +78 yards a game. It's a bad idea to read too much into statistics, but these things do matter.

I’ll come back at the end of the summer and make my official picks for each conference, but I need to think about the teams for a while longer before I do. For now, I’ll give you my thoughts on the future of college football.

Conference expansion

College football has maintained a certain status quo since the Big 12 was formed in 1994, the ACC’s raiding of the Big East notwithstanding. That all came crashing down this spring when news broke that the Big 10 was looking to expand to twelve teams. Of course, everyone’s initial reaction was that Notre Dame, a natural fit, would be the new team. However, the league opted for the next best fit in Nebraska, which has long played an ugly, gritty brand of football like that seen in the Midwest. I have no problem with the Cornhuskers joining the Big 10; it makes sense from a competition standpoint. I do dislike the reason the addition was really made, which is obviously money. The ever-greedy Big 10, already the richest conference TV revenue-wise, wanted the extra cash that would come from having a conference championship game, which the NCAA only allows for conferences that have at least twelve members.

But such is life. The rich get richer. The truly earth-shattering news just a few days later was the revelation that the Pac-10 was looking to expand – not to twelve teams, as people expected, but to an unheard-of sixteen. Even more shocking was the list of schools the league was looking to add – Oklahoma, Oklahoma State, Colorado, Texas Tech, Texas A&M and mighty Texas. The potential ramifications for college football were enormous.

As everyone knows by now, the deal fell through at the last minute when Texas backed out. But it’s sobering to think of what the Pac-16 would have meant for college football. Analysts saw sixteen-team conferences as the leagues of the future, envisioning five such superconferences that would run everything in the sport. In that scenario, all mid-major schools would have been cut out of the BCS money entirely, permanently shifting the NCAA landscape to a black-and-white split between haves and have-nots. We likely would have seen something like this:

Pac-16:

Arizona, Arizona State, Cal, Colorado, Oklahoma, Oklahoma State, Oregon, Oregon State, Stanford, Texas, Texas A&M, Texas Tech, UCLA, USC, Washington, Washington State

(Current) Big 10:

Illinois, Indiana, Iowa, Iowa State, Kansas, Kansas State, Michigan, Michigan State, Minnesota, Nebraska, Northwestern, Notre Dame, Ohio State, Penn State, Purdue, Wisconsin

Mountain West:

Air Force, Baylor, Boise State, BYU, Colorado State, Fresno State, Houston, Missouri, Nevada, New Mexico, San Diego State, SMU, TCU, UNLV, Utah, Wyoming

SEC:

Alabama, Arkansas, Auburn, Florida, Georgia, Kentucky, LSU, Miami (FL), Mississippi State, Ole Miss, South Carolina, Tennessee, Vanderbilt, Virginia, Virginia Tech, West Virginia

ACC:

Boston College, Cincinnati, Clemson, Connecticut, Duke, Florida State, Georgia Tech, Louisville, Maryland, North Carolina, North Carolina State, Pittsburgh, Rutgers, South Florida, Syracuse, Wake Forest


I chose the teams based on the original plans of the Pac-10 and Big 10, assuming:

1) It’s likely that the SEC would have made the next move, snagging some of the top East Coast schools in West Virginia, Miami (FL) – a school the conference has long coveted – and Virginia and Virginia Tech, which were rumored to be a package deal.

2) The ACC would have had to move to counter the new SEC’s size and snapped up the majority of the Big East, which is already down to eight schools after the ACC stole its top three teams in 2003.

3) With just twelve teams the Big 10 would have had to expand once again, and probably would have added regional schools in Notre Dame, Iowa State (a natural rival for Iowa) and Nebraska rivals Kansas and Kansas State.

4) The Mountain West, scrambling to keep up, would have retained Utah and added Boise State as planned. For its final six members, it would make sense to take the best teams left, which I saw as Nevada and Fresno State from the WAC, Missouri and Baylor from the splintered Big 12 and Houston and SMU from Conference USA (both teams have a history of success in a BCS-level conference).

If all of that makes your head spin, don’t worry. It demonstrates the potential madness we would have seen had the Pac-16 been formed. In that structure there would be 80 BCS teams, as opposed to the 65 now. However, this system would be anything but inclusive. Right now there’s at least a chance, however minimal, that a smaller team like Utah or Boise State can play their way into a BCS game (and potentially even the national championship). In the superconference era, it would be impossible. The remainder of the mid-majors not invited to the big leagues (largely teams from the MAC, WAC, Sun Belt and Conference USA) would never again have a sniff at the BCS money. And that’s not even accounting for independents Army and Navy, which have traditionally fielded solid teams and are important to the game historically.

I have always been against conference expansion. I believe that with a few exceptions, the conferences as they are work well, ensuring relative fairness and quality of competition. Sure, Notre Dame should probably be in the Big 10 and the East Coast conferences are a little jumbled, but the six BCS conferences and five mid-major conferences that currently exist make sense. The problem isn’t which teams reside where, it’s the BCS itself. But that seems to be a fruitless argument, as we’re stuck with the non-playoff system for several more years.

The BCS has been the cause of the near-Armageddon we’ve seen in the past several years. The horribly weak non-conference scheduling from BCS schools in the past few years is a direct result of teams trying to succeed by playing the BCS’s rules rather than beating good opponents on the field as they should. With better records, conferences can send two teams to BCS bowls, which pay out about $15 million. Conference championship games are pathetic money grabs, nothing more. With more TV revenue a league can leverage its influence into a private network a la the Big 10 and further increase the money each school receives. The reason Texas turned down the Pac-10’s offer at the eleventh hour had nothing to do with conference loyalty; it was because the Pac-10 requires its members to share TV revenue equally and the Big 12 allows Texas to take more than their share. Because Texas acted as if it wanted to leave, though, it managed to milk an even sweeter deal out of the Big 12. Clearly, in this day and age, money is more important to college football than ever before. The full extent of the greed of the sport was on full display this offseason.

As to how the Pac-10’s addition actually shook out, I have mixed feelings. The Pac-10 never needed expansion. It had the best organization of any conference: an even number of members, no phony championship game, five sets of natural in-state rivals. Everything was settled on the field in round-robin fashion – nine games, with each team playing everyone else. However, if the league had to expand, Colorado and Utah were always the most natural additions, particularly geographically. I’ll admit that I like the idea of seeing Ralphie (Colorado’s mascot) charging around Pac-10 fields and Utah adjusting to playing with top competition full-time.

At the same time, though, I’ll miss the old format. People have already started questioning how the conference will split into two divisions. North-South? East-West? The Northwest schools would be furious at being denied their annual trips to the fertile recruiting grounds of southern California, but travel would be split bizarrely if, say, Cal and UCLA played in different divisions. There are also reports that Colorado believes it was promised a spot in the South with UCLA and USC, but the league has denied such rumors. It’s all worked out to be a little bit exciting and a little bit messy, so as fans we’ll just have to wait and see what happens.

The 2010 season is fast approaching. I hope you share my excitement and choose to join me again on my blog journey throughout the year. America’s greatest sport will soon return! Let the new season be every bit as glorious as the last.